High Court Karnataka High Court

General Manager Land Acquisition … vs Channappa on 29 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
General Manager Land Acquisition … vs Channappa on 29 July, 2008
Author: S.R.Bannurmath & Gowda


§§’§ “?%°~§E %-§§{§§=§ CGQQT Q? 2§+;”3Vai3%a,v; 2;fi§i;s’f$v =
pagégésgffi % V
ma Hearaaa sv:$;: «3kL:gs?;tE’é;j;é;fgg§xe%€2}§:e2;é;*§%s
‘mg §~%G§§’§;E«?%’§§;.3¥§§§§V::1A.~§§;i§%%g?§;§§>§aLA $Q%’*::’§&
>iA;”é’:§V’§’e”E’é'”‘-?”fE:§a’§:.;.”§i.”*§:.fi’. ‘ 5 f’?4:f–V2 a<2r3?€ ifi-w 35$}

3. “Ewe §€;r;e’i§’§%
Land fixc:;;«a;V§sivt§¢n;__ i$*:{.P’;«,.,

?i25§Ve;’ar§_agar,” ‘ ‘
§?§i3,§.:$76g”3§§<6iL"«… …..

2; “%’?2e ;%£i::%%éi§v;§’?§va§ Sgeséaé Lang Aaaagéaiéémz Qficer,

— €45 pgziar’ EC ;*’§s%é1gr:sav~~ Wages: (LEKP);
* .?ii’:%%;2 é.§ég,;a4.§; Bagaiket.

..flzS?&§§§%”§€$

A i”{,.5y<.fi.§*'S,?§i%§, §aa;t.fi.§vs<:a§a}

. a:*~%a

–« 2. Céaaaagga,

S,/’Q ‘famunagga ivietég
Ageéf afieat 5% years,

‘C3′!

, fig: :,§’$a,;33#’e,

;”§a%%’§A::>$%’-;~,.”

” –.S;'<%__§'éi§a§§A:"§§;ap;a ivieti,
* a§T3g€vaej?«v..a%t;$';;§:.v3;§ gays;

Ag rimiissyést;

fimi. fiééfiawa,
Kfiifo fiodéappa Vieté,
Agéé $5925: 48 gseamg

. Ye%§:s:”§a§§a,

Sic Deédagma Metif
figeé afisasi 22 yeam,

. Saiacbanéza,

Sis Bewagpa ?v’§et”§’,’% ” .

&§%§ abezg: A29 yea_:*.-.=.:,.._ _ ‘

y.§:”e?”;¥é%,

Sis Sgéiz§g§.§g;.z:~’:*§§Eeti,–…__ _ ._
fiagaé aisgaf: *g’e::a;*?;S}”7.’ .,
§’*’§§.f3′{3’E”; .r§§g. Bg«3i::.;%2er”~n:a.§i1eé*’Séx;’£z;iav’2za;
;5s;;{:§:§<);'_;s:%r'vL%7%§VG_,;2§';4_ '

wig' G 5% éj-aé E mg a 'ggai .j§v'§ €*.«t.j.?;I

_a;;&;é a%ei:s.%:h 3'$'ye$a:"s;

;-. .§ :”a_s’s’ra 3 ;%i’%:?:,

Sjdiféigaiéngapga Mat;

agaé’ 350:3: 17 ‘years;

n ‘ “«.§v§%n$r by his msther énasmgaf
. .;%§§i:r§ana;’ Eéaiég

.$ahgéevg

vi;/3 Hanumafitiz %%E%§;

ageé aéeasé 42 gzears:

Ex.)

2; “%The facts are mat mafia §;ra désgzste. “%’%_%¥§w3’8§'”é’€’%.S~-§?~i____”.

$29 writ §&§;Z§’i§{3?’é&€”Sff’€S§$§%§Qf’%’§S §’:a2f;e;§:2; wa:<a"'a'axQ§::%»%'eé 'fgcfl

Légfie? é<;*§$%:§':a Pmjact 332$ $3: tiza 3&7';-:<§;,,':§:j%_ 3';:: _AA

C§§'E'§§€:?%S§?%§§"§ zégaa awa§"§ed'%33;f i%é':s:~,_'V:,.%;"':§: ";€a;a:;;_§§§*:_E\§§?:

Q ggaea 5&3 yafereaca a$§§%%%5a}'§§§z:._f.§~»,:é's" §§"%%
$$'£§$§%3E'§%?'S %£§'"'§§§§" $ec§%5$;:§ ':1$A ;;';§~§§~«..;;i¢.2.L§€1:'%§_ggQ:.2§s§§§m': Act
{'§§"%& Asa?' fa?' géasrt}. awards 32
rasgaai 6;? 5:§.%f§3é${e5E§ gersmzfi were
céaamngaé amazxzi iama is
be eshafiaefigA%§é'2.V:*§%:§i' §'éj%:i§i%.§i..¢',:«__z;eésfresgeaéenés ézereérs fiéaé

as: 3§$§§c'3t.%;?s:__V§aE’§’ xfiith ma awards $2″ iéaa refergaca

;*3;’§:§:_§§e?z<gd by tifie fact the: 't%"%e yefezrezaca Ceam has

fig;"-:a:_'s¥a:*:§%::¥V_ §%é5'$é*:'§*e$t fmm the éaie sf awarai, fie gama

_ was 'i£:%2a§%._;é:'::;.é~§§ $3': $39 writ geizéiésm as aizagéy féfgéififi, '§§"%§

V§ %3é§;§§.S§§ég§e Eaéfiga by t%'*:& imgzggnaé srfias $333 awa;"d§§

._A§§A%}é§'a%:*§t fmm 3§.§,i§53 Egg", {ha £a§a af awaré 3:25 ;**:&:v:e,

iiéé—e? §:*&§e::%; agfigaéi

%/

'Ah

3. Tfia Qazegzéam 3% far as tfia géaie {ram w%*;é”r:§é’TA

mm amsfaga V3,, s§v:”r.’;.:Sa§€’;§$*r§R2§?§V_% mg

amaas, repezzea 3:3: 12.3 29§’$1%§$é’:f§2.a;,;-.V:’§r§m éate 9?’ actuaé
$%§3e$S§€}§’%§-i}? ?”:r;_s§Aé?:..§i~§f%é :.ia_a§»:’-2-~.._of ‘.a;2.r€.;,3r .,. Er: am §¥’€S8?’i'{ case,

as me ‘;–:><a§:?: 3§?a?év€.3–«,$¥'.$a§c§%§§__p.e$$&s3E§2': £3 fagmésézafi §§; 'me
Staia §';§e:i' sn3: giaaeé in this regyé am

esgggjcélaééy 2a:%2esiz_ §$ 3&2? ifia fiégcazéay a? the G§a:$§"r:me-at

Ezééég' §§":!{§§£3$%.~:.$_, §§'°;f%%"é is :23 fiafiaéie éate 33 m 2% §§§i§§"%§

p;é::*~_$;¢.=§$?=$%'§'~;%fs,,V_a§é_*§*s'%%§ $5'; iésa afareaaéé £%§&, %?%@ sfiaia is $9;

fixéxfi §<::;'%'€:3»§":as§$ié?:§ éstayeat %%3§ii§ié fie §:%%e éaia $5' gwwd.

§ée%'ée:g§§ ét E3 '2.:e%ze:*:°%e:§%§§; asfaiéfifieé mt as gef Efia

'%"_iE*§::a§%a:* éstéé §a§.i,2§G3; iéze fiaia féxefi %€ awayfiéag

W-'mézsrast $3 1é.$.2@%2;. 3:2: mam §S 3% myme sf sesame

vssééy iézés figia is féxaé. ?'=§€§€?'?;§%' it is me éaie $1? ézaé-mg

gagaagsésra gas: the daie er; mézésh the éaaés were

2-/

{%

§:s%§"§':e':"§eé am as $3 am View, asgeséaéégg, 2?: ;t.%é'§e"§'%:§»'%;-i.

the pzmzaamaemefit 9? this £cé.::*t_§2f2} €:%:e."'C'a'$§e}'_~ §§»."§"'§:~§E__ V

caswszgsgmggg R.E§~%%§E§..l'?A'§EQ?%§:'».__ A?{$§.. 3 §f£j5§§??L§%sé§§%§§?;VT&'

ANS A?5é'.}T%~§ER {supra}, €§':€<$V:£'_§3"fi 3f._ '§'§:t1er£;§*:%'

gate sf award by $329 %ga{ne§'x4S«z.%é:g§.a: 3{§§§§é _é:3 gvéisi am
mega; argé rseaés rm §nt§é.%_?}e2r_er%V:c§5_»
3?. is the reagsét, $3' '*1v%:f§ 'f§%"%:Z_§ '§_§}é §§.§é'3é ég éeaseéd sf

mast! izésa aaiizééé. %s;1'§Eéj_V;ee:'.%§§=::;¥ _