High Court Karnataka High Court

Manipal Finance Corporation Ltd vs State Of Karnataka on 24 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Manipal Finance Corporation Ltd vs State Of Karnataka on 24 June, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil


:3: ‘rm mm: .::<;:,22.2" 1? E<.AR1'€;aT;~XKA :9; Baszs 5'-a:.,<)§3..§:. £2582 5.2' 3:9-,::a

11.:

:5: ‘ms H383 scum” GP Kfififiié mm A T s,a:«sA;.a%}:§£=,V

QATED TEES THE 24:5 Ems’ 0:2 Ji_}’?€E§_

8£FG8E

ma HGNTBLE am. J{f$1:3?éE;::f’ig§{§§5′{;§’3’§£¥.:_.: J

‘v’~J.P_?=§G_ 12532 :::;§«’ ggaggcmcmg} * %

BE??? EE M

4
E

%€%A:’\’§§3RL FWANCE :c>R::’$F<;.:.f':?§<::*:ve,":"s._
A N@:xz-3A:~.:K:N<a Erzgxzaagrqé czggmpaagér V
amras 5:3 REGESTRES QFE'-_ 2; 9%?

marazpag §%Oi.i$E T' 
;»=:.=a:4::--*m_ 5?s:e«:..    , * ;,.-

mm RE? :«g:’*e§»:§ gm 3% ma :”._??F§{;§:R_f3:’¥:§- «.
E113Nfi§\§<¥""£«53§S%*éAk€Y\g 'V

&"?2T§0:'~iER

{ifig 5:233, §"5§z,:«fé;aa1?2:r;;__:g::.s-:;é_;a;:::':s; A3sQ§;gg;%g.3= asvacargsg

ANS :

£3

M, ”

°%’:-‘2″:’& mp v:<;;etm=_:g1=.':=A;§;:-x~.– "
' ~ E? 8%' as S%Z'CRE;f§"s3R':*1
"3

a "Y Q? ?%:..:a;:.:_ A%ȎS am. saswazgss

§ .

%”«1§§éij.%€%§R RF¥Aé§S,

g; C3 ’33 13′)

.f§,:”.i%%,§§L£3%§’~é€3§ QR,8,5i.fi?¥§*§3«EC5K§Q ‘v’EE$fri§
§:’%?§{?s;*%§.,QV'”–%7 ‘£1

‘ T§~%’£–§1ie’$£%{3§:Ps£ G? %?%§{}’éA
RE? 3-‘s’ 57$ SECRE'{}’3.R’:” TS <3{3'v"Tv} —
' — f'x__E:'3'fiR"§"§'v'%ENT 3? F338 #43 CNSL S¥.iF-'?~'L$E$,
.. ?~E§3s"»£ §E%..

‘£3 $HA§’~4’§iUf\2T%§Ai.A 83¢
“#253 L§%?§£ ‘»”.’se’E?*4${s*-‘é3’ES§-§
” ASE? $8 “{E§§R$,
Q}!-‘Cf MEHRB {fiéfifififis 39$ €R€’I§3$§
Sfififififi E??? 43”? SH§f’v”Z-G{§fsf*~,

{A QES?QN£}E:”~é”§”$

{SR3 E\§.B\ ‘€§$§1’v%’fi£*éfi{{H £623: F@R Q5?

1?? ‘FEIE §E§*{‘}§’§ €:€f}i.’R’§’ §{;iiZ_}{A’E’?aE€Px AT :’-i:4′:§R3E ‘4§;’.?h’€’,-. E2582 {Ezf §:£}€}$

E}? ‘,{“E§}_i Zflifiii €f€’::{§R”§.” E«1?sE%’}’%?C’§:’%K.}x AT B?{:’~E=’C.§ ?sL{}E~’2.£._ ‘3@}1’.§’~§v:s; 32582 at»? 29-38

flnfiw

3&2. <;:.. gaggmm "ma sac $3 R2
3%. a:<;.*¢z3:nwAr<A':H Ami mm Res; ..

ms w}: :3 F%%,,EE} :m§§§~’: mgcggg 22$ ;:;»:£%«..f2;;::..:;L:T’.;~}’2:;£
$=;’f.>:a:$”z”z”:’2..::’:Q:~: QF mséa, 9~{~:,.c:*~.#;r-Age TC} HGLB ‘£933? :x;<:a?:':§::<.:sa.*;';'–.«_.._r::–~r: '
::{.%9:2a {:3 gsguaa 32* £3Q'JER%»'»%§f§E? 2* GF KAR%\é£a?A%<;% as e:w;aa.,:;s 2:223

I? .

g

“EHE 3r5’é:”5tE $3 f\%.Q”f fix: €,f7?7 €;’–%7?§’Z:’Z”:_f’~3T §.vS:: .

