High Court Karnataka High Court

B Nalinishetty W/O Late Prasanna … vs The Managing Director Ksrtc Depot on 24 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
B Nalinishetty W/O Late Prasanna … vs The Managing Director Ksrtc Depot on 24 November, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil And Gowda


-“-‘-‘-M “- -‘-‘—r–‘vwm –Iv”-wvunu VI’ nmnwmamzuit flivrt hwtflfli U1′ mmawmmmm ¥”§’l§..’3W C013?

I

fi% THE Hm: maxm mf mmmma? mmA;3::1%%?;Vv:%%%[% ”

aamn Triis ‘I”‘fiE am ms;2*c3§*z~wmwEg£’§;e:§:;91:VA_.::~
$33 HQKBLE: am JL¥8_T’$é}¥Aq§£}$&T§;..”.A ‘ VV
“rag EEQEELE gm;133f?:i:€:$ jE§’.””8’fx'{;Ef.aEfiI;§i€f§’J.g?§S3;
mg; fi®.:é39′:

mw/EEK; Q .A V

1:’-” .

‘we: LATE zi:¥3fiifi;P;:; ..

gags
€§Sfi:HQU_SEVe?iF’i§;._–vH;C¥;3,_2=€~, §’.’:’f¥ ::::.§;s333,
gm mm ” %
Eé§%&LGREj~56¥3 aaggfi – ” ”

H ..:%.??EéL§.A§§T

$3;-§.§t:; Bf;§,$§€#§2€§1’§?§i};__+é.§%f,,3

‘ ‘§’*§§§ ‘}:¢€_.#%;;&£3$§§ré:;A§§&§s*:’@1a;

§{.B&R£E'””;€* “§}E?fi°2: 3 . ..

§;E8F’®I!¥B E§T’

]y TREE A?FE§..£ :3 mm :§;g.m{1; 53:: mg my
gamma’ rag Jziagmm am §,¥§.&.Rm§;.&’1T’§3Es 3.,3,2$35
ymafim m we §§.3§i%i 23%: mg TEE mag 3? mm vi

fiflfiim 3&3 &n ER fififlfifi ” Afifiisg

Vwuwuvwviva.

‘§}£;fg§’§’€§;:§.’€. agpaai $&%

§fiJE%®fl.QRE {3c:.a.zna: maxvmag ms §?QLLQi?é2E?é3_i;%:¥–

Mmfii _

3?; This judgmrzt
and awarci wfi F%%3§3G}’;*%;’2Q{§1
an the §.fia%:’;’.ié£5I3.t mama “1”£’ibu%§
Basgaicré rafarraé is 33 ‘the
‘.§”‘3*i%mm_i”‘ f’a:;.*; §:3;:’=5’%;ii£%§Ve”:,i_.§ =32%:»;e Trihunai 33: im gmgmm

$.;;t’};$: bag a gum $5 Rségfirésfififii-* with
E2 55% gag fmm Qfifififififir £23 éepaait

‘ sag :35 $13 £é§§§§.§fii”f€ fa}? §$,$;€}§§§>%;’»n

r kg tha 33%? $13 aggeihréz hag grmemsfi

exmzzi $2: $133 gzmzfixd

H the mmpemafisn awmfifi E3: tkm fiifiuml ‘mwazfig

flags sf &&p§:”zd;:r:€:::** fig ifiaéazgamta 3.3% it raqaairm

v—w —mwpumu ‘Iv: una1u\i1ar\Kr’M’\-V1. IQIQJIT %uVJWKT WK!”

sf Es.3g}<},m$,:-

‘ i2m§:p3;fié:._§$*5;’i»fi@rwrafi§§L Tfie Txékuzwig in mm?

14;’

3. The byicf fazrts af tha mass. are:

‘fin agpellant claim in ‘m aha u
Praganm Ktzmax, 8; quaiifiaeei
‘ Pra£&§:::a:3m’*§ zméefi

Gauxmil. it is 133$ cam fig an
Reiiafiifififl; at abcut 11} fimmsed was
riéim his . ‘H§§1€ifi” i:<:j':.!;v§?';-«Q5-I~%I-"3'?'§,'1¥~
an fiiysam kus karnrg
£2: a rash anfi.

z2%3;igar:&:i’: fiaaimfl agaimt flag

fime-.&s$&. ‘éé tbs fiwmacfi sustaizmé

“z{2}§__’2;:zca:umhse6; ‘:3 $23 mm; €31:

the apwiiantwwifie fiifi a claim;

rgtary aviégfiass mafia fiihfi

mama; an 5%? mma fim czaim paafitisn in

V’ awarfiim mmpfizfiafifin ef §3§f§é§%€}{- $it%1 mats

mfi éfitamst at ?’%é ya. fiwm Efifiagfilisé» 3531 ziepusii;

“(mum-wwmus’

4; fiasarfi bath $i&& fer g-afiaidwébia iwzgth sf tima, V.

