High Court Karnataka High Court

Transport Commissioner vs Srikanthappa on 7 October, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Transport Commissioner vs Srikanthappa on 7 October, 2009
Author: N.Ananda


‘ 5%. I’5a”‘i.$.<x:;f}.<%:5.._"iT3jx;s.§<.

§N T'i-EE Eiifiii C:C}UR"i" 03*?' ;<:.aRNzrrAKA 5%.'? BaN:}g§1:;:éf<§i'VVJ.A. V

§I)A:T'E;E3 "E'H'§S "I"EiE 02% ms; 0:?' 0c;:1'<)Esia";¥e';A«'.;2ut:g~.: "' '

BEFGREE

THE fiGE'~I"EsLE§ :vi§"j}rA._ t’;’}E1i<:f=:_I,::;1i§: {§E£t:%e*%'* V ,…A;::pe-Bani

{By S}fi§.f5;§§I},#.§i§.1géI:§_i: &—-v:'~T.~ih;:§'na, Advectalzes}
Sliicanthasgpé: %

Sfg. Kcn1pé.::Z.gh _ _

Aged abazii 36 §g<':ars* .

R13» fgggzimda ‘fifgiags $5 V903:

Nfisxz if a: iéfiikfzajamma Extensiczn

‘ __I{‘e}ts_:,” V%Ii{}VEi?::’i:’§,i§&€’:§..5E;:§:§-,}:’3a .., R<;$§{}n*:3:*3I;i

Exiiaxadmnizafi £a§,*m2w?:r*{‘§ {§2t.9:4:”§ 2{}.fl?5§s.i”2f}€”iS, gszsgsasad tit’: Eiéiffi
.:x%g’:9;.$;23@a, an this 5335: 0%’ the ifiivii Jtaicifgéz :_5-.;;~.BnJ; {is mg; a” ‘M 5%
” §*j!i’§._;j””§’;’ Fioienaraaépufaa awarding Qmnpensaiierg of §~%s.2,35_,{Ji3EZ}f~
with %~r:fm*:::sz«.f. at 892% per ;;~;”m:1n1 fmnt thsté 3}’-77%:-E Q? gésaéiétirsré tifi

‘ rcaiisatiatmi

This appaai coming cm Eb? admésséan this day, Elbe €;”‘ur”t
:’§§:?§vm*Fa~r*% the §’nI¥aWir:g:

in

JU’f}GIv§EN’§’

The mattar is fistsd for adI:aissi£;11,_xx«*ith Q2′?

isameti Cc:-11;1sai for parties} ii is 1:3 E-tén 1.1115 fair fi;r;._ai~i(_’

2. The KSRTC has filed appmj in: “:ja{i~a.iii¥i0i§ of ”

compazzsation.

3. i have heani Swamyg Iearnmi

Counsel for KS§{?{; £:7:l{V1H(§L ‘s”;{£§if:.15’s;’§r_{.L:§§3.Ei}.%SV{i€i1}3f§3E1, Iearneé;

Cxéunscl for ‘V ‘

ii»; ‘The: is–_ih:_§ I”:-1_1;h-er of deceasaeci Nianukumar.
‘§”‘E}r: ziecaézseai was._.ég;é§{s. fdli3.§i1t 8 yearg at the mag ef acciéent,

Tha Tjfibunai'”§1:fii0z§?ing”v§hVé”iéueigrrcxtzztlits I’fif3{3ITfi{§ in ;Z(}€I§ ACJ

1, …«;}Q ‘iii: i:;§:.i.e “*~(§3Si3 éf§””‘§vfa1;§1zeievi and ajzotizer W31 Fvftzsafia’

‘aii§»§. ‘%2;*fii{%§};er}, 2066 &C>J 9125 {$21 the case {if $111236

E4313 ‘éiid “V3. Surfgakazzth 813:3 (3’¥fi1EI”S:§ ané ;L’.€}{3? z%C:J

_1éi».’:34 Lin’ ‘the C338 af fssiahammtzé ‘éfasfifizm. ‘ifs. ixrazii Ha anti

f_”e3$1c3$*£’.’i<:e.¢1"j§ hag axszarzied cempensatiezx Gf Rs.2$;3$fiGQf ~.

