1%»; ‘”E’E~§.Ei> E%§{§H %u¥:’:’ £325′ §«1é;R?€A’El%ER§z;—-»;2€§%:,>§”-~:: ”
?RE8£%?_
WE: %iGE€’§E,EZ’?vER 9.3 §§§\E.;g’§§__,
BE”§”v¥*’EE:E*%:
3 §x§;s.__Ars.;§i{§1§_EN:f§E*;§2:”%g§S§::s’3V .
RE? :3?’ ‘fizz; P§e{>.?R:.::,f:T<;::::__i– " "
:32; ._A3;:::é;,:”V:§ ‘3:VAm?s.i:%__A{:%E: %¥i?sJ{}R
{‘}’£f:C;..B”i.iSEE%§§3SS’,v«..
i€j3%§”E’ BE-“§’Bi’w1¥:§e’::%:::§3″”i*–:«:::AL. §7>’i.{“)’T$,
_ GP? §§§~:S’iig.%§?ffi. }?g§z~;a:,
5€;’.}€1′}I?~EE:E€
‘ .§23″3»~ 5; §§-EAT’, ASVSCATE» ;
fi;1”€{,?: */ __
SR3 id-i§H§§?e§i¥’EA§ ARE?
,.Sf’§3 §§z%ZAHg%T$!§§ ?’«’§{§:§F’&’§§§
_ _ QCC: L§}{3§THE§ MECHENE WQQK
V Qffi? V§e§§fl?§§§ €3§§§,
HUBLL RE;-SPC}i’€£}E:?*~«E”§”
‘§’}¥§S ‘s§i”,P. ES FILES PRfi’fE?%G Ti} QU£SE*E “§”%§E €%§¥E§E:R
“:::’i’-. :31.*;’.2c::9g ?ASSE:33 BY THE BISTRECT €Z’if_§i’§S’£}§v’i{}ER
QESRESSIQL FORUM, iéi-£«%RVs’§£§ {.§’%3’3?*%E;X~L} GRDER 8%’
THE KARENEATAKA STJKTE {i€)NSUEv’IER §”3IS’£-‘UT’T;§S
REDREZSSAL CQzVEM?s:fiSSEG?-E, BA§’*§{‘:;ALOR;E3 {E4 APPE?-fig EEC}.
:;*:g:s3_:;”3.§:_§,i:_.V§’_:%;~ _
REVEEEV §~’ETE”E”1UP€ N0′ 1./2638 mssgg BY “§”;H’£f; 2″:«.;ST’f€§.€’j:’:”‘ 2
Comsm-1;:g ggzsywas REBREISSAL §:'{:R~:§§sz§;”‘.,,:3’§—§;a;a%§;A.:;~«.. ‘
gamwgxwmg mgr; ‘THE: ORDER :’:%z’;”+;:;:;«:§;.;%;:3«:;§;g “E1%E§SE;E’.T]?% fii
&¥’?E£’sL M}, gzaggaza}? mg$gi:3 8575:’ :.*?;’:;E:’ A ‘fi.£%§*?;E¥Ev;%’§f:,§§$;
S’E”‘§§’f’E {‘:GE\IS’i§§xriER ETEESPUEES *;<::s:«::.s§£:_i_-:Tzs;;sm;~–§ii::;§§.:::§v::vs§:§:.<;;s;
{z%N§'~1E1}£~Q}.
