‘iéffa ?{}?’$f ‘ESQS
1%: TEE man <::<31;m' <3? }{£§RE'~§P(FAi{A <::;2<;j:3;%:"%;?§;:;%j§<é§:§«~:
AT GULBARiAY@;f ;:i:1;§’VV;2€:%gV%;A
?§€%:SE}$i”F’
THE HGE’%’BL.§}3 MR P.D.If§V£’i*s%iV;V1’iE{z45;I€VAV§’é’.3V_{3}-§EE§’ §fiV{§ST}CEVV
“SEE: E~iQI€’BLEZ ER’ LVEf§.§f§”3%ViV’;Ef;{V3E;«~7$}**V.'{§;£%E¥;3s.LAGOX&’i}A
m:;;:’rV givrsfi. afiézazfis §L~–KSR’1j;Q1
B€.’§§1″{fi(?i’i}iV”‘ . _ Vj.
Sri V5€V’1″ a1″Vs.I;a _ V . . V’
S j’ G fvia}§€:.Shapp::%. K’¥1i’2§§i%;?..if V’ V
Agaé 3332 §;€e;;rs’~ V ‘_
€360: ; Ni; {Exw ifiasstzéiiactc 1″
* T. <:*!,No;i ..:.,A£;'3_6«NET1<Rf5s:;
‘ ~ . _ , 33:2. 24–V<;T':'::§ba1'ga
51:; 5 ;~.1.';*=:gg; 2 "1 :_.3~:5 / 20
V§_>h3.j;1agai_’aga11i’V
Bnt§1’nna§31:1f,. Gulbarga. KI Apgealiazfi.
V’-{By $i*’: §’1;’i.£’iEas Kuzizar, Advoaaie}
V ‘ ‘ VV521éV§7–‘
_f’}f’iV§r:e Nari}: East Karnataka
Refit} Tranaperi C0i’p0ratis:1
VV Through: its Divisieflai Cantroiier
G:;§’£3a3:ga Division
Guibarga. 96 Rssgeazziafii.
{‘§i;}; 31% Suaihir Simg.§’:, Adv
aw; ?::7:3,:2c£>s
This Writ Appeai is flied 1;i£”}{§f:I’ S<3_<:ii{;fit.%..'_~ fize
Karnataka High (3011:: Aift prayizig is $31 a::sj{1::v{Ej1%: {;:*~:3§:1"'»Qf
iearrled Single Judge dated? 16.1£};20i'}8 in'£5..–?{4§"§fi'%%?Sj£%S{E;~»E§}~-
rejficting the writ petition fileszil .a«,§.;T3e§.:1a;}':._m:<£T:§:h{:re'E§§;
Omar far the Seitirag asids sf :.t;%1€:-Afiyéafaafii A..;§:3.$sr;<§;§_ '§3'fy"' {$16. -A
Learmad Presitiing (l)f£i»::t:r, Labm:fi£f_' Cgurt, €§%aT1i%3a[rgéé§'–£,'{;I' KED
N03 16,/GE Di. 3}. §.{3£3 a1:d.:33:«:i$:* f0r.f:}*1<=: re§r1é;%:;23;¢::1é:lnt sffs's1a
apfigeilam with full back s2?age':3._33.3.d c0nt.i:i'L:i€§: (pf- s&i"§:i<::3,
'i'f1is wrii; ap_peai* …g:WDA_J’. ,_ Acigiij-‘{r:3f€L%_’Lf§’:fe~ fefiowixlg:
This is +;i1’1r§<:i§{iij; the <}r<:ia';"~ aiaisé
16. }{},;.§S§_8 imrziafi Sgggié efudggis ii”: §%!;”ié
Faiiiiazg A§’3;{;1?; 4§:}~’:§””§’53~’jV’ 3;”: aff::”s;:;i;3_g {ha awargi af
La’bz::f{;::” “€L§u§i.:a1″:ga £2”: ELK} N213 R3} 29%)} {Rams}
‘v3.§,{17E “a_;__i1€:”e§fi {Em §’r;=.;f&:1*€§;:c€ is rtajesiaé ‘£133? £3113 §,aTbm:r
{Z’Q1:é:_”:.T?.3£3;§ii* the appaféiant has saugifzfii far an a*é:a:*<§ {if
V _ f€§fiS'§"&tfii1§€Y§?. zvith 513%} backvagag, §:{;1::1:im1%:j»; af sazwiice 312:?
K V' W .,€§i;E'zs:::* céiisasquenfiai bamrfim afiat sétfirzg aside tbs @1662? of
. ziisiézissai, urging varieus grimnfig.
