Loading...

Thimmamma vs H P Puttaswamy on 23 October, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Thimmamma vs H P Puttaswamy on 23 October, 2008
Author: V.Jagannathan
'samaji pg ;noq13 pafiv

'm1t>ns'w '9

'G81: LLQ "* EIIBAWIEW
'"°¥*3"€I'«RX'3 SEN 0/at
'IIB§BEtIBN'9'M olm
'fipmea amen @
Hpmofiaqouaw a:;v3[ o/(3
'snaszi 53 tmoqle pafiv

'emmafiep *9   

'1oI.:ns:<:1 wipww
'9917 1.2.9 ---- IWIBJ. Bfiptmw  --
'nqop; 1'l.1'BA1$'3I1.}£§}I...__ 
'nraddox zztetzeuemn rim  IE7'

"6PAx0{3 '9T3i7.¥'?"P~i'?V  ' 2  '

epmo8:;1:{:}u"ew';2;a1'..o/3   " A'

'$139!; }noq@: psfiy T'

me;3    

. ..  =¥€1'i;r?N @ 
Bpmnfisqofifiyq "-:i.;f@I_ (.2 +3
'smafi W1 ":,'nQs18¥?~?3%'_.

  .  *-- .'V¥§B~I'9-'§3;§;'?'Ei *2:

_ ~ . :' 'Wave amen @
'  v.E11*..P;_¢.0§€it{DtIB]N 241;; 0/3
 " .'§;_r.ea-:;1§ (317 znoqe psfiv

'ziumms '5

..... .. 'EPMOS alga." ,@
B"{}:SAO39II{3'£1B1I§ 3:91 0 [pg
'sxeszi Q; moqwa pafiv

'B'IIIIII'9¥IItII§t{J4 "[

3 NEHMLQH

  Q6521 'ON '}V'.iIddV GNOQEIS hiV'I£1'.E)EItI

   £~IVHJfin"f1v.L\mav>i :10 ,Lano:) H{)lI~«I an; M1



éfipn? two 911.1: J0 era 91:1 no 30051239 '0N'V'&i ms: passed

9003105 P919? 991099 we ummfipnf am 1813838 -3-C1-:3" 

sq; J0 09}; uogoag Japan pang geaddv puoosg .n3{nB:;g

( ':-3 10; awmapv 'om 19'1T91¥101¥9T¥J?1d'ST¥1\E_'§iS $37 ')' "  :7_';V.   .

s:g1:zapuo(is9;g~~   A. s 
'$30 02.9 ~;o3.11s:c:_s'~:9s1€w A ~ ~
'HHIBJ. "9«md'i\['4L 'mom -1"-I:m"Ht1%a   
'afieyggp, 1_'lfBdd0'}] *e*{rep;uto»3as1aC['.Q/3. T 
'szxesui afqnaqe pafixgé
. _ 'Bp,2_u10fis3"a1é§g_ 0/M 
V --«..'E13m<*%39I}'9.w ~-WEE' 0 _/(1
   [   '?'TP?'S'3 '17

  :' "~'.10!:11*t'_'[;;~   osge
swam mam Aiq pagg zr,1g:>3;3,;)L:if;1;ft1'"£V':f;'iiV,;t9tm1Btz1.::;cI

put; H0§SS9SS(;f I   .£§§1iIfi%{d mp, _;o 1§I'1S
am pasmap  311199'  91; 9oLreA9;.fi 119:9
{arm pasdde 'pfuo:)_Qs  Vpfijsefiiéi amaq 11:10:) mm 9131 I1;
  JG ségfzmussaadax {@391 aqg,

: 31'I§A<iOf[0_; sup, p:;.I9m_;{:;p

 55?; AA'A?3__p  fiugztaaq .10} I10 Suguzos [amide SELLL

V ' itteAB¥Bw '('*?1C} :1?) 939:1? '(W13 am .:0 am am I10

 1.

