High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri M B Maheswarappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 16 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri M B Maheswarappa vs The State Of Karnataka on 16 April, 2009
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit


19$ THE’; man COURT 0;? KARNATAKA AT BAE’§.c’_;:§rAvLO:§§’§ —

mms mis ‘E’HE path DAY”‘éF’APR:.L
PRESENT A , . ,
“ma: HGWBLE MR. 9.13. D£§ég’§<;aRA§é';
ma z–:0N'BLE §&R;gLIsTf'¥$E1f;V:§;s§§ABHAm*";*

wlmf 'P;E;TI'r::'é'r€ fit). 1{§j:2¢V_1 2'<3aé" "

BETWEEN: * '

3;

s;R.i__:v: E.V;§§A§::gVs’»vAgA:3E2%..,_.,.
:€;’,I<3 BAs;AVAr&f?i'§AP1j3A _
R1; 0 31:3 ;EHa:;;,.L'I V: i.~,;./we —
§§AS&BA 'r£ 0§:z{_;:_' '
§-EOEALKERE'; Tgwii—

;<:H:*£'R;.»m'uRQA

V-'%%.1"ia.;»E,gA_.YAPPA 11111 ~ "
_ 3,15; PP;i~T§_AMESi~£WfisRAPPfiX
' ~ R';:.Q'%E:1::E:1~–:.ALL:
.i<;aSa3m.{'§~::3BL;

HQLz§£;§{§2§$E TALUK

ci;;’i*rR:mURGA

_ :§2,.33.KuMAm??A
‘ ‘- gm 82%SAVANT’.%§&PPA

” — ..*R;0 EDEHALLI

KASABA HQBLE
HGLALKERE TALUK
€HiTRAI){§R(3’rA

OE

smvamiia
Sm GIRETHEMAPPA
Rm EDEHALLI
i{AS§%.Bi-‘x HGBL1
HOLALKERE ‘§’AL{3’K
CHETRADURGA

C-HAN DRASHEKAR;’a§:§.fi

S/O MARu:,APPAxAH–. _

R/O EZIBEHALLE

KASABA i~¥€}BI_.I ‘

§iOLAL§{E.RE: -3f’Ai,U£{;

€§HI’f’RAD§f.§§G§;’ _ i V’

J. N. NAN3A?:§;3.

3/ <3%.s;§B;%a:,£rs'::AV?PA.'» ' "

R/{:1 EDEi~'m;:–,L_1

KASAB1%'Hs3BL§j'-»..%' ' – _
I~£O£,a;£1£{E:RET_AL«U'§{_ '~

€lEfi'E'RA£),U§?.;GA __ '

$:i,i?:T:%a .. _
'§33;'(}..A'i<UMARAPP;5%T"'

.A ' -:13/<:'2_, 1:-",=:")E::~§.;~'a1_,1.,1

_"§a;;:L;és:.*§s:g§<V;§i"'rAL:;;;

.’

. r;§£IT§a:>;;:’:eGA

§;5LE’*§ (:x’r?.iDHARAPPfi

‘ .. V3/0 ‘SHiVALINGAP?A.

” V R20 EDEHALLI
‘ “%?SABA HGBLE

; HOLALKERE TALUE:

r CHi’TR1’§D{}RGA

EAGAMMA
Wffl GURUM¥jRTi~§APP&

same thrcmgh G:u11€:ieI’i viilaga §’3ir ?r;i<:€ Shep, b

fer the past two months thereby q;:§Vas§'1:iiag}v {;?._1e'i

by {ha fifth respcanzient W119 _ diz*aé'ied:"–th€

§'fiS}_i}=f}if£(3€I"}.i ta (iepute the ratiefi"c;fi*:is of pef;iti0fi=3r§;'1.vii1£:g:3 to

Avinahaiizi viiiagc fair pricg s}1Q;§"bje".;dat€c«i' '1m"é.2ue8.

2. It is av§:’rrc{£ are
rfisideuts of ‘giv:-$1 a regarssentation
tax the fcgr”t§*a:1sfer of ration and
kemseziié’ K V The Feofi Shiristheéar,
%~¥01alke§:. gavé the mahazax’ drawn 311d

Tahsfldar siii2tn§i:ej:i–. his 1?:::§<3r£ to the Dcpuziy" Cm.missianer

far agtiozé ‘i;1~~-2:-‘fispeci of transfer of raiimz carat} of the

:¥}fffL{‘fi1;{3L¥}{3§’%’.”§.”*0tE_1€f pagans of {he viiiage, The Bepuiy

mdsr éatgd 25.16.2698 pas$<–':<i ms szfier

depufing {he distribution system zhmugh

.:";:1::{1_m: Price shop on the ground that it is inmnsmniefit

— f§::a–zf £0 get their ratimxz. 3116 said ordézr was chaéienged fin

“W;P.Na,140§8f2G08 ané {ha Qraissz” passad by the ?[)e;::nuty

W2

Cemmissianer wag set asieis 53-‘ <:s1:§t:'1'{ia%:¢d"..&19.:.«§:i."2QfL§8; T1§€.

petitianms and @ther résidmzts ofA:'zi1e'-.viiiag{~i'gau*a 'a1%:é.i:iz::é1:*~.x

rfipmsantatgien to file Authb§i§5;~V..V'Mg9 falzfi éieps 'V

regaxtiizlg the older §as;s;{:d byVAV¥;1fi, s " I-i<3£:v'e:vr:r,v 11<;s steps
have been takan thought V V and Civil
Sugpfifis passed at: zL

3: “”” “E;<.

ciinactima is issueti as per the submissiciyef, ‘=3.¢.:;:_rx:<:*:£i}"

ASA. ,

3. We have ca:1s:idemdV.’é;h,¢ cofi’*c§::i’ti$n iszaijnééi

ceunsei appearizxg for the the

maifiriai on rer<i.

6? The leatimfci A§?;3§;’_;– Aiiée respazzciems
has fairly’ arrangrzmam has
airaaiiy ‘£0 Edehalii vifiagti
Where #16 1’i’£’éT.iV¢”‘?(‘§.- §);{T$I:i gesiding. The iearfiaé %GA
3139 subfigted ééhap mag ha Qpsneii in Ede-halii

viiiagg dégss after the data 9%” parfiiamemary

V. °:*:}.5c:cV’:;i<3A:.x;_';:;n;':s;~'i.« the %iégé::1ed cmmsci appearing fer the.

.§»é:!;«é£':"V{§:'}.«$:.::I':::V_&A::;§;{tT:':T._ $0? ckigpute that aitemafiva arragigemanis

hai$::4 ébeer:.§é§;.d% for suypéy of foaé grains t9 the rasiciétzzts af

i<'ii§ag€ and therefzxm, agaart from rsceriiing tbs

Szzfifiissign of Ehfjf learned Gravamment Aévocatfi that su§pi3§

§i§:'01:g%: fair mics gimp woulé be astaflishad wéfiiin sL*{:§,

\Sk/E

.§_':1d:3§;: Y6S,;f§.Ov'!''.V . é

.1&¥é§}2§cs*ai;%—fégesjme

days after the parfiamem eiscfiaxz K x
:10: aniifléé is Gmex' rfifiefs £12 A
Ac<:<:)rz§;§ir1g}y, the wrif petitisfi» .C:vi'$§{.'i:#.*E§ii.
aimve sank} absezvatiozm. — ' «
% %f[Sd/-

Justice