CRF. Men. 31 .. 3003
IN THE: HI[£I3&I'I IiZ':IC'JUR'I' OF KARNETAKA AT BAHGMJBRE
}1_"m'I'}EE-II}! TTHI3 THE mm mm' «:31? "
BEFCIIRE
*m.II:f- mi.r"mIn1r_n.-. mm .. rr rczfifiirr-1:-"'h;r ._1r7.na'.-'mI .; v . V " '
J. -L J-Jim! J. J.'In-1'-In' -Um?-I-HL-4 -1|."-Iul-\n'l.-I' We-4" V-Ia?-B.'h-9'-I-.:'_ "J-'I I:§1:|r_': J'l'.fi J-is-_l_ 'V v.
3
_%: -.-'u .'-'%T.J'Ffi.T.'.§.1'r§'. Hfiflfi VI!'.3!'?'aY..
'i. ,. . . . . . ..'
Rummrmx '_
'w.«'c".';» IMTE $1-mNH£.RAP1wa L
fih.~I:?rE.]Z:s gas;-q;ru*r 55'..':t'EAEE " '
1%; c.:«1:r- 5y...1§c.*«a. 1V'¢,%
1f.té'h"§$.€%R' fvmayfim ';i"EI€T
HfiLflfii.3fEE:Ij-" M g %
'EBH»lN'C}.:9aLf:%{}ELT 5::~.'mc=a:3'T4'
j %
,r2am?.1ra -ma.e;auT%:a YEARS
_Ffif~£}F~"~V&3Yi.l€CJSn'=13'~;}'§.N1'JI: 14,
J' TEE'?
-r .-n nun
M Emflfifi
, F*Ffi?fi}e1fi§fi.é5;EHA
E4; .51. *:r----,.,a.*'1*1re'. nuamwnmanun
'V ,1-I .u.{ .B«I.ul.uo II:-I'-l.l.1l1.II-I-I-16-A-E-I-'h-Ildl. -LI-I.
" ;a1:3E.tn .AB=DU"P :2? "?a'E-ARES
R.g'iZ'}}?'*" 13 fllifi 14,
% ' * a..;1TiE?M3}IJ'PflLL*:'P.1tiEEAR vxmumrm 'IE}!»I'I"
~ H.F'~..LfiaE>URU
'|'.S$,-'[3' 1'\:2l'n""!. A T J""I;("'l'E'T T H4I3'.J"H"'iI"'\i2l
1.
..»: .l…:’ 1.11 u….I.rI..I..n…a ‘u..:.u.’v. I…- -u 5…–I..n..:-1.n.r
13AL!kKRI’5HNfi
awry MPH: SHJWKARAFPA
.15 A”‘:’.:,’£§ T”‘n .i!.E:1,r”1T1′ a*_§lF.’. AICFQ
.r.u.a1.: J…-‘ n.1L;«’ L…-ru mu 1 un:.~u».:n
I*7&f,.|’*[f.3′]}”‘ S’S!”..I’IC)E3i.. 13 fiflfl 14,
,;;l«I’£3=I3I.IFALY’A .’flEAF:’ VINPu’YAI{& TENT’
U1
€11
CRP . I-SI-:3. 31. ‘.2093
I€lL2″1.LJ!’L&”:’+?£.’IRI_I
EiEl-1’I|£I}!*LLfl*l7~?E *1 3
»l”fl*I”lI’-ll
211.1:-s.r=a..:'”H’i’I~iI..#’1LfiL
}Il’4,s”EI:l I[J3L’i”fii SHANIMRAPPA
fifi-Eel? AB-DUT 34 ‘EEARE
E?.,i.*’=£;i1-E7’§?3′:”..Ii.’tf.13!:’.=£.. 1-1.1, .»*%.1′!Il: 14,3 ‘ -I * V
ml-:’;:vGUP’AL”fA WEAR ‘UIflAYfiE{AT}l”‘ENTTT’~.
