High Court Karnataka High Court

Vasanth Kumar S/O Sharanappa Dead … vs G Doddabasappa on 2 September, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Vasanth Kumar S/O Sharanappa Dead … vs G Doddabasappa on 2 September, 2009
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri


-nu-I1 -II-vi! In-«\a\ii\I \Il I\.f”‘|l\l’P’\|.f’\I’\I’\ I1I\J” C

IE ‘§”i’$ Eflffrfi QQJRT Q? §§fifi§%’£’£’§sK;é. 2%? 3&1′? {2’rAL{§R§«

§&’.§’EE THIS THE 2% 3%.? Q? $EF”‘TFEE§EER QQSQ

THE Hmmm rm, J”£.3$’f*£CE: as;-mx 3 m:zi%s::*.zA§–::.-‘j..’.;§ %§R::?%7–‘;, »«

BE§’§RE

WEE’? ?2*r1’r:m% rm 43%? SF 23:39 gg:;;«:;.<:m;%

§E?§EE§;

amzéaafiggggfgzsagit?

¥@3&x?H Kfifiifi
33$ §HR§$§éP§&
aafig 3? Las

fig? Kfi§J¥LA $53 LRTE v§3§§%§1§t§gg’
Asafi A563? 33 ¥$§§§g– ‘ :.I *»’=’

mmammmm __V’~,Q,«
ska L&T$ §A3&§?x»%§g&§_-.”
RQEQ Aaauw E? 3E&&sfif–‘

3} K§fi.:fifiS§R?KA fi, a _ s
EKG LfiT£’¥RSA§Tfifi§§%%§*
A§EE A$¢mT 3% ?Ek%S j

§§%:?:$Hg§s=1:B§ KRE fiififififi R$?§§$£fi?E§

.g?=§&?§aAL:$3A§arAxV§5%H§a §E?:?§KER

.§.”{§jz:} 335$; E€L??éfiII’€é§§?.3’a§{A?*E”$ Vlidgfiafi
§i$L~%L’%3iE§.’:§ ‘?5.§fi}E’§ ”
.. . . FE’§”§’§’§{Z§?§E3§’%,S

;a§=§§:3E§§§H§a§§A §A??A§R§fiETT§, RE¥g;§

‘§ §§§§fiE$Sh?§R

“a$f@ $;fi§RE$§??&

Rfififimfifififl? $3 yagagg §C$:fi$§E£§i?§£E§?

fififlflfiflfii yzggagz Bibifififififi, gfigzz,

.:°s&$§LaR ?&L¥k
‘*§HI?§3§§§G& EIETRIC? .§g R€3?$§§E§T

{BE $fiE:fi%fiE5E R §§§E§; §§?g§E

I “vs 5 Va-vvsu vr nnnlvfiiflnfl Hififl L

‘ gfiaaingd fifiiifififii

3

with ma admiitted agxaiuma 52$: Exizibié S@{&} and 3-»

2:53. we ma: cam mmfmea the gag :’«7fi;¥«§§FC?”B§.!-2:

Eawifived by $113 mama, tflzs getitiam is 1s=r§:zi:§ii{t§:§’;*

3, Sri Ifianjuriatim : 1:;.¢u

caunssel far ma petitiar:s;ér$..L:’L:$1;i3mL.§.%»§..

Kama: ciifi net £mje:~;~,:~a:3_f;e ~ ‘§p:e’$iti9nE::*s
harm Cififlififi tiiz: ‘£3′: iés *«.f”i’§Et§I§3§§g’.

fkcwrding    armht ta haw
raferraad    far aaagfiaézafgzg 221$
   a: Exhibit Mia}. me

$1′: tiha éfifiififififi mi’ tiiis

cg;:;z’:F%%i:: firms ;:af SR2 ac;-:*m*:% mi: AEJQTI-{ER 2;}

Arm 3’§”§ERS mpmea ig im 29%?

