High Court Karnataka High Court

Durgappa S/O Hanumappa vs State Of Karnataka on 16 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Durgappa S/O Hanumappa vs State Of Karnataka on 16 April, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit
 2 :%é:§"CHA:%:§7fi~a?~T;;"""

  V  ' V 3  f_ ' * BASAPPA

3%'? '?'H£§ E{§G§£ <::;}:;:m* <2")? KAR?i:%TA§{A A'? Bszx:r3A':g%;svE§é";£:T:.'
§3A"f'E§ 'F'H¥S 'THE 2693 my (:2? SWREL :;{ia9..' :'   

§3REs;:N*r   

mg: :~:ah:'BLE ME. RD, $§§§:5;*a.§<.z&x:éfi;§fs  ';Pp;, _  
S/0 HaNe;;_v:A%PPAV._ A _ 
AGED A805? 514 ms  
GCC;.f§=i}RZL,  ' '

 R/G~'_%?i.AC}i3B?sL '
 °*£" Q 7G=AN€§2'%¥25,;?Hi
 3§'s*F, K€)¢PE?;§£,,_  _

. s;i::.._s§nmN:s:-"A
. AGED $808"? 52 YRS
« .  'Q59 A{§--RiCUL'FURE
. " .R;.£:T CHELLUR
 'TQ, G§§_?*~§flAV&THI
_  EEISTRZOPPAE,

 AGREE' A331}? $4 YEARS,
" {}(f:C;AGRICUL"I"URE,
wm CHELLUR



oil-

01

YQ {}IrA§*¥GAVATH£
BEST E-iOPP§sL

i,AXMIPATH§
3/0 BASANNA

M339 ABOUT 55 YEARS}

OCC;Am'* 5.1. Y'€;;aé'3,  

OCC;AGR'i{3{;%,LTLIg*E%"- ~  

Egg? 'CEELLUER «V
TQ C3;ANG:'--'E7§}Aff'}r¥.£ ' ' _ " ' 
ms'? £51033-AL '   - 

A?vL%xR'§w:Si+1AI5?AA'..v " 

; ;~:;v;_0 A¥*mNA'G@Ut>A
3 ' ':'«:g5s{1}_E';{3V A39 i;?r.._4.4. YEARS,
A _  Q::i=fC;Ac;;R1cuLTz§RE,
' " .. V §%--,!._A';* '€:.H'£a.:,LU§~2

TQ »:i%A:~:{;AvATg:

 '-»*a1sT-'.:;0fs3PAL

 BA:,A?%A

s*,i,§?':3- MUBKAPPA

V " 4_ AGES ABOUT 55 YEARS,
':::}CC:AGRICULTURE,

V" " R/AT' CHELLUR

TQ G-ANGPsV£¥FHi
ms'? KQPPAL

GU NDAPPA



29

 31,

3/0 LACHMAPPA
AGES ABOUT 53 YEARS,
OCQAGRICULTURE,
R/AT CHEZLLUR

TQ GANGAVATHI

ms'? KOPPAL

GU NDAPPA
8;' O LACHMAPPA _

AGES ABQUT 52 Y'E':ARS', W

{3CC;A€}RICULTUf~,' _   iv "

R ,1 F55? CHELLUR

*rQ'GANGA%vAT1~:§   .  '

ms? KQP§3£&L_-_

DURC%A?§§ffl;%;""    .,_ .
Wm £::§:~2c:e;9.I>PA  

A... 5130 UT; :23 YEEAERS; "  V  '
ace; I-i€jri?S.Ei%'é:O£;ET},"".VV__ _ '

R}'T_fi§i" '€%§_.¥?:'-':[J:;_;{:{V$:'§¥'  _ 'T ._ _
TQC;';fiN\GA"aI_A'F}§--Z   "
§:sr:s:_Q;??AL_ ' '

V -§,RVA;§AsA$ "   ..... <4 .
 Sm £€;;ASH£MSABA

" -» _V :'§(?rEi}«A.E'eQUT 45 YEARS,

' £;?,:C"3€S3;§1C<rR1'€3ULT{}RE,

" .._R;'A.'ri»r;:H;ELLu12

TQ. €}§;E§é13AVATHi

 ms'? 'KQPPAL

Hi3§muRAsABA

""_«Ss,/G HONNURASAEA

V ' ' AC%ED ABOXET :34 YEARS,

0CC;AC§Ri{3i} LTURE,
R} A'? CHELLIJR



13

14

TQ GANGAVATHF
DIST KOPPAL

HANUMAPPA

S,!'O THIMAPPA

AGED ABGUT" 44 YEARS,
GC(3;AGR1CULTURE,

R/' AT CHELLUR

TQ GANG.z%.VA"f'HI

DES'? KOPPAL

HA:~2UMAwwA  ,
W} G HANU MAEFAPPA T ' '

AEEEB ABOUT :31 YVEARS,  *

§CC;}iO¥.}fE§E%iGLD
Emir <:I~.{;"EL:;,;;¥R  %
'§'Q <3g2€:";§_V9;fI€:ai' .;  A' 
3:3'? :' 7

;%{}E}f>«ABGLf"P 2:5' ¥f.1:_§A.R:s,
occv-§;Qus£:e:<;aL;3V 
_i€,iAT {3=§+i£«2§.,§_,L§R  ' '

V _; -ftgu .GANC+;zyATH;
   ..... 

