High Court Karnataka High Court

United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt J R Thriveni on 23 August, 2010

Karnataka High Court
United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt J R Thriveni on 23 August, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy


3? V , §§’¥§§fi€§§’EE2i’;}Z§5;”; 1
_ p_ 3; §§:m§:,.

. j T’ _,.Q, $§i*:&*§’§&%*§§:§R§;

wgagvafiggyayyg

3% ‘§’I*§ Efififi §€_Z?¥§3§’i§i’ £2?’ ?€§J§’z’3:%i;% 1%’? fifiigfifiififig

m::”‘E§ Eféig *2′?-Q :2;:s% 3%.’? 5;}? £:.,§§*:§$:* 2§§§_.~~ _j

BE FEEEE

EEEWERE

%.I?§§EE.”3 $’§E£ §2*%$§§%%£%£.”:E _
RE£31®§£§;if.3E*’§é'”§§E . ”

— — vfiazga a:m.m:§.2:’.f;_ _ ‘

A ‘ 4 ,§§«§=§§.%§§.:.fi§s*:*>
{By 53:

5.19%:

is , A ….. .. N
;%.gE,£:.,3§ “fE,;§;z”13Ef2
W; jag $;:E§f.§i aggfifiééfisggfifiiafi 3

éifififi §§%;’i%”i7f”§” E _ .

gé§§:;3%;%,.€%.£;:§?§ *2?

:3′?

§!,,§.§EE

5″ $3: %?&m’::é$??§3.

awn §§§€Z:r«’i§”‘§’ 4&2
%fi3=3E§%E”‘vi%.3fiE§ saw

?;.LL £% R§:;”‘§£’§%E§;’fi Q? ‘£§”§’§§§€§.§1£.
Vfimfifi fie fa: §:’fié:JE§{“,5g
Kfillafifi §§§§§’E.Z£?E§ Efifigfififififififi Q & 3
fifi I: §§%E§E§§i%’§*§§ $3?

Efififififii %%W;;,1..§;§T$;f§i”§§%?’£§%§ I

€%§§§§f:'”” §§sS£»§%E§ £3 _
Efigfifififiéfififiéfié 3% Egg ‘§’EE§;I§€§§,_ ”

§é.1..§®§ §”§§2€Z%E ‘
”$$fQ,E§?E§,_ ” _ 5
K&TRE§2%§;?,§gi xamyg ~ 2

” §%i.§:32.¢:5Q§%E§2’*3

gm fifii §¥,Q%?fiJi.–,%.%3§€§3§§_§§>%§ gag ;%a::§~efi”; ‘.%:%:;
R3 2% as % §§§f2@Q%¥¢»:””,,5 E:¥;~:f_§:_ fi’:§”*;§i- in

R5 M» gggwgg éifigm $:;’§~?§’:;:%::«*:;§§:?;

33:3 wfiafiz :53 sgsfrmg wag 3; $3? aw £3?
As-33$? fafififififi §§z.’§’237:”r§ 3;}; mg was
aaasm mi ;%;g’§:s::; §s;:m’§§_:;’%2i»€:§:§ 335; mg: mg £2? :3 mamafifi,
§;… ?§£%2’§:%’E};E, gmgawzgg fiwgamzfia 9;

fig-&2%%*§:+:5§2?_vj§;g:4§&$§§g~ E%’1″E§.E:$”E gs é% $3;

. E’%%§ **§%*ze:”%§*§§§i3% §%:€*§§:a”:@% $22: §.Ef§£.£§§a’?E£§%E

% ‘.f’fE~fi$ :::~z;;

G QE§ §'{?R

“§§§§% $2552′; fifi

“‘§f’EiE Ffiéififi:

Q § § $* E E T’

a £3 by :h& agsgaiiani ~ kfimrargm

fiémmny sirimiifiggézvg fig a;:’:s:.% awagé datfi

<

Vt $3 Exfié fifiéi '

' L. _ ' L j ;¥i':X§P5s &

f§§.«€;~§§§. gm fig fik fif '€235 @

%.::§§"§~ fig?

mg a ‘ .