1*~7i’FLLfi.:”€FI.ifi’i_I _
E=E- 351 I:ThF’LL=£f.14iI3]:?.’1I_I ‘ ~.. _
?_”‘I-Til TLT T”Tl:u”.§I T Ii”fl’I-1,5
I-_.~ Jar lnLtl..ut2.’l».Il..I.,¢ :.
[:15 r::;« .L.#’«’L’I’.Es s1e1raI«I4Im.RnPPA% .
..s%.1i3-E:-in mm? ;=’!:f)”‘.1t'”E£’aTl’~’;Sf’:= ~
p1m1′-r= SWHNQSII 13.4a;I~ms14?
m’:3¢G’U’PAIJfA m:%AE vmaymm TE::Iii’I’
TE=£«3;N!?I.§?:i!”.I’>4{;l4:Z3~’.Ffi,_I EiE;§;§ti:ri;?E$
j1::1,m 3:,,fi;1*E –~$E{M’IK&&RfiPPA
.Ir1′.r”-.’|’.’! 1””« ;”l- ‘.115. wan: “-£_u””l:2:””.€’|1’l:_lg.’!-
‘I’.’S.’L..j!fJI!»’J.._.:-‘ mm. M 4.’,.s:a=.;{ AL-,!;.furji.3;’u:s
1::,v«=;::H.:r’ E»?a”*x”..I*ID’.:L’a..’ 1.3’~m¢’r:: 14, A
¢.;w::’L’;t;:’.:=h.u;I:2’2a._ iaaazwz vmmmlm TENT
J g I1Z£s.L.&:iE1E§f1%”£I;I
]FE?.;!.€§j.I~3’=::.-“;fi.I[..vI;.
A }¥T’1i’V5Er{KlDfl
PETTTIONERS
£12: :K14.Mz:E.NmHANaTH
.;.t’:=.1»;-‘=,»~a:,=m* 53 “‘.«.”.F§.1ARE=..
:;’:}-,.+’ -1″) RE EfHAW1M[JR’THY
Iii’ LEVELLE
E$**l~_;,!’Iil»5_,. LA;wm.L:E RCFAD
L~::3:.a.L.:::w3m;n ssaaza um
I’-:’fi71fl’=fl’}{‘?t’A”nEuI[fl!uIIPL.
.. …. …I:[«= .. _-.-_ ..
Fc3E”r.7:f»1′.”it AHA” ‘ 5211:;-Ai”~v’:fi
CRP. H-3. 31. 2003
‘W’,:”LTII ‘.[..4.a’x’H’.’E’I£ S3I”iIKEAMUNISWAMAPPA
gu.*n’r4*- aw varam v: at Man 1 4 .l’r”1I”lTT’DM’.VA
‘H. ‘m*’.L |’..F.I.I:J.I”I..|’l’\-.i’I=3.”u’ ail.-LII-.9″ -uIo- I’ ‘5-!””!4-|”\ulI’1-‘ulullul-Jlnfill
£’IE-ME’ VII’ifT.r’iYA.ICA ‘TE NT’, H.M.ASURU’
EFL Hfi73’fiL’E3i3RT..T flflfii
-‘3’HflI’IFLfiK’3T ..
:a.,rmI1″‘r. M:mr1’r’r’v -‘um ‘um: n’I:3’|S..’! : 4′ . ”
-|l”l’I-I|.Ln’.I.-.0′ -Ir}.-§..F’4mI”‘L.P -F. I” ha’ 3. J.JI’1.l.’\.k.3 ,
:+:~;,»’a:> JL.-fi{I’E; mHmKmMuH1swAM:mPAT?j%& 7: AV
Fifi {:::«1»’4*’ .14′, Jc:n:fi.:?AL?5 % ‘
E’J’E-All-iii’ wxmm-:9. TEN’§’_.__ H.B.LASI.I1-W
HE-NI3-flLiZ}DRLT saw 0%’ k
‘_ ‘,
.smE1::..am.:xLIT :51 ‘r}3a1e@.[ L ‘.
