High Court Karnataka High Court

The United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri Ashok S/O Shivaputrappa @ … on 14 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
The United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri Ashok S/O Shivaputrappa @ … on 14 July, 2009
Author: H.N.Nagamohan Das

ifi $33 max»: @333? Q? _
amexyrr ggrzmi gr: }33AK %:§§V._ ‘ F. % V
§fi;f’?E§ Tfiifi $23? 14:93 §=§_;§:;*gfj, f:2§:2a:f}”‘9{_
‘§’f§£E iiarmag mg §§U$*§§é§$2§_.§:& fisga
2§§,:m§;*~4~z€o. ]g%4;1s;:%;~;é:j:s¢z% im%} ” ‘

«

“§=::~§ £31: :T;mz:§?z%:s:3’ gm :”:i1é; ;§f§*s:§€:§;é;xNai::a: {:<;f}.:,:§*:f;.,
{}§'R«'ES¥€}§'%§f'Xi;vf}§?§¥fE{i§éf:§

P.;;3.;é'+:,:}w€:§, _ '"

._”%§;:5;?~§§Z’s;~”; MA §:;::~§;,.i:>_§:>;{;-”

. S.§.E%’§3<":'"§E\z?~"If Rimi},
'
._§.~??::"~"*..sf=§e:f§;:.S'::%:s2f:%:%:3:3 E?' {:3
E'Z':VE¥;?§-'E_,?';1'~':f:-?s€$u3'€f's.{"%SR, gag???-::A,z;m@*

{:32 E}§¥§E.i§:E&£S§€AEE..2%, 3132;: ::~<_:::'-3 3&3; Araza 'Ef§§§*€§~;.5sT§2§§§*i}

% –

3, EERE, fiS?§€}§{
j {} f’3Pi¥VAP{,.§’§’R;’iEV~’E3′;%
§§§§§§’?2§.§3;%§:3 {§§:1’€E{.”i:~§rZR,
faiftiif} ‘$3 YEZARE}
$95} ii} ?°¥§f’2E’T§%§ €.}2%.§.;-L-L

‘.»/.74 E.-“x,;”‘\

YKJ

JAM?xKHf”zI’~é§}I
E’:%;%.{}£§.;§<l'éC}".'£' §.1=i':'§'§'§éEE{3'§"i

gm. §¥é§dE:Sz§B
325:: 5:53: {§«,»%§*~§E§~§gE;;?; fi:B§."}E}i««€?«z%?%E §¥'f¥.?~EEE§£'%_?~€§T}5 S __
mags; MAJ{7}R§ _
Ego "r';§§%4§.§{AN§A.&Fif§{§§?

‘§’m,1:’:«; ;~§:n:1<;§§::rei, :

£35§,s3A2;s§§ E}i§’§’R£€f:'”E1 _ §%E::s;:;%{3.:2w{§§«:::§*::§.

€33: $9; zx;§§e:M:’:my;:~z5A§f ?r’§;:”-5. ;£3A§=;%:;§, Qimv’ §s:f:;’§:z $3: ” V
::22-s2:§2:z’§;:};; ‘ . 2

‘§’H’ES Mm :5; ;:*z§Vé}::;> 12;:x:%.}:>;2§’—-‘§g;;»§§::*§fEg>za: 1.?3{:} 2:}? ME?
36? magma’? ma JU:3{§’M}§M?F’._V ;zm;j~::_ &’«J%1§;R£} IBATEZITB

T§”{);’%f;%{3?}f?’j.Pfi§*€¥;E:E}”–.§§’§–._?v§’!Ei~E\§.’:§.E5€1?}j{}f§ ms THE: EELEE <3?
'§'HE: PEEL,<;i£*;5}L2;}'i.?£3€f}E§§fS;_E€ .E)_N§}, L3r»…H«?*<:, MELMBEER, :~e1A’§:€§3 A C{}M?E:P§SA”?’Ef}§\3 {$3
§€E§,:§,S€}._.Csf}!:}/~’=§x?’E’*§7H ,15i:r2.j”§~L=a§, EE’%”i'{:i§€ES’sf’E’, §~?:%{:;M mg}: IEATEZ
£3? PE::5::r2r:~:$§*;<*,

