High Court Karnataka High Court

The State Of Karnataka vs Paramashiva @ Parameshi on 27 January, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The State Of Karnataka vs Paramashiva @ Parameshi on 27 January, 2009
Author: Manjula Chellur Gowda


‘2: $mi;§fifii§a

E3 Tfifi §E§§ fififififi Q? §&R§AE&§é5 Egfifiééfigfi

aafiga $333 TEE 2?%§ 3%? G? sggfiagzf 2§3§’ g

§RE§E§T

€33 fififi EL? R36 §$$§::§ m§§s3§A_¢g$;;$Ef~:

Efifi

$32 aagfgzg fig. §§3§:£§ §¢§gg$§:v§5§;§$fi$g’,”

fififiifififl g§?gAL’£§;;$:§2@§:¢T} x w

ffig Ei&%a ag garnatakg’ “5],g;,g§§g;L§§
{By 33: §,ghavgs:_s:a§§;’g§§:{$§§; ,°

§§§

1, §ar&fiaghi¥a’§’§§3%&a$&if

SEQ §axa§§§3 $wam3gg

V %§&fi_%E¢&§ Eifigegrgg
figéiégéi fiagtag fiesiieg

§§$iA§a$géa§3:ii fiag,

$%i§§§a”$ig::g§:

.7» 3

:§§$’§a$a§ éa fiwamf
.§§éé–§b§fit $3 yéayg,

~.V%fi&a£i§&: $%&:§§

3′-J

35$ A§azaéa§a;:: fiamgf
§§a:ava%§& Eaiak,

§hi§@§& fiistrict, ..§ 2§§§§§§fi§:g,f

Eags fizzgmai §§§aai is fiéiaé unda$ $$§€i$§§

ii} g {3} f $K§§ Q .by

§E&§ifi§ aha? this §$§’bi§ fiaagi Egg fig §i@3Sé§_t§

1:.

ieavg ta f

E”

§§&fii
fifigmfifit a:,5b§,2§$: yagaéfi, by .i§§ *§fZf£iu§l&
§:§§a¢§ fihiga 3% ac ggffifgg $é§a§§%ifi§ tga
E$fi§$§§§i§&$$&S%fi v§§,3 §§§*;;§éy.§ff&§aé fifififlfi
agfitiafi 3&2 rgaé w§t%$§a§ti§§ §éME§§.an§ &$aa$&&
§a.2 fiaz thg .$§§e§g§»H§fi§ia:a§:2 §fié$r ggatiang

é§$wAJag§.3@g’:§%§4§i:§L3é’§§ :§§-}

§§i$_izifié§3l’$§§aa§f$§mifi§

gag *% ‘§§:§$g_ §%£2:§§ 3g

3% fax’ Eeazéng

V

w&££ fiaiigexaé 3&6

.,..VV 3

§a:§@w:§§g*,
H ‘ . . . . .

‘* *§§i$fi§@§a%E is égrgatafi a§&:fisfi ifia jgfigmt

@§A g§§iifia£g Ehe akaxgas against thg aagfifiaé

fV§az$§§$fla:a far @§f@§$a$ gamzgéabie mafia: gastifig

:)é§$»g E§aa with gaatiaa 34 gg :§$»

age ~$?§ §§é”‘t§g “§:az§;A’

=33 33 agfigal agaiéfifi ‘%%aV

\. , _ .

‘qiéiggx

V_@2kg§@&é;:§e :31 izaatmani Ea tha £$$%&S%&a

iJ\}

2. En bxgaf ihg factfi tfiafi lgé ta iha fiéigg

af ahaxga s§ee% againgi tia acagsgfi §@K$@gSy;£ a§~

gnar:

fieaeagaé Ehaaaiagmi :§”W§%@ ;&a§§§%a§vfl$§W

&§W§l$i§5fit fiméfiggilamg W§$ 7g$ §x§§in$éT a$W

§.%L2. §.¥.2 Qavgafiagwamgxwig “:he_V§§fih§$»”$§

&§a§3$e&* §@aeage§K §a§V-§ivg§, ga “fia§§§§§% ta

aaaas§§~E §%E&m&$hi?ET §’fl?%§3fiQ§§é§z_3@3i§£§i $§
ggazaéahazii 3-.§:~ cxisatéz G5
the §aaea$§$:§%§$§i%$ml£§§§i%§u§§é fiaifi waéieckg
a w Aa ak§;§{%fi§ $é$§ §aEm§§§§§%3na:§;§ éiaé. Ea

fika fi$fizim§§ia;WV%$$5 _fi§a 32$? 35 §$c§a§e&

%*’§T giaagani gag, 3% iig

§§%§&i§k3§fifi.%%$a’*

:$$§§a§&flfi£?g$$u5e& E gfixi 2 wegg giving fiag ma

.”§ri§k§§&§flz§aza$§é§§ iaz aii iég iififip Efifigfi ié

§i;£$ &£$a$aé§§§g§a§fi éfi 3&3 $$§%fi&§

$§a£$ia§£§fl was aéficiaé Eé &i$§ha§; wfiiafi

fkifi

~ wag fiigciaggé is fika kgifi 33$ kin $§ ihg &§¢$§$aé

égzing fiex $:§:%$ is fiha §a§a§fia£ h@u3&,

‘w’a§ Jggfiicag “§§zma: afifi g

3% E2,3y§S 3% afigfit §.3$§%: thg ¥iEE&g&r3

izcm Eggzaéghalii Efiaugfit Efiafiaiaxmz %§$. §a&

£§§§$E%fi figxaa ia hgy h§§$@ ai fi$leb@n%¥&;;i :éA$%

wax :§§$rmi§§ aha: fihanaiazmi 3ft%:,’§@§$:fi§E1

N

figzgéif wiih kazagaafi $@i

a$$§t ?A3§§mk fig: $5
haapitai’ Eaxéng hgx stag ig i§% fi§$§§fi§:;w§&:
éaug§t$z fifiaaaégzfi. gafagggg hag’ §§§§%_ :%@ 2;;
iraatfigmty &§§. §;$©V”a;&§é%$§§!u$ffl¥i§@’ agcafigé. :9
a:aa§ai§ Q3 acmagfit fig §gu§§%$§g%fi @§§ éigastiaa

1: tag gigs, gfig gg:V§§2§e:§”g§;aze ta put an éfié

fie ;:§é;&’_f§& afiggégigggi i$ég@§,: samiaiat im

§a£$a§%i% §§§iSéL$§%§$§fi; fifiimmga :3 ifié §3%%@E$&

333% §&%& ifi %@

‘Vui%§:§fi@:é§J,#;ihim ihg Eimgtg §a§a§§g2§r ggéisa

$i§ii&a;’§&aéra¥atké faigk, $3 irzme §a,3§§§§ agfi

– FEE %&§*§éai Ea iha §%?$ fiaurtf §ha%$§§3%§éw

‘*,3. §§ria§ éfis gauxga emf iagagtigaiiax, aha

~l?§§;i$$ &§§%S€%§ aha am$&$§§ §fi§$$fi$ aaé ysaigaeé

ggze-,:a, he33é:§v{1§7

thaéx :=%g:é£:i -. V

ikam %&§m§% tfia iaazaafi $E§$»; witfi Xfififififi

5 ané tag Saurt

W3

%§§3i$%t3G& ané =§ :§;3.

Kamanéafi. ihg a$£§ge&« ia fififiiaiai ausigégg

Bifiimgtaiy gm %E&§aigXhi gxaaafifivéaég

bazfi i5§§r:eg¢

Eagisiaxeé 3 amga gfiéar geatiag 3§§Wéfi§x3§§Q$§v

EES,

%w figriag ihé $Qu§:§V@§ ifiV%&ii§%tfi®fi¢m§§$§~,

mahazaz was gagiaafiafif $?a:§m3§%W-$§ fiavezai
wiine§$&$ v§$ Eaaéraéé; ;%v$%§3§é gfi@&fi cgma fig

