IE’? ‘THE Hifirfi CGEIRT 3? K%I’ZA.’I’AKA AT
DATED THIS Tim 13% DAY 01%’ JI3i¢E §’j2£t{}i§ ~ _ _: ”
BEFGRE
THE I~:ozsr*3LE 3m..ms’1fIcE V, ”
WRIT PETITION’ No–.. $’i=3-,1’7’/V2®’§’£€§MV;}E§fiSi’
BETWEEE: V’ ‘ V
1, Wc;1″ldv£i{i£: Shippii1Vg I:*1§:’;’,’E’» . .
E33133. Houssxi, Pa:.aI:1hFur”
Sew Mafigaiiiifi 5f3;75 {}»:’i{};’~ u
Rap. bi.-‘ =25’r::=f:;c.’is*vE?e;’r1.*a§.r:d_:> v .
Iv
Sefiidi’ i%3:i&:g:utiva. V :
iii} S.AShV:1pui’3.’ i::i::1f12ati€;11al Ltd,
Eiine %f}*Wfie:*:?s3_Fr{>€:€:fs’S~mi’s and
E.15Q3GI”‘t6I’S 0f’i:§::;1ta:ii::€:”
P1/im, ‘Wing, “}4i?;;nai Court
_E’~”‘*’.;os: §3(§,%:._§’5{}; 167:3 ‘
.. «.;§\3’ai”~ima:: §>*z:::;1i;_1_:___A .
é – ;vii;:”.;:;1i’:x;a,i 400 £32 1,
_ ” ~ , §§’s;_p;.¥3}.:,_ €}e:1€rai
V Mé3§1’23.Tg<::i* .Xf:§36Va&(:sa::1. . I 6 .Pe'i:iti0I;zer3
' _ { Sri Jagzaram 55 Jayaraxn, Adj
A.N'I}:"
” Managaéere Port Twist
” Vi3″a;T1a:11bu1′
;Ev1angai<::re :*"3'?E": (31%).,
-Vfiep. E3}; thfi Chaimmm theraaf. ..HResp0:1den’i:
{By Szifséaimzzrhaza RN. Adv, far
Sri Asimk Eiainahafiig Acivy)
@
£:¥}”};_V iiemanci in terms cf Nmice at Az1:1e:x’11res “(E53
E3’1.:rf£’;e1” the _p€2t:i%.i<3:1€r has $0i,1gI':t ta dficiare
Cause I'1{}iZiC2E3 anzi the canseqzaarxt' fie-1:'1'f'a3';zi 11;:-_ad_r~: iltc' 'f1OE.iC€
dated 16. 1.:2£}{}'? are alike ifitzgal, »it'ggxii:-c§fii$1:iii.;fi;}na'1
AI1I}€X11I'€': "F" am} appesed £0 ":I?:i%:V.%»p1*oVi£~iO11»$ :9f 'tI*ié' Act to
resi;rai:'1 the respoxxdem v§}jo111 f11z*ti:'e§\, gctiara in
purs11a;i1ce theraoi.' and dire:;: tiifir%a$p£;§id§:r1t'_'.f;<3 rrifund to the
petiiiiafisrs the Sfiilii' ._»:3?:'. Rs}! :2:,'?'.Q§ £98 i_Q§€ti'1€z' 23;-'i%:12. interest
GE' Rs. 14,€}9,8€}'£9§.i)€,§}.{i:i$~::::€:1*fi~§';:{£3d," iii":?s:m€x:1re «~ K} calczuiateai
at the 1/*a§:;:s gg3:.;12d$§
2. vi; is ‘:§::§e’:: aft €156: fiI’Sf §)€”?1£§}”,§Gf}€I’ {hat E3: rec»:3iv€{‘i
:.f%::éé2’i;«3i::\_…g;§i’;§:3:;2méi3;;§iS :>§”E’35’§%:1€::>z’1§t§ in §”;u§;i{ E;£:m*€:€:2 Essiag,/’ EEEQE
aI1’i;i_ :’:i’£:2;fr “asifiigth zhié w}’;a’:’fag& (312623 vs;-‘era E.-:3 33$
“” }€ViEi§ A:-:;} $315: ~ ¥fé2,€ 0%’ 533% gm? f£f}€f§.”‘§{‘f iiiililfi 3.5 $’pe<:§f2€¢d in
" -Ti§'£.'€fi:'zi'2 AA 5:€ ";}z the §z::?;i§'i»::af3§az': daisd 132. 198%. The firstr.