€;’3V6I’4(é£:I”T’0N’s’0 H1: Z(}0EZ’.»f.”£”{ P9191) 99-mp PUB ‘1’€I’=?U13}?'<1F

ptm pascidra sq; 3t£§SS¥_ZtIIS¥_2p 'xnppew '('II(]uIg)

E

4

@3389 D991) 9138 p9.I91S§39.I ‘B .i9{)II¥1 B[_3A&Og2)I{i’.)II’8]N

QHC} mm; 1§:1J9do.1d ggns gm pasmqzxmd pm; £91.11 gem

swam f§,I{10{} {egg sq; mopq 9313:) ‘smrapuaggp 911;, .’ ‘4

”[I{)§1Oi.Il’i_fI_I’§ zusuerufiad ‘

30 _}9’§[9.I genuanbssuos 9113 88 {pm 131% ,t_i?€’>’g?.;*1=*g’.I:B{:}:xp 4′ 2

.10 J’=3¥{91 9113 10; mfinos mumxd m:1__ ‘1uéptw.19p : A

91;”; Kc; JROAI3} Sm 11; p9J,no9x9 pgap mp iie’-

‘9.1o;939tLL ‘p9ss;u1s’§p -sum’ .Lé’q3-.A%%é}{{91eum{n
ptm tunes snn Alt; pspuamax 1.1391111;-A112; V§5§i.’,Si1§”p”e9{

199.133 paxgnbaqo ta-_ [II_

smapuagap pLI<jd:$é' i}§I."iS 1911199
ma 0:; p:).:.z9_;a.I ciépé fl§S.f;J9do1d mm 91;: JQAO

11:181.: 0U"9ABI§[_ gfiisqj 3;;gr_z:_1'–3{d @1163, go txzytavgi)

am ptxe s1ueptI9_;9p puoaas

.913"; uoysnnoo SBAA 919111 191;: 99233

5:; 1; '&;,.;§dQ,I§ 9195; 91;; ‘I10 .1911’-3′{ pm: {Q61 ‘V(}{ no 0111;

S’8A\ ares gs 111:-}III99.}3’8 U8 pm; -/0()()’g’sg{ 10;

91$! {)1 911188 91.11 {[98 O3, p99.I3’E3 SH ‘{86″[ QQ1

(1

‘K
91;; 30 moneg LII_ paap ems sq} go txoyimosxa sq’; gem })UI”i()_}

1.¥I”lO0 SEQ ‘KIPUOOQS ‘S1¥_I”E3p{1’C~3_;3p Qlfi }() .I(){_)[I9A

911:; sq 0:3, stzsddeq ogre oqm ‘”BpAA039[[‘:)’£IIE.’§\{

Sm pun tum t:99m19q_ 01:1; pajama gfes go gusmaaffie, ”

9m fitzymouoj g;;..I9do.1d 131-3; sun go ‘{1’61a.2:9$s:.Qd_:V.”

me! gem _gl_T3¥.I[8′{d am gem tI0{S1″i[:i)’£I():)V:»)I.[‘1 ‘pégfifd. : V’

gsuappxa 91;} Bupzgpgsuoa Jaye ‘ptm-v.._§;;i1ss§. ;2:::j0;3§’g3;:ii-2

am pm: muss; 1q31_t9 p9IHBJ§~..v_”S9Ii.;’I’é’d

puma pgesajoge 9111 go sgstaq am’ i:13 ‘j_1;1E’t;::} -1,,

.1;:–;1S 911:: JO fessguxsyp. ‘sputnoxfi
gsaqtg [IQ sq”;

pm? asgoci €}L[1: §)Z9t]z&*;..p;)ifiBOBA osqe }_;§1u;H[d
9%?! ‘W111 P3Pfi91I’fi’é’9:.’_49C’Ié G%€§?§§_ii: 9Q 01 9¥Ci’3!I
seas. .;;:.;3:1g9;d_%fA:.’;;”q1 go ‘aloggxgtu -guzepuaggp

91,11 _A1’::~:__V.1:!”{rV:m-.13} qonm pznnoaxz; pgap 9133 sq”;

:;i3z;;4xofi0i monag :1; K1.19d01d 131$ 911:; 1199

.15 ‘;Li3}:.I ($u paaq S1tI’£i!{)II9_}9p 9113 50 .i(}p{I§)A sq;

:”‘P’«’:3’»’ ?i+’32%?;¥:a’-3%? ‘{E’1é9I Kti”9 911811 1omw9 1:361 ‘9’8Z U0 Jmtiretfi

Z 2 ‘ Ir; mpusn sums X1311 9111 KC; pmnoaxa pzaszp

‘j:;:§f1b9sq_ns 91;; “L{()}.”1.S $9 ‘pm; A1.I9d0.Id’ 1313 9111 go

.s.2*:j;.fiUm0 9111 amoagq pen’ X9U;1 ‘9.IO_;QJ91{.} ‘pug 1361 wytz;