2. {.:€§”£3ifi brief factg éiiffi siateé far the _gm:*;:za>s:: sf’
£’ip§}1″‘€{3§3.EiY1g iegai Caraitfjziiioizs m’g<':»:i in t;E'1i$ aggsai in
§'i,§8?;J§.fi€§a'§l§Qi'} {If {Em :§'§:iie§'S ;}:"a"».:t3<:3 in 23.235 25;-':"*§E; a;:3§3:::z§i gmii 229E313":
'~e's?"§i 3" Eiliiifi
a View :0 find out as to wheftier $16 iz11pugr';€d ~,:;é;i';«:i
awagrti war1'a;r1t intaszrference by this Saar: in –é:~é€:f<:§.$7<:; '<2?
€3<mr's'S juri$di;c"tion am}. powar on' '%fi;1<:« .§2:Z§"€L'}"'¥.1i"_1'*.(§.:AV'1fi"'i'z;"E"%.'i:' €;fi;6i4e EST A'
subsiantiai question of law t%1é£;_ "a%ai3u§é" -.8I'iS€i "f_€5:*. i;:7a;r
cmasideratiofi?
3. The appei1a§’;?. :” is ;€%:?;1§;i.§$§r:~.§e working in fiize
3″esp013dm1t~North=– V Ea§3′:’;”- — :§{8}’fl8,?,€’i3§.a’V “R0362 Traiispori
Comoratien {}::€Lr;ei§AE3;fi:?ter’:{ts:1E¢ci r__3sff’tiic’: C$1*1;}::>m:i{:»:”;’, fer $§”‘1G}C’€}
from that year” »’£fE£:.VV__wa:2: Served with {Em &rt;iz:§.é::=; gr}?
chargafi {ii}: 3.1. ‘1é}.2’£}€Eé}’T’23§1€gii.:g €E13.?:.wi’3iEé: ha was dis+;:ha3*g%ng
hi5 éhitias 3;S«–.:;C:3&:1ct:::f é”;§f_ £315 bum b€a:*i:”;.g E%eg§str8;%;i:”2 N::’;.§*–
__;”§.:”i? ?ufie~G'{ii§:%:9§:’ga §ffii€iTS€8.’§€ rouia <31"; 8. }€}.2G{}€§_, E25 §':3.€?i
fai3:3€i"é:0 i'::%3t;1?é~:ickats aizé {:0§.i§<:1: {am EEEIQLEIEE 9%' RS2 E ;' – $2331:
£:a:c§;T_{%2;1é ':§f 'E:E 15e_ sigh: §&SS€}3;gf3YS §:'a_v€i§§;2";g f1"*e31:': }3'z:m':a Stage
§*%0. '?é '"t§ jifitagfi E'€Q.'=f)é, Wham iii. wag szjftijeciaé ":3 Check
-at Stfigé Saswasi, E: was 3133 §G”£;,E§’3§ ‘£313.: he has} fagéiad
W gzgsi s’%;agewise 33:37; af stages “E; H) %’:”>€3. ‘?}:;.§ gigi; af {he
V’ 5<i*'f:_f»,«:%;4*:¥,*ge5';<;¢*. are Harraisfi in izhe iizzpzigztfid azssazezi pasgtad 3;}; '(ER
–.j§-aizéar ;f{:r;>*&I’§.
aw, 7::::r5;»;§ag
4. The chargiis were fiemed by {hes an
isriquiry under the 1{ar11a.taka State: R}t§acE
Corparatrkm Servants (CQn€iu<::t '4 Wéi-;§i'jt;3.i3:i<)VV=;'1,_§.'
19'?'2, was conducted by giving rééxsoféafile J
apgallant. The I3:1qui;ry fe3;11*;:_;ci' sf {€16
Charges and subnxittad igiiqjuiifjgs i*€:f§;§01"t"€;(:"t1*:é4{i§Scipii:1a:'§,?