SEC§”i{}§\i EH2} CIT: §§¥’~£SiJi’a:”;ER r”3’r’3iG”§EC’g”_2_{.,«°’€’-£ .1-‘_£3″§’, ‘EQESS r”~;:”~.:’–§J §SV’:!;..§g..i’.-“:$§”-%..L.

8&3 AND i{‘~i§?EF3iAT!’v’E PRGDUCEED AT A¥’éé§’5§L}é;.–S -1%?-4– ,_E£Cs #32
P*ET?”%S§’~£E?~’; ES C§,€’?%$fé &–.__3§’*i1C:¥

vi

S§{3T§Q»”u’ 2? Q? “ERE §.Z€’}§’~é;’Si.3:”2’§E7;§~2V 1-;’.9’§€f3T££T€Q?£ , «. ‘S
i}i’s’CO?4ST§T§.§”?%{}!’é2’%’s_ :’-“‘==J”~a’S ‘ufflifi A$j’E}{F’Lfi§NE£L”%N »A’E%i’3′{E §é7*§E’ij’€T§C}?sa’, V’ ;
3%’ SS FAQ 88 ‘{fr§E ?E’é’T§”E$¥’~i’:T.§:~Z %E’;fT_S’53,’r.?’-»SCER€’~a’E{.f>. Qi,:’!31Zt3%’§ “2*§;CL”~F.§J’RT?§ER’~

%’?€{3$EEB¥E’»é§S EN P%..s’§€$UA%~s’C’i C}? ?%”§E’E¥”%Q%”a’ §3}’:’:i__J$é3 NQTICE !S$L,iE$ ER
E_§3′.¥*~£€é. 3552335′; WI €?CQ.'{?éi’> HLEQ E595 ?€ESi7-‘_QNf}Ef’~i3′ ?a’€.Z’~..3%N C€3?§’1P§_A§§’~£T s”a’C.,
2i};’2€£3}’ ‘~fiflE Pu”~i§*-$?.£}'{{f§?;E;«~!’% _§3’§$3T§f32H{§::§.?;””£§:’-1′ ‘”:’f~~!E’RE»’E’>?7’a’.’;f’r£EIéE”~.?’?7″§§G’Z3 W?-§%s.’3é-1′
3.8 new ?E§=é£a’EN§ E3xEE3QRE_ —f;3?’:_’§?~:”§~*fI_.3G:*=._ $§$:§’§?§C:W:7..1::{:3§’~3SU§’s;’§£R BESPQTES
§3éE§”}%~”{ESf:3fi.L r'”~”$%{}!’%e”i= = – T f , .A M

Ti-%§$ 2523.9 *$’3§¥E£’«é{3 Q_?t§,.5Q%§ §–*§?:jEL.bifs€f%’*é;e%725E”=.§§:’§;”«:;iiR§§~§€3 3:: ‘9 GT5: :3?
“2.’H:E% 331;? “:”§-:£ C;C3a;§%:”{ éazéfaiié T§%.£’~F{?LL53’£%’_%?€G: ‘
” ” % +ar?3i”§§:’Lkk i

‘§’?é§1$’~:%i%:2fié§:?jVEi3; ia§§r;’e;**: :§_§§””?§r cangéafaraiizm wéfh the
canseééfi £35 :éa§§1’é%;§~§:§t:’;.;§:%%’ge:–~ gpgeanng far bath ihe gariéég

arszi an %§”:é’e;j§f¥am::3’»§ f§*;.§i’,” §:%’;& subgeaf mafia? énvgiveé Er: ‘:%’2i5

géaéé §$'{{5§f”1E¥€’;§f§y $Q %£é?:§§ by $332 asfier gagaed by fiéiig §:€:r§JE”‘§

‘ ;:;.4{m::[a~§s. z%*:3′:::§-:–%”_

“§”l%i:”é pefétégirzer in ihég géiitémfi hag mug??? ta @5213?