%

M1 J01 IQSIIWJO pammt 9111 we tnBun.fUBw’s°c1 ms

S3I,IB”{{9€iIdI€.’ am 10; {QSUHOO pauzezsg am p.I’t39I§ QAEQ 1

*:;:gns 312141 at; p;;.19p°gs–:’.’1_c’3:1 ‘*-

pue pzmrmg 3.r.;ms. $91199; on SE passggxiéyp-«smut

19:11:29 240;), mm pzmofi 9211 U0 asuapuad J, V’

93.: go BQICI sq: sp.re3:;.I SB s1uepu9;:;;p–v..:é)’x:{; ;oV.11Q§1£:9i§1§}Vi2 ‘v S

9131 P97199593 0549 11 ‘E399? 9T93 %I_111 JO .$$’I1i”f§V

911:; 18 :;u9s93d 1011 GEM 1{I’E?pII9_;9p-I

31.11 03, pagans pm; gr; .:i§:)t1«9ji)§;(g:-3., go emu

3001 $11100 91’e;j:§d’daT..;i3m<$f§{Q1§j;~ ."-u{1.£:§tii;”t»3[{9d(it3 .{‘QMO{ 9113’ ‘Q

* ” 4;L1g)~”g:’_ip9;i¥3Jc¥ SB ggugegd 91.13 go 11113 sq}

A1{9:;9e;-$111131 ~o:;L’:1§ino3 mm 91:13 pg; 121;; noses; gm’), 5;;

fl” ” :.”f’p9:;fi’px ayes :;.:i:nu98 ‘9 SB peruzzsuoo ac; 71012111520 {II;’£§.'{Q[[

go moAe_; 1:; psap 3193 am ‘9.1o_;9.:I3q1

. ‘i3a1’$.o9x9 sane; pgsp ares sq’; uaqm 1L’f3S9.Id 1011

sq; ‘asneosq p9AO.i(I 1011 Sam S1’£.I’E2pIJ{9j:9p

9

ppsq S; 1u12:pI;:t9;9p sq), go .m0A”t–::_; tr; pmnoaxg psgp ares 91;]

93110 ‘me; 1:; snoauoua sg PQQQBQJ Ii()§SI”l{i)[IOC) am ‘t,{:3ns

$173 ‘ptm 1.11100 ]”8’§’.1″1 sq”; Kc; _;o gqfigs 3901 mam suogs;Ac§.;*:a’« f ”

‘.;;s:;:I’;;’;; fizz pun AYE-‘I go auamaxgnbzsa ‘E? 1011 S; .:z9sI3I.{r>,,ii*:«;1’

91;; go asussmd 911:; ‘ram 39913 11; exam p[ni§m * _ ‘V

t:0;1*a,usy3ag sq: 30 1 L ama SB Ham Ste: .37 afiiugtggm 1 3

L9 pm 98 ‘:29 ‘as: 98109098 mm:>m”eiiI=«.i;z_ pi¥B”13\}’ _I5§9$Vf§

91,11 50 suogsas SHOQHA 9111 go .{3a31;mqus
‘S061 ‘TWV {I0!19~13S¥392E¥ 91I1.A”‘£f 3. S:’Q§S¥15;554ii5i’:v,Si;l0¥~I9A

0:1 3Lrg.1.m_19.I ‘saueygadgléé ‘g

——– ”

-{ms 911*; £4
mp, 11911113 j,t;%;;s;’:;,:d’1Q:1 9’2 {gm ’51 5
1391813 229913 f%5I99_ P9§i9iS.E39v’4iV 9111 -ISPIH1 911::

% -‘$1.19 193’«:.1i3i pm siuaptisésp atn am: 81133101:

;-;>.«x;_)f1G1E’};:s,;7′ ” – …_s1:-mg. 1u:mIn30p

, ;)é}¥’I-§1i1″£ftif..g;\X’9?r&1.v megaq snnoa am .1:;q::,;:qm,,

t[B’:;)(id¥3 Sm”; 50 uogssgmzpe

:C=}’YI_]CV[‘}. 9q1″:;§a’1~ ¥_I0[‘],’B.I{-.”)p'{S¥I03 Jo; A\’i3{ go uugzsewnb

étrzmonos mu 99mm 981: mos SEILL ‘2.