5, 71:6 iearfisfi -:ffi9'€::135;:=*.i £31' §<{.SE"T'C Wouissi suirznit that

V {3()1}Z}fpfE:1'1SaIi011 awaxzitzi. 33}: Tzihxinai i3 ssenisrarjgz ta tltm

J\? » 6' .<s,.,

judg1na11t.0;f't}3e :§u1:m':me C;0u1'tT, r€;3»011.e(i in 3
(313: {ha case af Lam Waa:i§3wa Vs, Stats: cef "e~:«.::£€§A 21-
decisian ::3ft.E:.:is {T;0u:r"£., I'{'§1'}OI'§;E(i £11 EL.j?;?,-G(}3A_ 'lfiflsvffxf _ V

§, The ieaxfneci (ji«:3z.111se:i*f'03;f_. piaiximxii» wm;a.';%fi ii}???

impugiieii aivarci.

’73. The cieceageaé. Ei¥:;:jg;’ wa*;~;; ‘£§f !J:£?i£;I’€,_8 §’f:é1¥’S 3: ‘die:
trims 0I”a:::CiI.:i€;z1{¢ 3:; Va (i»3~:::i;ési0:3.:V:’€:f§fi§«;sJ§’a'<:f:.§ in .f;3£3€}%§ A€.I:J raga; {$11

the C385 of _.::z§:Qth;';–;{ :"fe".s'. Pa} 311$ others},

the S11:§%re1né' £T;;g<s_::s:"r7fh2;;":; "1'%f?'f'f3E3I'i'(fid; 5:} {"116 aaariiétr _;'11d.g1116:nt sf
'(ht SEi§fiI"*:11EEf3 efciiifz: __ "'§,3.:.a Wa<:iE}:wa's case; wigaitfiiiii

pcs::un.ia3:'§; €'1€3v§?}§V}(EE'3,§€§;?:1I:i;C;}.1 i:i.i3A Rs, 1358,6985» was g:*a1:te€§; fer

tixev-fiézagig Qf cE'1:ii$:i':i».:–:;–«Taged bsttsvttan :3 and iii} wars, '§"'§.:€

'fffxas accragatesi 1. _ , '* . .. 1

3 L. 'j_ sum (sf §€$;?Es,0€3€};' ~ 33 ::Q:'1–g::r:cu:1ia_{jg»*

gf::2e:ii';-

‘ . V €301B1)f£i1$:i3Z’i0§1.

‘ ” fig fag casa an hafisi, ‘£325 cieceascsi $29}; was aged ahoui

.. F yams at the ‘£i.§.T£if3 9:” as:’>:€:ie:’i£n*£§ “f’E3e.3:*e§§>r¢§ ciaimrcmi. is

fififiiifia to §)z3e::u;:’1iar§; C€}II1’§1)€i;i1S8fi€}I1 :31?’ RS. LS{},€3{“§Gj ~ 3:151

:n0I1»–13ecu,niar_§z” <:t0m*g€nsaI':im1 sf Rs.7.C»,(){}{};' –. u

had :10 _justifica1:if :3€’%..§;?~ef’~..

annlzm. “”E’her€i’1;;:’::, inmrast is I’ii’,{§”E1C€(:ig1’i£3:’5′:55′<:;2 pef~ai2n};m," Z

8. in the resuiét, I 33333 $3215′

U0Rvێ1 *

Tha afppeai is a€:<::en'it'4e$¢.i-T. award is
mctciiiied. £§»e}I1;g3::§fi%$;aai0£:§ f awzmfifizi by
Tribtinai jg 'T-biz' said 311101111: shaii
C3133; j;:§:5féSt: rim Clam csf petitian iii};
the date €;:f and iI"£V€:S¥iIH:€I1E 3§1ai1 136

in the ratia ézvaiveci in i~Z*_:€'~ii?ufpz1g:1eci awam'. The aznozmt in

Aggieyzctifsfi. "i3e t:*e1::.$§3r:z'a{£ to B:L§<.":T at Hsianamsimxm.

a3"%¢Vi:i3;Z:z.3::?ifs3:_::T to 3363:" their cams.

Sd/~
JUDGE