IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALQRE DATED THIS THE 3" DAY OF MARCH, 201Aejj[_i~~.__ PRESENT THE i-|ON'BLE MR. JUSTICE.K..SREE--b'H'AT§*.'nA'ofg, AND THE HON'BLE MR. 3uST1CiEA_.NJENQAGQPALASTSQVWDAA MISCELLANEOUS FIRST Ai3§ii§>V'E.A_i.--.I\_ViO.7.'15é3:/v.2O£)V}i:1 (MV) MISCELLANEOUS ETRST A_r_>3EALTSNo,'7o64/2004 (Mv) M.i=.A.No.7158/2004 ' United In_d'ia IraSu'ra'nCe*C_.d'.' 'Ltd., Ganganagar Bran-ch;..Ban'gaIore. Thrpugih its R.eg'i'oriaI Office, #V2'5, S_hankaraha.rayana Buildings, .M."G.R"oiad," Bangalore -~ 560 001. ' ,R'ep.. b.y'itS-D"eputy Manager Sri. 'P.TS:.'~CVhh,uas'a. :APPELLANT ray"SriV_i3.'C,S'eetharama Rao, Adv.) AND: TS:ri§f;Rajashekar, '¥.Ag'e'<:i about 45 years, S/o. C.Subbaraju, E ' '"'R/a 'Praveena Chandra Niiaya', Premnagar Extension, Sonna Shettyhalii, Chintamani Town. :RESPONDENT
(By Sri B.R.\/ishwariath, Adv.)
_V
M.F.A.No.7064/2004
BETWEEN:
Rajashekar,
Aged about 45 years,
S/o. C.Subbaraju, _
R/a ‘Praveena Chandra Ni£a’ya”;-…
Premnagar Extension,
Chintamani Taluk. _ “‘–…Ae:APPELLANT
(By Sri B.R.VishwanatAh_’°8; _Sr~;_t R;aVrna~-._[s1_eh.a_n, Advs.)
AND: T * ” ”
1. H.R.Ramana«th’–Set:ty,major,
Son of .R’a’n.gav Shetty, [2 ‘
R.G.C.=7 Road Line, B’ae’E.aji”CQmp,eix,
Suitanp’et,* 1l;___ 3 V ~
Ba”ng’ai’or.ef.- 5360 0S~3_;*
2. sha.ya]@ shrvasha«r’ana’p_pa,
Major, Son of r~a;’ya’r.«–nLa;’
Kaggad-asapur-a, ‘ *
_.’\i0.:, C.V;-Riarnan Nagar,
“Ban_LgalVvore -“”S6.Q..£’;93.
‘ –VB.A.v,Rajah’Reddy,
iY3aj.ofi=,vVSo.tn.<)f D.G.Annaiah Reddy,
. "{\Io.64i;_71/D Main,
'*-4…Om__i'ar-Layout,
Bangaiore.
V’ A4.h”<The Branch Manager,
The United India Insurance Co. i_td.,
N0.108/7, Bazar Street,
5"' Main Road,
Ganganagar,
Bangafore.
:RESPONDENTS
MFA l\io.7158/2004 is filed under Section 173(1) of
MV Act against the Judgment and Award dated 14.06;-2,004
passed in MVC i\lo.602/97 on the file of the II Addl;«i_,_D~ist.
and Sessions Judge, MACT–III, Bangalore RL.l.ral’_»D’_ist~riCt.,
Bangalore, awarding compensation of Rs.4,_2’=i« 267/9–iwith
interest at 6% p.a. from the date petitiori till. re_1’a!isatio–«n__
and directing the appellant hereinto d_epo_sit ‘t’h’efsar’ne.i.V
MFA No.7064/2004 is fi|ed:”:.unt’lAer*’;Section” 1″73′(–1,j*?ojf
MV Act against the Judgment _and Award date’i;l. ,1’4.”O6′:.2(J0-42
passed in MVC i\io.602/97 ‘on’*t.he file ofthe,II’¢Ad»d.l.–‘ Dist.=U
and Sessions Judge, MACT-I’I»I,”l»Banga’lo_reARural District,
Bangalore, seeking en;_hancem.entv.of’wcompe’nsatio.n.
These appeals “~cxo’mir’la_g igovn””v–for,:”‘h,,ea ring this day,
SREEDHAR RAO J., delivered ‘the?fo_.l-l.9w.i.ng
H’ i,:V’=iuDGMENT
the reas{on_s’st:ated in the applications, both Misc.
Civil. Nos.hi115105/o9’ii&”1’i406/99 are allowed. The order
i.30.0’§.2OCiS”‘is”recalled and appeal is restored to file.
the appeals arise out of the same
aicc:iden.tid_”BTi’he petitioners have filed one appeal seeking
enhaiaqément and the insurer has filed an appeal
ch_a’ll’enging the order regarding payment of interest from
___the date of petition.
4/
3. The appellant / petitioner sustained’..gtri.e’vous
injuries resulting in amputation of right hand.
disability of the limb is assessed at>V1OO°/e;””Thie,’~
disability is assessed at 50%. ap’piel3ia4rit_1is.’said’
lorry owner and a booki’ng«–.._Vageriti’ VBec’ai.ise__o_f
disability, he may not be effectiyellylvfifunotion as a
booking agent. His inA’c.o:i’n_e Rs.4,000/~ p.m.
Income loss ‘:Rs.2,000/~ pm.
The total of disability
would be m Rs.3,36,000/-. The
appellalnteis for pain and agony,
Rs.j_.,00,00(.3/’~ foriosls of amenities and future discomfort.
ivieldicalll:bilils,_,are produced for Rs.2,00,000/- and odd. The
isifigranted Rs.2,20,000/- for medical and
inci–.derital-expenses, Rs.24,000/~ for loss of income during
laid up period. In all, appellant is granted Rs.”7,30,000/~
T “~,_irv’i*th interest at 6% pa as against: Rs.4,24,267/- awarded
” the Tribunal.
4. In the instant case, the owner and insurer of
the iorry in question have been impleaded beia”t’eVd’i-yf”after
about 4 years. In that view, the insurer
question shail pay the compens;3’t”iori*«wit’h a-t:6i’% ‘
p.a. from the date of impieadment__oi’=_insureifhli.
The entire compensation sha’i£1bwe payable’v.to’_:th’ewa;5oeliantV
in MFA 7054/04xmmheupproyenmir6raepo§&;~we
Accordingly, both 7158/04 are
disposed of.
Sd/%
Jufiqg
_____
Ind E