Par mafia, 33% Mfiaah E. §.§§§3si::; £313

fag’ Em rasgandfifit mzbmiifi

mat in Ehe firitire writtazm gggzamant} ma §§?.ifiQfi,¢f$

mm neat fianiad Qzm meaufiafi af’ ma gzwzmteg maszzh

flfifl.

iess} flazzyirxg Q? ciisputmg Vasanfi: E£:..,1ma:*”$ sigizaizzsra

am {he samg,

5. What agpeazs :9 %Ifi.’¢¥3§« ‘
‘Friai mar: in dismimsiag
petitianars have met .. éf ihé’
deceased Vasaxith – fiii ” 5333 E3:?§m~i5$§?§?

mm at Ex1:1i%:it

m-mnnmnu mun LUUKI ur KAKNAIAKA I-HUM COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH 1

in efi% ‘-

at’ fijfififflfii. “E’§:§2*&f<;§m,

mam T me fiamgmn m mi' mmm

:..'$ans.wxe:sa= »_;5é,MM

-M » V ‘ -*x1je;~»a;.»*g:;:éiaa$”i;i»’T2:.3,f§!;;;.£;”:Q1″ ‘f;’}::.&: faizts af ‘iiilifi !~ $e:::t2?.az1 ‘?’;3 inf

I’!I\J”‘ I-\J|ulI|’ ‘LIV
f’;.=2:$?=

f;$’?2~, ampfizwfirs the Caurt is

._ __ disputed gigfiatmm w:Ei:§: ma aémiiiefi

V. “I”lI\I ‘I’D If’I’\l”l

‘She Cifiiifi cm rafer tézé é,i§§:.3’£,afi aigmzzgrg

” .. A’ far’ Qpiflifiii at’ ma anger: fiiiififif 311$ mam $2′ an 53?:

‘yawn –

i It 3 ” ga ;p :;fi:3icatian fzlcé by 9:. party} em; ii’ iii hag my éificuity

; * u in arrivim ai ma mnaimsiszz as 2% Whfiihfif C227 :19: it is

£314.

III|ur’1III-r1 a nun’;

v \I\J\lI\l Ia!’ I\r\!\l!l”\lI-|l\fi\ l”‘IHuJI1 L.

is

the gfigflaium 31’ am aenggmad gzarty, fig»: matigr fafzis

wifizrin the fiscmtimsz bf ‘rim Trial Cami’:

‘E1 Ne interferamce ifi Vfifiiigd’. fcfr. 6:: “;sat::ic:;~;V’ ‘ ;

is éiamisascd, No arfier $3 ta s:f:;a;.t1si;..,_T

8* Howewrgg is §*é’q:;1i:I%& is ‘me
made. if the: :2 aigzzaiurc 53
gmudg, hmmfi 3. gzzesss,
mane}. 3 ‘ In this regard, it is
§_2_:%ié§snt 9:’ ma E+EGn’bie Apex
Saufi’ ‘*:*H:Rms*3N$-Am ELLA} 2:;

2~;g;v;2:a:2«§’:~:~§g§;2s:av£:a: & gxmg reggrzga in gags gag

Yhe raiavamt yaragagh af this saezié

H ‘– igivfitrasstaaé hmeinbslaw:

“.25. wgmzsmg :3 mg mg gm fibeszfi am

£33???

? rfiim & ififw
mnmfnmn by mutt wfifwm {ifse sf may
gwri, has afwwggs km mmfiewfi m be
§%?wfii£:Ts2m£§$?m£§mm’ is
F2814.

5

rwbar::aaw;:§mm%m:?w£.§:,£e§flnfi,s’
inggmmzm wfih gm mama gfigzwr
$3 withmxt .mysZrz.§ am it gm mama
are: sash era Qsrzég afisrgn ‘
mg’ the cfzaxeriamiss fif tfm ‘
irrwmzszsimz mtg agar mséjgirig’ ’37§§;”£§§;’§5″?¥V.§%§;§%.’§’VV
cimaezeyams am

