High Court Karnataka High Court

United India Insurance Co. Ltd, vs Manohar, on 5 October, 2009

Karnataka High Court
United India Insurance Co. Ltd, vs Manohar, on 5 October, 2009
Author: N.Ananda
EN "¥"HE iiitiié tZ";(}U"'"f' C}? I{fi.RNAT°AKA AT BAN.G$Li5__}§?3 " 

DATED THIS '1"':iE: 0:--"3'i'H DAY «)1? oc:'::>1:3§;'§<~..gcséj59  % ' '

8E;F0R§: 

THE HON'B.LE: MR.».T.:;z$T:'CEE~:., Afififliggg». , " '

MISCELLANEGBS F'2R8"i' éJ*?i53AL N.o.'5.3_6'3; £2685' mv;

EE'I'W"EEI'4i7:

1.

3
L.

w

 _   
I'viiSE"sI(.?:f\%__ Ra::m3, .I3.fn'i1{fiLfiRE;5'60'--€32?,
31? RE:;:e*34m.:.,--';{:1?;"<1Q§;:.._V  V V »

IVLIS. UNiT'E';.iT) iI°~iEi,.a%".«.-..i:fv*::3¥k,I'J':'V\'<}%.i§§£tZ?§E2'.§'it§§i_i§T"£}.,

 ~E_NSU: §:.A:~:sf:§:._é;c:; ---I_:f1:i:::~;_,
s,11AN;<:;'A5:A NP5RA.":"A~NA BUXLDING, I\.-'LG. ROAD,
Bz§N(Z%ALvGR£~¥';"+-560 61am'; 1- ' '
3?' ITS MAMAC;jER'.' » .__ " ~ 4. 

 Q. MP§ H"E:.$§§ g;f;v<:::c:ATE)

"'..._A/:}a%%§';;2_:;;;§;fa"'$;e. LATE SLEBRAMANL
'  Acvagfngégiaour 35» YEARS.

Kiiffiiflfii $U<3{§N§ DIG. ifiT'.El SUERPsMf1NE,

,  Ac;-ED A3013'? 29 YEEARSR

' ' KU§:§Af"<E Kfiififififlffifi Dfii-. L;5{i"'E: Sflfifififififlfif,

AGE-if} ABOUT *2'? YEARS.

£iL£f§RE 17€'ff§?': Jf§.VR§'§T'HI Mi~1"fTH;%R,
F':%RA's§A?*~EJE §"GS"E', AP;I{O!'§§%M TAR-Lffii,

.. t'&Pi~'i:}LLfi1"~i'i'



 -   

–*E’f’f1?i.§V}:4″3~v V1i;i%””-:’E7¥ff:?u*”;15s2*_, <:z:2mi;'~:::e cm' FQR Atmiiagicsm mfg

VEiLLU§§'i} DESTREQT', TAMILNADU.

4. R:YA;2: KHAN $10. ‘1″AKi§B KHAN,
AGE: MAJOR,
N035, 100 mi RING RQAI),
ELYAS NAQAK J. P. NAGAR,
BANGLORE W 569 9:73.

(Sfi. K. R. MURALii{RiSHNA, Afivi:§c5T’E i?’G¥§ R51 fig
‘NOTICE TO R-4 ES D:sr*.$NsE;.La—-ta;IfT;§}*~-.

TEES IS A13: Appgggajg §:j:Lii__:§::{ u1i~s,”i.:?3{~;} 0:? MV ACZT
AGAINST THEj..JEi_D€iME_;N'”f”{‘ AND,;fi;i;§:;:x;'{‘::”V§n’ATE;3; 17.7.2307
PASSES Iii. §’vf”a?§?: 57}3§;;..gos:;5iIQN THE FILE <31? THE W}

A::B;¢_V.%vJ'i;:;:§::;:§;, '{i§:::::r42*;.*_""~::;is' S"Ev'EP§:1.L $335333, MEMBER,
Maazfiiv.3,r:E:":'gsjé;§':,§f§*A1'?.§i::§:A,;' BANGALORE, :s<::_:H.m:;.3},
AwARDm;fé'_ 3 ':::"3:x¥::r*;"§:¢Is’»’.-z1i.”‘v_:”«?§'<:{3ix;i 'THE: DRTE cm Pi3"E"'I'T7i<;}F€ Tfiii,

:sg*{;'*i'*1«i:«;".'é*:§:§?;;%§"i* f}ELiVE';RE;[} 'f'i~iE; FQLLOWENG:

JU§){}E%iiF.;§\E'T'

This appaai is iistegi for admission. With {::031se11t Gf

" "V-iéazned cmmsei far Eéath pa:1ie:3,'i'£ is taken up far finai

disfifisai. M' AIJM '

6.’?

2. The insurarzce company has filed this appeal :0 set

aside} reduce Campcnsation inter aiia conten€i§ng”~.._’t§3._at

deceased was giliity of contiiiautoiy §1eg];’i§,V,fJ;i,«r.é’:’1′(‘:éV:- .

compexzgation awardeé by the Tribunal is an

3. E have heard Sri 0. Mahesfih, 16?-‘a;”1fied’TTr;_i}t£.iis«é}”

insurance C()1IJ.I3&1]§g” afié R. _Hie.z3_f:tI1€:ii

counsei for ciaimants.