Autharity 0%' the C01"p50%*a:iivi€i€’_:’§ Légxlziafiff ‘€}?:éi” _§g’;’iu v D Eéaguiafimas, the
disci_21§11::;:;z”§,*..f%’ui£i%;4§?itv”‘§asS€:{}””3:3;’°9rdar of dismissal 22 aiiizsi
$ _’ V. _ ; ,’
{ha apgfiéiiéfit : f:i;§téé ‘3.1€3w29{}jE., Tbs isgaiégijsg am}
‘va§i€E§”ij,r of {E13 33id~._g’:1′.i€i*… éf éiismiasaii wag Ehé: su§3j€:{:’i zizaiéaz”
gf u ‘d7i:~3:g:–ui& misizci 33}; hit}: iiiéiifii’ Sézizfiam §€}{z%»}{£%.}
:§3:f”f駔;%?::: Disputeg éiiafiiataka ;5;m@:’;
of £194′? (Hereinafter eafleti as the 1?} Act far séiertj
. ‘V’z7:rgéi:g”§%3é”i6us gannés fiarisizifiiézag the ffiiiiiigfi if the i§1{§Uii’}r”
A V”-:§:{°”§§.§:é{:’ a3 fifffifififiilfi ami €f'{‘G1″‘ ii”: 33%;. it was 333% §}.§§”g€(§ ifihai’:
395123 is 8..C$fi§§’%Z€{;§ by €316 éisaipéénargf ;t§s”{.§§§iQi””i§:§5 E-%?i§;.h;O”£fi
appiéaaiéan Gf miizfi. Tharéfafe, gjiwayeci is S€§€-:’§.S§.{§zi’3 ma Griiitr
0%’ éfiisfiaissaé jgaaggfiéi agai:3$§
WA “E”°€f2?’§;”‘i2{§&3
Hf’, has aim atiacked the i::1pt;g:;€{§’f’«–. {Ef
€ii$fE”iiSSa§ afmr refezriizg to the féifiififé <:0:":si8–f;:?;1g,5?-§%:1*
C3″ii}{i§’€f:1f1 am! {he}; are afi :3XC§'{13»§.’¥¢}fy” d¢§j€i.i1€§ii;,g,:’é. on Vf;L%.S’
ifififiilififi. Eva} asaummg, ‘£333: ‘i:’§f1€7._i§ii<ii:"ig:;35' ufgf..€§1i§'._E§i€§u§1f§7.A '
Qfficer an the :::i1arge3 16ve1é'c£..§;g;a»iI;sAf fcuiifi
is be prcsved the eV:~;:r:*,j.1V'c;3;'.::.<:.V-":<:.V"§ 'griizi-fir "='€ht: éiscipéirzagy
§%.uth9rit}J is dispr0p0'§.;ti%}:'1at%§{c3V gfiayity €33?' Em: aiiaged
méssoxlduct §:?é%f§{§ is in '2z§c:§.a§i::':;": <3?'
Seciiém }},:4~.¥% V__ga*:§:{§ f::1't}1er (:@:1t€}':{§.&(i 'ihaz the
carrier :%§.spI'0p<3:'{i<3I1a%:é3 $0 fine
§::2*mz€d n:a£$e:Qi1d.:§<:_':. .f'"i'ia:r*::?:£f@i'{€Z’Ci$€ :a~’i::* 323’ the
..V_éhisI}$€§i§§fiEi§§ bfizififizs.
5), “?h;@ Lafiazzz’ C3223″: %1s;:$ fagisiered 5:325 €§§S§_’}’i3:’$;éf 33:1
i£}.15’€<:a3§.éf2{§%'}}.. "§'h6: vaéiiiiiy of {he inégiiiafy 02': iihéz 'gaésés; Sf
the? %é:a{i%3:3."*:§ {if {Em :i_"§:” :0 3E.%€_>T:” *.m_$ :3;”§:A::’§ 23$ 3; ¥’:§*é:t§ii:1i:’*:;«;§;’$;
5 .. 2.» b
am ‘?O?’L”§,:’:’£{)08
i$SL1f§. The labour mutt Vida Order’ 27.2.2094 fiaat
the §flCji_1i1’fy” is net legal and vaiici. ‘I’}*1:*,1*€f:’,>’si’€:;’, “t}”Vnt.-f:T
133116 is e’E1I}SW€1″€d in the :1ega€;iv§:<a1'1d éthf: C§:::-f'};':V4:*rg{?:§s:.3i:?2 *§s~;,:=fzas 3%’
fiberty to Read evidemca at the -t.{}«. §§;f}é7.§éT’~§.$suéA ‘
r1c::.2 regarding the juStifica?,§é~:.1> oréiez’ 01′ j “e:__i§§:”i”£iSi’3$2 pagsézd
against the workziian ri:sy ad;:i§;1<;*;§f_ig é"<.:i§i€:2'1<:é';a;f:°ési'2 ?§:€iif{§3."€': "iéaii
Laban: Court.