‘§”:*3§%} Ema gggxzfag afifigagggfimfs :3?’ V

i’z1§§:a’mt ai §%% paw fiam fim éfiffi ‘

szzfiméffiafi fiat; 23$ aréw ix
g. E: g-mum;

Ki

a§§.’ém’13+i$%}:2a%§5 fig:

Ex.?E 3335; 12 $3}? fimi fig: éfisasfififi Eiémafiif 5:-zgémmiztfizi an

amgafzt mg Egg £5 finiy zmwfisaéhéa €33 23% gmiéama

mg: wmgaagésaiizgzz <E§%.§"fiE€}'§Z 3% §§§'§.:'§$§; {:3 flag

' é ' ;§§"1f'§1$:;'» A V.

Eiawagwg hgifiltg €33 ‘ihififi szaasfififii §;2:£;+ ‘Eggs’:

31$ ctssrmgmzzwééfigta $22″ 5:243: firs? 5:333 r;%f%:§£%§s:%»$::$

ixtmiwnmnt gf 2312 §;”3;£§fi§,”§£kE§T”‘.&”i’@’ ‘

~–

fififiw-$5.33, Eifiifzfifig itha $”3.3§.§§;&.§1?fi ffifiéa siésgfiigfifixigaatién

mafia?

ii };2§3~g%. sf §£:”2§§§*§§§:2f£§ mt z-
Hmms, ‘Em aygwfiantv fiaaifisi ia my
mmmm & mm
ammywarxz 33$; ilzaa aigémmaisg

fig E2 11% ui'”iz3:§fi:”::iré% @332 $2’: ‘flag ‘$333323 fif “ikmgfi
23 mgfi § zézfirfi mag :33

aeafga :1fs§:* 591%: m $3; iiéfi ghmt far

gig Qmigg m gig’: mi zgnjuat

. §:efi;:f:;§§«?;:1$$;:é::§¢;v”‘a%m§§;&:% :~;L%$:::%é;s§:’: 3&3-=:% afzf §§€§§$E.” Vaéfifiéfi gszsii

fizifééfmfixfiég Eigzzmz, ii :13 azfigzziitiaé ta ggm fizifi gg

‘fizaé, $2′: :53 ?::aé:§3i.3é 5;?’ €335

5;.

“ém gmégméfifi

§; ‘§’§% Ewmfi magma} far €323

Efi maéfifégég magi fififififiifig :23’:

‘ V ‘£75 V is
ffiéfifi; 2% {Ex E§§a§§ wzfi 3 :..:

VV §%%:'<§%; Em aka mm:

«§€§m.’%§é§i?;

§..»§’0é

“%”r§%§u3:$E Egg fiwagfiaé Qamguammfia-3. Qfifif E325

firifi mmgiezzz :&2_,:%:&fi:€:§e* EE§§ §%§éz% fimi flag A’

Emfi mufifigé Eliza; $_£i3§.§§$13″§;. E3′: ‘ammé €e2§z*%s;:”§§:;%%§;ia=§,*V.T.::é%._ £3 ‘ ”

$::’§§.t§i’é:t@& €37: sfiiéfimégs iiém

3?; E %;a?aas:*-; ‘iéifi

wsfizzaai far ‘ézézfi aggpafifini §g§u§$;23§$$”‘%3§§:::;§m.«. _§.’fa§i’:”;’:§%

magma: Em’ aim rwgmgnfifimm,

$5 ‘?§€: $:z%$’&:é§§§%»:: aiégf t%:§V~’$§2§§:é;:§§s;.*::__V§§ Ezisumncfi Cm,

‘1:*;§-*3§é;;fi: u§~:;:’:s2£§a:1§§} §r:a»%..§§~3 mam»

ia z*%*s.;?s..%*a§ 13 2:9: “§§f:f. H
inwhwmami if ms’: §’=&i%§§; ii} Eiw: wriitan
giaiegmmia fir amfi 5%?’ Q? the afimtemmt fim

