3% THE §–IEC1_r§~£ (_’£fj}?5F*IT €315′ E<i§3;RNg5xTAKA AT BANGALQRE3
DATES THIS THE 24%: my 01:9 JULY zowk ix
BEFQRE
THE _HmI'BLE MRJEISTICE Q.m:1.%:M;g§ég;S§££;§:;%:'~;?7,
CREMINAL £§PE7'EAL réQ.i:3V1i:'.'. €3":%2<5<3.a:§' ,
BETWEEN :
‘1’at;’r1§I’a3a .
S ;’0 i3haEna’§§r€gm¥€§u:%_ ” «-
Residfint Gf Hannamachfiialii V
vifiage, Ku;:3iga_1ATa_1uk_……»_r.
‘?un1km~B:sz;;~;u:.:__ j % .’.?xP’PE.LL&NT
{$37 s;:*i:kA%.2–{;31~;aga§g&an, M;
Am): V’
Sfi3;’L€i;;.QfK£3_i’1″ié’té}§E1. ….. <4 .
. "Big V. §*§uiij}R,z?%:§~!_:1'ga. Piiliiffi
7 'Rc:§;3'c$r;vr1*i:c§;,1f_ fbj;
‘ -*F1″::?,f Eflis Pr0$6£:utm”
Efiigil’ C,ourtf’B?:;i1éi;1g$
Ba:’;;gaitf_3Tré:; , , . .,RE§SPOE’*é{}BNT’
{§§?;S:”i:BeRaj3. Subramalfi-‘3 B3131; Gav: Ari?)
–7This CFLA. flied 1111:1252′ Section 374%?) {§r.P.C.
agaifigft the juégiant dateszi G1.€}€2:”.2§{§4 passad *5}; {he
.. -P’r6SidiI1g Qfiicfir, Fast Track {‘.0L1I”€–I’fi, ‘§’uI1″1}<:ur, in
S.{3.N9.1'§4;'20O1 C§I1ViC"Ei{1g the E3_§§Cfi;fi.§"lf."B.C(3U,S$d fur
the sffencie punishabie under Sectirsn 39'? 9f §§"{i zsgnfi
ssntencing him :0 uniisrgg rigmmus iznpriscygznmnt far a
Q/.
2
peried of 5 yearss and ‘:0 pa}; 2: fins cf RS.E§(){} g:§;V§if§§1?:;£?if’_4’T
‘:0 uiflfirgo Sifiipie 1II1§fiS{}RiB€I3*£.§TiI’ ems: ‘:12-=:’:ei:1€ii}~..
This CI’LA. rV=._}*1é;3;1%égrig”Ti:,%”:i$”‘dé3?;~-.323 A’
€I’:€v;1§’t Iiiéfiafifi {ha f<)iE0aa2°i3:g:~»
J U S N A '
This Czinainai Agéimgai i_$ f"':'I'f<.:«:T< i; .';1g ii€i' er §e.I::i;:s1:§ :3-mzz}
of (3 *.P,{). $332 $116: §€£tI"g"£u:€€1:féj:§,'V'_"_f3}€ appeiiant.
amused againsi ” WE passed
by the ‘i;’iiM1:’i-E11, Ttiiflklil’ £3″:
Sessizszzf &’.§i§<§f1;2'iz.tti:1g the appengm
a;cc:1se(i f<:VV1i" 'f_"3:1f: uiiflm" 8e£:t;i-gr; 3&1}? z:::f
IPC: AQIECE "$;s2V;:t1;a:11€:3i:. fer afiéiieé sf five years afifi “:19 gm}; 3 fimfi
éfév §f:._§i;§:fa11§t ts} 1}.fiC§€I’§€.) firimpia im§)r:§sI1m:::1t
far A:’3,,_§3»$I’§:.€’,%€T§_ A{T>3:1é=: m@.nfi:ag
AA ‘ E haw heard {ha iaaméd Counsai €01″ ms
as @1263 as iearzzzeé €im:::1sei for ‘(ha :*es§30:’zs:i€m:
” I have pfirused me recortig.
gr]!