‘ D1033} [IO fE.’§.I91?3HI

9:51 pssrusd pm; 0123 “BUZI\3’q”1()qSI1.IR{f{‘S’]AI LHIS

‘ I

:;:x9 paap 912$ 9111 8tI;.mo[{q;__ :

z€;u9d0.1d gms am 30 xsumo ‘Q1f1{C)SqB 911:1 Qtxtaoaq V ‘

sq; ‘U0 3:91:31 p’£IB Ktuadmd }1_T1′.-3 3113 go : ti6sI_7ss¥$;:.:-:}?.s’.;.ox:l:’ V’

1nd gem. _g:J,t.a;Ie[d 9:11; 381;; patpggmqns fi1;§1£I;ta*4{iij§,i;r;9puoV§is;;;;;»». j,

sq’; .10; gastmoa 9911.199; am ‘pueq Qua,

., ,. ‘:f;§f1<;9{I0.3.I::;

91 uogsssssod 1:; Supq
[em 91;; go fiugpug. 91;),
01 tzsamgfi smn. gms 9m max;

p@AoI::I9.I SBM seq oqm ‘§«,-‘gyy(f{
go muapgas am A”:;.I9do.;d gyms 9111 30
uo;s§;.9s$§)d 19133. panytxjtqns [asunoo

p9u.m:>;,_9′:;1:i””>;’:Q¥;1,1.i;v::s§::a:)i§ SI tzoyssassod 9131 S13 re; 31;; ‘5

“2§§.Ie>c;1{i;£:6{:”:;{t1p9I;:>s gins 913 JO Jaumo atgngosqe

mqt; pgaq gmeq 3,011 pmoo nnoa mm

j, ‘:4;$_’.’1{‘;¥_’;$§3′._1v?V8>’1;1′.”;A””§)’t1″Ifl3 99118 10:: mm ‘epmo89q’o:mw .I()’pU91\

V -»;5[%2s zguanbasqns am, 30 1un0:x)”s3 1.10 gm; firm

Sfimfifivv .l31.111H.-‘9’£d 9:13 so flonsanb am 2191111 ‘prr-Em sq 0::

8

. I

4′

go gzrgod I1; .2t:;~§:{.Iea sum. irgazgq s:u:m;{9dcI*3 sin go J1’10A”8_j

U7! I'”CI’XiE'[ P99? 9199 3413 T3111 9? 999$ W10′! KCE i393nP0-Id

S1}{I£}Iji.H”l30{) 911:; mos; 39913 9; mqm ‘.IE}13’8I.fl 91,11
J0 139691:-3 sun pgassnosgp z§{2>:;1a*.:oq_131:: seq :1.mo3 ft-3g,r_; ‘A “”
‘me; 11: pmm em LIQ}fB’3, sq 1ovzm=::> money ‘

at}; ‘mo_;;).19qi1 ‘pill’? .Ia.z1s_fi:>}_{–qI1g 9:13 ‘A
swam paap 9123 any; ugqm 1u9s9.zd xsaztsrr

mm mm 131911 anmg m.o[3q_ .SZ1.§I’l(};)…u:i;i!;[},”” ..f_?;1_ :

“mm H; –’11{§:s»~:lfL’j;,iri;>ci'{§::gi1′:«”;::t,;Lf1,….ér1 p.It-339.1

{$111511 mcgsq s:;.mo:) Vpgus sq IP81}

:1″; .I’;;*q:1:;)qzn S; péxgispfstidi)” 91;; ‘uogazapgsuoa
Jog pasgm sg mLf;4._4_£v;B1 j_0 ‘.{iO[;§S311b p’~3:1Lre1sqns am.
()1 pzvfigl $9§1u’%ad_..9’t{1 Jo; {asunoo p9(I.£B3{ sq:

Kc: 99fi*-?”% ‘3’té’:”¥SA’S¥v”?”:i’il?’*9:::”PEBSQJOJB 91:1 .10 imfin am “at: ‘1 1

