IX THE I-3.18:}-I €93,385? 3? K$RBIATA,KA A? BAEGALQRE
SATEB THIS THE 1 1*}-'* DAY (BF SEPFENEBER, 2998
QEFGKES
THE H{)N'BLE1 MR.J§JST§C§; SEESHASEE .8..»5;{'§! 'V
M,F'..!'§.E\IQ.614f.}!2QQ-5 {3's»'i'«.:"C'E
Baby Chan&'i3..s.E:ree,
{Bic}. H, K. Suresh,
Agritzflg y:3:_~:3."se, '
No.S€4~j3, Gpp £0: i'\Eaia1'a_;i Euiiciing,
T. Dasamhalfi; '£'u_mL::1r Raai
BangalQre~5§{} 95?. '
(AS the agapefiaxxt is minar
represantad by fathaix' --.
Sureshj. _ ' .'}fs.E>?ELL&i'~E"f'
(33; A£%Ei§§;dc€?£%_ .f§{"3if;§**""
1.
The Qriei;::t£=.,1 Exisizmmée C-v.:>.*£5:d., —
Diviaiomj ‘:’*~7(:>’.”-Si”,-»AA V’ ‘ ‘
Szinivasa §*arE£msi<3:1, " V. ~
§~%5.364q' 3, }F3F_hAM'B;' i'*;§;3sL:*1.F:'£2a{§s,
3%' Biocig, Jay3:fi.;a_ga.r,'–
Bangaiprfiéfiéfi C¥1′;L V
S§z’i;4 E35. Méithaifimtz,
_Isfi’¥e.ji; ?ai*i._ Rjazngasxvanzy M,
E),,_1’4 “€J_7E34l3,« I’~Jife§1.:a;sé2_r1:.:1r’s1
E?-‘:1;:sr=, Line, N’c:ér'{}ovt. P1′.5.E}1;’–?.;£’f,7
Heaiih C?-§:m;;:*e.:’e; T’. Da,$arai1aiii,
-E0 ..
_ _Bang;a1£:§1″€;;. RESPC)N}.1’éEN’§T’S
” : {B}; Sfi. M, yfinzzz Paxmagpa. Adv. far R1}
MEA, is flied U/S. 1?3{1:; sf MU Act agamsz: arm
‘Lj’–.3m:ig;mn: am award datzed 26.02.2005 passed in
_ L’~..M’if£i,N0.?92]2802 an the file of the Ciwl J1.1r3.g£:*.. Lt1cement of c:}111pr3nSs,tir;s11 with
intsegagt at 129;; [.72. E1.
‘E’11is appeal ccming on far ‘Hearing’ this day. 121:: Swazi:
(ieiivered the foilowingz
JEDGMEKT
This is cla:imaI1t’s appical for efihancarizezifi ‘r fz:=f
Cempensatizz-n.
2. The Ciaimanfr 2′: miner girl m§rti’s,e§i%£?.§ b}?’fafi1=ar’. 1:-asé’ ‘
guffemd injury in a road accident £§n::i3{V3_,b1.:?;;0f.}2. ‘«;>3i; $1’
the rash and negiigant dzivifig ti:-{ “‘?§’e1é. A’ said
accident, the chfid sufiemd Q16 tsndcr
scar dersum ktft foot. ztgiggz and Rigiéigéi.
:«m-:1 stifixsss left; by minus 5
rjeg. Wasting faf Left: anlqi-3 fl::~3 15,
ext»-Q,’ 5. Gross iimifatisélig -«i1:£’;?>1W:é:1éiio_;1; £5 supinaicion feet.