‘3. Eyiaf fa<:t.S <:::f the case G1' the '§,3:':3:si:%:t:":i2§'t:i :f;jfi..Tgig…
as f()};§O'%i€;'Si ._
That, an 1::'}.€}f§.E€§f3{} at abafii ;3;T[:.:L 'i1éV f:':11’I1a11m.{:hanai1a1ii figlagfi was :.,§1§:’z;::*r,é:§..,» §§m§°’&€:’1
éfihargegheet witxless <Ci§%:,;f%" §*§§;:*1':1§:3.eg::.?da and
the accusea. V’ (“3§’13.”E’g€_*;§.§-Effafifiij
ieviitnesss E~Ec.’:;,i _:;2i<:k€{i 8. ciub and
1'f3SE}§i?L (pf fisizich, Ere
Sustainéizsi €23} §;1£fi;<;?E;{' ' V.
F? C}”ifrz?a¥;;§€ $353.3 f§’8I§}€(T§ agaixzst. éhs &(3C’LiS€{i.
gaieéfiiéii mat: guiitgf. Theraafzer, ‘(ha
§?I’US<§§§1;i?.i€}§fii €53-aznified PW31 ta: 4 and EXP} ':0 P4(a) W€};"€
m$:"§§'ed:V___va';:§':i§"~"I§£G§ 13 3330 marked. The d€f€2{1C€3 éici amt;
._ exa:11i.;":e:_a1:y wimess but got marked EX.§}i {Q 34.
' The findings of ma '1';-13; azam: is as fefimasg:
' H B031 PW1 31141:} PW? dep<;$e& tflat: tfzajs tmk the
u w:i'I'"'1j:fi'ed from '€116 Spot in the TVS 0:? PW? {G }'a112ru'ff§:u:"
Cm':
incidfiiit Wfifffi 1″<3§5s§e:'*ec1 mm are pemiizig _.7ii:fé:i§"<j»:':é%%;- _
€';.';au1't. NQI1~6xam.i:t"1ati0n ef tbs _,m§di_
tmated the :i11}Lzred cw: at. I\§:i>1:2h{_’aa”;:3 }E»T§_€3′:~:;§i€ii:Q,’§ :”a:”:'<:?:_'
medicai c-fficer who t1*€:ated"€Z_§'i?J..1 at";.51I11I'"i7},'(}T;;?;£i§ '?1'fi§¥§&I'}*' –. "
Health Center who ha8;__:i.ss1:€:§_.§§§:'§:§?2" V§t%iO:El¥1%Z£AA{:$?;§i'iifi.C8.i.€
has met been exalziixéééih? * Ema f"Li1"¥;h€1'
ebsartvezi that." izf;: 23:; ijkfficea' of
Nimhaxzs, '1j;ég:;as net exa1:11i;'1€<:L
As SL1Q§*1;"'L}1;$€ = is " {$16 Qpixzian that. 11011»
é:;§ian1i:§3a:j::;:;§ V' Gr Meéical C)ff:<:€;1' GE'
fi;T£1'§.i'1¥§.')1}i_EI' ?-;*;fim:3;"_§-'__ E?i.»%:f:*;"a§;¥:'£;: Cxantez' in no way gssifi aifszazt
" '~ fihe: {sf t11é"'*5ec:_fi;i0;”1. Cciigifieiimg ms antira
LéI;icie*:1C€:%..pf3.ci:i»:§{:1.:3%iZ§G{} at E<:.He'3:ma:I2aa}i1ii1a}ii Viiiags. With
V' rfigard :0 the im:€11i:i–:3r; of the accuaeci 1:9 commié: Iiaurziar
" is C{)}1C€I'I}.€é, E116 a;c:::::$ed assaulted the ir;3L::*ed by
31:33:13 :35 c:iub«-M,{}. 1 911 this heaé. 'E'hi:f~s is S°E.2f§iL'i'§€I}.§ to
J?/'
5
661136′; EL} 3 C{}I.Ti{‘;§i.£S§O’I1 that. ‘(hit in’€T€21:;i{>17; «:1? the a£€)L1§Sf”:{‘§
was *’i.»::> {:0:11_mii: IiTE”L}FCif:3I’, Thc’::’@f01’e, tzhe ‘T_7’féffia§l” = .