?§,Eé::§z; 2% §%’.2itm*§3£ka5@w was pfirifi far

–,. §;§’;:s€*: ~%:’;%:”$;§:i§i’:t_ wag :33? fiaiéfifizii fag’ $25 ufimiiaéfisi

mafia ram ¢€:+.::$»§§3ga

K g; Egg FEE
a%s’g..z§ ‘iim

iamaé ii”: iirim

&*§:’i:@:”i5{:§§:gc$’3%§%€-=g 232$ gym hag %%&§3:

%®::m%a£’§%}r3 fix §% was smaig ‘my %mi§’mr &§

giéézasaagéfi :22″: $5 Efffififi iéiaé. Ema ‘;::%2:: rfigfsmzézi £23 érima

f£«fi:.;.3*°§ ffi@:=’§<a& 33:: figfi?

‘ $§§§ga§t.§§x &

§Gg3§;;§$€§§u §§§ *§:’a:g in élfifi §”E, “gig aasigézélizémégaw §a.$

$33. sf 3 szgfifiazg téw &:;3;€:m’i::1§&a%m3 gagzm m

sigma 5.3 §&::* Es§r:§E;§ ‘E 331:1 52% ii :3 ?;§,”§;§: £2233 :§’:;?: *

wag mfimfi Ezgswaawr Eézgrae £5 :3; :*&§’E§’fi2’lt§Z??”;.§~Z.”f’?£;§;E».’ V

fiékmi. gm: i”..’$1Jé§%:”i $2 fiaefizefi fig: §2′;§s3é%2?g:§£€_€:££§:§; 1:i2r;:*~.s_V:.%;§$_

mmgaategsi a:z_3;%:’%zm7=:§¥:§: fhg Vgf .235
§.*§ffi§”I”&§ in %;;ia§- sfiafgfi gizaazi $;:¥”f}§ fifififi fig §;§;§:”§€%:;§S&§ by

fhg §.%§g&.’?;15a:-1:: a%…:?éf§§;f§i§: ‘ VA —
ES. Efiimra §r:;§’%:§,%:55:f%:’:§ ififiaéééfiis’ Eséi “§%§:3*§m” “‘-§a§§Z1$$ fig’:

fax’ :i:*:m3§§5§%’ {kiéa 2:2: Q@ l
?::’m%1z.m £33′ :::s%m§* mfifi
W§ $%s :;?§z° Ezsfizi £2′: €$Z”fi$”%§f :3? ihfi
33%;: éafifififi ‘E33: 221% .@pwZ3m’::£.

agglméfiaiz gamma? fafarrfié fling

*3: $iZ?§§ 35%.?

Eeéi g §f$

§ ‘w§;”§z*a it Egg ‘fig: Rafi firmtz

z§?;.»’::’f’=»fe fir: 5% mfitfifiig azimféiazfi if:
V §’%4’§§§§éi’§.{?$ §3&i’t:£ ésffizfiggfig mm 63:: §’fi€}£31″€f{ §;T::&_I3;’£’T1§E
Em §:»é:’:§:’g§E§:§s& is £232: mi iézat Qiéwr Cfiiziféfiéifi

aflzzémzifii 21:: rag: gsaft Eézfimsfif Eagaii fiiit ‘away: T T
gkmweé. M fT’§ ?§z%3::.g§”:§. $2: §.”$$%§§’%’;§ fax §:*:z.2.:*~§;a§¢ szzf .’
pmvézg mzséigr fiifiiifififii ~–~ saéméfi % :¥;”*$§§fi§ 1;§m_;!;:”–:s;:.:’:§§ 4′ .7 “”
:& Esafifiity fig” érivm gg $§%:”:…éfi.2% *sa=§%:§§:Esa X
firzia? fig gig; £9225′? gmégatgg akg§§§:%gggg§%

ggxgi’ ;:*i1i’?§ Egg mi grfiafifi 23%? J, V’ A T

ifigfijg gmwé — éiafaéfi ‘Ea iisfi ” V

32, §’§$,§”3.§.3fi; ii £3. éwaiéfi 3233:. ‘iérgléégazzt éaégeé caéw gm

FIE $533 yéaamé fer a € $
aiwz. Tim §'”%°’§ 21:: ggtgkp-.:ég§m1’@§ 33%;’: §§*:§:s3«E§%§:§:¢:;:i%.”§£ a::i:§§§$§%E*…:a§%?