‘9:)”£x:).19;91t1§

10:1’. ssop :1.mo:) {£31.13 91;”; 5:1 papxoa:-L;
j, ‘;J?i{V3″* ‘~:éJ;0_;:9.I91;{:1 ‘pm; 9fB’S JO Jusmgafie 30 9112;)
. §;itIgs;t§A3 _}_}.”§1[1″§l’-3[{i sq; {mm p9r1I1:u:1(>:) uogsssssod

minqns 0:; sassamgm 9:11 pufa _L}{3,£I{1?3″{(II Sq; go

6

2′
is

umggansfisx .I9do.zd sq; 112 [)91t1QS9.Id sq

– ‘same

[feqs ‘[l?}I10[1€IO .10 Aixosgndmos sq uog13.t3,sg39.I
qons .IQI.[18{[A’1 ‘1OV Sm; .IQp'{_II”l pa.191-3:39.: sq {)1

1¥.IQ’EII’lC)0]T) titans ’63 pm: 33 ‘:9 suogqoss 1.1″;

pgtxotmsm 3998:) am :11 1d93x3 — ‘uoy29.1;sg5a._;.. .

Jo; guawnaop guasazd 0:; suos:.iz2g ‘ ‘*=.t«3;,,_ ~:’ 9′

L…

I.2{9’ptI'{1 SB am suopzms qsyqm ‘gg

3.173 ‘i1:)9ds1=.2 sigqtg 1.10 :;q8§{ mogqg ‘:;5g«

am 40 suogogs 1lH3AQ'{9.I 9111 39$}E-5j.3Q”‘fiQfi11:3,;;s§S:.}a
am go suegsgnoxd sq’; o:,_ s1__1 sat:-‘$31′ ._’:’ .ffir3;gg,fi§§§;H-qy;_S

9111 9»I0.:993no9x*»?4*~3¥?z§A53?1®{41fJ 91$; %;sq,es llmpuagap

911:; go 9:){I$sqH:v;§i1*iiT;;’o ‘i)ti’;{1u98 13 1011 sq
03 p1_9t{ sq {ms é;t;t{e}{;§d¢ife;’ 1:11 paap aftasg 913;}.

J9{J[32)l[m sg p:9,19ms”£tl~3 Oi: 1I”I.;.I ‘ tgugod 1:1″; games fiupq s1Lm11acIdta

1399;) 9139 sq: go 339; sq], ‘9.to;9.19ILL

Z ‘ Huo p91t’1:)9X9 swan {asap spas pies sq”;

%%tr:5V=9>Aaa ‘z–d’X:H 9! HDIIIM ‘.I.I!’1II”‘§’E-‘Id Girl 50 .mom2g tr;

.’¥?*’=”i’:5~’-?fi3′ QTBS QILL ‘I861 ‘VI 2: 110 pszrtaaxa Sm 1: P119 91:12:;

Oi

3%

tr; ‘.IB.¥1S1_39}_{ sq} ‘maddva os “.101: up S'{3£()S.I9d
11:21:13 [[19 ‘.},IIQp'{3:)B 9′{qE’p§OA’B'{I{1 .10 ;{1§s;s:;a:)9u
1u98.m 0’1 fiugmo ;; ‘1eL'{1 pspI_Ao.1d

396 P39 98 ‘+26
‘gag suogaosg .1;-){)[It1 UO[1B’1[19E~}$)JZd 10; pamoue

awn 9111 Hwmm lame 8111-12219318921 9111» 9+1’°J’=’~>.1″%iH %

szaadde ‘pwsazzoje S1’-3 pgspxomnn §}UQ§1?2 ?Jt4;§,.. A ” ‘

stfigssia ‘s9Ap,B1LI9s9..Id:9.§ .1§9tp,_..1{) “3,1i9{x1 no0{3 . A’ ” A’

qcms Butmsaxa suosgad 9q’1″v._$;3QHII1. ‘–1;)v._ A ‘

Sm: Japan psalazsfim II9″iISV.1U?§Uf11D9P 011*

’68 mm 88 ‘LL ‘Q2. ’69’gi%’ ‘kw szgpgmss
1.1; ptm med Sm: V11; p9};_Iv;_ji=3f;7£VVIt2:§_V
91:1 0:: 109€<1¥1sii H4} –

fit: uozzv-a$?5’3¥%%%M ~ *’%J0;féc:.% fi;t3fii”~¢Ef ‘vs:

– Ji9Jg;etIga.I9q

.IQI.HIBt{1Ep91éG1j}U9fi{3flFf pma p:9:m:)9×9

3 f{“9LLIO:’;1;(“;’–~]i@-:.I&$v:¥§;0d A “”‘k’§f1 P9310111???