*ka §b$$é”W$&:@ affanéaa afifiz

¢m§§Eg%§§§’§3$’iM?a$ig§é?:$n,

yfij gag iéafmafi Saflgg sf ifie a@m&:ti&l @333:

°x3%fi::%%§fif”3%$s mgitex ta fiagsianfi Qaurtg ag ihé

‘,§§§é:né$ a%$ §xC;u$:¥ei§ triala §§ iha iafirt $5

$e$$:@§sQ”§§é 3§fi%$%§ §@§$@§$ §i$g§@£ fiat giéig

‘ §s 2&3 éfiaxgaa 3§§%i§&d agaiaat thaw” §hex%f@ré,

r %zi$£ was sfimmafigafi,

gs: thaé §$_:;::€: cf aim;

. /’

‘u_w&%’;a§§:%i§é af-

, Va? .. ‘ . A 4. .

-fit:

S. 1% aiif 1% Witfiéfifififi waxg axamiaeé. fez

fiha fiffifiéfifiiififlg agar? fxam xazkimg 3% fififififififitfi

anfi 3 maiezia; gbfigafig;

?e Egaraeé; ixiaig §§§§% 3fi&3* rgfiégdg

séaiamemz agé §%&Ei§§ ifia gx§é§gat$;§:a¢§ééa§Ciefi

gagfi juégfigai fif asguiifiaif lgg. Ea: “§§~_§f§§fi$é*

§a§i$§&§:% fifififiz $§$fi:$a 3§2_§ea@.%;:§t$é§%;@é 3%
6%’ EEC sax: a&§¥iat%é %fi§a.;¢$§$aé EELE fiha

@§§%g$e §ERi$%a§l& $fi§$XI$é§::§fi”§§3w£ §§§i&§§ifi§

fi?a 3fi¢a$%fi §$.an&&:§a f*§§§§a$;i§§ri$$n@§: EQ:

3 yeaig aéé4é;$d;i$ §%§ &.§ifi$ af §§,2§§§§f~§ in

fififgfiiig fim -gfiégrga “$ file. éw fzfie ~nt far 3

mflxiéga “§¢”E3:a §g gcaa5§éw2 fig 5©m$@z§&&g fiha

w w;

iig Q§%f§$Sa

ifie gaié jgégmfii af

“K2

‘be:

@
wk .

s ‘ M .. ‘
._;w

5%

5

fi3£«

aa§fi%ta§; _i%e§ §ra§$miT %p§aa; is filaé, a§§= figs

‘ a§au§§fi%i Eafi fifii S§§li%§§Ed E15 $éfi$:fi%i$E afifigx

afgafiigsg §§§»$ af :§§”

~§§aia§aEiau”:gfiazT gaaiiga 3%§ §§ Z§§§ Zn

‘zéafif with géctiafi

:2» ?§& fiémiitaé Eacis $E% ike fiegeagaé

Sfiggaigxmi aabaaguami i§ hex §fifEiE§% ;:¥aéf§ i$

é §%&z$ ix aha xfifizimmaiaé hsma aiafig %éfi§”%$:

kuskanfi amfi mtfierwinmiawm

§§@£%fl%fi£$g{ égzifig Ear £%a§ja%”§@ §ax§£*§fV%fi§$=
ha§.ha§§§ mmfimt ia the mafirgmxiéi fiame, as xgfy

kusfiggé baigg 3§§i$%@é i@ $£§Q§%1’W&$’§%$&§$ifi§”

33$ :ii%txaati§g he; gmmgfiafiilyg $§e_ha§ §i?$fi

gaaé imfématiafi §§* h@r1;pa§é§:$; amé firaifiaz

33.Tfh¢g§h’§§af§é-sfiéét”éamg ta h$ fziad fag
fike @§f§§$é$ §%fii§ha§§@”§3$@x saatiafig 4§Sm§; Efifi

