High Court Karnataka High Court

A K Gopalakrishnan vs State Of Karnataka on 20 September, 2010

Karnataka High Court
A K Gopalakrishnan vs State Of Karnataka on 20 September, 2010
Author: A.S.Pachhapure


Efé ‘%”§°%§ %’§§§E*§ C€}i5§?.”¥’ Q? §{§a§§%fi:Tfia§£5;§ fififiééfiifififi

Eifisfiffifi “§”§-%ES “§”§’%§ ESE” fififif §F §E?TEi?:-§§%§ Efiéfi

5E§’fi§E

ma i<§§%'4'§§.E ?~%R*3i_.ES"§EiZZE s;,r;g9ac;~§Hg§z.éé;EA

WW 9sz":r:€::?§ féasg19128'?5i$'r:%3§=..,fa§§é§ :' AL
msyg -» $384 :3? mm {gag +;%A§§:f5Té;_§§ ~

fi§'?§¥E§%é :

2. $3: A.x.s9aa..:.§x§2§sH:w§
mm A$£;%i3T 5? YEAR? .

5§@a§?€g§I ggagws V

2$ 5%: 255m aaaamxazséssiaég

_ $.x;r::.:.§,m:…:

A§Efi&§§i§T fiavmfis 1 a
wig gag fs;,;€.;;@~s~.§;m§::s;;:§;-gséggeg

aefi ;R;”§§T 5%: f£.§§E%~’;§§. :~;i:3;;§% _
%a§§a:”§’m %F;§!$$E’§–«5!?’_LA§i’f’£s7;g’§’}?;%Zf%%2- .
§-§E§§§3;,:i K£;:.L&:$&~.’~~.

§%§:§€é,§”?’¥”§ .?§;§:§;, – =
%£%m§:’?£g:$<., . .

ifififij-§3E.Ei?”‘&”§%i§:3§i =

K3. LA S’§’E§”‘£6 ;éA;%e’s*Aa”§f:~i 5.5%;

§2§;§’;:=~J.;:s:;e%.:%r”%%51;$ ‘mags
$§$5$§.:-v?*;%A?:Aa:;:%3§

agaérgz Eagwgim *’é’Efi§§$§
2~§.t%aa;3?V’3*§:§V{z;:§?A

‘V §fi§%3§:i§}T’F’§ K§¥.lYa5§§§THfi;§A ?§§’§”

IRKW, .’€j§ifiaL.%SSE£z’f “§.m.;§<

% M' " ' ., 2§§3zs*m:':, szagaus. smra

fig ":<3§$"r,'té':,aa§g mmzvg

fis%3§§ §.§$i}T '€92 'EEARS

""%¥§QwfiR§ §am«m;'5;:-:§a!=;

Rsarigameam ééfiiéfifi
:~§§%é¢,?§§2;:ziay5?;a

szaagmw E§£§,f’*{£iE%THA§§ ws?

mmagggy ‘azmgx
ézgggsiaa §;ifs$’mc”§, rzsaam $E”§%”‘£

“§’-L:

3% 3%? §{,’s.?.’§’f3§%’¥”

£$E§ §fi§$i§T 3% *:’§,£’;§$

$§’$.$§.E §+$.&R§(‘%”

R§;iaT.£§;§.§.a¥§?»i.§«§E'{;§;L éifiiffiefi
K%.§§€§§$’§’?”§ iéI§.I”!i§;¥*3″¥”P’§§§.§» ?$$’?
Kfifiéifik §I3’%”QXiZ’¥’} Kfikfim $3-§’§’E

$3 $2; §§F%”§”

mm agmgr 3% ygaas

Sffififii ?§<f's§,.f»§fi§§'1'§E
R.,;'fi.?.E€4i*g§_§.§;?é§v!AR§'§'AL §<¥§i§;$E
§{§§§%§§~§§'§"§~§ :i::;V;a%;':"%e£.§.za.?:é;:3'§'._ .
?i_E?é§'é%.§R Qzgmmg §§ERfi.$.A .;$'T£?E"

$2 $2: :§,§»m5:3a{;~;-£ . ' — . :