1%a;'£s.1_%z;2aa3 {ma

' '§«;%?;?%;2;:é::s€V§§»

'" A::*_~i.':';s:. &E§}?§?{i:i¢::

Egg {:3 Eéi-VAPEETRAPPA
$§»i§.%;A$;;;3Ai§ GANif;}’£€iR,

” .. ;fa:;;–§::::=~44 ‘*§:::AR§;;

* V §e’*;’._ §%§:§i’§’R <29-§;;,:.3
' *Jfi;?sfi2E§€EiAN£}E
; i'}§E§'§': E3;'%GfiL§i3:§§i:.,;1§~:*:*

{EL-§%_”‘ f%:§R§¥ ?v€E€i§T§”?«L}fi§f’i% “%’A’.§’z’3: .E3fi£’§{§E, figijiéfi}

a.;w.efl

x/’ 3% ‘v

}”i§’~%E}:

E, ‘SEE. §%é%J:’é:ZS?:£.% ,
gggi} SEE §}fi;x3:$ ..£a§§:s:§§,<§;r§r&§§ ¥';2'i"€%§i'§FaE'%'§i%, –{
a ;a§3:}U”:* :::»:;3: %*:2:a§z§§, ‘
gm”; YAE\é§2§~;A?é?§§fi}€;%E}§,

‘§’}’iLE§E{ E-EU E{%{E’:§§%EE,
§3:§§.;<;a:_;;a §}Z;%'£'§€§{i'i', –

:2, ‘”E”§-Hi i§§’s§§’E:’EE’.”3 E?%§§§fis. §NSE§§%:%%{?°’E; l{::7;f;::?:*;’¥–;_V’ . ,
?€€},2é%} 13′? §=’L{}{}§%,
;1s;;~§::>;<; ms:;;g3%,
i'»é§E3PE'%.f'%$i, §j}3'.S"£"; zsggnzsgzmg
l:1%E1§'R§§8§3£%'E"E§{)E5Y :*r:«:; _ _' _
.§3»§?A?~§€3':§¥ ?€§fi;.?%AG';%E§E€:._ , ~-,.m,E%Es}S?{f}N§}E§E'~§'%'§§

'§'%£§§§»'fs*if,j§EZ% "ii; !_éi«f:":;,«:¥5;étf; EE?%i}E%:§% E¥§{:sI.'?'§'§{}?¥E :?:3{z__; <3? ax!
£§{":'"§' A€;i~xi??€S'"§ "-fE_'i4§£«: '=.;J;:;::;3.4,:;;;:}{}*? ?;g;~%,:§;e:;;;._§?e§-.:§;:*x:::~ 3=5{>.:§99;;2:}§$ mg mg.»-:. E3325: {:9
WE zgzmzggzsgzfi ‘.:v§A:%m”:;y
;x:,,mvz§:;{_a ‘i”‘E–¥E « <:§;_m':a%: §}§?:':*§*:*:€;:-§ §*'€__3§E §:::’s3a:?:<;:<s
f%'§:H<'::_{:§ t§E§E§E<:Ef~§'af}.._§%i§*%E%§£;'%CEZ§¢§§:F%T 53;? {f{}?vIE3§.«3E\§$;%'2"1€}'§~é.

2'§§'Pi*rZ,s%E:$ e:i:<_:zvi:_:_m we §?-we :%£}§i.«E§S§8E{}§%7 ':'§~:::'~;

' _§:§;§g'§;j'~:?,§f§%:: "::.:gi:»2–,%;zr'T§* §i):e::§VE:RE:i} Ti%'E:Z §'<:§§;1_,m&v':_:x;{;:

dUEj}G?viE§:"~E"F

.. :'E'"7fE':,zE::a?-fie iW<§ aygsfiaig 233:6: (§§Z'€:{.'€fiC§ ;:g2§i;3$€ EEK: asii.-%::a.:*€Z

AA €§a.€§é. }€}.,{}¥%;2{}(}"§ in M,'£L('i.N0.59§f2G{}i§- '{}aSS€:'{§ E72}; s"€§§s:.§"§.€.2:*

E%{:€?§€§4€:':n'€' {"§§:»;:Lfi:$ 'T:"§§f:::;¥:3ai, e%§'a::3§«.<:E1:<::::Ei {far §f%:{}§€. fhézt