32$. 35? 23 d§£E§$

Véfiéi wi%E_é§é::¢§ 3% Sf :§$§
$%éa§. éamg %§%.%& _§;3$fi. :3 zaggaat $5 $§§@R$§£

ihafi

z;:£§;~;« iraitar 232% 23%.: £’;&2:.:*%; 233$; ‘:3

se§$i£$z’:ée saga §§ ihe gresaaaiifig ffifi sffafiaa

“g ym:;g%éb:§ afldgz gactiafi §§§m§T afifi fifififiifin 332

3% 5f Z§$ §§:§: fia fax 33

gasaxfiifig .fi@.”%§$f

Séfiiififi é§%~& :3 éaaagzmaé, tha avifigncag

§,%g»E %§ 3 £3 Ekag ifitfi caxgiégrété

fiitimiaigg aria; $§art kaifi fihfii thegé ggggang;
aza baa: pexsans fig knaw tka fatg $f thé*fi%¢£§$§§_

$3 ifié mtrianiai fiamg an§4 §én§:fi%afi_’&$§§3§£

fig’: £i§§$ fax ihe @§§&fi$€ ‘§§m3§h3;g»,§fi&er

$&$ti§§ égawa $5 £§€,

2%: £3 a maaée:- §§E:§a¢i;, a$ae Qf ifia

wifinagggs §&¥é §§@fi/§%§$§3£&§p&$@§i fifié gzaseasa

afi aasmaeéwfi; §§:§$:+:§¢l&wflV;fi. iéa mafiziaagai

éazkanfif by §ré$é§§afi”.,=?h% gvifiémgg ig axiy

ififixfiufifi gagafiefifhagfiagfi amfi §at§1§§ wag

; ggaifigt ififiwfiéfifififi gaaggaé.

.5 2.-=

vg-:;Q7 §§é3r aamfig t@ aha mgzéafi $5 iéa

fi@xsgs&£.~§§afiaiagfi§° iaa grggaauiiga xaiieé, §§&§

_V:§a efigfiéfiag Qf §¢§$&1 $3 3 =w yargxts, Exaifierg
“aafi ‘§w¥;% M fiaéaznai gxaia 3% iig égaaggaé,

“§¢%$aE aaé § maigkbggxg %g$ Eaya iarggé hsgaiie

§:.:::é§z1§ Ee:x.§'”‘,’? is ti-tgg ::a:§@’t §§f%.&§?:8£&,1’Z° 333$ §g2:§E&§.E; is

%;%;?’:§E.G”‘ $;§.?’fz:”@;i’:éZ,’é{3: .%€:fi’i;§$Qé
§€$::1fiL4§- ?,%%’.§;§ z<;'°§":£: c:z$:%:@;'§&a':gfi 33% ~§.1§:"'{?':%$'3§§;f:;g§'§"i1.'i:.®f);

filaé ~:t;":2a.:v::;f& ;§%::ea°%:*.;: '

:5? §:§§a;%::ra?:1i_'%;j..\:«g?_:' " §*mé;'=§;;@:::::*:e.,"s§:a:'" §.§e;a:i;. as %

iéaegggéz ::&f&::::*s:; c::2r:..ff2:*;e.:;_V i:$,?:ja3{5i%:m§:%§" aizfi Eéazaggzzzergi

2,"?

3 «:§e€3&.:i~;r:a;aa:i;é,_ §§§&’i£’f§.1§é§:13§.a§; E32223 ::?i.:;& ii;

a;.?:z§i,:La::”t*,é;t;z: Qf Qgf téaafzz zvmra aigziéa ta

$9

fgafjgg %§E’zé%:,2:%;:~:*’ “%.E:£1:_ A:i.a;*§*i;’;§. £225 %:;§2% éémegafifi wag

:3:;?f”>,;:’:«’L§.~:’:?:»’,%Z2fi”;:i@3″:;5i,§» zizaxéax 212:3: ‘%:.f€:z2’§ gar’:

dag’ ” _L:;:g.z,:§.§<':£.:z2._§@;£, ggpgarezziigf tézg éaaeagaai

§%3:3.$:*gs;§g§.«§.:x'%.i:;:.:%Zj—- jiafém wag gizffaggrgzzag xiii: §3"££3:'§'iS :a?&.-3