:%§.:%§ §’:é’i’§§§3€§$:2 afigéad 2G,§_C:@; %s;$s.;ed by $13 §i’:s2;es::”2§*§”s&::?

“:::f ‘ ‘§{§ma%:3§:.a as igwaééé Séfifié the ggmg 53 mi if:

V’ “§§;*:§%*:>;”;’::*’:y %5§§??”§ the $3535? 5′-‘:§”‘3:§ti’?’§°'{‘;$§”§? Ema; Eééfififi 2?'{2} 23%

.« ‘~– 2 H . « -. , ,-“‘-._ mass’ :,. .-“>§{k<'? N,' -':''::=
Q, §:%f.'2§; éifi._£§:i'€ vi %§:!1fi,'l$.i,2;,?g&,\§':;}'L'§'34?3§_:§E(.)§. 1§£:§sa"2§.,i,,a,2§ii§ vs=.§.}w. 2.-E: -,f..3%,52.;

5:: 'SEE; §::<::: »f;'.€T3"€:'§~E'E" <32" K.;*«..E%;'-r£Af§':'§=:._:-'a 2x:<§'r':ee. :.::;:;:3
)5

.. .+..:

§”€.§§§§a,§?§§:§§=?$ afié Efififiééifiéi mafiarfi _:§.iV{s»-rzgfsvfiéd

fin 1&3′ Jame 2§fi§, Tfharzizfmre, ihey

faiéewéng fine gem? 52353:, ihe iragiani writ-~§:safi§%:::”;’~»§é§asf ‘V ‘V

pesiiiiarser may 353$ ha déspcged A

5. “‘E”%’2e subm%ss%s:y.mafie’–.Ai:-3: §ag2.*.i;:e%37 “cfifi.:fi$éi’V

agpearing far bath the §a:*t§r;.~»:-.r–;<*,'~:i.,"":;:s gfsied '3f:::f':,_wé::v:4'v§ s"§i3c$dVV

an rmarfi. _

8. iii the Eight ‘<::§';–?:$ -'_$u§:.sr:i§;f-:,séQf:.%rn9§e by §83E"'!"%é§

mamsei appeaiéng f§r'VV_V_ b7€.2*£;§1 ;:*a:§%é'eéi1i§_..:;'$ siéted supra,

'§§'§& ir::_3$iE3§*a%é.:n;%:9§j;i?:: § éi;f§%:¢h*fi'§_ed ifyy fiie peiitiafier fig éésgsged
si f5i§'e:'-géézg the ';:«:é*:is§?'"*;§ésfé$§ by %:%':§é$' Qwri in firm C8343

::sf'§'-$35; ,S§2$fiE%*;V§:1§§iaax%§a:*s §'§§i3S§i"§§ §~"¢u:2§a%§m§ Vs. Brig,

g;Qf e:::%%%§M%L',;,%s;;%(kaezgaiasz am fitfiarg in sza;,ma;e.?§é§;2§§s

.~f»2A§é:zf_«€:V3'<31i;é"r:§a¥'§é$ matfarg éigpasafi an 1%" éam fifififi

«V 2235 faifééé raasarig gigtea? '§?'§$f&§¥'§' wifh ffié fgzéiawing

éjiééfiegiians:

{E} “lffrée §@%§%i§§§ !::§’i§§§é§’}§§fi§ Em

{:9′:*;$t:7=’fs_§’i§a:3;1a§ zsgéieféiy sf Sash: geaiiarzg {:2} am’ {3}

igiifiii =if€_}i_.=ii”_i 3}? §a?x.§*:§”§:’3.§i3:.§-2:1 5&1 13£iE’€i_3 [KL-.}2.”3:§L i%’}’,?,’w, 2,:-LS3: mi 2%-3

liifiii C€.}iiE~Z”£’ €33″ XE’ §%?x3,’~§€3 ;’§§¢€f3~§§.a’1 ~ £332 -3? 2i3=’3$

if

:3? Sézaztéafi 2? af frxe fasnsumar §4″>rste::%i@:§’