This Wfii pstition c0mi€iLg..L§:p far ?§:ari:1g
011 this day, SABHAHIT J” II1a{§.€_t§3.{i’f€}1iGV¥’iIig-…._A
This writ petition is ffieéstif’ 33:; _–§z_;:.é+ .g§;;3__§3}c§§z1:’:I in Agipsai
i’=Zo.2i§j:2{}Q9§« ‘<;'»w.:._1 _'-':§*1e5:A_ iii: Siam Cmmumer
ifiispuéas _§éé';€§$éé.1 =T}5;§3;.i:.;:.i8s:i01}, Eaflgsism, {ha:"€i7fi1a§'i€;:
éraéicii "§i=':V€"8'{3_:{:_&f$::::::§s_$ii.E’:.2.;2{§{‘%§ v;%hl:*:ré:’:{: $56 féiaifi éfamasisgimg Eiasa étaiamifisaaé
:ht:—- :a;35j<%a:%a§'~~ am? :::<éi£i§'i%m§:{3; i;%§::% Gffifif gsassezi Er; 231$ ."§}i$§§i=:;°*a
?f;;§<;::%s*;:V§;:tr'v§§é3§é;:f:&§ Rsairaggaé E»':}:*:;:::': éézérsifi aféiiéi' c:5zEE.€::% '$316
§3i§s§::§<':'7§ _F;':f3:";;:1%:={§ E§aEEg£i;E{')§'fi'
23;' ''?ha :'§:$p@:3.{§€§:'§ Eizitreiia iétié i?{§;m}";Ea;?2'}f:. §'k3,i§¥,??'§12%Z§{}'?
._{:z§:' 33.6? {$5 sf §%s%:'i{*§; §"¥a{§; zaw::”§’é:1g iiéai E25
‘ ” “;}u§*€%::»1s€{§ a igzfiafi gxazfiéigss 51’ ‘gfigéitr Bzazié’ §%zi§k»:3’£ fimm $226
§’€3§§§€§§§{§{“:f1’§. bf Rs.8€§,§{“}{}§» 9:2 ?;}’;;;E{}{)€’§. ‘§’§§.€3:€ was
g3;ZZ-‘§:”3.E1i¢Zi’€ fifi warrazztsz 3%}; {me jgsar. “§’31¥: wrii §;:”:t1?ii::>:’::::’
\;9′
4
Wm. petitiener submittezi ihat they woafld repkace thg iafifze
macrhélm: czrdéréd that the iaihc 1fiEiChii1€;’: sshaél ‘:::$.v’:’é’p§,é;€fe{§
ané aim awaztiad iizffirast at 8% pa. pa§;a’s}:: £5332′ “§§Eg:;g–. V.
sf gajgmfizii and 3139 a,”%};’a3:::1ed <:0m§€n$afi:;§:17' *0f:'_£€S'.'i2,iL*€}{}§ -«
for maria} agmzay anfi. .Rs.1,fiQG}~ *£Q1=s~*sgti~S' Casts. E': zafiissg;
erésraci féaat if ma laihe maciifigs is é}{;é':"€pI2;r;fi?:?:i; wi;;hi:;1 aizefi.
mcnm, {he c@m§§Ea3'n.an'§ s§2a§ '23§é f."ji3f£1it}'£{i,.:iKO .' Rsfgfifi, EGG/_
wig} intsresi at 8% fitéf "a,_m§u::t fmm the éaia of
camyizéifié {Q Bsing aggzéaveé Eng: the
sgzié firdér V fix: Qisfiiici Ehmm fijgpsal
§¥0.i§f24} Was: the Saki agpsai was iggstsii
.. .. bsvffgiie State €33{)§;i1':"3;3.§.SSi€}.I1. 'F136 ieammzi Cazirzsaé; apgsearégzg
V {of :he'v.§3p;§é1i%$:1.E: gmzgézi psrmissim: is 'azfiizziraw the aywpeai
&sé:*iri21g§ is maize the Sigma: ¥'::3z":.3.m is gfit {he
§}t::,*s:"*.:;£:.:*..:"§"':::2:f £3616 aréer %.§:*1%:e:"€§11 ii is ohserveé '$23: at 31% Eimas: sf
V. égfgugmemt it was gubmiiisd f{}I" {Em §'€Sf{}{§}"i§%Z";E§ ma: 52223:: rams;
$13- §:' yfiaéjg 3:1: z*€§}:as:r{: figs Egafiis fiiaéfhiiifis in Efifii-"§' Q? iézé:
'garigé ':m;'1":;§1is§;'s;:a¢ apgsai iasazg éigmissaé as; aa?§:%1:i§:ea'a%*::¢
'E'Ii35:°€"3fi€-":3", 'm":'% gm: éiiiiazier Efiéiffiiiié fiéfié: §{{"E'§§€*:E€ ?§:%Lfi§s:3:3
M
5
§’éa.1;’2§{}8 am} the Saws was dismiss-.3€é Egg 212;? xii-§$T:zf§c§
§'<;)rum "fig eras: data}; 3G.};i2;2Qfi8 fafiezvmg {E}? .