}*2;11p  "    .10 Qagmussgldal

  11119873 am ziq (:3)

.10 ftxosmd

-4 qzsns go US$498 .10 9A!_I1E’.1I.I9S9JZd9.I sq”; Xq (q)

.210 f19p.10 10 99.I:);;p 91;; Japan

‘£913.10 10 amosp 12 30 A/{dos

T . 23-30 9$e::> 9111 1:1; ‘.10 ‘gums mp. Japan

8u1_ttm_:e[:) .10 fiugnoaxa uoslsd QUZIOS Kq (132)

I?

7

*€

{fairs oqm ‘mnsgfisg-qns 8 L[1§AA pafipog

sq flew (1) Uonsas-qns 01 osgaomd :;>’qfJ, .1apm1

uouosxgp £2 10; IIO}’1t3:)”§[ddB Kim ({7}

°.re9ddB

03, os uosxad qons 30 1q31.1 9113

go _;[;)<3ItI:£§q Kgsgms 'wtsfie .10 11335312 I

'9A'§1B1II9SQ.I(iQ.I '9 S8 fitzgmgticie

uesmd Km»: go 9913:} 91;)

sum Kain mm Svfiauvk Y

azogsq fiupreadde $1.IosJ9(§_V_;§{;:;

Kluuapz 9111 0: sfiitesuréix
azm-ti :l '

01 s3,.Iod1n§IM_V 11,1:

91:1 Xq {:.§93nQi駢::§,_., sjezéa ‘;I,i9I;;nQc:_»y:

qans 10¢’. 19 _;:5;rg.{1..E)u:>

to)”

pm; ‘3}U3[II113()]_;) am Vp91no9x:;: f..

(B)

— uodnmsm

Nxitvtzs “3tI§:é;$§?¥9a QULL (9)

‘;§i919gjfp_1e .10 snosummuixs sq Alain

(1). \”.7IAvt’I.J\§*1{)€v)§–‘-!Z'{“f_i”§._SVA’,;,f§-i3’V[Z)IE{1 saouanasddv (2,)

?1_g::a.I91é;3;>:;I Kraut guaurrmop sq), ‘Q5 uopsag
” ;ig;put1–‘4_;a1q”éXed Aim J1 ‘am; 91;; 01 uomppe
“‘§i:);;*1jio_u1a\11sg89J .1:;>do.Id am go i;1§3{I1()tIIi’3 am
1131 Butypaaoxa mu 911;; 2 go }UQtiIz{“3d

..,__ Lio mtg; 11:):-mp Aiem ‘sqmotu mo; psaoxa

1011 saop fiuuesdde uI_ /~’ie[:;>p 91;”; msqm $9329

3?

‘ I

%”

3I,I;.191s;8az am Aq psmmexs sq {mus uogensfigx .103.

aszmgdgsoe 9.Io_;::9q 1IZ9UZI1″i:’.)()p 1{.K:A9 gem suoguam 0S{8

$3961 ‘$91113 txonenszfiaa Bmeumx am .10 It 91113 ‘tuov

uogausifiaa 9211 go S’£,IO1S;AO.ICI QAOQB am 0:; uon;ppe.–ifi’ ‘ ” V’ ‘

“‘{I[Q.I3{{3 p9un»i31:;’9m1’1’a_v:g’8 .3 «

pma ‘pauogguam sq ./Dam suomtuns (912
4111989 fissgjomne Kmp fiq .10 ‘g§q;gQ AA
‘goggo tIup,m1s§39a am, 39 9:1
3{I”[‘..ii_TI1b9.I suommns B
U! sloartp luamtmnoa 511913 %{Ai.imi:;>_

.10 msggo qzms fies ‘ :’:U(j§1:§J;)S”§ g)

:1; ‘mm

qzma go udg;”e.af;{s’,£9i” Kgésssnsu

S; &IIotfl:.§i’;s;ifi ” 1.109.196
Aiixva go 9%5!Ié.IB;:§ddfe’ ‘p91u9s9.Id
os Bugsq ‘fioytxm ‘1I:;9u;m:)op
_ V, .10 ‘uo;1¥2:.ns§:u
Suguasajd 1109.196

g1 « 3; ssaauzgm 19 gunzmaxa

fo sxaqm _9.mpzaoo.:c{ ’99

% V ‘s.19p.1o .10 saamap go sagdoz)

Aggfgddn 21011095 sun In 3u_rq1oN (9)