5.; »<.::-
}€j’£13*3§v” cgmrqmawaga Arm 144;~.J€JGU1?AL’fA
i-1- ‘li” Ji’n’*~;r.:’1″1:’r1′
1L’1’1″aI 1!: W1: ?l”l.’l’ K; ._m’.HI.’1r.r it firm A
M -1111.51 I .l Bil? 1 g ,. ‘ .a.”‘£i’.3|-J EU
ga-a.::=E:. I31 AEie*.:fiI§*1’77 *14§3_”§TEAR;t?~
,:’ -‘;,._s «M. ‘_n’ l_{H”H’l”!l .«–g”1z”n’*r’Ir_.-*v}-“um. ‘I. it rm’rr.n1’mI .1 1 Ir; van
¢;«,.~. ism Am 13:2» 4.;
17″m.:gn;w1.k,:n;~1%wn1v1nrrfi
my »::v«£»&” E=:’.”:”..I*ECJ5.:1*»…E3 ‘m~i’I3 14, J-:::m.IPAL’m
M 1_1ra’E£-$i%:Eit:-.’R#’l”i%{,£4;’fl3c;E:aZ;flL’*i”‘EHTfl I-I.!%LfiE’aURU’
_i 19333-1’E’IiZ§’:FL1;.%LT1_*f.13I~fifI.,I sfifivifjh af.’:%
1;_;%:::?.!«w;7:”;:;sa”
” T%H»a¢:rtE. ;suac»a:::IJ’r 3? mam’;
E3.»;|’ij-‘{i}”§¢*é<E cmmmmuxswamappa
IEQ3. 3.3 9.1′! G 1-4, :J”JGUP.!*.L”:’A
I*i”E-fi;1§{E’Vfli.flYMfl£ TE-NT’, HALASURIJ
am «arm
J’-‘m«IflARA*f’ANfl
..¥%’1′..’.?%*.’.EI-.’.T.’-‘ 4%.”&~”JUT 33 ‘¥;.’§’;-.4°*u”r?;E
4″‘ LT} §L»fi’I’E’$ CHIHKflM[}NISWfiIVIAPPPL
HE-‘f§}1’I5*”‘ S7!F..T’Tl’}3$,. 153 T3 14, -}C’3C?r”.TPFL” YT’:
1’33’ E-A1451 “u’II’if.F&”‘!”i’-‘r£E*i’Z.£5¢ TE-NT’? I-IM..ASU RU
}§JH’I*Ifl-ALCJEORLT 56$} fltfifl
wmwmava xaaaavama
}’&.+éE&E-El EEEEUT 30 “3.’EfiES}
CRP . Nu . 31 . 22008
:11-W ii} .i£.-WTEL #3+E§IE{K{fi.MLFNISWMJAPPfl
1%?’ £1113″ E§?..l”§ 1-‘3 .’!’*.Ll”.l”I3 1′}, ;!’£’¥GI,IPPJ..s?;”;
I£IE’fi;.’E7rIJ “*u”IN..t’~’iYAK4fi TENT, HA1.-HSURU
HE?’Eii:.:§’J.’IE’%.”[‘..:”‘:.’.-..[“:.’:jiw'(.i’I.L.:i. 5If:”:fl 1″J{}E$
%
..’%TEe!:I}’!’;§*£’ -4*? “rf’E..i1.RE ~ *’ M V
‘lj31,FC.i| ;:;…m’:s2: aamkimwuwxswanmzj .fi°= _
1*E:7.w;;;”:=19’=” P:fiI:,n:1%4, .}tzGtIPAL’m A X j
]f*I11m.LFa’vII’I;AYA;E£& TEN’§’.,,v’I~!&IASIJRUVV
Jfifi-I’M?-.’rAla’E11UEL.I San M
}::t:::{:asH–HNA.1naIMA . f ~
i::«;’ «:13: I…A,’:fE: (i:HmHA’§’yiUHI:§WfiM.&_P*Pfi
»r;:n:.:«’* 3YI7FHdj3?|13…%Hfl 14, ..Jc.*}EUP$-LEA
HIE’-.a€aIE3€i w,a3’I~.i’,.m.r;.a..:a’«;;:i.. ‘TE. rs::1*,.4HALa$1J:Feu
~ “é ‘rm 3*}-3′!’ .r*~.”r”‘.L:5.’;11r’r 1&1-.7. “Vxrtna ‘ . *
E«E:.Pu h..3i.[“‘i..L.r’1-..r:”:Jl.”o’.,’»..J _.-_wi”.«.”.v’I,..i’ ,4..r{;t::4 4_ v.