maé imp it Em img §%”% mam if: m

fiflflfiéifit %}3iE:§!vva:;°:x@z::%§:§w$§’;:éi§§g’ ‘:3? Etta g3.afi::Z$a:*su
:3 fig: fafafiaé 23? $313 iifiufi. 3:353 féiififi zzgmn

fififiié 21:: %;%§§ @333 aéf

a %§§.; ;’ff’»:§7%%;”ifE§& «

éggzfifigry whfizfi it

$53

V’ V. _ “‘A_’§’§4°’ra’:,:g« at §a’;$ musafigaififi méabimmt? §¥’§:~au§

fig; _§L2§’%::i§::-3 mew? afiwfiéfii §:$gfi”%E1fi§’§ 33% a §§'”i’:i%”?:.’;.’f’};$

V “‘=?;§;”§’i:i£.T?§§ Egg Eéfiflifi” E5223: Efifi igmgg” é$$”:§’ $3;
thmta fififiiififififis §”:*$.::zi gwgég 3&2 §§§:§§§§%3 agrfgg

* E: jéziigficgfizzé Qt’ éaéiffifi

Ea;

§:$$§%§;%.a’:§{rg§ £23″ éasmfi

Qbfégizéfié E23?’ 3313 %$;:..:§§ <33: ifzfi €i:§m"%g éfi 3:

zauiéitjg aézzd rim’: eras: E2″: €:”:f;”2f;?% :35 3.3%:

fiaxzé agm: the 3° §3.§a§’:§ *

srfiariizmag fig fisg $2?

aka §fiE”‘a§.,L”‘§’fi» 21$ 3:: $523353 3% .
Qfiuréfi {the $~§m”‘% §%f’$€;§ ‘sagmgra fig ‘ n .
?:z°3}1€:%;°’$f.’;§. gwwaz ‘at: 235:? afiifiai
f’:”a1;;& ‘§”fi2:;’E’£”izi’;%fi 21%;; %E:$z§V,.__€:;;::;:’*f§_
wéxfifg €32: Qizufi, £3 23:’ ‘%§2€.E’:
§z:;”:22*§ iigfifif fififiéfifiifi g

9. T§E*::s: 523%: ix}
fig? ::?:$ a§j{§&;%§.__V in . A ‘ V’

M $§;%2.fgi£%i%@:i iézaa £3: fiffléf E5
haw fmmxmifififi a. fma.:z§§ E?

ig ffiffifffié szazggm :’:&%::;:§ :3 §*.»;é;E§§$; :3 rsmafiémé far {rash

::»$§.?§3§;{§§.z*§€i::*§’3,*f§f§»:=:”:’:::§$z§&.:§’§%£figm:&§3f, :3§’ ‘:}*§.§ mm? :3 fi®§

EAR fif figgag §§§§»m§’:§ §£mm§ Ergmrwmfi

:2 where i’: has

;£~§m§;§é$%g§%«i*§@ gg

L

K gf’ fimfit fix §ré*%%~5m’:%§’;m%.i§r: in
$353: w m firm gm fif’ guéii 73:; 21:13
6.2%? Emfiflmfi {Ea gzééfi iffiififififi §%.;2:* aiiésaarézig zfie
afiaém §&:§:%icm E3}? Eféafi
§:;mp§::§; a§§$§§§i§§}.§ 531%:

“E1 2% §:as;;$% {sf Effilgfifiilfi

gr}? faafizzzzi $5 aififiéfififii

«—- §:.2&%§i§m§:¥§Eii§; :13? ‘é’;§;§.% 35$-*”&f§§; §$;%S%;””:~f;1§ $3; Ehfi ‘.
Eéfifiii “‘E.”§’§.$ §£%£’§’ 2″‘:-§E§§}3;§§§§ Em: aigé Qmgiié. ms:
gkm $s3% f g£¢fi an aha gzfigmgai sf V
Q fi§ Csmfi §;§% :m:’:5i;:i$r3i§?;;gHm% ifififéifi—::}{?§’V’..
the §£aa::m;§”,§3 fig mg amfifimt mm? §fé:.f3§§1f;<2§é2;a:»g::;{:;§;*.fzfi" k %
ngéigenwi fifi fiifitflfi in $333 ;