£€.3?E§ .§:z§§L%’r’~4:;»%?§g§;as _ * ”
azmz §{§AL{3i%£..§??fiR.{“£’;§’éL g-saaggrgg _
K£§§§?§§’-:TH K:;ma;%§12j-%§aa»%.§%a:V$? .
ma a: 23x §§$j’€f§-:§.%:’%§;.’ jatam ,$e::&:§”§

§¢ 5§:%:”?: fififi 5 % ?é%Ev&§£H§$-E§C§~
fi£E§3%’§?a§§§i§? :§w:??E;m§ ‘
%§;’§a7;:’.?§%§;R’§§”E§G%’ %%%%% .. V

‘ A” – §;§§’§”,*E1″*%3*»1″‘%”i’§£§?%.§§§ géaésfis

» £§;.a,?17’%”jfE”‘:”_§{‘:*§%§2:’.LA ‘ségngrssa
* :<ai§;s&:A,%«a§a;:%-a%v:s Rg'_.§2$""%§1$"'§"
§<&g«m $;*:;§fr2~T, "

1 2.5 §’; §¥;§p;2,%iMH5aas&
?°?§§M§§€}§}*;_?§i.§..§P?§:T§”§
‘..m§Ea aamr as ‘fifiefifi

» §.g;a3:%n~4¥§<m Q: amassa
' –..I§;§."§'7E*'s"§§§fi$

§¥}fi.?*:%£"§"?';€'a§é¥.1§

¥.f§:§;e§§ §Z§"§'§§;§?

§{ERfi.La5: §Ta%TE W §?§ ?§2

V éagsgi gxmgggz

Afifi S §%§§§§§T 3% ?E&§§
$§$.$ ii $s$§A§§§a§¥§
Q;’$;”%°. §~%§.§§¥”§”I*iZi

?§;?§££ Viiifififi

1-W3

§§E'”%””;”f; ‘§”§*°§éi_%§SER,°’%’ ?§s.§.§.§%§
§{fi%§=§§€i.§§; §E§’§REf.3″§”

iifiiééwé $T§!E”E

iiagfii %’?§,§;.$§”‘§§?’§?$
33$? .§e§$i,§T 33 ¥§§..E.§
5§’§:1§1§§.5aH9§:§*§
§«§§gT§§*§fij§fi:.”é’§”§E§§¢.

§§$§°’§§g?<% iz'E§,§_§:§E
E§§"§"'f'§', '?§°§£i.fia$§E?{":" §'fi,{,Z.§§€
Kfi§*é§§i§§.. §Z%'%§"'%" Vv
KERALA fi'"%'1&TE

12,33: %€;g,§z3:.:

§§E§ éfifiié? 33 ‘EIEARS

asaagm fifi fiaké-éfifii

§im:?§w’;;§»% vzzmsg ‘
xagzwz mgmssgavragasg _
§§A§é%%§.§?; mama’: «
xsggag ST:fi;{E ‘

{sag $2.2 »%4*5*¥3

Ai%§:

it §°§’§:’§’E £125′ ¥{&R?é§~’%’fi£’ii’fi _ ‘
%£Z§§r=§A,§fi; $ §%.§’£%¥¢i£e__ ‘
Esfifiiifiiégifififi M». 555:? 331′
§_§’:’§’1; 9%’.’%””$’S aE2;§«r%.E;.E.:§££§§TA§;?

2: 1 %r:~a%::”;:_3§»::a%::+~5;sT;’:v:::a£§

“sa:;:*:£a:;V,,_:.’.;ramz$A*sf:1e,.affc*;*
»§:§,a::=:;<E:%:-a— 5?; 29;

V ‘ 3, ms *:;aé«é%:s;::gaa

:.§»gV_é$§*::..5§,@g%§{:;s«%,% gag;

‘§:§fi::}?§:T§’ “mufisc
..%s1m3;ve£~2*
§:§$?$%%§E§§”E’-S

‘W535 %fi§Rf’E’° ?E’¥’I'”‘2’E$fi§$ 3&5 ¥EL§§ E§§§§§R §Fi”?’,E€§.§S 22$

“~.§’Z22? as “ms €§?éS’§f’§”i§TE§?§ 5:: zmza §&§:§:§%§ “gag amfim”
me §;§$$$m§*:a”rs %§$’§’:$ i:%~¥.&§3§§ ‘ms asvagaag 32:05:93 $3

