High Court Karnataka High Court

The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt Padma W/O Late Narasimhaiah on 25 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
The Oriental Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt Padma W/O Late Narasimhaiah on 25 October, 2010
Author: Arali Nagaraj
IN 'me HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA AT  R
Dated this the 25?" day of October, 20,j:l:0    

BEFORE yr__

THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE NA--::;ARAJ" 

M F A N0.1399/2_.01OV{I\/_IV)  -

BE! WEEN

The Oriental Insurance  Ltd.  g  "
Regionai office, No.44/45, T V  V '

Leo Shopping Complex,   . 
Residency      
Bar1ga}ore--560. «   

Rep. by its Regiorial. 

Mar1ager._ ____   ..Appe11ant

[By Sri Shara  ' 2'Xnci'v;]

AND:

V 1.  Padrr'1a., V

 /{'e,1a.t.Ae Nara"s'i'rrihaiah,
 Aged.abo.1;t 33 years.

2'; ._ 
'  D/ 0. late N arasimhaiah,
 aIf)out 17 years.

"  S / o.1ate Narasimhaiah,
v   about 15 years.

  .:.Respondents No.2 and 3 are minors

“pare represer1ted by their mother. the

= 181- res ondent herein as a natural
P
guardian .

§\)

4. Smt.Gowramma,
W/o.1ate Narasaiah,
Aged about 73 years.

A11 are r/a.G0ndhihal1iVil1age. V
Puruvara Hobii, Madhugiri T a1uk;».._
Tumkur District. ‘

5. Sm1:.G R Sujatha,
W/o.M S Shankranarayana,,_
Aged about 43 years, K it .

R/a.Ver1katadri N’i£ay–a.( V j
Raghaveridra Extensionf” ‘ , ._
Madhugiri .f ‘ ‘i’uml«:1i1′ « _ 3 ~,..Respondents

This .4isiil:_fi:i_i;ed -.1′ 73{i{I_’ of Act, praying to
modify the” _gJL:i_dgme11t._a.’rji~dg_ “Award dated 19.11.2009
passed C.i_Vi1_ Judge.-.v{Sr.Dn.) and MACT at

Madhugiri in NQ.9_1’0./_2007.

This ‘Corning’on:_4fo.r”admission this day, the
court delivered the fo11owing:”…

” « .,._.,.,IUDG1\/IENT

is iisted today for admission, it

takeii,__’i5o1′ disposal by consent of Sri Shankara

C, 1ea,rned counsel for the appellant — Insurance

VCo–. arguments are heard on merit.

H;[;i1€ only ground on which the impugned

iijudgnieiat and Award dated 19.11.2009 passed by the

c’–r””””””

the deceased was aged 30 years as on the

accident, the Claims Tribunal has

Rs.10.000/- towards loss of conso1’ti’u:ri /12.

towards love and affection toW’ard’so_ minov_:fi”ehi1ciren.”–

Therefore, I am of the opinionjteihthat
did not commit total
compensation of of all the
claimants at the rate of
6% p.a. f15’o:i1i:” till the date of

reaIisa1t:iV(‘)1’1t.V ” 1 .. fl

Hence, th-e__present’Aétpfiegllé of the insurer is hereby

disn1isse,djas being devoid of merit.

amount is deposited by the

iii'”‘n..appe11eir;iji¥ in.st1i’ert::u7ith this Court shall be transmitted

~.(.z”‘[:t’.;’.._'[)1’1-it’. Claif11s’3-Tribunal concerned so as to enabie the

t’-cilei-ir§’12i1:i’:»s_’:t;o withdraw the same.

Sd/-

Judge