§,§{'f7§j,A2;'i4'i{f§§"3§?£; zimijs paiii iihtégs {$1.165 an beiéaif of $125: Em
VT §e::i:.i.<§}:'2@3', '§'E2€ §.'€iS§£}I"£€"§f':§3E mz1.és:- a aiszzzaxié fa}? §}3}=-"z:;e:':£; {sf
}'<':"'$.V3'2§?2,?}82.?i"3 83 S3"}€).§'§; Eevy ::;fwi1a;°i'ag€ E171 §"€ga:'*:;i :0 {.316
\w/
said s§1i_pI:1ez:ts am} issued a 1"mi:1§<:e 0f demami. Aft;:::f_ somzzé
.32;3″73/93. in the §11ferreg*:’::1:11:,’;’Af}1¥e’«first; masts 7
directéid ‘€23 pay at the rate 0:?’ Rs. 134?’: :S’ujbj6:c’£. §::?A’ad;§1i$€ii1%é:i1:L
after <:0m:ius%€31"1 sf pmceedings.' an o:*Ci::§" 200$
vicie A33nexL1r€~A, this . ._;1§é::a,sed '£6 fiuash the
i'I}ema;1(£ §'~§'c;tices «:ia.1:.<3d and 1'?."?. 1993
on the ground t,h%:y :1:%§v€"~ §iG'Zat.;¢5i' the principles sf
naitxrai jigstige a:i:';:"z.Ew'ér¢"a?iE:§aiivé 0? the provisions of S€C.56
of thfi Mi'? ,e'~'»<fEf;,% 3 '$635' :10: ggreceded by an e:";qi_z§:'y
aftézr a;f§fc§f{%Aing ai'1'~:)§p£21'§:':3:1it33 to the psé:駣;i0r2€:'s,. 'i'ha (Emir:
A':',esé:*e*.e;:i {ha 3['€S§}i'3§'.1d€I}t to Beds {ha fi3.&§Z'i*$I', if they
SQ "'<5;.e"':;§m:§; 1";e-a"s.%ii":§ 332 cazitsntioyzs Qf thszi pa1'%:i€:S are kapt
3 spam.
” V. n if:;4..é’Fhe1*ea§”f.€:’, the E113: ptétitiezzer again reseészai 3 shavan
__1<::TémAsgt'~:» rfiaticae {iatad 2, E 1.2i:){}{} f:'*1:d$nt rapaaiing
‘4 2.31%: same <i&::aa1":;<'§_ fzzr Rs. E13,' 2,982.'?:'% "éiawartis iihs: difi'e:*&r1<:é:
in wharfage eharges. The petiti01'1e:* once again :'ep1i@(E"*:.¢ {ha
Shaw-<:aust":. matice Stating that there was no ap.;:}_§céiii%:i~:1""s;f
rnind an the part; 93" the re$§30I1ci¢:<1t; ii} the qz1é;;<§:f,ie§_;~~.T:jf"A1e1:§y
and the dezrxixand 1'1-c::t;i€€ was witizagilt b;8:;41_1§?}L(}}f"i"~'i;}!* .§3f 1f5;?.V'§'5«";V "F'c
make the e.{:t;i0:{1 65251} more E3ian;<~:woi't}1§;–,._ iI1Sf;{3§iTi(i'A. sf' 0ff§'§:'<i_n[g
iegai §ust.iii’ <}f
v4_i:}:rar1si§;;e:'1%.' atitit é;.:s.?§_»r:;_ ____ __a.:3S11:"fi6€E by {ha I'€iS§}€}I"}.d€I1'E, me
:§.§z§'ii§{i€§¥3,;€:E":?~.i hTafi "£:;§ other aiterzaative but :0 apprcach ibis
V ::':w1~s::2-;r §?3{é'.";3af::§§'1:§ time in W? §'$aa54{}?j{}?2, $3; an arder
{i'at.e::i {§sI1Ii€3XL£E'f:~}3), tizis Cami. aéiewed the '%%E'I'i'ii