Cmivicteci Ehfii a<::::_:s€,d £61' fhfi ff6jIfj1:_ff1V;e _A$3 the –. L
viCti1n~C’W 2. i$ 13:} fi”§Q1’ii_i, 3 :zV10:11§i1ai_=.f;r;e {:§i’–RVs.S(j:T}fm was
impesézd.
6. é}.g@’:i.;::t;_r»=:>;:§ izby, Liiie aézczzseai hag
giraferrzéfici this _
‘?. *-f£_,»£:”,;:a:°:’1é3;cI A{.§{‘m.._;%’iiis€} far 6:36 ap;3€fiam’. $u’::rz§:ai%’.’E;§:cE
ti1at,._%§h%::*a ig f’1i}.._vi&I1C2’5€lf%’€ fer tbs C:’:%_m€. 3&1: t:§%_1§%I”§”€§ has
“§”}§i’3?£’€€fi {ha irgjnrsd and {£18 aazzcugfiii avan
%5:§:1’«f:hgé1’i-v4iia£§;’ –v”ar:{§; ‘{>thr::§* $3.}-F1 F1? 5: and 2 are Big}
iflfiifféfitfiii éagiziggegs. Ewsiz ihmzgh savfirai pe3:3::>:’:$ z2v’e:*€:
-=.__V’-ga:heri’:~;:;jE__ 3ai $323 5336:, no i:1dep€mieni.wit:’::=:s$ hays be:-,3″:
“:T’*<: :~:gt§'§"?1~i;.1::e<:i by tile pmsecutian. £331; }:'3;(}i.'2{ir{}G bugtie
– téagk piace amciagst. ‘fififi vfiiagars am} Iizafiy of them ware
V’ ‘E13-znzrad ami thay ‘i$’s2’€§’€ :%{§Zfii’i’€.€{i E0 the: Eiospéiai as per the
D,
wi’:13€;$st:s; — E:’:ju:;’y rep@.1″‘t$ st?:’::3mi{.i,€::’i ‘U3;
::1::}:’ –~ §:30{:E{}i”‘ not examiiifid ~ E%€pQ:’t.s
cannet. be ustéci by praséaztuéion E15: ‘{)E’G’J€;”‘–«
ifi}i.ii’i€S ‘L}.I’i(i€?£’ S» 129%. ”
$. Léarzled Higli {fiouist G§w:rm”:;é;’1_j5 Piéaéifir ”
stibrgiitted ‘(hat {Em inzziiiszztai 55:1
PWS} ami :2 arcs: E116 ey&«;;;ift§2e§s@é’~._az1é :t;’£3g:f:*ii’* §’10
1″‘€8_$Q;{“1 ta éi$b€3:EtE”:¥£’fi ?}:1€fi’:. is “i};:e”* J:::;s§<§i~3;:igaEing
Qffiesr and E26 co:1di_;{::t{:d j'i:hs:: 'i:";zz:n3S?ig*atia:i Véaiiai éaité
Ch&%f£'g€ShE':€17 §}€f€jE"€ the
€§. _§–'W ji fhasv ':"s;§2.f§,efi._~ 13:: his fEV§£Z§%?;i"§€:': thaé;
a}za»1'1§32V1fi:}€:{._E5£iV:':_Vi;:'§:?.;,i_§S_ iT}§5ts§f§';&?';%'« ..,€3§§1'é';{%;§ia}': aixi .3133 231636
Lmgaiézli *ii?§1§7{E2v'V':*?'§:§f;.'%;i5E{§_fi*;{§¥:;A.V'§_¥."1' {mitt sf }ianuma1':§h;§§aE':"S
§":a£.eE.. 'E'}':fg;;fg5%:s:3;$ the fiziéiagxzz fit zizai time, €315;
. _ acc »*.;:i.;§;é§"'i:' 3.;E¢'i4aV.1;;;':';;.3V1fV;:~€3é_:__A 'iiig aasaalii SC¥E'§1€§}C&€§:§£ efisé: anfi
assauit {3}} 03"} the head 01' £3?! 3. Efiuzéxag
".%f::°,Vé,.."cr§$§-égéfiiigzatiari, he fitatss that} ha has met. made
$:a%é::1€%V:"§: §Vef0:'e 'F336 Pgiizze E3133: 'fathiraj attezzzptad ta
'..ffvfifs$a;2§t %sa11:€§ad§* €£$€ and at tilaff; £32316, {ha 33332;}: fail
E/,
an the: héad sf E113 patéérxzai zizlifiew '?}'1t":}'e 2a?as-'ab{:{§:%.i'L:'Ei§(: .