7 . V’§”}’j; é:1’aé: iabour couri in
p&i’1I3i:.:_ti11g _t}§é._-rasjfiezifiéixi is giiiiciucé Evidfince aims}: bfifisre it
to pi’Czv%5; £116 ‘».._a7g»,éi:”;s’E. the wefiilzaan is s3€z*E<:;':is"§f»;
q'a§;:§;£icr;€fi ifi» fh€ 'W§'i3; peiitiem am? in iiais agzpeaif PEa<:*?'r:3g
'&;f§ir€§1*§g°:*§€:E.i;%'a1<3_¢€ 'ijxpiifi the d€"3SiSii3E1 0%' thfi Apex Saar: 2:': {E15
A"'€':a;:é'§ é§:§.3}:_$i?§'v§€.é.J G'{§P'i"A vs THE': E?sFi}US'E'RL§L 'F§€EE%§,§E%Ez%i,
:v,"'i;z3c:§«:mw ANS ANGTHER 2'{:par'{€d in 399m; LL} 22$,
§.$_C§1iéi&nfi€€,% fiia the §@a:*11e«;i 531131361 that {E16 Labem" Csaéri
"§_3.} €'§§@:*{:i3€ 9? its pgwéz' ffiéifld aha}: 8 {};G§};3E§S§i€ §3§.{§§.i§i"_§:'
"'1:i{::"1c§'i;<:ie6; ':33: Size §Li${':i§}fi§i3i"'}' .é5X%.i$§iG§'iE§? "§)}.'€£%j{§§};'}§ figs: 0r{§.a:-:3"
Sf {§i$:r11is$a.% E3 fiiagafia. '§'§":€§*efaE"*€, ii: sfizauéd i"i€}'{. fiave aiigwazzci
flag 1"fiS'§}Gfi{§€3"§E E0 as:§d2.;;<:€ € b€:f{;;-;;: $16: i.a&":;{;~g.;* €f:{;'a3"*i
'v§'2'«'i '}'G'?;'};'§£§{E{§8
ii': fine absarxce 0f 3. pies': in 'aha cazziiiér sta3;em€";';::_' iis
}')€I'fi'iiSSiQi1 2:9 adciuse aviiierice §'}i3fC)f€ ii to p2'? 0'§v€
'$3! a.(iciucing evidence: afmsi'; %:efs:*<:L':;5:"9é;a;:::;t*i:J;'é.ii}, {I13
event of preliminazjz issuaa if
fifiqzziry is invalid in iaw. Ti'7.i1s;_:'L:'§;:::::§::@A1.~*{;:c1*V:A35'%: <3?
zirzasféiei" has no: brazen ::3Ja;¢r: i_r1'i;o:.§§3ii&s§§€re{1ii<;::t: €:f;%h€:* E123: 21:35
La%::«o'"a:" seam 93? by "§}:é '}é:é3i'Ii§§ at the iimfi: af
gassing a.waz*d_.ar:§i'—ordiér 1_#a$.p€c;ii§2?_t_:3§g.' "1é;'herefore, thee Eeaxriied
CG1};E1S€'},,'»¥""';.1}.ffi":'T3{3i;fr:if:'f§iii".fi'}at %:1:a€:-.<:;;f<i€:~ af dészzzissai is viéiaisd
if} E3322.
8. VV;%.::30€,hé1*._ 4Vfg;fr’0:2;i:1<§ sf aitack of ihé: ifiipugiéaci
~ . §%isH:;»i';€a:isa:};_ <éIjci€r' '£2-x1€i____3§;s?a:t§% gsasseci by thfi Labfim" Cami E3};
"-_p'E;3é.%;1g –r€Yiiaixé€.__upQ11 am E_};i"iE'€p{§I'"E€(§ decigian af this Qfififi
éa;:;«~.~:§a%%%25§;:2'§":?:L:;3{%i;':é«%'in Writ Apyfiai Fig.3/286$ aim? Wrié; Agpeasz
I3:5@5/2.€::::§§{:,-§<sR'§=,:ar<,i §'::a$5si–':<§ in
we $3_%.€.§. C2136 wiééi E7€f£'3}"f3ti'§C{f K3 ?;}3;{f ?f~i=%:Z"%'§:{3€i §'%::g§j:1};2§§i<}:T::-3 <2?