3,. Afizer 1 pemzaei af thas
award anti afisr amluatifin sf “ihe: V ‘4
awiiabie :3-:1 file, What 6I?£ZifiFg& £3

mmmittmi a grave array in t?:1<2:"-i:ii¢::=;m:3'V:'¥§;'7Wt7£1§

éwsafi at Rs.3§%Q{ ~– §.m.V'_
rzsaaam itirzemh the as per
the C-arfificate is3"uzfi "§:j,f
Exm, Eiavizg aga ef the

ésmmseég irmamaa sf the

-v mxfi ffi’ gszhar

&m*$mec1;=._at« ” at ‘thfi mags; iearnafi;

mama} fQfv._ €1’3e ‘ submifiafi that? the

~ v;%;$§$€$§:§£%1§%;§;§: aif it§@m;$._.a:£ Rs.8,%Q<§,i~ 39.31? waxfid R an 3.
iimf; is» when? t}mn§ aertmkz gum hm in

fig éuzmm €33 aim. M saifi
g§g§mi;§.a§§%t;_ Eaikia 31$ sufisiazm far the rmgfizz fiat? fimfi

§:..'¥:& fiéiésszanz fifiaé, {Em axemzgfiinn aiab Wafi zzgm

sibia éefiusfiezz is gimfi

L

X'

-…..-.. -. ……………-.5… …..m uwrulu up-msnaanm rm.-aw uutzm ©W&(.$1WNi%:”§’}$’:».%fi mm-4 cam

‘A éfi stazafi ahevm the

téxen, kg W23} :19: ‘mi. iiakm :0 gay any immma iax. Sfizige

agmifit is the mfiy demndwfig §8% has ms ‘sa -, V
{awards pamanai &:pen£@ ef 2,21% dweagai. if gigégéf’;
the dsamasw ix taken between

» piggy’ m’:..3$’£.31piicr agpfisabia W§st._11§

313$ rlzghfiy appiieé; the muaapfiagégj we
anei fiterrws ms 1. ‘Eas csf
éewrfiengy? at msazzfiza :3:

9 mxfitipfier} fig’ by tlw

Kffifimmifi

fig i~’:E0 ‘a;*:F:§va;’s;;’~4’Vi:::<;{$.*;;§aaé;:"11a»9;t51fis§; awarfifi mwarzzia.

éthar m:fim§i:§.;é:;3;§ §::is§a:ii$=§'§7 jug: 313$ rmgmgabis and '€§'2.¢

319%. at tkfi banéa agf this

V'

mgwzi as $13 fasta 332$ ::

6: Pigzgégémxzt wfi

gamx by {$313 ?::::m;m§ is Bahia as Essa mfifmi iafzfi

um»… -…v–a.¢.-a…,.. .w._-. .-

u.-nu-1:-vvu-mu: -uru wm

i, fawarszis was of éspetxiansy =« R3. %,32,i}§G-Gil?

ii. Yawaréa iaas afgazmartium -v Rs,
Yswards has afastatc « Ra M

%m Tawards §;rmr.a3 m –

V. Teswaxés tramgacriatian _~ ” V’

‘?m1 Rsa%.*:§3s§Gi9r$*3

3* *”‘*QWd”‘%:A*’*£e[“1″*]*% afiiwliant

31$ afimsefl in dam

magma §IG,3$’},”‘§f2QQ3.

£5 mm} mmpensafinn {sf
§M§2,gm%;.%%a§ k§;gg§§;;sg:jL:e§.2,%§,a@9;m, “§’i°:¢ anrmmea
£3!:i; §.£§.,13«i5,m3$f~ {R3.*§~:,€s2§$§{%-2fi~fi,C§S}

5% E3-1%,: mm am fiata af gxxciitian tifi

VV _ ._ flag. $§’%§3. V_ §é@m.§

mafigensafisaxg a sum 9%”

– with gsrépasfiifinaia mam: smfi. fig key’:

T %%%;::§%*me& magma in arxy Eiafiamiiaeé fix’ gcgmum Bank

‘ v-=— –‘W-v-* —V-P-H vi av-nivruiranan ruurn HUWRI Mil” nmawmmmfi. WWEIW flaw”? Q?

in tha mm 3? tha apgfiamt far a gmriafi. sf five gmars

mrzamahie by 5% yeam, witii fiermiasimi ms the . V

mwifizfirawzkxeawm, zed intfimst paricdicallyg H

§}mr ‘ ‘ am’ uni: rjf

she}: be relmaed in favmzr ufapv}:§e3ijax1t’a::§”éix§§-xagii 3?

the fifififlflt by $31,143 r&poV_:3éarzt~g§.%§’::’3sfi;-c:ra_,ti@:.i’,

Qfimimctaaga
‘V