p@;'se3'1$ gathered theraz. S0 _E1§:.__ ;:a::~:1§'€ "
3:'§Sa1iif€§ w1'x0:::':.
18. PW’? has sfiaiteai”V’V§;1;; E”:i$ 5:1
15.0E..2{3€}G an Shzulkjgféiiati §z§£’1e;; Catitia
923$ jumping @3362′ VA 311:3} his
§ai:e:21a1 Li.:j;83;a’*:’é..:»_”~i§.1;;§¥:%<=,~:':!; {.352 E. amé he s:T1staé_:':eaE
i1}aa{1i:1g i%':L§:;i§if€:–s;s% €61} <i€:w:'1 a-:;r;.:;i 203%'; E33
{?G1}§j§:£C}i O?:*};'.§§'}{i3§§.A- ._"'§'§v:&z§., PW} axié hmxsaif Esaifieg égiiaéi injured
.{§I3.,'T'\§S V%;s::. 'i}'z& fiearhjg Emspiizai aéaci tizere, thfifg' éaciyziseai
é:hé§':7: i5::3'éfi?2.ii'é_i,.?£d5E*}.a §;:f1§T:;.m{1 :0 331316 Qihfif haspitai. Then
i;§:€§f 3;-::§:<e'¢<:%' 'ahgi §1'.2ju:*@s:i ta §\E%:1fi1'ia:.:$, Bangaiaifl E}':.1;§ii::g
.. i'xis—.§:1'0$s-eXa:11§11a§"i0:'1, he Si.8.§Z€S iiriai 'Ei1€I'€ %¥€iE'€ abcauz
}i:§:§3G"§0 490 gersergs gathéraci at 316 spa': ans} {hare was
M§ ighti13g §;}€t%'%?€fi}'1 ;::'1€:mb€:I'$ af Ja§1at11a. 9a:'t.;;' 3:163
::t:€m.b€::'*s {if éffangesgs §?a3'E§?. The ;-3::s::1,:s€:d was staliazliézig
?,
Ea'
EB
{mar 'the ham} and he": was not hatriyzig zshzb in _i;3i{:s ~ V
CW1. 113$ Stateci b L
£1. PW3 has i.£;1’I1€€}VA,-31-!T:{Si§;i1€§j§O Q? ‘{.%”:<–:
§3T£"OS6{3E1'fifE(}I1.
:2, (}ff’i€::e3:. He:
:’€g°ste3\§;§ 1: Ni}. 3.12 ,!:2{}{}{:2 af
VEEII ‘!i.:1″1;:_”~: ‘basis 3;? £326
S:ate:I1éii:_ $3? ::*c’::c{‘>:'{ié:v:% Egéléz $”2’a§fi;:s:;e:’1i
0f cigftf \s,:t§’i§1€s$ .::a:::@:;g,=~ Sizivagmfia and G1.m:ia:ia1m ‘$16513
Véliifi_’v:§:.£'{}%:%::€%£f:’§{,Ei¢.,_V’§:.’::§ me Spat an ?;9.€.}.§_.2{}Q’Ci 3:15? %:1$pe<::t:a%:t:}
giE§{4; .__$g§é;;:{"_~v.a:';%§'"§;);'e§3arc:t§ 'E516 Spat pa:11{:h:~:ar;aIz1a. €317:
:2'?. {§iT.§.2{'){}{1%"'§(:ez:s€§ "v'i"§§h the Gréaz' Qf a:1tir::ipa§;0a*:; E333
Va;;;g::r.¢a:'é€d befare 311111 3:1-ii he famzafiy afiestaci Eaifii anzii
Aiitiééfiisici h:§I:1 an hail. Ha rszceriifid 13116 staiézlztizit ef
{SERVE has prui; his LTM :31": the $'{at§m€:'2'£.. 'SE16
<?§3m’§I1g ms cross»
13/
E3
e:~:a::;1§;1″1:3.t.io11, PW4 states that an }V5.C12.’,;8€:{}~–;i§:§éi*é .