29% am gczms 53?? am}; 2SG8_f{"Z'PR ;?;:s%:{§4–AV:;':§§:"VV
§is%r;§c:"'£ §'r:3;r::-am 7:133 as gewer is 'zjevizi-=93 §§;is'–,e3w:i"-ra=: : :;¢V:T’:’;;ai§ é;omg§:§s;:{§:1 me: {ha Stats
{Z3§1af;_issi0:£A’b};*:?:.é:}” aivaisé 9x£=f;;E{}i}9 émyagzzeéi £31 {£33 ‘€.>;**:’i:.
§;s3:iii{31:”:§is:1si3?.e;3:i’ fal’-g.J._;_p’¥’E’-,’:»A”=;”‘;”L
‘>3: ‘$6 §1:~3;s;!e’ Vheaagfié aha éaazjafié Cfiugagaé agrpearézzg fizz’
V ” 1:73{;é” rszréé :’;3s:’:E’i*’;”§;0:z{::z’,
A “_”_i..»§:ég:éé%s:d munseé apgsagégzg £702” {“233 §{:i:%;%.:ée::m:~z”
§;’::a§2*’z”§ii?;3;i::{%,’v*i}:afi figs ariiési” passflé; étsf; ms S5%.a§s: €c:§§::m§$§§{::i
%%€}§£%i:1g”i§:a§ zwfivifizg? _’§}€§fi§%OE{E is 225.2%; zfizezifizégsabéii fig §:;:%’§§§::~ is Em
aside amé firm §}:isé:*i<:§ §<'m'"i3.m Wag 232:3? §%.,:§'é:§§§,eé ':33 <};6;:=s;'é§:g
~2.*§:§§a=::€§m::é Qf 3i:£iE§'§,€ 335% :31: 8éT{f§m§SSi{3':} axzas madg E3}; 'aim
zzmmscé agégeaiéng far 'Sis Wm pfiéiiisgxfir.
\s»/°>
5. We Eaave cozzsidered the contezztien of.V~f;%;1zé_¢’V3:$; .€é;x§j;;é{i.¢
counsel appaaring far the petitisfisr _
material on recorci.
3?’. ‘T’1’1e mafaréai (>13; z*€<:Gf;*._:gcAs::VVEé’:v:’;:;~:§xv;i’A}.§,’ were takea far repiacemant of
{E16 mafihégfifiééor’ 0f the compiaifiani: is
prQ;s§3d’ batfarcr vfiisirict 90mm and the ieanmed C€3″1}.I}S€}
firm pefitionsr herein submitted bcfom {he
1§i»sj?.§*;iT:ci~.’4E11é&:1: btifarri
tiée’-«.£§’0Ii:_3:1;.§§r§.%’ faaéy {:1} rgzplace the Iathe machma and in view
{§Azf ih€i.. maiefiai an rmoxfi, the: fiistrict Fcmm ardsreci
” ,;*::;:>iaé:em€3% sf the iaihfi machine wziihiza {ma mamh from €315
“_:;’§,Ea’Es’: £3? I’€Ce:é§%: of ihfi airiar {aging which it ‘s=i:=*as ezfifimd ‘Lida:
f€SpC=§3.d€§1E shag §aj; 2. sum 9%” Rs.S{},1G{}/~ with imiezrsgi at
8% gxér afimzm frvzmi ‘€336 éatc £3? Cfimpiaéfli ‘£9 {fie dais 93%’
\gJ>
mafisafion and 3180 awarded R$.2,{}O0/- tswarcis znental
agony and Rs. 1,006 ,1» tmvmxzis casts. Btitifig aggziev1$<i _§;:3:?*.Vfk:€<
sajé Qréer Appeal No.1924/:2€)()S wag rm: §36fQ§f:é."§Efi§§V:-.S, %{g3:%g'~. _
Commission and State Cemmissiafi d.%s§:{)3r:€£'»£:f'~?é"z€~ a;3_§:s3a1
With libsrty $0 flfiii agmefiani hfisgixz I
befazc the Qisfiici. §m°um fer-'_ mvééisaé Sigisfiét Féyraim
rejeciezi ihf: ravylew petitien 'imfiugfiaed order
W33 pasafiéi by the Aypeal 10 1' 2&0?!