\/
am 'E{3?.3fi«3{}C%8
C;o:'piit with regard 3:0 fafi”i.ii”‘€ ‘£0 issue ‘€:ick&t$.§§:7;_:i~._¢G}i€Ct
fare from the passengers who have beaxfifié.-‘ :§§h€fi ‘big 4:315
w<3r%.’é%%:”f23;:”:}i€r4_’f:*om {i”1€§
Siage, amaums to failure is disch”‘av.«rg%?;_’ his ¥i3b1ig;3’té§ér:3_;”–~..§§v;é was” 5
fomafi guilty at’ the 111isc01″;€i;L;:§’$..V_a1″3Wc.;§’figeV i:afi:*t f{>’1:%:C1
the chsxge: proved wasgot s<;V.g1;%%i*gfe '$Q.as t6':2:a1fr%£:é: impasing
€X'£i'€fl}.€ gaallaéty of ciisxiiiéfiai'"z:2f,§':i§%:é4 fmni his fiervica,
Therfifam, thg ig:3 .Z::.QI3:j:' }f"3f€I'I'€C§ case has
exercised–V.§}{§§a2é:':':'1izgeiézcirsjf 3 1%) of the 3"} Act afld
re«:iu{:<=:V{§' {tag dep2*iV%.ng the Warimzazz in aha
saiéi caae his' :'igi:t; t<i~* .e;:}ai;+f11 backwages, after sfittizzg asiée 333$
«_VQrd§:%'«:.<3f{iis1néSSa1,_.._.z<:::;*<i€re<i "£9 reirmtaifi E316 'w{}:*E3:*:iai* :3? aha E&:a:”:”;€:d Siiagéa
and the awazvzté. ef the §3§f}{}’§}§”‘ cauii. “$155 ‘E}i¥i$Em’: Esrgch
V’ G? thig Cam’: éici B{}’€1 §:€}.{€f’§€§”‘€’i véizék E316: §.E¥8}”‘{§ of
raézisiaitimfizzi %.%3fii”:£3::’?§4 bazzkwagés 352:1 with €:{3:’::§:’:’:;i§;ijs; af
§€:2″‘*s2i{:€ gmréiazé bf; i:§_1£:: Eabazsr Ceziyrt, wizicfz wag affi1’*§11€<.§ £232
£316: §€;~::*:':§f.$ E33; i*, ?:ZE”:€ Séifiiffi afi’ir§:”:€::”§
vagza ?<;75;:2{;{s$
*{:js; $16: Divisiazz Banal} by {fii*§1ETiiSSii'§g {he Wrii; 3.;;p4:§iE.s*:;»f %:»<:%:I:'":
the Qaréies. Tm: Said deeisicn has 4' €313
appsfiarcri fequested thifi {3{}'E1i"E ts; aygjifiz ifié "s2é§;;'i"{%<é_ci$§:;:'u§'
the case GEE. hart} in szlpgazi 0f {£38 ;é;p~§§€:fi}3§::E €316' "
same miief :3 the appeilam; ééixtiiiiygs V
9. Azxether §'<3,*i l;":(i qfggf #36:' vi;r;1p:a§;.g:';<~::§ awaiisi
is that {he awaré pass§§d L€:a"z.,:z*?; 033 Eéztgs bagiés cf
evidence add;1ce fi__ uéziéfisrity befozwéz ii
WiE.§§};Cifi1"._. tE'1ei:' :1Q"'~«§}_§€a<ii:';g in its eaazamr siaézezixfimt
3&e}~:§.;'1g §3:jri:1Vi8Si<;:1'-«.353 _E%3.{i d1~i€€ €¥i{§$i"1C€ in me eve;'1*a.: <31'? the
p3"e§ii?;i:'1.3;§g Vis~3r§_:e"'rega1'{iing ihs vaéiiiiiy of the aiermizaiiit
§i2::;1:i;!E§;,"" ilgié {G be invalid. '}'E"2ef'6fG§':=:, ms 8.W8;E"{3i of
re; éij:i§§§1v€§§T.f'6f7::rv$énC€ Qf that gairzis 0%' C§.iS_'§}U"£i"',' if fly: éisrégzissaé
V VV _ ef fiifi a§;:§:=5t-E151}: is had £11 13332 in View 0%' the jaiégizaigé 5.3%' $336
.€S¥_A§§:?§'_:€II1:€" iC0:3:*t in iiiesh R93 {}u§ta's {Z886 ami famhfiz' $15
éT'~_._p:3Tiiis'i:m1ent af dismissal ézxmaseti by {ha Bi3<':§pEi._:2a:'j§:
}%:iflaGzét}f "apex: the appefigfiaixfi. is simaéaizxgijyf disp:.*0parii<};";at$
:0 the graviifs ef the pi'<}'£?€{i 1"{iii":3C(Tf§};éZi{§'i, Whish is 33: viaéafiari