bxzsifiez. T§”1<3I'ff: am abami twc: Qther. ,<_;a.s@§3"i:1"' GE
tilt: same ii"{ECfi1£11.§I"i'€ an 16.6 * :'?.'G_§
€':I"3,{§'L1iI'€d in the viiiage, _ v§;s:}bo~':iA§;' =;t;hé
i::1-::i-:"}.{=;1":iE:.. He state$v:f:.1xa¥, $i:a::i1':' Wfifé
f<:»u1"1fi. on M01. §_?;a$ ' '4 {ha wetmd
cazfifiaate frargg}. A:%fififi:¥§11;:* Pri§na:*y
Haaith C7€1{}EéI;:_= 5:' ~ ~
__ 7E;h€:.";§.g3}I§ee1}a:é-§Qo.t1;*E possesses fuli gmwfir {:3
ga E1113 Eséidezzca _aI1{i 332 reigcvaat
ci3°Q1.:{ E3526 guilt G1′
fl,f§;1ff:, i;:§*§;{;~€:¢:1{:€:V 9? the acmlgaé Izewevfir, “maxing in :rn:i:;”::<i,
':}3?é;3:_w%€}if:3:5*6»_V.i_;svigfiié "iziitiai prasumptiasn 0f imé ficfifiitfi 95 an
a<:s::§;:§&:§.: tkhfi fact of acsiguittagi by am: iriai {ff<:vu§*€[. if
" V» .. 33.3.1 Cimfii. juiigzafint verges 91': {E16 @€}"'%'EFS€ig 331%:
' 'éxfifgéfiate C0112'? has 3 {Suit}; tg jufige am} pass a przypar
"§1'€i«e§: if tram sséews aye r@ase::ahE§: gmssibie; £213
a§3p€}1a5t€ iiaeufi: might 11:3: :6 iniaifera with ax} ardsr af
ex
E3
11161611031 afficers have rim. bc:<:~:1'1 6:43 mi1"1ei:i'– '#33? *
prasecufizm. €311 rztareful exa;§:1i113_%i'§:2–.Qf -FEEL," "ii reEw~:_e;}SL'..V V
that there is (16333; in i1a.1":<iii1':g.»':':;:'i:f€'%:}tf A'
iaarnaé 13e'£a§'3i3'at.e. Since t$.14é~~..%i11j1ii*e_d 'éagas ta " '
Priniazjg Heaith Cie11t.€r;.j fiafi ffiéxvthtg: advice
0f the 1033} dacter, he §¥.%.$ fiaspitaiw
in that prQce$s'3%§§§:re the FER Er:
my view, fiié §’x%¢I?– filfi FEE may :15}: be
i11ts:”1tiv€3″:;1 ‘aVi”z§};£};V §1{:i g€:’ the me: ef the saga.
The afiu§:”:§f.’%;<iC? §1:3a..:r€{i by 2;z:€a.12$ ef 6311?;
whic}? is aiifsuf; .?;.,fEét'v.§1§"'}€:1g'ih. Tiia Trig: 9,0111% ;z::1ai:1E§;
. 1. -riiiiefi 63:: ('£23 €¥.2'.Ei;§éf:'5<:'%i: Gf PW} and 2 W215 Spaérifi a_ba3.:t
L-..*:§:..f~’ :::1%;§3. Thfi ‘§’riaE Cami’: ‘C€i§1S§€Zi€i”‘§f};g {ha €Vi{§€1″1€.3€
“”~:’;f thé :3jé€f~EK?§{‘1’1€SS 313$ $01216 ES this $<3§1€h:$§;9:": {hat $16:
~ac€¥iS&é afisauited an the héiad sf {fie irzjzzmai and the
% = ….@5§"i'{'»::T3.{te: fafis "LEZ§.1d€}£' Sea::i;.im1 Sf}? :33" EPS.
La"