THE ikféfi W fiifi §’¥’ZF€G.2§.i:’i$; Zififfig &§*£§ EX. SF fiffififiifi
%*’£L§…A§§ ‘*§§§fi..}?E”‘§” ?%§~.fi figféfi 395%.: §E’§”{}£..1 fifififi ?&§*§§H$§”*s”‘;3§TH;
iifififiefigfi §§§’i’Z 5§§..$§$§§%G 3% ?§”fI§fi%%§§§ §’Ei§T§.TE§ 3% 7353?;
?é£fi§§ ;’ §.:*”E!’§%RS §$Afi§E Wfiiflfi fiéfi §E'”§13_§§§E§ FI?é&i,I”§”%”
‘a’%’}TT?~§flL%T.£a§’~i Qfififififififi ETQ

mgag ¥§”§T{“%’EGf€§ caragzm 3%: mg $§S=E§i§ *§*§+;::. ‘::a;é;’3:,
WE §$§§§3?’ ééfififi “§”?§E F$§..§.$”;%’2§§G:~ ‘ 2 ”

?§:s$® gatfiémg havg mag fiiisszfé §%F%é€~e:§;’é§ §§:’s§:g§£;.§::*;;»2.,V_’i:?4a:§

%e:§;::%g §%3§’i”‘§!?’:§§$§§3§’2$i” met 2% $?3§§’E§!E :5§’§a”s–‘:ea§&§s;§ss; ffiiséréé: 5:}?

éfga égné 3;: séé sigma? §%%as5;’§:§¥.:;’;:..,,s’§§; . 3§ _E.f*§§i:,
2:3_;:é..&; zzijiaa, Eiiiififi? 2v:’:L;;i;é;,; ?”2:;;’:é;;F; %2 2.:;:é3;
Eéayé giswey §§a,2§;1;’33, $12.22;-;;é§§;;%’é$a;_j#1jg;’:’;;;’za; zmgza
zmzeg 2mg=§,%§:;;%zg3sa, 2;f;i;’%32 af éfeggafa
§?§E§a§&§ fifam §*a:§::E*§a§:§§§m
éifiéagzs ;2ag:%:sg§§%L%% % % &

2, ‘§V’xE”::§ifa::%s :§:§”§& §%.§§’§Q§% a? fizgga §§$3Z§§2§GF£§

am fig ;%%”§:;$$§’§

“V.-§7″\§*%§a.A§%:a,:;:1;é$ e§1u?§%€ei?$t*£§ afimee aaéara §a:§*:’;%2a5£§ fig S23

§3_;t§i:§§_;’éA:::.r}${“4._§§¥:§*£&.§” j§é§ar&§’2E régégtaraé aaée fieaég §§”¥§ is’:

§a.sr§§;a#$éaafis§”éf:%3é; 35% émés axastzfiéfi $3: we 2;a§*:dm*s§ rim

–.[.T’_j:..4.4_;’%a:z2$$ fif tifég §at§i§i:r’:e§§ am $i”%§§§”‘&§ Er: $33 mmrfis sf §*§§?:%:$

aE§ é5€;;’;%:%:§ 31$ msstaiésa swim’: fisaawhéigg $23 fiagssizi

‘+–._ 7§$fi:}:ss*v’§%$§’ as? ?$:’e§%: gagfiméiiafif 5% aggiésgzéggz fig {E3

-._ ;§;:%é§;:%3: $$%”3*§?’¥°:§5§§£§§”‘$&E”” $5 fiéafiagu; ?«~%§§i§:e:*’§ as gar §;E’§§”%$Xi§§”$

w 3 éatgsfi E§g§§,2§fi§ Es éeiéeta SEE rgamag 3;? $29 §%$§i’¥§¥3&i”§

arzé ta s%m¥=s 53$ Efifififi as §*&5e%.:*=a_§é§ famzgt éanég. 35:’: turn? the

mfiisiwg £§r§*;sr:§5s§$:sa§” as gas” Aaeaxmfe R éfiifiéi §;%;§§x2§$§
ésas %:’:%a§*r§:%§ aim fiegams’ fiarzgerzzatsr af ?§§”a$% satéség tfgaat

ism gasrégééctéafi in féifiéfifi 5? §§”%§ geiétésmg §§ mgfiafi

Taéméifiay a?’ $13 Taéigk aaszxaarnafi a:3§ it 33 _

gwgar actéagsh That Qfifiiii?’ s:$:a5=§§°;§;§:ar :f2:*””?*V L. V.