£3? Secfim": ERA} af thé EE Lafmm' éifiézfi :§;:%{E';}§ring the said provision is the fact situaiiaxx ‘E{§««f€j§§C€ii’1g
‘aha I’€f81″€I1C€ am<:»unt;s :0 faiiure to e.:=:s:1"c_:–§.i3<: –:*g}':g§3;–:a§
j?;lI"iS{§iC'Ei()I"2 anti powar. This as§::_es~'i;._(3;f 'iifiaii 'ii'::'é2;%j;é:t%;"§*' 1r:3_»s'-?:_j3é5e;.:
avg? ieokatl by the iearzzfzd Siizgif: Jiiiiiga '::':';1€t: ;E:93f2§:_{{:%g3;:e<§ " '
o1"{i€r *e.»-a-?i':%}<3 examiniizg the :°:ié:'3:;€3%;":§;:1es$" 3:' L;?.1V5V i:Ii§;%iigg§='1s:%{% awaré
passed 3:3}; E1i1:;1_. Th€re§€):*€, fig:—1-":.2i§~réjquestéci~t,<:..–$fit~a$i{%.e 33:16
impugzled Grder Efiid a1s"e'V"Ci_'5<:z~§ r:3Vi$::;?{1iS3ai am} pass an
0I'(}f3§° of miristaaiariiengi witia .C73:%.'ri;';111§:i:j§;'V of S€1"%"iC€3 ibr the
pzzrpcase. ~– _ b€fY'§;€§':S aizci Qihfii" p2:'»:';3f;:0€is:::ai
b€:::.€f%.i$:;'–._ " '
ii}. V'"i%f_ith r€ i" eI*<<:_ri<:::;".."':i.:; {E16 aiimve gaié iéiggai <:{};;::.@:';§§<3:;'1$,
~ . are Ejiéivéi _é9.tffif"::§§§;=" '€§i3a_§}."£i§"}€{i '$35: $331 pzggmeii i}§;'€§€:E' ami aswgsxzi
-..j§;éa.s$gs.”i E.:§§%”Vf;E;:5′}é:a1’1″:s:{i Sifigéa Jziéiga and {E36 i,ab<3"a;r C<§:.:::'i
Wiih "QA 13i€i=;– i%ii}.5'a11$1£?é:§* $316': f9§}0W§;:<":§ $993353 '£3133 '=~'*'0ifi{§ 3i'§$'~'3
'Vfgr any ~£':QE"f=.$§(§€i"&i§GEi:
” ; {E} ‘v§?’i1€:t%;.e;: {E13 {}1″‘%Z§€§’ af ‘£335 §e3};*;m§<,:§ Simgie e_§'a{Eg'£: ii':
afiizziiéng the award of figs Labauy fjfmzrz E3
£3rm:1aa}:1;$ e:g;::3.& vitiat § E1: Eéiiif?
{‘2} Wfiai a*a;a;rd 13 b6 pa ‘* xi?
Lfi»
%¥§’a ‘?E}?;3;’i?G%i}?
E 3
E1. Wfi have p€.Z”11S€(i {ha c}ré€1″‘ §,>§;S$€{§_’ “$21113
p1’€}ifi1ii”iBJ’j;’ issue rsgazfiiixg fine vaiiéiiy 53:5′ ‘ii€%.;{i1€S§§C’– A§,§f;i§_’4ilii’_fg§ ”
data} 2′?.’2.2{}{II4, Whi”)i”‘€:i3″i E? has :3aL’.:}€€3}”:i”–fE{}::if}.*.;li;..£}’7§$.é”4i “I;§i;*l€A.__;’§I’i:§_:L1%}’§’ ”
haki by the if}i$::ipi§1’1az”fv’ Au%}”i§:2;?i§j§;
of a. piea taken in the <:'0:21"zie:'f_fi:_é§i;z,'{};¢:1};¢;1'€,:.:§%1€;_:%13e;;*;;:;;~g;i,§@:":
seeking pe:<*missi:;:;3 0? {Q adcizlcst s§=e.*%.r:%e:1{:&
Qfffififi in the :5-:ve1':€. Vfzsf o fi*1eid ':0 b3 izzvaéiati
ta jzxstify afieii :0 prove
{E36 a(:'E:$ _Q_f_ 'Eh:-*3 WOi"ki1I8.§"1_, fiche
Eabaur error" ii: iaw in 330 flag tiizit
<301*;;{z:*afi0;"i" :5 a<§du:{;€._é$*%;Ee§1<:e afresh anci ca:-:'1si<§<::1"ii"2g :%1a.i
f:f%.:§.{i;§§i1»i:;i«: Wi*€3ngE}?«' Emzzifi ihai $16 l"i"iiS{3{}i'iC§ii{2'iZ sggaizifl
"a:;s::;'::;1.T §§'1<'§v§%=:£i, £3 :18: Egg} and 933351 as 313 saws: is 3:';
aa:i%:r'a§*é:1t§0F;§;é'j__{?"§' the iagai prirzcipie iaid dawn Ezfz,-7 221:: §.;:a€x
' Ciauri in Eéieshra' G1: %'3 C336 rfifarred E0 3;; fa, ":3, an whisk:
. .4 V . .} § P
":.'@1ia:1€:€ is rig1';ii3* piaced §}=' 'aha: A_§:2p€§§a3"zt'3 w'2;:"§$€:§.
