High Court Karnataka High Court

M/S The Oriental Insurance … vs Sri S B Shanker on 19 August, 2011

Karnataka High Court
M/S The Oriental Insurance … vs Sri S B Shanker on 19 August, 2011
Author: A.N.Venugopala Gowda


emgiayment, fiurésdéctisnai gsfiie gegégiemé a gage.

Engaged Rameg@va;§a féiefi MVC 86@;’ZG€}9 ag3.§§’¥§3:§’««. t§*§f.?3

reaaanéents and me agpetéarzt in the MAC? at ~

gait: petéiéan was aéioweé am {he a§.§ei§ant*;Q3″g=§§§:”é’Cfé§i my ‘

degsgéi the cgmgengatéen amszzint ~’R$IT4.5′;’€’$§$f’»: xz~,{§§:f’si’

interest,

2. Efze :5? :*eg;§je:”:ée:jfsVt…L:?E:;!a’::dj”a_.L’§e;i§t§$«h._AAu;j§ier 8.16
9% Wo:=E<men's {far ghari 'the
AC5), agairzgt gézgf asgeiiarztg,
daéming "V§VpiéE9V:'";:ear 3:26 wag mated exparie by

éhe..fi:<:m}missi@.fi'e.ér«#50:" WorE<m@::'s Cempengatém {'CWC' 50:"

»3§2§:3s*_:v§»..VA%~:«s:;2s2:é%s'.zf:_s°, §Z§"2& appeéiant %zavmg eniereé agpeararace

%E".:§9%;;:ig%;:"%':%;.'~»j.5.e;:;%%éeé aémsaie, flied giatement sf ebgecijéans

-V datétfi ..2E%..flfi2:2C%Q8 arm sgjmseé fiche céaém peiiiiéern

AA 3§$&:”Z§ 3:: the ;Q§€a§§E”‘sgS, Esgueg wag saégeék

‘:5: rfiggaméntfcéaémani fi&§G3€§ am géxggfiwi Ea P~?

E

/”‘/A’

as X!’
M’
X

wera mar§<§§= Dscgymévasa ?'='?i§§"{§'3'g', am :’t§’z€;§__a&§é<$,Pw8 gs. E"-931:"-*=,«<i~¢{is;c»§e

markeds 3&9 apgaéfani, which wag the re–::§3$éf§{§–.sféL::2i:T

izhé céaim yetiiézén, déé :16: afiduce 3fig_ev%é_2§fiCE;f'_';§%i§xa:€a;§s%.1V_

the mgurance geiécy was ma:'§<ed;":.'a51'_'%E:<'T;Réi

"E§":é E:-§-=3 E"7z*«:?

Q€i§’EEO§’§ wag aiéewefi by t§”2éT{;’-s”:,{C &?%{§:’7{§”?.3 °eiffc§’r9:ie._;;;s*3.:¥%,.$;§ti@r: 2 L’

payafiie wag asgessefi at _Ré:;»3,,_,.é:€;_»;812;je,_ ‘ga:§ff;3?a%z wag

fiéresteé is Se zjepaSété’:jV:%'”ib_g?th§:§.»’g§§g3–é;’Eé§%%;i_w%th%r: 35 day?)
and in case cf ‘r;§;~’efau£tg”:’o ;3’a3i”‘$12050 from the
éate ef def1a.2.;Ei!c.,’ i:E’:$ }§a’i’a” a ‘%’dEer and award, the

Enau ra n§:e__::0f’r:3M §;3 :3s.;3_zf_ hE:§’E$_ 1’CE!_éLZ§ ‘t%2;_i_s af: peat

4″; ” Sr’: ?B;§V’;’;Efr:e§§-2.__.’ ‘éagarned advecate appearing fer

the figsgefiifiéeégg ::<§§:tea"€{§.;eia'f«..%:E*2at, the 3." resgenéentfworkmagé

%:a:;fs'E';:g :$i{,sff;ereé""r:c:3.w_f;:tai inguréeg far hig Qvm negiigamca,

é:3n3a2<}Tf5'v.g;§;2s§§f:4s.}:;:sm§er:satém. Reéiance wag giaceé an the

§5:»»ac :Ig§§:§ §:z"1":;s'::é;,%:$ :m::m"§$ VS, mug KGRREA & mxsemggs

I3 §£;§'<.. ééflaa 268$?' Laarnaé CGi§E'§$€*§ aiiarréaiéafeiy

A {_'~€:%:§*::<.?-é :5 'me waund ce_:%:sfi:;,_ate._~"V"?'i:*$?gZ "Ewa_x:§Vn§§_
examined 'me céaémant hag 3Ea'§e&'tha_5t,A~'thé'~_:E'er_{%:':aure:§fL'*–%:é13.i