:péiii.§(§;5fz–.:§;§1e:'e§f2 21: psira~«9, {ha Cotiriz «zzsbgerveii as fafiewsz
"E 313': Sf {.216 9;3i3'1i01": ftha"€. {he
gmtitre &0e$ ROE indir::ate as {:3 in what
:§33.::,a:::3§1€z* 15¢ aariier lav}: is shafiwiaviad
E101' {mes it Ixienfiam about the
fiatigfaatiarz sf §.§ nde:'3t am this
aspect. Efraibztunateiy, the order at
Am1exu1'e~Q is no iII1pI'E)Vs'f3I11€I1{. It
suffers from a geatér fefly of not
indicathig any reason far the order. _Ifé"" 9
0111}; recites about the developmenigté V
and rejecteti the 1'(:p1'esc=:11t£:3.ti<}z1,,–» .. , " '
{ices 110$. wan indicate ;:ee:3’*-
consizierfid anti. as to forvfifirhat rtiaS<3I1'*». 2 VV '
it haS been rejeCted;TVA.__c1aSS§¢_: VCxan:fj'1é?g
0f 3. neryspeaking era-$f;'–? '
4. ‘1’I1ez’$fo;re, it;quaS}”.1_ed E116 €§éi;1é’n;_d I1oti£i’e’:s”issi;ed and
sent it. back ta the rcspoiiderfi: ff3 i’ {‘i)I]..S_ifCft;°.;}'{?11i_§_QH and to act 3211
3<:<:m*dar1c:e xvith;~'ia<.§ %;n iiifm; g:*€)u'n;§' –:?;?a€:fi.1__i;}1e demand Izoticas
iasuafi Contrarfi E0 the provisions Gf
Secfié af £%1€–_A€:t a§r3.<i""3'j1:";:";§"'**E.:;<5:1i§¢c~s _ wars quashezi by this Court. ‘}’hus, the
Hlaitsf-¢01i}d”_”_h€§;iii again 91113: with ‘£113 issue of fmsh $.I:::aw*
Esause xfmtiiigzf, ‘$%}1i.ch were in compliance with 8:3-:<:.56(2) mi' the
§%3::';. i7:;'T1'-»:::nga:4d to the pariofi Wi'£hi£1 Wmch such notices maid be
V " 3' Tim ground of attack sf' thé $hma:T~ca.use mastic/.»: is £213:
it is iiiegai ar§:2£t3'az'y and issued in §::Zaf,a:3i Vi{}}&§1i{3I'£ af
\w/
pmvisions 01' {ha Act and oppamd to the pri11<:ip1€S ofgi§23_tL1ra}
jugiica.
6. ‘”£’he I€ai”}1(:'{i Sznéhuzzsel, M.1*.A.N.Jaya_.Rma_q:’ ‘éifgpeairfizg
on bahaii’ of §)€i€i'[i{}II€3I’S has p1aCe€3.:;:’:1’e1:i;§;1 1§§;<§'Lfiégjfsg "
R1 $39.34/12/$9/'rGA~6 date:i..__':.:2;'1.§§'8':2
eariier writ petition. _F'urther K ivfalziéanae upcm
AI1jIT16XU;jT'€'–A No.34/' 12/ 1 .__5. W}:'1€:I'<i=:i11 at
SE.N0.4'7 rega1'd§I1g_ "tizaemmfuatratgad " 'fiané gaods net
otherwise'iiS*£.€:;.?f_;is"3iiic:iti§}:1ed_fi3f 1:116 purpose of ievjzixig
wharf?-gage é§7:aI*-gas-91*: 9:' <:ubic meter and kilo iitr-6:.
'i_'%1::': gajgi _vt:1T2'{.3"j§' gs. mt é2.;:3j§§iicab£e ti} £1116 goeds; in qiuegtisri.
