High Court Karnataka High Court

Union Of India vs Sri M S Gangadhara on 13 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Union Of India vs Sri M S Gangadhara on 13 February, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) And K.L.Manjunath


1% was 3:33 caaaw a? Kfifififiififia fif EafiGA;as x 7I’

agxgn TEES $32 13″ gay 9? FEaavAg2,m2sg§’ -4

PREGEWT

$33 Efifl’B$E ER. §.§, 3:fi&£&fi§§”cg:§E é$$%§§§ _

fififi

$33 EB§?BLE fix v§fi$%:£3,:;§,m$§§§§A$§

WEE? EEEEEIQE-§9,3:53;2§§gagg§a3§

3K§w§E§: _W
1, finiag §f5:n§i§;”‘» _,
Efby itg §§¢ra§ary,n
fieggt _,» fig ._§¥_’j:-3*tg ‘ >
flak §havangw§éfi”$e1hi:§L

Q: §@st fiagiéx §§§&:a;} “”

S5§gR@gi@;§_§a;a¢&”E§afi§
Ban§aieré4l, ‘V5 ‘

M”

V.?h&R§§E&§fiQx sf Eéstai

. $@rv:a&$§4$Qut§ Karnataka

L Eeg;§®,ME§;g¢e Raaég

‘ 8§§§3ls$$~;;V

fix The $§§:@§’$u§ex3aten§&fit Qf

§a§t.Cffiéés, Myfiare fiivisian,

fiyaaxavéfi. .. yfiezwzeasgs

_=._f§§g s::¢§§§mara5h, $3553:

“A,_ fi}S.§aagadhara fiffl iata

fiA.Si&&égaw&a, 53 yaara,

.,a§:§a;ea.?,«.{a.3.;;~;fa:s $a5§’:;fi %;:3 be éixaziziaaazi an £3’i.7£:v2é3§5$

~.iE::4E;«:*a=:aii:¢€:?._.; iiiad a ::’@”§fl@”§~? yatitimzg bafazra thsa

” ~s3.:?*:§;:&3:5 9: ‘§1§ ifiieii an aypaai. bafaze aha Cezitrai
a§;’*:;::::._;.é’t,za;t;;:?e Ezgbaggal 5, Bamgaicze aezmh £
.¥§r;i,_3:31;’a:::a;i afizfir ‘érzueaxzizzg aha yarties cam ‘rim: the

». _’ xéiarzaaixzggrm-3;: that aéfimaiiy the zsaagamszzdmzi: 7§”:a§g§.f§fla§ >§;§:5:§2:
payabié %.@ £2323 Qfizaiuvazajzzf 3*:§a§§§:&;§*.:-éihi A’
‘i:»:s*ias:a.td$ a;:rI§;c3; age :{2′.%€Z1$3:,.=EE’1 air’ ifiae 037
Ha was fivarveii with g”§xi*;:4c,”Z:e$;’V’VL’Ta§%f §;;a:4:§es;;; ‘V§a§s:’»;§fi, 23::
the 53:39; 3;: e23«:.§:..:?:g.::*z,§:1;§,s3,§::t $3? 365%: 33i’§§'”f;SZi*G§’i4

Eta: e§§.@3.3;:’y . ‘flag re;m:5;?§+:’E Vfé3@,;z::*g:2:@;’.”z’ia by

.235; Qrsiamf §a’?;é<f§ :'1:'~'§i:'E€:-'$5:/".6"—V'
:3 , Re$?§€é§<.§e§z¥; éf;é;;:;_;r:.¥;§;.,é*.i;&é§ tha arafiex aaf
ziisntigsai. "fr:-55:; V' ~:.,.'§'.s$'1T"\';«"":jt,'E£i'29_, _ pzeéexrefi 3;: a§:§ea;':,

EZEQEQZE ?=:7n§ .._4§;L:a¢i:¢F:§. " Eastai gexvgceaf 33:21:32

§é'§t{"".:v§a$'i:é;:,_ afiiiexag ??§':i€»§§ gaetitgen $31233 tax bé

gé3;s:§:;:§$.aa::" Q'? a §,2i}§§g §1*':e.a.:.§;er;§:::§ tizsazsa 3:221:93

fig/%

-4-

§a§?1°’1£:€.2′:U£$ ta Cheizgvaraguf Efiaiiaziava and

btit ingtaaé 523:’ abtaining tkmgrfi ::.;:;;@xess;i©::s..::’::§§’x.t3*3§

azfaresagié gerscnsg ha ‘gzadg :3;:~s:%a;:3i.[;*z-;ea_

hizrgraggiaas an ‘$333 mane? v..:’2:-ri;:.:i;ez= ‘é’EQ*§§3Gfi$,V”‘§§.1?-f}§§ tiiaav

mike; mzimays af Etizair fmzfiiziéfi. Vtigé gijtifiiiiié
that he 3135 fai§1 §e1ai&_ iia _ A abacsizzta

intaqzity, sexvige @fV ‘§hé ,g£a$§§§§$nt was

temninateé. “§x*’_;?;3mz:;:a§;:. . ..’r;:a3:9a:%i.§é@ri:;’g that the

X?&$§+§i?’;d&:1i’?;: ;§§i2t3′..__ 3:2-. f-f§§£”§:’§§§;é%:;3§:@ “-tlrze
§a§;é&3 éggzzifgiéér ‘éxfiarf gizzfia ha hag?

ac:::§r:;1″%:f:e&€iu”z:§§§;’i’§g :»_:*1*g_”2:«,E.f.;2;ru:.”‘:*§r :2: 315*’: tax’ mag 72%

__’t,”::1::?:b;.j_3;z@:t’&5es1’i:*§_j$ Q: tha payeeg, intexfsareé W332;

V.é::§&’v§%’;$ is azaiied 3:; quégtsmzz in this getitianw

M v<§_,_ iiavging heaxd the amzngej. Em: tiza

" –..~§a*:;t.;iL§ner3, we are mart 3.3: at pczasalticn ta take an

F

-,@&

$5 in the xeguit, zggs §&t;t;an §s §;sm1s§éégg_”;.”

= “~”:X2?&2§§