..__"'§"'f;€ %:*e§iaI2<:¢ piacad ugzsorz 'E116 said iificision $3}; $25 a}3§3::;i§a§:%;'S
__ :'%G:1nse§ is jusitified and the $336 casai apézifg appiéas ':5: {ha fact
Simaiian Gf the sass: 02': hami.
\N/
am 7:?5;2<:2e$
I2. EV€11 assuming for the Sake sf a1'gu11é(::1§;"~§§':1e:t E1216
m§s<:01'1<iuct is proved an the": 333313 of s:vidé'::*}.€:<:__2:.:iL-ililvjfi afid”3ié;:;$;;ef§;;;.;;;§(_{E16 ”
fifldilig of fact and hoiziing €fl锑 p:;v’%:é%
against the W€31″i{1na1*1 1:3:..acceVpi:§;& -aS–~..§:01;fé{:t%.,,.@sz%}:: £h_:::’s_ iii?)
§i11§’OSi'{iGfl of penalty of .¥€0i’k1’i18fl a>22i’i:,%:;:0%.:$;
iiaiiijiig irate c0x1.s;*’fi <::ra.tiQ':i "3.'*eE :33 1’*€<;"ui§e<:i
§_1flfi€F regzzlaiiizz-Efi . féguiséiezas and net p1*0vi:'1§ %.h_<3
past S€2"%£'i§.3€ % by ma}<:ii'1g %;£':{2 zfizarges if}
{ha a:r'€;iC§s:~3 'ea?0u2’= Eizmri caaziéé 1:0: hasmt raiisici
‘”~a:§9Ii’;:”%:i1§__LV’s;:~3;,:I1£: §’3¥f:.;v:::.<::.2::€;f3'a§r1g {ha ordar Q3' ciésmisgai ggagazzé
V 'agaéiég w._o1fi<fii1:;§::":.
” _ Elifififfifid murigfifi far @253 appi:E;%8.:’:’:. S3}: Efifxfiiasg
%Z.”§:£m$;3:,” if; fhig appzéai gfiacfirzg 1″=I:’:fi8§}{3€ 21333:’; ‘Ehfi ‘:%;~:3;§:§
7é~:–.;V§gAi€:§ii::f.%1£.=:é gfiiicipifi ‘£35; $33.53 €I§€§§3.SE:§§:3f;_E@§’i Efiéizmii {}f 333%
V” }su._;;§:~ame iiaziri is’: me case sf fvEAE’€{E%EE{“%{}i%§B.;% vs $’§;&;€§ <3?
" :'6*;:2<;:;:"¥.:i:é in AER Iééérfig pagfi 345% and Eliza: s:'ii:{:i:3i@:";
2:33' €i:§::.<%: E}§.'ii'i.Si€}§fE B€:2'1{.:'§": 0%' §4%:i$ 'E2: fake 5:33:/»: 9?' 3
I
34
Act, Whi.<:h had ganted {Ems ffifiéif 0:" .i"€§§i£§§;:§i§f§§i'5.CE';§i %%Ei'f}:3*;
(:{3i';'§ii"iu§'tf¢' of S€E"\é'§C€': wifirxeut "aackwagag t0_.A'E%':& %&r-%i'i i<%'I;§'1*.'a:3'2, 25};
{hiss hag $152153 that the fiwazwé; ~~;:=asse=.':§H"'i§:'* .'jfa%}i2a.fifV {if
waisiixxiaii is proved ta} ha Eggs} a:{é:1«Vvé¥_}§.<§';
34. £31 £516 Stags: 0{‘>§:{fi%z13»isSAi£;:’1__, fig
eovfirfiii $3}: the ufiifififiijifid «:;if t.’.fiiSvv%i”3::§.1i:§:*: §’€:f%::’r£=:é ta
Su§;31’a, mt directed Szzefizir Sizzgh Ea”:
accept the £’10_§Ti?,’,a€’-.;O*lfi ;hahé_j’§,§ 0f”:f%:6: C0?g«*;§0:’afi{>:1 zmd 2%”: have
i’1%:a3:*da__hi.m E{:<:* {:;G31:a{;,e3:1_d:%<i Ehaé; {hit u:'1i'€p0:"i;::<;i <i{:«::§.siG:'1
£3333? be ézggpiieii é:_& %}f3&_'fa_céi' éi%'.ua£:%0;': "Sui 2&5}: av«:a:*<i C§”1′:i:”;;u§.'{5:
:2? s§;§~s.s*i€:e is %A%1,;::’3%e*1a:*i{§§:3ez.:”‘;. ‘§’%’;is s§ub:’11iss§<::'; {ta E"}.§'}i'3?; a<:${-:#;;':€:{i
{:3 {{3} '%'3?1:":._._:'€:;";':S(}:': Efiiaé. €533 Sear? Ea': Sémiiai' Efiéi§§.i€i'E' has 11%:
"'_§:1?;%_rf€:}'3}€i._s5:§;§§:2_V*'if:e &'éi?3i"{§ sf Ema éabau? gzrjmrii wh5§z;=;i:'1 :3 Ezasé
g:":a§j:3'£,<:s%.. f,i":£:"':*<:i:"is%;a%;a?,;:;€;':t wiiiz s0m*;i:";u§%:'fg {sf Séié""'»ii€;?€E '25-"EEE":£:ut
' §;.%2::_}<::€-figsgag.