133:2 9;’ V

mm: as agffby fiézrfimgg gm
Jam 33?: mg fa fig
W $3 mmd mm

, irzwmsfim
be tmifiaytefi :23 :1

” £319 ggmm $5 $3′ £’§’ze
gm zzw awmgat zémmg
.. 3% way: jfiids mm fiim

L “é:n,m»smfm ma a d fifmmfi
flaw? wad WEXEEE zfw mgvi is in Q»

Vwiaazar $3” jinx?

pfir:ts,A;f5§_ smwrfi § jinmg am

I\r’|l\3’J”‘|Il”|l\l’| U”l|\.’l|”‘ \.\JIui”‘ ‘Jr l\l\l\i’l”|F!”\!’\I’| “‘II\.7l” \.\lIJI'(l K11′ NHKIVHIMRB TIIKIPT LLJLJKI LII” fifihflffifiiflfifl I”fl{_3I”I L

V g

«Q {Sf $35’? fifiéfiifi

‘V 9:’ wry fight fix mm’: géfiméd 2m:
2 fig an %::.s§A§g§’:.g;mé. fig wmffifi
h fstgmj wifi Lgiit §B§§:€ ggggm} s§’m*s:£d

“I’\s7|”‘ ‘au_,\-IIJ’l\’ HIV”

as Iwim apra

aéfxzfid 33%;’ £:2%.$aarm mid rgmrfi :2

III\.?”‘ ¥\IIJ’5’\’ \J’ ‘\I’IC’\I’f’IP’II\l”

fififfi

I II’I1llI ‘I”IIl”‘I!\’T I !I\UI’! C

‘E’

zfsetiem ifiexwemive af ifw
€:fil$”£t£€& figr i%?§I§ . _ .

mfifim mm by tfzggezzmn mm is saga :3 MW
afiixed hisfixzyr ixrzpms.-flan mm ifiafzazte £323
impmsslatn in mg ‘ 22$ mfg. Q &A
mag $1?’ mt aims; mking ia ” V
m the wax: armza ?2e.§:@e ‘:z3 – V .
aermen msaa cm :13 gmrrz mg’
wwm ma; aaszmaz firwr gwmmgg.

aims”: in ceases where r:§uz£;~£.§

take up w}: at

rrwmnem Sm<i5:L ax

m2mmZ_., E6 -;f.}":«.:£

fi s asté -_ .

523 mm? fa?’ wag
_’%3€.’3??wa:°f;:w=r: af 2%» 2mm

_ ~§_fT££« £9 sewraz a fiyfiw fiiéféfifi.


$23   :1    
"    mar mtfisw gfime ardgemmi."

 

– ” tha Cam”: firms my-an gamgarixzg that im
éignazuzce 32$ gazmima} ‘Ema: smiaimg asf figs
.§:9i:}:i£::i fig’ the kwmwriting w@€:”% mum “E36: zfidzmdamz

” ‘~ i9T1* futiia axamise, In talvfiiig fizia viawg 1 am fartifiaé

‘ “fig ma fiéssisiczz germ my Qaiaafia E-Eigh {IZ§”:;?:. in am

$fi§§ Gf .».%.JQY Kiffifig $53 ‘$2 %§§;L?&N£ §&S

rfipfirtfié i:1{2£i®7} 2 figfifi, 252?’.
93334.

-n-so-‘ \.1.a\a-1- 1-vv -vflliuirurrwvvw III\.l’O

– \«-_!-IV’!-an’ vu nmmu-unnn noun uvunr Ur AHMVMIHAR rflufl LUUIU UP IKAKNAIAKA HIDH QUURI OF KARNATAKIU HIGH C

S

3.3, in {is}: rmuitfi this psfiiim: :13 §1?:$_:fi.i$§a§

with 3. eéarifieatian that {ha Trial Cauri may

referrirzg thgfigfiter we the ‘_

mnsiderixggx me argmezf-2&3′ *5:ha;.2:: j’:s..§’::g;, %.3’i’–3§*s: Ems ‘ i

any amenity in ‘ere1.”if§*2T:’:g:}:& $3-.>’;?_2′:z§z’3i§:A%.’::*&.b”v_.._A.A % % 2 %

1 1′ Pk: crder” 3.5 tc§”¢fé$i;:$g.