aiateci %::;'2:2a§9 "€E1é–.St—its Ccmfiziasion hag held that the
{}:ie;?:I"i§i-_{<'<§.%_u13; :5 review the caréier and Cafiiéf
A§3§&a£ bia*e;é, difimissed as Withdmwm by $36
V. ¢_ <:§§2§2:s€;__LAap§ssaz'§f2;g iipgj iha appéfiaai and haaziizg regargi :9 figs
' §V:§fi§§?:£3I':éA$§:.:3-V'€}}ii'.'V:§?'iij{,::{:§§-fl', thrsrc: was EH3 maxi: $3; $13 apgmaé ané
a;:¢<:r:§i§:g«:§;§~,. éésfiaisgaéfi €136 a§pea}., The Eiséiztici Fcrum has
a%isfia..i.5$§:d €216 review petitiea Whfireézz it was csmsfiéfié Qléii
"i£,11€.._cevsV.i'::$6é appfitaring for 'aha appsfiazré had 33': made a
Alfiiiififiififiififi that ihé: apgafiant hfimin was ready as mpiaea
"'"%he iathe macksmfi ané figarsfare, {ha pr9<:*e€§ing$ 23%" aha
iéistzécf; §<'<::rz:a::2. and £336 mfisr éaisii 31'?.29{}8 wizsrsén it is
xsf
fiifiififi {hat 3?. 11:15: time 6% argnmazfis ii was __1i.:'£'}<-.t–.}jé' _
{ha respomieni is {sad}-' to rapéace figs" ":fiac:Ahifi?€
rfimams 3:: recorfi, 1:10 ground is '=_mac%:'-3 §:}éu{:_f51'f ic§..i$"i1€i%;:vwé3::§
$3536 $3316. S1f:3mi$Si0Ii made the er€§.F_:r"a11c} ézvézz ;c3t;*1&§'§&'riS€,. '*
the €CGfi1E}33i11H1'ii has fz*resv5'§' }§é'- a:~z::§;t§'£i&d; is
raplacfirnezm; sf aha {Q Iéécffi Of the
casts: mid ihsrefofé, th¢W§v1"d .§r Wfii gmiiziczn
£Z3;€}{i*S 11:3? $Tz1fi?<::: f:f;:%":m1 as {$3 ztaii fag:
i:1%:6rfe§::;;§:A1%<Tfi€:§T' jzzriscééfitiezg mi' this €,fG¥.§i"§.
?%.C<:{:1'::%vV§ii;§j!31f§=; {Exam is :19 maxi? :73 35333 WYQ3;
§€t§§i§)_:; =§;§s3 figs A?;'7§;:t}3;3::"s%;?%;i:sg {§}"{§€f}..":
A %:fi'i"§é%é:§Qz1 £3 {§i8EBiS86§.g &
Sd/v-r
Chief Iustirm
sari.
juége
Ealdsx: $63; Ni’; In
Me!) H05? 5 /No,