"i'I;:s:ref@fé,i-.::\{*':e*§:::1p11g:*ié€iA aifiznazzd :10ti<:§: is bad in and is Iiabie
{<5 33% g{:as§;;;%,:i". . V
ffhs .i<§arn::«:i saunas} fer §:seti'£:i<mer fur¥:h€r C£}I"}'£€f1{i€C¥
%tj'f§;«::::A cié:t€rn.1iI:a.{,i%.’§:::9i:>r;i Esemzeezz May 19%} and March 1993 by $116 resperuiant
is :’1e.:::: 31%: pr<2peI':i{:tem1i11atior1 of Charges 'E,ip{}1"} U516 pet:iii01':r:r
\\\wu/
as the demanfi zzetice has nut been considered by t,a_}{;13g into
€~1CCDE.II1?Z {he objecttions iaken by the petitiozier i§fi£i:. féfsrézgce
to the provisions of UTEEE MP1' Act; and the"
a1110un’t.wit1’1 refbrezace to the gaedsixa Qiléfifififl ‘i;s §:Ic:;i.V15£3SVsible
to be measured in terms sf either cu}3ic}:a1eter o’:ijiki} iiiirééafzd
it dues. not 12311 wit11i_11 the tiefiriifién of “é;;1″€:’S’.-V-T}’ié:;”ef0r€, the
qL:9.nta’I’1ca1;ion of the arnétznt by r%:3jn;afid§ént is “:1.§:§t: iegal and
valid and hence requested fQr._qLifg–iShir£g S’:-“~;:1::1<:.
8. *i’i”r:;e – _i§éj;»31n’éf’::}”– é:tit:_e'<iQr:i:a:1diz}g that. the qzzaniificzratiaza
xi;'}f–.£.§1€' :§E1?1;}3._11':%iAi-S i1 V:'<::;)r:Vi'a1':11it§,=7 with S€=IZ7.56 of the MP? Act
;f~§;"EI?_§f:1*%fi'ii1:g :,0pp0rtu:1it§;* t0 the fi"I'S$ p€t,i':i$neI" fer filirig
" = 0b}ecti§:{r1s has been atansidraraii axis} the _E3<}a1'd has
~ : -'::m1<:* is £1032. factuaiijy and lagafljs C(}I'Z"'€C'f €'i?E:I1 aSs:..1:fiij:ig;_ that
gowads in ciumsiion fall '£Vii"hi}1 1me1'1u11'1{:ra£ed g'<3o«§1:A$"§5«2M%§.'
of the 1mt.ificat:i0I1 far {ha sake 0§'g«;rgu;I1€1éts—- saiii _
511:1}? appiicabie 23:12 E115: geads H1 <f; ::;¢3§}'i.<;}5L
view, this %5<)ar(i is required i;o':;:f;4:-I310
ad} the fa.<:t:L:a£ aspectfi ..;;§{;~3'1.i.i:c3:1i;i,<.:;;1'2VsD§ urged in
statemezit. 0;? abjezctkigns 3'§€:Vif.%5t;§Li§ri;Vt$1é«.B9ai\:£_’ 1:0 femcéxamiiia the Whcie 0133111 if
the: first: pe£:i£j£:I1V&34 “.§’:>$:s,r””‘~:;*§?:;z:1′ s’;r;’;.d:%:;;;’°i11g 1:116 :’e3:«:vara_t: §)E'{}V.’ES§€}E”IS azxzi
reievaijfi “e:::11::rjg«* “§’:r”§5I:: {E18 zzaiéiicatimx and CQ3″}S§;Ci€1″ the
V. Ist,ai@§§_,1 efi$k:%I’ Q}§§.§3{3?.i$E”}S and ciispass Cif ‘{l”}.€ Santa Wiiiiiiri isighi
é7§;.’§{‘/161%
:s:¢éik8é'[‘if1f0:§’; $15: zééaife 01′ rsceipt af¥;E1§s arder.
ELLE. “‘°E’fZ”‘A:§$. Writ i3€£i§]§.O1’1 is iiispegeai 0f in abovfi terzztxs.
Sd/-5
JUDGE