A E3. ‘§’hi: ‘L§’;:’€p<::"{§':e:§ §€{§§;$§(}i""E ii} 'i;E"::% a§<;::"<;%$aé{§ cgaga 0%'
V' '"i.§'15 §):ivi.siz32""i Eiezacfz sf fizis 3321?? w§*:'}f: 3:3 f{}"駧'S a§3;}i'3=" ii; Ehiz
€353? :s§mg;;t%es:':. %:Em"1{:e§ Em-=:* $31235: '€s§iE.{3Ei§{3 ix: a§}p§_%€:{i is $326 {jiaéifi
53:; §2a:;':€£ magi §'a§"§?; §..':"2<5 zfiief iii 'fa*¢{::m'* £3'? a;3;:;s:§§:-mi. 3;};
\\\\V/
E3553 ?{}'?$§;":':{}{? '
a§1swe:1:i:1g the <:<)1"1'{€:1"1*£%<)us fxsiziis f<':r1:I1:;}a%;::e:i ':§S;«.V;f'-':3: 31%:
urimperifid decisian ramiereci ifs; this. (30331 i.:,:§'s "§i::3i
afié {E36 facts in the insiaime: C3Si'-'£§I"ti2- :'~;§;m'_i§a;',' "i;¥.':fi: V§i1sé%,',iei§::i:§°
couri in fifis case faiéfid ta exe1*Cié’e3 {£1215 jU:”iscii<:ii<3.:1" is A
8;(:<:é§p%;@(i *9}; the iearzied Si:1g1f::?§.i€':gé. .'"E'h,s§v'¢fé};f€é;"E$'€: 31% 'of
the View ihai the afsreazggd s%,:?é'5sE3:;i:iiés§._qz1es%;i<::2*"€;f E323: wzfigié
<:m*iajf:_Ejas amiss iii fififi <:aS€';.[.é;:§{E «gm S.§'§7S'*e5§_é§E§£" 'éghe saimz 'fir: §"av<':s:._§;:;-
of the apgsdiazgfa ' "fgasésialg §3'.:}€"f{5§3.*':?1 aréar:
16;. _'5fE:é'L'v:aa&:f33:ri ;::;j,§§$s:_é:;§ E2}; 316 La%:;Gu:'i§g’§§”;g xihe fipp e::aE. “R16 sieziiai of %3as§;v§ag€s :33 {ha
V§”{}:Ti£Iii3ifi. .fQi’~._§ih€ §}€fi’i{)€§ {mm 26$} {:3 ibis ($33; is an
épp’19a§z*ia{¢…p:{i:iS§:2flf;}Le1″3t 15% be ii}Li}L%{}S€vi§ in the piace cf :>rd:ar
. 9%’ §§$1:zis$§E is Qbssrvad. by $316 Diviaien Bfififih 0%’ thig Cami:
€111, aféérasaid uzareperfied dacigien 0%’ t}:1§$ Cami» ‘E18 awafci
{hie Ea’§3:’E3v .fi1’€. _
Wlfif. appssiai in the S€£l}’1€ terms by €;’*1_é=._g§+;iE’a:i”§,,;;f”i1%Eh€:
Labaur Court. V V ‘ ‘
* Chief ]’1;’;SfiCe
‘. \\ Sd,’
Iudqe
Brrzfldaz