“$23 §r1§§§:a§§s:§ :3? §§%;g,..,.§5:f§2%§§f-§éf*:’s”‘* V
Efifltéfifé 133 ii? tfia £22 §$§§é Egg §%;aa_f:::;:;’9.§”2?é«:T;f .:i§A’§§–§’%’ V.”v../
tésat, anw ms E§’§§”§% i§1_:%§a féfieflré es? ‘ V
agiéievaé féaaiétyg. am: t%%§**§é?a:*F_€fer§ A:$:.¥3.§&§”.
mavergaga §a:%§m:*i%%e£ am ____L:é::%§§a::a_;*:§a§€; « §§fé:*sgz§5
a;’:%:”ias *a;:;sa:*& §§cs*:.*§$ita:.t:c:.’_’ 3;é}§§L” ;§.f:,;;: §z?%*éfM mt H
sfiangaé 3}} kiss Qsa§’i§i§¥AV§i9s3 :é9§E*§*:%$5:_§%t;%*:g§.s§4 3:2? 533;:
gasiémriigr $€..£§”2:fii’»E_Q§’ t$§VV?:f§§r%=;;e;§:r*;fi%}v}§ftV_ Efi azzééésrgéargga

wit}:xixx§i:+m§?s§:;~;s%*»2§%%secgzcss :32; :35 gag
mafia? __§§g?E*:§ fif tiréa §§”$”=fi$§8f’éS
gg am :22 Laaga; :2:%*f7e% t§’§$ fiat”,

Sag if t§§a..$r;§:%§’ §:§§:z~§a :fi’%’§§§%§&§ 5′; iéaa %’%*’§§i°§%.£& a:_.:fi’m;”é%.§a§;

33$? ‘?§~a§%éé.”Lt$”‘E$£s..:a réflsfififie is tins §%§gE§§{§g{$§ gézgaséfi faééwg

§%:*’f$§§%a*§T2*’V§;’*§%=:;.:$%s3’s_§%iEf%:.;*.V§§ee:’*a*.§¥~$a§$fi iéfiéfif $333 §%”G**JES§G%’§$ Q? Sagtifizfi

L 22$; ‘m g; €§*2a§t%r 1: Q? as Kamaiaka ms

“»-w_§§a*s;§§’:;é&7’fix: and tken gags 5?: aggzfisgréate arm? if:

V’ é’::::az%é§£’;2m ‘:%:§t§’§ 33%;

%, Zr; 32% €§E”€§3f”§3§i&§’i£&§; E am sf the $§§5′:E¢§; aim? it is

31.35% argé a:§§r:3§§*§a%a& ta émasa §§.§£§% fiérggiéaas ts the

J1

‘*5
gr

s*$§§a:’§§$:2t£ ta $6 saw”, %-Ems; i:%:$ gaiziiiaéé is aiias-ms Er;

gagt T§’s% §’€§;§f.’§§”‘3§&§’§E aya fiireateé 22$ §a%§a@%s; Eififi gig-gar

pyageéaim be?-‘aria the ééfiaféga a? tiza ?’?£E,,§§%?§§fE §;=:§%§§gf j%,:§’vv_’

reggae: $§ iréaa ééggzstaé éargfis rafarrefi 3m §%;s:32:£:. 233$’T p%;$’$§ ‘_””*A’

agfifmgréafia $€”§$§’ fififif §z:::§§§;”e§ $3???-;*”§§%€§i%.§¥”:§.4 fig: _.aE§€;V?:Z’~]§’_”*’§V§:§’§.f3%$

with $3??? mé agtamirgg 2% fiémgzsgr iééfif ::§§§:$5’§{a2?§%%’§g3.:§;<&«.

Ragerzgsg Ac: 'me psatiiéans arfi ?§§'§€.§§* éésgsgzxgéfi

sa/.7
Q*:»iT%Jfid9e

fiiffé