iE§]£*2-E1-I*«”;z$L¥3§?’f§f*;. A «–
..:=e,%»:::-as-»1″:~::1’_*’,; ;r:;m.~::::»1:i§;*:* 51.
4:3 il3£T;$I{I1}iZ1e’£hPsrILIIfIIE3′;’E’.Ee°&l%/LFLFPA
Jf.’.}GLI?AL’ir’FL
raEc.;aa.a:a: <"=::I»a%;:rafimm:;n3a"I*}3:N*;1'*, .H:1LA3LIRU
_ ESE Nil}: .-:_'1'9..I.'.'<Z"vA%JI,"E!".'[..T'*-.v_?':eE':"r#*."}* DUE
" "j":~..s%5:~»iI«-L;s'ra..:1…s:1°»a:IA.xéi ' %%%%% ~ '
A 'V' 3:;;mi';% 1::e:;r13mmMt;rim1:s:wAMaPPA
.rT*».=.%..r :-w';.rsrr3;~=;.. 1.3 MID 14-, ..;fiflGT_IPALYA
M E? , .-.-',I'T.1.'I'3'.-.*'4:,'1"L*5.tJ.¢."*-I..w*3… TE-1"'ITq HfiJ..-.%E'LIRU
?i:".4.:"}T~:*';E~i'i;;";'%'-.@':.L~=Z:tw:I."1¥L¥7.,:I sum mes:
% REJE-EWKETI
_ .:"-'lw."sI".3"J'.".'<]Z'.i JEEEIPEEMSPUT 41 YE-ARE
M 1:11;' 45:3 .I…….~"i.'1i."1_F',! DC3'fflQfiLBe§![§!'E§£5'£'fi.M.f£15'?fl
.« +1
as
1=::r_,a'«:::«I'~"' t'~;'a"3:'7..I*Ir:IJ:'i=.. 2:3 M11?) 14, Ju:::::;rJPAI.:m
T'3iA}:WIaJ!'3'7's.i"t;? 'wra:m'mm "'1'*E"1'*I"E'*, 't-1fl1'"u;n' at; RU"
EEEI-N'IC}flLCt'flR'LI 55:1} Uffifii
1. ,, I ITTI3
F’hPw’:.}HE’w’E 11 1 «:1
|’.’.’RP.N-:1. 31.. 3003
“I”HEE3 lI.”.”.’F~213-“‘ 15:3 FIELEEJ U;”E’s.l15 CIF EFL’. AGPQEIST
THE 3.4-.§”‘ P§..«%$P; GE I.f’1..3;’-‘s:’iI.«’*.–.i’f:.r”‘:'”-_1*~i’
r.:;1..s.res’«:;T::.4:”:»:’::r;;;:«:2;,i 9.25 {W “.I’!£~:ELE’- FRLE my ma. 3c}c:~::;~:x_;
L”;”.I’T”.r” :::.m;a;.., fl:..I*TI_'”’34 SE JI.n::n3E., E-fiLN{}J5LI,.fl=1~’¢!_ET<– [C(:i£440},%T
]3IK§?':l3\é"z-V.Ii.*'&':'»1€~IE€I*iCI'a'~ I..s'%.,1'II1'J'J…it;'s FILED BY ._
Pmfifiizm W'-'.".;= 1?' R :1 c::sF ~L'.';P€3 F R»VEEJECTIC}fl."DFv
133*!' A T'l':'.l""Sl"' I
-I. »|hliI’3.IJ-I Jl It
aiffiivfifi. 3r’:i’~rE’=*\?’ia”iii.r.7II’i . Fetiti::m’=. .mm.i£;ug ” M1′: far
AEMIt?s:§{iZI#W am thin?» clay, 1:116. mafia _tfl1a_fr:p.11:3wi1*ig:-
Q g n ,
‘fixes: }I|r’.E#3Zi.Ti!§Z3ff1fl1’El- o.I’der datefl
1.4.”!-_].=::£!:g’IL..jE::’:lT szafi
n
.u-urv-.11!’