T §s’g=:$A%;.;iV?g:§§s.

.€¢;'{3.,§GL:.i$§§A?PA
?sGE§. ;;a3m5T 45 ‘KEARS

O€T;L’C: Ei–i3USEHGLD

Rggég’ cagzgug
TQ GANGA’%f;XT’}fi

AA ‘ 5:23′? KQPPAL

H AMfisRAMMA

rézspxzmcirztziis is iizitiais acquisitian §r<;»c=€e€ii_'{1;g':s* «

Secfimg 441} 'L0 pass an award nmier Sec'§if4_fi}Té”

Lanfi Acquisition 86?; ané award; compefigafiai; ” I:Vo.__L

getifienem whess iamis. am when 91.52:’: by EE1$ é:Qs,§§<:£1di:fii~s V

£91" farmaiiien 0f pubfic road.

3. it is avazrefi    the posgegsien
9f the ianés  taken for
impr€.sveme::1_t_.     tbs E31163.

belafigingfi fiééfifisner is tbs 02x:11e:r of
Eami the owxzars Qf varéaus
Exififiifi §i’..?;;a}L:e:i para-2 0f {has writ fifitiiififi in

sizzvsf ~n_11:ai::fe:r-:~§A 3;s’1ée$c::{‘”beé in para–2 0f the wfit pafition

§%}§;:;e:ié.¢nis possessien af ‘(E16 Eami 0:” tbs

-§3e€§:_;L=£:*; €::?:1»e~§3;*;=;¢ 1<3%;ig%3ack ané mafi is formed witheut fcselicwing

d1:£:–..413r9¢c~s$"j';3f iaw. Petitianers have met "seen awatfifizi 333%

vc0mpe£;$_%£ti0n am} 'themfare, the wréi peiifien for the abave

:':'e§1?efs.a The ieazzzefi Sizzgie Judga after censirieriag "aha

V. céntention 0%" tbs 001111361 appearing far the: petfiisnfirs am}

K9}

the Eeamed if-ECG?" appeafing far 't§}f:"i'€'.%4_§}O125:E'3:1@%§');"é u

is far the Gavemmsnt to pm<:aed'1«Aw£?}1"9.cqu.isit:m:_ .t3£ié:~

pmpsrty and fikfiiififiiififfi hav:<: ?j.f»5r£::?; fieséesgiagz –V§aV€;£:i it; = L'

the year 2933 itself 3.3:1dV__ »§_}fivv}§€ti'1éi§)§1 is be
iejactfici and remefisg _ _ $36 is in gat
ztempassnsafion sf ihf: 1'em¢dy Eieg
elsewhare wfit grsetfiion,
E1CCC)I'(3J:Iig}_§z'i by order dated
by .– dismissai of the Writ

gsaizifion, 'wrii: fpefi1;ién§:rsVi;ai?:3: tpzefezred this appeai.

'E315 hé.a*::.. lgeazféé '£316 iearned esounsai appfiaiiizg far

.%:%1e:, _a;7§)efLafit$, and £326 ieamzefi Gawszzament fi_&ae'@ca':s

€;?5:};z:'V..1'esp<3::&ei1ts.

;.I,éV:$1′:1ed counsei appearing fer tag -3.§p€;§3IE’iS

“. ‘v§§’i1§’§:”;’§i’§§’iZ€i’:a $3113? the Eaflzis itzelonging :9 thus appfiilemts Wem

over and my campexxsatian has hm}: paifi arjfi

u “fi”mre:f€s:*a, necegsary direction may be issuaci to the

zespmzfients ‘gm pa}; 133$ compeflsatien.

\;}

Q. L{i33TI}{*:{§ Govemmcm: fidxsacate f1i€d5 _.::i’)§3=j§ig?;£§€£%é1’S ”

séatemant avazfring that the avtimfiiefits” «rg_:a.§. és.;%’£;u1& not 311% and thfi said road with ‘aha

A’s§;aid.fi3 “uf.$?>:;e:V.:vas in existence even befam indepanfiencé

as par _iiE;:+s: {2.iEA»3V,ag:: map of the fgfiar 3.93’? and therefcam,

7 ‘V._ “‘»f{i1€S€it’33£1N §Z3f taking pG$S€:$Si€_i1T.i of the lands by 3:13; of the

V”‘V’§~::s}_3’§::1c:1e11ts prior £0 thfi year 2086 as aflegaé in the Writ

pétition (1063 23:21: arisa and therafore, the writ appfiaés are

\)«3

VT -Eaéfiifix: 33$,’ K
V ‘ ” Web Hes’: B?E§

‘E?

beionging Ea {E16 p€titi@ners»a§;g3ei’::ant$ 1:1&m:l.::3g : hgcé’
{aka} fer fcsrmizig the mad witimui
3:3: as: 331 stibstanfiaiad and is §j${1t¥;S;.7″§Lf””‘ to
recozfl amfi ‘thexfifars, the 0r{i€r’€;5:%£é:3:ed bf; émgié
Juége is jugfififisti andv vermi’ 9:”

iiéfigaézity 38 ‘£9 sail far’ ii: Qaurt apgéfiai.

Accfirdingly, Wfi      m $21686 appeals
and pass   '
   /

Chis-§ justice

A  %   %%%%%  Sd/*9
Iudgé

   a=svw<

2'
x'