V' " *E'réT§:::2§::»3;§'}

' E K /4

2? Tim gziavanafi Q?" a§§&§§m::i;' E::$':,:ra_:;§t§::

in MW: §°é0,§418§2%€;3'? is far gran": 9:" c:;mp'a%v;m;;§:§::'"¥:;;3_;isL:4»

fim héiaéing E9353 9%" magma iajézih ';a=:%c;@:\::::v. ;0if .§§fir:fia31n§::3t' T

éisabfiiéy as excéssévck The gi'*§£*§'a:ié:& 5:' .§:.}f;;;&:V

céaimafit in ?¢i§5'2% {€0.28 $3.223; ;:%;s; p*<f:a::V%§~._:¢':§€i:T""é;:9;:$ $5239

gma cz21:3;:"i: as mafimfgzgata cc:m§}7é::s7aff3i3:1g

3. Hfiaxfi 9:’*gun3ejnf$’é;:i’: ‘E”..v€Zf}’§VZ:§;. ‘.i3°V},€””.S§§€3 333.4% }}€i’iiSf:{i

ihé: zfinféré 73;i%;}§ai’A3}:;a;;«¢3:’:3?’
A4. ‘– “1’%;é”:%::¢a’:&z*;ifi§«<:311 reczjgxi ciiscésseg that siaimani
$223? §E:;ti;é'€s$~. a€ fha trims af acsifi*emT§ ami ha W33 a

§3a::fi,:az%::€ ii} rm cargyizzg 9:: fiuaiaess, Thzémfgzsrm the

V iéghéiy E33153; £316 mfinthly igzccxmfi Gf ihc

Rs.4,{}§{}j~. in the acaiéefiig flag ciaimant

a%=133~%3:i::xe{§ gfiavaus inguries reguifing in 53%; in the right:

" Jiépyezf Eéémfi ax;-ié 25% to the right iawfir iimfi, The Trihunal

has rightiy {aka} £116 fuzlctiaziai &iS3bi}i'€}7 at Efiiffés.

}
ffix./J'

x 5; 'R.

.’\M/),

§4″u.::'”§h{::’, %}.m:*%,fig Eifgéiifi, {:3 f§’i{i’ sag»:-i aw? i’.E.z.s_’;% s::T~§.’«”§:’:.:::2′.«”:.;”:t?

as 5321.3 t7i3;e ‘.§’:”§E’:s2;::,:.-:».”:§. §’§g§}§’§§;’ ap%;3E§.6:{:’} M» Z11%.2§§§§§}E§{3£1 ‘ ¥: ‘

:’,*i§S’§S 5:2? i:;:<imm= :–§:':z'§[ :'§.§:~:;:a:§';i§.§§}3 iiéii '§"3'°§.%;5'=2Tz,'§.;a.'i– .33:

zfifi er: {"f3§°§.3 §}s:f':§"§?:'a§:1'i'§.€..}§} Of E33, E;7%?:%,{.}€}{} ,1 ~ §.1;'2§'§§:j'§" Ea», '

E §<;::~::':%§ 53%" 4"'

%"§Ii{'?€}Z1§i':? €1.33': :a<:£'(2:.m§: :5:-5 §:<:2"1*,§1:~.2,T:::t:*;:':'tE' <.§:'S:§E.;§.§§"i.}: '1' f"§."_,%.'§i-;':Vv§§.;§§:§§f%i.}é%fI'?§'.}. '

0%" §:§'£€:?f'§iE"§1ii'§'i2:'§.éi§ Caz: m?:i€.%1{:%:~ §§é!§{I§'§3i"§.§,_§'§i'EE§f¥ j::'i'.;:3r :'§E{rg.:L… §v§3z:'~s.3
gm j':.;§;§.§:§.a%:2k% gr<;2::°zT;;<;§ ts; i2*:1£.:ét1:r{z:éi':£: 2s;i€,.§: *':§';€'-%.3ri:;:1ig}fz.é2{.§. zizwsemi,

;'§:':€?€;2'ti.i§:::g£f§, 22$-siig 3329:":=:p§';€:;4;E;§'é§,1*:§'§*zci:f::%§y :'i;:§'z:::é:f"€f=s:taf1§'L