$a:$taine§ fraature ef radius é$}__L;"§-siiga of?-§gh*:. aim rafié-..€:EE*:1Ea & = L'

fibuéa Q? éeft Eeg, m%_,2 :sea:._e7f:2»._?2:2:».: fe?2*w{'§3_ Q§f :;f; Ehan 5

mcasiaris and was sa:"bjé£:f:e'dL E}3;a%Er':i'::

–.£f><aminat%m'z an

24.,G3«2CIQ8w :PW_;2 __Ess:;e§”‘Eyh:§é§ ::i§i’:5′:””:’é’.’¥’§«:ate — 3&9″?
arzé has as2gs:s;==.;’3:.<;4§*;.: ::§:'_?T1@~ at 285?'?/9,
fhusf §:j1'_Lg_r§,;%'"«:;s_:§':–;VE::§:A;§é.d'$.§§ Ef;a;fi§.:ifEegpondesst/wo:"§<r2*2an by
acaideégfg 'ihe marge 9%? mg emgiayment

and the *er'2jf:p2Qyé:"_ »–m}"e;»i§4a$ insurer am iéabie ta pay

<%:err*;§fefi:a;Aaisor%{" ~

A 2 'E9: '7§:fis:?s__§rQx/§$€} uaée? §.3{1}{b) 3?" '$39 éifii: %:a$ {E5

3;%5§E'§.;CB§vEV<}:'E""'?_C:V'$158 gage an h&rsé; girgca the amgeigyee wag

-V me: éi:2§é;é§f iéié E§E§§£é€?E£§ €35 éréak gr érzgggn TEEEYQ fig as wEE=fu§

* §§’:”$:3i5″}ff:’~;’3§§Vé§”:C€ $3; Em €E’fl§§{i3’3’€€ is an aréfig’ E><§§'$$§§'*}i givers,

– 5; Eda we §:><§ra§5%:z framedf {$5 {$25 ;%Ug;;{}€§§t3 £2'? $€{E.§E'f§"":§

, W?

‘:3

9. ;, J_/

“”2

.0′ .

.1; W, ./«

. :r:A*:»??§<u§4s"1gV';§a;zs"r2@n%: :3 {E26 céaémmix E

2%' {he QWC $3; makiézg refareaae ia the gxziéeasae

sf ?\fs.?S 1 & 2 3:36 the media? recsrégg flag fifiéé ':h.;§'£.i!..::':«§'f§é<25ve

£3; digamtiigr :9 an extent 9? 28%. "$76 wages W-as ~

at R:~s,4,Q8Q,-,. having not been éiggggstgéfi by"t'§*:§~:?_;f;«.r%€';3E§yes:_V

Fer a éréver, the wageS rec%’W-2,
the comperjszfiigr;:$$Ses§§s§%i’ .;.f:Va’r”r€–*.:_”V<:ij:i;<i:':<¢srV:é'd VVV'% be deposited by
the a§Vp_eE.!Va;fi’%;..f”:’s;\V«:.;;?_Qf; is net against the
evidenicjie an hag carrectiy apgracéatafi
Ehfi evéé§*’:{“,::e3V:'”:55E’ <:"s':S: 5s .:.=";~:é%:*2":er'zt sf ccmperzgaiém fig mt

a?b§,t;if3f'yA..

A :zi§:eVA:”‘é<z-§_$uE:_, the agpeaé wing fievaéd {:25 meréi is

€§~%Z§z–<:Vé+:*;se:f17;-._ " "V 3

"§"%'=..'{e3.&:"%":$:::'2t Er: degagéi 5% trangfarrgé {Q {fie CWC fisr

<2

?a§*§ées is baa? time" ;*&§§e§§:ive cogtge

%<sj,f~