Emffiga ‘iéza ‘”§’:f§?§@z::’§£, 82$; ifféés
is agams ‘éthg avifigggg ;__?i%f£Ef§_i§vv§3’:§i$§:§§§1£§;éf:§’E€Z§§;A

mg §:§§2§3:I’§g :3? ‘éhfi V 5E3: 131%
qfifififififl iii éézzi érévgr §1§ga€f:,%;3Z:1§§V_.;

:5. Es: ffifaxzégfi maré. ;§§.£§§’:§§:’;i¥;’§’§3i:”A:!’§’;f “£3323 mam atfi

égigigézg £333? £33 iha mags;

raktti awn 3. {,%§._ %_g§§’%f§:;- :§%%:;:;5:m*%%:§iVA§:?§

sf Appwf Tggg fiifiréfifizrggg

; §§€%:%:*:: ii’

~ v.?&3:”av

‘ ” .. Ebfiafara Zfi§§£ it sfiam E§i”;£fi’?£

§i’:§§”;§,mi§:éf§f:: if.:°§’§m imam fiws fiaé mfgfizzs: :fl§&a’J&
‘wag §°3;3%K aif wk “mg & twm

7 as’f::h€§:= mkiwia wag rémfigmétgfié fig: fim

‘ f5§s.s’,:a:;~§%é1a’és.;§::§ aggixagé’: wfiasfi fig? €?%s?’fifi’:.€” mzzfi R

* fimkzia 3; ‘ fa:-5? giagtfifiiéf: 23%’
…. $3′: as éaéiii hmffi Eéfififif géfizimz
V Efifiwfl sf’ téza fiaig fwga wag §€::%$f:%3i§§§:%i Q’

mm: $ £2? its fiéam <+::§

K

5

£21m 21:1″ f$,%EE§§$$= Eff, mag-$ whfzra am ”

$ @fiE fiéméwg mag: §fi5′;§”2§£i’=Z3%a {saga amzzfifizg ‘&7§1§’

fifiiflf fif’ if: Efijy’ % afigz %§

$3 afiaim an 21% ffizség, 7ms?fi igiéfifir ”

Efifiwfiz a? $25 ,,§:::;€5 ‘§§%m%: 3% bmgmgg

wig “Em §&z’m§mfii%§.& 22:; mmémzf fig.-“*£,§*§’ ”
Qwféfif éf fim fifiéfif %E§f2~i:::§é*;–.L. £;’%7a%§§£%§% :T€z:T

amfimzt mag; fiéigpaztg. %:§:§ §i:°’3~§§’§:z?3’§
maésmrg Tim &:*%$:*ii’– .%};’;:$i ” ‘ zzzlaézzmzzi
may §”fi§:. %fi :5-:1? 3&6
rmgaaziantg $f;’.?§;€f;Z’ EERSE ms:
ammzfifi 233:: fimégf mi’?

mug: §fa:EiV._f::%” 32$ aikwafl m
2 W23}, Etamfa ‘m

3%’:

namfiaaréfig ‘T§mz§i rgfizgz fim gaam 5&3?

ymvizig ‘$%”:.:: ag_::t3%~=:§£:§%§ Egaszé ?§§§;%fi

A $1: $.z,:%::a:;:f:M3i’§§?§T :23 nihas V§§&_,gfE’: $3′ $25: 1″%@fi§,€f§}§;$= mg;

V. ::’$§€;§§;aif¥éaI:%3&fii Q? gyavizg ‘ziéia £3335′: hfiarégzg

asgzég $3; $”:.:’:}=$é:$t§«::3 :2; ‘:53:

‘::§;§:: 331% i’%fi§a§%:?fi§$:”:Z$= is: 35:

¢ _ Cf.,;§ gégfsnfia fémi fifi amsfiafii Wfifi “%”‘T§.i§”§$’§.1i
4_§a’:é1″€ wamié ammzgmé. m :*:%t1?§§ fiifi sfimtt

” –. E$§’.fi%’i;€’§:fi§’_’fg’

K .§§§§a:,.1§’1s:;”,

ififi éfimgrzgéig §m5§

K

3%. E3: s:%§’ 22% §§E::::°:i3§:}:::z3 mafia §;~t}:: Effiffififi

Cnuxmgig E éaafim gmza thzfizggk fizsa _*;’2.'”a§g2rm2:;: azzé gwgssai A’

by :3}: “3€’r§”‘:3z§:aE; 37:: 22% irgéitaxzi §>.§..$§:.g mg “r ”

ed éirga §

“fmm ggégfiifi fig’-A;:.f:.%;fi3″z’*f;’L–zfrA:_g Ea. VV

a§;tc:*i:;§fi%’z§:w wag ézzwéwfig $123: éémrfi £3 §*:2:i:§&:°%:§:”é% %£%”§:§:2_i:: ‘ ”

E3«:.?§; Q? 333?? Eff ‘aim: 23.3 13:13 :e.a§£§”%i5?;”i:¥’£:_§,§,%§:%§;§§;§:*§~: E§$”§::3%9érm

Qamparzy {magi haw §’&:§§;&:§i:ss;_é %%::’éW*§§§:%§f:11§.?$3

‘Ema xaegrwsasgr w%§:::za2%a; Ea mag}: $5§;2*:”f2.§§ by makfi
riawsazy a§:s;g;§i:_*;a€zi::;s;;”««[:%;sr§– iégfi §*§;’:5<:{%:.':«g§ §j_'~–::3;__ f5$xas:*a3?.$& yaaazaar

awiiefifik Eifififififi' J flag, £5 gr

Seazftlsssefi 1&3; §:2%:®ai$z3"%;§::%:9ij'-~ and; §§T;%»%¥§=f «sf Q
':*;e::?sum2§§ mg g:;g;::;;:;§AA*:¥§:=;§§;:i%%ga%a«j}s;m:: flaw Q13 am Wmm $5 a

wfifigfi :32: gafi: af

'Sam?

§z2§af:;=£éfi,f:-2; sf ayétzzmgazsw; 33% £2? {?$§iEE§€ii%§ 3%

3? fififiiimfizéfi aazfi. matgrfiifié abjmtg

. 4éE:%g’f $;:§E”:~~ ::%’z;E*:..@:° §@§$§$$ as 2333? Ex: géztmcriéjaaé; afifi 33%

a:e§ fififififiii }.§E§ .

*@ éfigwfifi ms 5% § Ski} 5;-§L§.§*€. ibr afi fig

._

:3?’ $33 Qfififi; a:::§

_ 2 ‘ L» ?:’:”$md;2.’§m§ 2§’?3.

K

3?’; 33;: “gig fiéaém ;:£’ii:2%$§§L %:..?~:@ aésézzsmi hag aaaitaai

the aazmrégémifisgw wag $5-Efifi :32: mg z..;§m,,,§_z’§fi§?;;,E _

samg 3&5 9; faéafeaigm it’: $333 §*”f§?;§§:§3 :2:a%&:°:”2$:::,_– ~§*§§;:;g:gg”*~z§%3g: u

baa %%3z’:: awartégai? E3 Stag ?:*2I%§;.mE mafia %§,é;a§§:’£é:_;2:%::;

jam
C-nmré, Baum} ftlifi a,3§§:’s~ea§; ia 7%;
fimzmt 35$, fig-ggiii ha ?f§.’;§”;%;§;f.§i§.%%l§:§;é§:,€2§”

REESE

_. §§*$:§$:* amé :i£:;%&§z 1:221: :**$§u.3§€:««.;%z§.§ £:=§::é:*f?§&;§*:::§5.%,:h§;’&§ vizgétiféifi %