‘QIBIII PIOQYIS SE Biff

II{IOI{AA O1 .iTE3.I’}S§39E{ 91);) O1 1! p.}}’3AA.I(}j {f1.[A\{[}.I0_}

£1

‘I

47

‘e xiq .30 ‘K9’£LIO’111E3 ma ziq psmosxa sq 0:;

Sunxmirnd 1[I9Ifl'(‘i:)Op 9 go gsm am 111 (n)

“3II2)III'{1i)(}1I) 9113 go
Kpoq sq; tr; 1IIB1I1OC-JXQ trta Se psqmmsap

gnq 101; mm sq qsnotp H9119 ss9u_3;m__

13 SB K'{9.I9tI;: 10a {mm uo;1oe<s1r£z.1:;I§vt;{:1'…T&Afjv

01 i;'£I9SSIE% Sm 50 39:10:; 1:; 1u9t1r_3_:)_axa

SB gusmnoop 8 sufigs oqm UOS;IQ::(i.._;'{{I'£3V. .('p–).._

fguammzaop '£3 {:0 pasaqpus L
"E3 .10 tgdyaoal B stfigs oq;y{"uQ£3J9;5i (5))
V
9[qt2p,o39I1 '8 s9$,.1:c'-A=;g;1'1_:; oijm €1'1£§s1QEI'vL)_£;t1g. (q)
Sm
SQXW3 51133693 ti: p::e1m»uueo B
go 1u9m[g;ng 'L.'::'x:-V "€! _;"t)…_?;L!91IIKB€i9.I

am .10; ;{1;i;a¥§.s"s9u1Q_ii;:§q~.o't;;g§"'aI Bmpag was 91:1 ‘item sv ‘$91113 % i

am pug 13v uogensgfigg sq), go suogsgnomd psuogmééimv 4.’. A

gmoqve 911:1 01 1§.m.z3,uo9 sg p:;)I.{i)1E3’9.I I103:s:n{3110$ V’

sq; “M31 117; puma. Se usxeg sq 1omre;) u1’*g1§;:pV , ” A T

gfes mp, ‘1u9s9.td 1011 Sam utmpuagagj ..9s11″t§a9q’

mm Smmotx U: pm-I9 Sm: PU’3.__33V Ak%fi0:éfi–us£9a étxxaoj

MEI go S¥.I0§S§A0.Id ppaszuoge sq: id v”_pL;§’ygf:_; stat;
moo rem 9% ‘-I’3~’f~.19;”-3;~”=*”_é~§*(11:;”#S étfm ,tI Aofi;”E:..,V;§j;§3,””;c> ‘8t1’ip’a9.2 pstzgqwcr) V “M

<._,V%':""s;;1$2;fi.:%e:c4i';'§1;:1no9xa sq 01 psaapgsuoo sq

-Liégpmnfi .10 A”9u.1o1113 sq: SP3

V’ Ham’ :1o§pt_ .10 Jcugtxi .10 [“E’d1i£)II{.Id
91;’; ‘gg udfpég go Qsodmd sq; .10; tmq 103; gm
i9%:89%~9iré% 99 ‘vs ‘as: Sufimss 30 sasodmd
K ‘Jag 1[I9tIInC)Op am Btmuosxs uomgd
01 ppq sq [regs .1o:ua.m:) .10 IIB[p.IE-‘H13
go Kamotue {gens ‘3geun[ 10 1011;); me

go .I(}’f;’E3.IfiC) 11333; E Xq .10 JOIIUII “(-3 go ‘(II:’3’§{).I”!E31″13’

91

(1

4
91.11 moi; :;q81_;1 pm? 911111 31101 KJQA ‘3 max} A”;.I9.;d i},[F1S

SKI) JO {IO[S’3QSSO(i {IE [I931] SEQ SQ T.}”E3I.§1 p9I1’B.I9Z1§’9.I SEQ [NIB

mm 01 1nd S{I0§1’S933I’1S am {[3 paguap S91; ‘zyoutspgng 910;

:0 asmoa 91:1 Un; ‘mlmmd 911.1. JIQSWM 321!”-1U!’BI(i 91¥¥ :.i0, ; _

9C)I.I9D’§A3 9111 ‘z§[.m{nog.rad 910111 pm? p.IO1)C;’#;I”‘i’£()’€)Q’1iQp.yii»-;V»”‘ V’