4. Claimant N<},thé_ 3c;;1.'{:ii?.;it:<i£::?;s€:ci and ciaimant

N032 and 3 u;1i'1;1§ii:::£e:i daugixters of the cI:i:<:ea$€::i
Smi. E{£é:s«{h:13;u1;31é:,. xii/h<}.§;§.Iic(i in E313 motor vehicie accicient

13:13: §§0G§; piacel-3': 13.11;, 02.1 _i'5§.i3t§,;§i€}§3f§. 'Tile: Lieefiased

.s%:'ass_ a;gic:::;§…a;:i3:cir*e1*£ 56 yaars at the time of ac<:ié.m1'i.. SE36 was

v€i";{::i iz1§' aiso wogkring as a servaxit in a 301105}.

' .:':3!; £5; maid be seen fram the impugnfié award, the

V. ciamasééi was a gzeémtxiazi. Ths accident took $31306 when

Iiéamzhg van {Qmfii} bagging Ne.m«03/ Evi-i82G (iashed;

' ' ''''s:gamsf. the daceaséd, The: deceassd was cmssmg Bangaioztfi

{U ._Wz&%k

iiosur Road near Viramagar. T136 accident took at
abotzt 8.15:3 13.111. The C11-ivezr of ?w/I'a,ruthi Van hggg
examizned. to prove that the dcitcexastzti had
the read and had made it: in::pos$i§i§ie"*fo1:

3.cci::i€:I1t. Théltffllfi, fmditxg of the
tack piaace time 1:9 rash :fi;§ d”1*iv€2:’ of V
Msiruihi van, (1063 not £01″ Vintééifaivéngje. .’ V

(:3. As regmés chiceaséd was

aged 51} year; -3115: pi” .;1C~¢iri_eIit.”:« :Acc01′(;iing to the

judg;efi:i.eni~, in ..:: iié’;::,$¢a*,’ appmpriatfi: muitipiier wauizi
be “13′, hévsgwir %h€.;1″Z%”i’.i§3*Ij;.*:’,f’l’._ft¢’;§.i has azzioptazgi ‘I2′ muiijpfiar. fits
t}1e,r¢§g 13.0 a1:3{>€:»?3.1:by the ciaimmli, this can not be mudifieé.

Tixe Tz°ii.:~.m”1;§i..V has; take}: inm C011sid€:ra1::£011 age of the

dé€:§¢asé:i”V”_£r;_ détéfmine her income as Rs.3,G(}{)}’ – 13.111, T116

‘£1°il5”:;133££iai:&Ei1g iI}t€) cansifilerafien {hat the ciaixxjams :2 311221 :3

h zaré unfizarfied 3.3.6. the}; ware dependixzg 91; the fie-ireeaseé,

“‘§fv’$:£7§’;*”§p~’i;33fff§I§€’?’£T*i’E{‘§ I jififii -:33′ magma ff)W8’I”£”§3 perswrzml and Ewing

a …,€;%;’:3e1}éit11r& of éecaasséi and awafiieci campensaficm sf’

Rs.:2:,88gf}Q(}f~ tawards 1033 cf dE:”:”§3€I}{§€I}Cj5;’. {En

mconsiflevafiera, I do not £31163 any g”m11ncis for ..~iE*;'(‘:fC’J’s”.E&_€§1″1’V’§’-1’1€5i’1t’

with this find tag <:si'tI:u?: '?'r3i'bun.a}.

7. The ‘T ‘$331131, i:<:sné§icie1:i33.g; ' T,,._.~f1.;C–'_" '–ném.1'e pf

sziepexzciezxcf.-=', had no _j11s;t:'f§r:zr_:tioI1 "{C}"'-€iW8JT"Ev"V~'.R$.i{},€?0€);'t- '.

tawagrzis 1933 of estate. '17'i1er€1'i3"z%,V& i;i; is CiE§f:*'.lIS{i'.'
8, En the resuin fi'he_ fo'Eg'wii1g:~

(53 Y mgipeaz is; aécéfiafefi. _i1T;Da1't;

_ g_is?.s;;’ ‘”V%fr:1,e”4é:nr;;1;gn_¢.::T awaui is modfiied;

_ Cx;fii1§en$§_%::z:en of E’:s.3,i8,GO0j-
‘V ._swéxx~aé:d by me Tribunai is
tézkiiiitsécé ta R’s..’3,{}8,0{}Oj’~ with
. i:1t$I’€S¥$ at the raie of 56550 pa. f}'()I3fi
flattt {sf petiisioxx tiii the date cf

rsaiisé:-man;

{iv} T336: inszzxance campany small
ziepasit the af<)r&–sai€i
{){)iZi}3€:I1Sa'fi{3£fi amezsurzt. Wifilifi eighz

weeks frgm the date 01' this uréuer;

‘f’\? , (1:-éf:;\__ (W. _W.§.

(V3 The 3,111-zxunt depesitezi by __Eii.e 4′ .’
i11sm:’a;1Ca company shaft. ,\ V *
transfexrcd to I\!i.BQ§{3.’i””.’,’ «{SC’.CiH::.3}” a
Bangalore; i T’ A’

{vi} Partiezs are (iLif’€’3C¥E€i to bsm”-V». ‘

casts.