3. In this fegard t;b,5′:;iaiz:nia:1t mzamizxeé ‘the doz:-igr as
P2352… The; §é:::jLb:zi1a}. disigééziéésizsrzié *3}: efidcncc Bf dccior an the
gr«::n:;:-_’;d~ 1;VE:a¥i,V}:1s: is:t;’:;:+;:«?§.1zx_iz1ed fits? more than -3%/gs. years; 911d he £$
not the doE::t¢3r iiffi-I:;–..fi1″:étsd the injureé. it also did 119%.: ccnsidez’
v:{h5: grant ef”c9::épe:i’safé:ion against the éisabihlty er amfinéfies an
Ag§j::)u11£1L__tl1a€;” the ingursd is 3 4 j;€3;x*s giri baby’ 31:53 Eiééaijg is
‘ ‘ ‘ A ‘ggéé. 1f:=r<jc:€I€1*' 'stigma
u Learned Ct::u;.r1sseZ for the appsfiazzt sn.1!:smit.s that, the
;:i;oVf:%t<::r has stated that, She has sufifirezl 28% éésabfitgr OVEEE" ail
bed}; and thus: tribunal net. swam. censidereré the nature: of immzg
caugad {Q the mine? girl arid has not awarrzied 3:13: cemycnsatian
tewarda $116 less of smnixzg €:a}'_'!3a2itf;', less csf amenities zmd gain
and sufiermg and izgstfiaci, has granted giebal ccvmv;,ie:1sa°mT0:;{_ {Sf
RS,?§,0OO,'~.
5. Lseazzrzzsd; counsel appfiaring fer thg ms 43::
submifiaé that thaw is :29 cszidzmce ta? g1%é:1′;.. c;Qmp€:_t_iS9.f:’iQ:{1
taxnsaxvis 193$ 9f income. f)oc*:«:;r’s evidence ca”:-“moi: he re £i:2;I,’va’s he
is net tha dc-«ate: who fifafzé $115 chiid’ hér
after 3% 3,–‘€213.
5, ma mzbunal 5.3 its finding gym héEd.-~£31;&f;’V~.t§:cre is crush
igxjuxy in $11!’: fem: §;:;3.$”_a3s<:é:_fo1_:m:i5 tE1:3«t'i:;E3f:V_c;Vi%;1s!:1 Lnjuzy may
get recevcrczdV'ft:~t3a:::;m3::"'V9f-_»thr§ i';».=:;{i<:1sr aga. The uébunal is net.
justified in ebsemrixzg S(.1'VL"r,5,"'.7f'1!'§' 53,-v:';Cf'?:{§'I' has stated that, 0132: max»:
surgsry i$ z1~:¥3€~3$a1'};. Efizgizv thrjugh thvza. disahflit}? is :19! proved; if
thétre is the foot, it may result ix: cleformity and it
may I:at.11;*.fl;;%" reéiigicaéi-.t;h& gmspects Qf manfiagg :-3:116 may cause
' ::=.s;3ect.fi;<.1iW the Sazuciety.
AA {T?z;jrnsi?:i’er’mg the eviéem:-z-r, even though the doctor is
«s.?é;ra;cI1inedV ‘agar 3% }.=”€.€–.¥3.’S, but lmkmg into the maturs of injmjgx
= . I am1 ‘:£@c€Qr has stated that one more $urgc1″y 13.3 mquirsd, the
“m}§énsa.fi0n awarded by ‘£3116 tribunaa} is mquimd 4:9 be
siihanced. Accarriingly, i-:3″£*.7’3.’i?’dS the surgezy. axmther
R$.15,Qi}(1I/» is awaxfiaé. T0Wa.:rds loss Qf amenities angthar
Rs.15,0€)0,/~ is awaxded and inwards pain and s:ufi%:”;:::g
Z32$.1{),f.}0G,?- is awzzrded.
8′ Accsardinglgz, this appeal is .’£3;§Z()’.}’3€{L The C’.,}..¢’,*-‘_:1.,mE:’3§”£7L”.:.»”;”iS, :”
szzrtitlfid for enhancsd mmpensation cf E$:4Q,Q0{}f>v’
ab~:>t3e the cempfinsatyl-an awardtad by the 1:1:§b:3:»;1:::E -éx.?i?;lf1 .iat’§:2:éi~:i{“Laf£ Tr ‘
£1122 rate of 5% per azmum.