19139 9111 go mfig 9113, I1; passsssia 9q 0; anésq «s;sT:;”:1i:;{;.zsAV «. ”

pyezas 91;: go sauspym sq; ‘:95 ‘s1éq_fi:I::;11 I..V’1’J,1=3{‘§”eq§}’t_I€§it§Vv”V

am pun aopgod sq; riq 2{1Ia><:Io.vI::;{..V.3,y;y~1S AV-9;;i..I.19_;9.I S”,1,[IB§[9ddE 19131.19; “§>g.1’q3noq1

‘$999 9111 go :1:J9ds;’é x1’iojs:§i;sso§–.__ Smguxof; ’91

‘:;2\;:;e83u
am mfg p9.z9msm=3 *[3;}ét€a.;f:’;;a;1;4’i.Io1_:1s9nb [B1_.’11IIE3Z;S€[I1S
‘am f9j1°39J9H%:§’fV 911*: J0 Imam; HI 1861 9’32:

“91 V. “;::_re’,;1;>’ T33 K:;19do.Id auras A1191; am mos

Qsixoégie ‘ ._ ‘cfi)3 :2 ‘ ans SE ‘ U33 991.11»: 1011 tin
X ‘ , II 9 . .

Kfisdojd E;;s9.z91t1; fire Euguymax tepmofisqamaw

m4_;:§.::V1′:sA_» pgusz go utmsanb sq} ‘apmofisqrmew

H. L’ ” « sum 30 urged Ir; ..I9{[.IH9 psgnoaxa Sugaq

bagp 9188 was 5211 Due met at pwx 9c: 0?: PPLI

.V’*sgé:i;:Iepu9_;9p 9111 Jo moaeg LI; pagp 9333 911;: 93110 ‘Q1;

91

19s are ‘p9II.I:;¥.I)”[IO:) sg Kusdojd gyms; 9113, go Jsumo mmosqe
sq} s13 gguyegd am Supreyoap se mgosuy ‘mopq sunoo am,

30 smaufipnf 911’; “glad {I”_[ psmomz sg [amide sq;

:.;9p.xo Bugzmogog 9111 ssed 3 ‘ssugrq ”
pun Al1.I9do.Id tans sq; go .II€3’£IA&O mngosqtz 3113 S13 . %
sq; Bupxemsp s9 .112; OS mogaq s:;.mo:)
9:11 zspgse Etmws go Ztuguygg 911:; o1V.j;;J:t§:cI

oi), zamseq mm [’99dd”E% 9111 ‘SI1OS’89.I sq), .I(§,’gi- ‘:’z,”[Vf;

_.4″3’3¥’i1Té5éi€>}~I91¥1¥

on salgnmj fiiggptrg p7§r33_V’V’21«L1″1«f”p:;uI:;0:I03 $3; Algmdmd
gyms sun go IIO§SSQ$S0d fitxgéq. 4_;;1;3u§a{(i am spaefiaz
S12 1.:{10:> {e;,;I::_,1 gig’; fiq {3:;r_;1;}ta:9.IV11o§sr1[ouo:> mp, -313 mgosug

‘gauépggfi Bugpug 13 go Smptrg asxamad

gamyg 09112 ptm moggq Si;.iI”102) 9111 go
;{i§.I.it5;3uo3 E’ Bupq ‘fiugptig p1_CB’S am ‘qons
‘1a§.’nvV?;»q1 (mm pzumoueo 0933 1.11103 amygsdde

— ._ A _§T},'(1″{‘£3[€1I 91;; {mm 1199:; seq no;-ssassod
3 p{9q seq tunes $91.13, 9131 ‘p.I0O9.I I10 pssegd

‘:,;:):t;’;>p»;A9 [[3 JQAO 91;: 3’£I?[.I9p1S[IO;f) ‘8[E2S 30 1u911::3a18r3

…. V ~/333
ems

‘ DQILIQSIIOD SI

Zxiogssasfiodv.spgi:e§s.§ s*zég’ ~:s:’–;1=:{ II; 319111 01 9[({E’3′{‘fE3AI-3’ sagpamm

fqoné ‘:~13a,-3’ 12-3 9.19 stumfiadde QLLL

‘ W H ” f.p:;qJt11Sfpun :gta[ 9; uogsssssod mg Bugaq gmuyegd

2 -sis: mopcg smnoo sq; JG fitigptzy 911,1, ‘9p’§SE!

Si

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information