‘$88; ag amended téii flaw is hereby a*iS;z9f:E§éé:*§;~ ”

mphaiding fiie aims Q? the ss§;i…:3.r¢v’E$§1é§%g;~~’–. 1:

{ii} The pgmeeasngs ;5:;Trs%ua7:a¢Ae;%w¢%

1″””,.£’.V

impugned shav;–causé;:r:§%§€:e fiétééfi’ –§_?:_;G’§–, 2:;a;8
éggued in E”;<ecL'e':'i.r;n ?,:3%'%iEC§r; u?~¢i«::;. S5g'§;%:"§fis*r3 £2':
aamgiaéfii %-$::_2:3!'2§£'}}' %pia=»n§:gT §%:e§m»e the

Shimaga E}§fs§%;*%$i;=s'T',z:s§3,-*§::r?1'e§" 5f}§$§:3;£.é5te$ Redresseé

1*-4"m;":;f::f2,V {}§;'§§§$"}§E§"%E_;¥:¥f§%§{i3§%:I.¥§-":'%:§ éf§"he§eby qasiagiéeé

dz??? ._.=;::<n %?:–'e–z;3_fmsg:§:j:V'i%:_a€ whéie gassgéragfi the arse?
vibe §?s:&gé§$V'i*:*:_z%.é~:.' »– éééé {Ede 23% Cf§§'.fi;E£¥3§§

E

. «.{?r"{j::edLaré", =3%$'§'3A .353 mi c:::;:r':"*;;:§§§ez.=i wéérz,

.._ «.{§.%§"*fa;%3§fer aaianég raméfiesi bask '*3; firm

"*¢§2%é§–E'g'*zag§ gfififiéfii, wiéth 3 éifeéfimfi fig 3:3; iéa

gffégice Er: a$€:5§"§§f§C& wéfi': ihés ;3:'$ce@§.2*§'é§

"'§:::*gg§:'ébe§i unéef éjfig iflfiiéé T3? {';':i:'§mé ::a%

éfirécagfézgra magi wéih S£fQ*$§fi'§§fi¥'E$ {2} am {3} 3%

Sesiiézan 2"?' sf fiée figt; an meréfig, Ea ifie iigifii :72?
I/t\'~–\

.,\'="" T ' 5"', " 'T' 7 , '. "C "'- . 7 'K, .' 3-' 'k'.. . '5": «.''''n "D
1?» iii; §§§<?EE€f\,:E,;E-i'i 5.}? §;.=?§§,{?*§rK{§?a§%?2 A2 1ér'£'%{§A§_:3§§}{; '~?%..§?._.~§a-. El'?-§%,-,, :55 £412: ' 1;

xv 7 -.,« . f.'.'*, V . "N $ ,2 .:.. . .'''s'
E}? "i';Ei';. £2331 L.-=C3L.E%T {xi K?%.§«l}a 'C?~.3<.£a A? £3:'%.}5<I§,3«'<.L€,:RL, '$2 .?,?°«:v= 1.253? at ESEES
_{i,.

the fihsérvaiians mafia by iirzés Sang”: in the ::z:”i*§ éf,

éateé 1%?” June 2039 in w.P_:2:e.”ma;2Q:}a5 _

cannecfeécfi mafiers.

gjjéi} Thé pefiféerzér §fi$:ra%fi[A.£’$ é9.3’§r1@::~,é:5:fi’ :¥:s:: ‘*<.'

appear befara the t;'c2_:42':::;e:°net:i- E"4a:¢;.2§r:

Aisgiigsfi ;'Z§§§,§ %2;if;é::<:z:2%__"'v-.x§¥:aL_§E§:2§ any

n:§i:$&§$a;rr:m0ns.’ ” ‘ ” 1

w2«'<;*" _,«. — 'P'-' ,5,'-. -" '?"i'.'x'€'*-,1 "}".'§?'E_)?a?», ":.§2(3«"5 ..''*%'~,*.
3?» iii; §§§{.2§§.§j§}3t,/:5? {ii §*x;5sR.:f'=rs.§T§'éi1'~<..zE; Fa: L§r%;9<{;r~:Lfi,3§"\.§,; 13:» =.-;,'rs,=< L-.¢;u;;. vi £32543