j bz*<;*§g';zf;§'; i,.::" a aiag fiat fig? flag huaéagaég Eat fig? ihé

».§:?.§;§,§§?§:*;§ ax" the :§',,'§.ii&§§' {$213 &§:i":3;§§£?€§ wag 332$

$;–§%: " §§€=$&§:§: at "itfizg E$$§Z'%£:3.§

fifibfifiqfififii %:$ ziaaaagéfl s'a.2gtair:i::g* Efifféiiégv §i"';:z:;..$
sgiazza éamigfié smi: egécabiigfs tizza gaéiii arsf téaa

afimzseciég as tizarwgé is §:§t§".:.T.i;§";§ $3: zfiaaxé. *i:.s%,';§"-.§§:2;::z;%: ::§<.°:::?.:E2wi2:~:$.':a? 'i~=*?;;%:'§ ;;:":rr;=:$a:::f2: ,:?:'%2.:;%;z":£.:z*§:::.::;:Z¢

Eéfiififi *;«2'E:e;': d§aiZ3%%$&é§, §::7*;:'f':§":2–;'i'v-L W52: tiiaa
$§$$%3?;z'?;$ §::é -.$,:~2,§iz:;g$i §@:*;;’:§,;’%:::”;a fihat
iémg ‘;*§’$Z€°% §E:?%§&§’2’*i;”., whazz’ «:?iée°;s;::’é;a.$§é’-:§€»;:;£1:ja;.E\.::a§¢ §::z*::s.b

*£::..iia§’43z§–:’A’z+§:2@ ‘ ?.§;*~££@$,,§%§. ta ‘i:;’;’:$

:zz@€:’£%:§;2§::jf$ ._g;f§., a€::é.~:V*’V..3fVfi§;~ 3;’-.f2%;2;+’:–z: 332?. gag aha? 31% 1&3

ilza ?s§;::r§ “aaéség 31%: sfiiaza <32'; ihg »§%:E: mi i*;E:a$ §m%;%::@:”::’, ‘i*é”§”1@§?1 §:E::%

‘V..,m<.*:'é";E'::a:}:, 3- faihax azzi :':.–z§'§§:%:::% hazza ::aé:$s§€;$:;<:a§..:%;§

" ::;2':;2§ff§'zs;~:§£ Eisgffisia ilém §:£'3°':§.i'?: tE7at €.T.§§€$%§&€i 232%:

§§;:§:.:?_$:§e aizjgéiiraéng §»$E2%:: tiéay iaaé: hag: Szzbséagéggzat ifi

3.7%

admitting her is téa h§§§;ia; haw gfie $$$iaifi§§

$3323; éefizfiiteiy it wmfiifi n$t iié :2 :hgV:@§i§

sf tha §:§§%ag::§§ ta sag aha: ihaza i§f&§f3$§§x

eviéagga fifi $§§w fihai thésa a$&m$§ém§é:$§§$'3ét~

%h& §$a§a$§§Aabla2&3

:?g In fifiai ¥i$wT,§f tfia Wma$t§$;A";fi ?i§&

gfigéfifia gf any aging' éé¢iarafi§§m.? Q: Qifii

sigiaméai E3 aha éafieasaég'fiEé*§::ai"$§&§a wag

fiusiifiafi in figifiisg %§&t'f%§%*f§:@secu%:@§ wag

gkia fig &$%g§ii$hj ikég saga' ffir' ifia &fffifi€%

éama :&_ba é§%a§ii$hé§_§@z 2&3 affagga §m2i$§a§:a
§§fi$$ gaaéafifi 3%? Q§'E§§$

' 33%, §:a%é§;~§z$§ &§§ an§;§, fifi arg af aha

.W.€§igée§ %%a%%th% fifiiéfiiai §i&Qefi %&§@3§ $3 fifiéfi

fiai"W:xg§i:$f $3 %a fieifi ika xaagagifig $§ aka

;a&§§e& téiai Efiége as ga éfifififim 3% §&rva:§ity.

.-&.v.-'x4

Eaaszfigggigz fifia a;§éa4. fléaézvés is ha

difififififififi afi§.3fia§és éismisgaég

E¥S%

I