Petition moved in HC against triple talaq ordinance

Mumbai: A former municipal Councillor, a city-based NGO and an advocate have jointly approached the Bombay High Court challenging provisions of an ordinance that makes the practice of instant triple talaq a punishable offence.

President Ram Nath Kovind had last Wednesday signed the ordinance, according to which giving instant triple talaq has been made illegal and void, and will attract a jail term of three years for the husband.

Seeking to allay fears that the law could be misused, the government also included some safeguards in it, such as providing for bail to the accused husband.

However, the petition moved last Friday by former municipal councillor and social worker Masood Ansari, NGO ‘Rising Voice Foundation’ and advocate Devendra Mishra, claims that provisions of the ordinance are “illegal, null, void, unreasonable and arbitrary”.

“The very construction of the ordinance shows that it selectively targets men from the Muslim religion. The provisions of the ordinance are violative of fundamental rights of Muslim men,” the petitioners’ lawyer, Tanveer Nizam, said.

The petition has sought an interim stay on those sections of the ordinance which criminalises the act of pronouncing talaq by a Muslim husband.

It is likely to come up for hearing before a division bench on September 28, according to the high court’s website.

The proposed law would only be applicable on instant triple talaq or ‘talaq-e-biddat’ and it would give power to the victim to approach a magistrate seeking “subsistence allowance” for herself and minor children.

A woman can also seek the custody of her minor children from the magistrate who will take a final call on the issue.

Islamic Law- Oppression or misconception?

An insight into the triple talaq controversy and other Muslim personal laws in India
By : Imaan Saudagar

Being a law student, I’m often asked questions regarding my opinion about the
oppressive Islamic laws in India. The recent Supreme Court judgment, which scraps
the triple talaq system of divorce, has raised hundreds of questions across the country
as to whether the judgment is an infringement of the right to freedom of religion of
There is a difference between the sharia law as established by the Quran (Holy book
of Islam) & hadith (prophetic narration); and the Muslim personal law that is
applicable in India. When I studied family law as a part of my syllabus in Third year,
I was never able to draw parallels between what I’ve been taught as a Muslim since
birth and what the law followed in the Courts were telling me.
Divorce in  Islam  is the most loathsome of all permitted things and should be used

only as a last resort after following certain stringent provisions as they have been
prescribed. In reality neither does the Quran nor does the hadith state or give the right
to any man to divorce his wife by saying ‘ I divorce you’ thrice; in one occasion.
The correct procedure would be to obtain divorce when both spouses mutually
consent to it, which is followed by iddat (cooling-off period of 3 months). After the
lapse of this period if the spouses do not wish to reconcile, then the divorce is
confirmed. The Sharia law as distinguished from the personal laws that were
applicable in India makes a provision, whereby the pronouncement of divorce in a
state of anger or the one said without an intention to divorce is held void. Any
deviation from this is considered to be a mockery of the book of God (Quran) and
should not be practiced.
So what is the reason that law in India is contradictory to what the
Islamic law actually states? The deviance from Muslim personal the Islamic law is a result of cultural

influence and personal convenience of people who are propagators of such laws. ‘The
triple talaq’ was a part of the Indian legal system, and does not exist in any Islamic
country across the globe. Such a tampered perception of the law exists only in South
Asian countries, which makes it quite evident that the source of such a law was not
authentic and is not derived from the Sharia.
The question about, women in Islam not being allowed to go to mosques have been of
major concern. As per the prophetic narrations, it is established that it was said, “Do
not prevent your women from going to the mosque, even though their houses are
better for them.

“1 The disparity is once again seen between the Islamic laws that were
established and those that are being followed and practiced in India.
Islamic countries across the world, which include, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Malaysia,
Turkey etc do not impose any restrictions on women with respect to their right to pray
in the mosque. It is again only in the South Asian countries, where there exists a
conflict between the Islamic laws and personal laws of the country. The reason for
this could be the illiteracy and lack of awareness towards the religion that exists in
South Asia.
2. Such derogatory laws cannot be Islamic laws, as they have not been derived from the
authentic source and need to be revised in accordance with the Quran.
1 Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Baab maa jaa’a fee khurooj al-nisaa’ ilaa’lmasjid:
Baab al-tashdeed fee dhaalik.
Saheeh al-Jaami‘, no. 7458
2 Research shows that, south Asia is home to over 50% of uneducated people in the
world. (Business standard, New Delhi dated 15th December 2013)

Don’t politicise Triple Talaq: PM

Prime Minister Narendra Modi today urged the Muslim community to ensure that the triple talaq issue was not “politicised”, and hoped that intellectuals from the community would come forward to fight the practice.

Addressing an event marking the birth anniversary of Kannada philosopher Basaveshwar here, Modi voiced the hope that Muslims in India would “show the path of modernity” to their counterparts across the world.

“There is so much debate on the triple talaq these days.

Looking at the great tradition of India, my mind is filled with the hope that powerful people will emerge from the community in this country (to) eradicate outdated practices, evolve modern systems,” he said.

In his 40-minute speech, the prime minister spoke about women’s empowerment, equality and good governance.

“It is the strength of our country’s soil that people from the (Muslim) community will emerge to save our mothers and sisters from this trouble,” he said, referring to the practice of triple talaq.

“I will urge people from the community to not allow the issue to get politicised,” Modi told the gathering at the event, which was also attended by Union Parliamentary Affairs Minister Ananth Kumar.

Source : PTI