1;..sa;i«:¢%; am?
at: fim mm ._{::»f’f_ n:::it;;,r Civil 3:. Sasaicnrm
.Judgne:.._, E3a1ig}§f§@r§V3f£3G}§?=#3fl).have prueaaentecl the ixustant
rmrisfw:-11 tititm… V ” ‘
:1:
£1:
E
E?
{-1
§;x.~.=;_1«_’-:%r”.§::¥’,;t'”a:’:fi:aa.1m:r: a.z:m:’i p’=E~I’1I1EuIlE:fl.t in_ju1:u:tic:n. The
mfi’tta1*.-‘:”=fi%:a:.+s.:””}pten’n=tl§rnh~g miiu-ntiicratio,t1. The pat.iticsne=ra haw
:L%i;§5:se3u.3! thwae a1ra_juaI::t”i’:t111 at the prelimizlary stage
r’¢:_§c:a:21tm?nt1n r.:nf pflaim. pr” by 1:._.::: firat
:i~af¢n1:i¥f:£a1t:s.a:t.’T’iP2?a..fiEE€} ham film I.A..N::a.J1f3n under Order 7
ELIE Ta? 3gxr1a.;5.r:”=.n§g itsn mjeecit the-s pakaint an thsa ground that
___________.
/4’0
I
CERF . Ht: . 31 . 2093
1311:: :ia1.1:i§:ri. ism Evaxwuml hay law and um nnaintainable. “Afhar
Jayme.» ll”ll.’&u m:mt=::r”a.’fi. yumra the said applicnatiun
§.mtitim~11s:’::m Shae]. C.'(:!=I]1’1E: up fa-zr cn::1aidarati_9fi’-.bef§r»: tlie ‘
A’:i’.’¥1b21″‘t 1.311 M-=iZE=i2€.lf.”3′?; 5:-¢.”I.i.’..«–V&y}_”~.;}.i.*-:.~s_=;_*’..~§a*1.rJ-“*.*:,_ ‘l1,-aa’
‘szufiaii :f”f:f_§fia:1=’t£§£i .’r1-::ifi*mg ti:1.r.°$1’a:?:_ Ea rmg.!g1-rjtinaii’; far _
i’.’.’«1.’.’FZ|lI3153I’t!i”.fl.I:’.’=.’!”.”§\i.”E§§ tlm amid. at stage.
Furtimr i1: mvm 3. _ first
raspcxmflaaaxnt iea. rt1i:a:~~a.1¢3.in;g§” tijL1&”‘~p1:¥ai;n§£s at’ law. arfl
fitnrr «$2411.:-fiav.;:+£L’;:n.€’:a.=::._ jV1§z:e1iV£=–iE* ..駒1)ie::i?§.ti perfim:m’anue and
a=tmca.-:m§:{i11g:l:@’ 1 j:r§;f'[+:a;’:.i’L$if1«.f»cs.:v.%V’tiaTa11f:%£«aa}. 0f the: wait. The said
unit maa:1é£nae_ Fax’ ¢::r£:.a:iai:?q;1im=:1?&s’tfi§iIifi¢ hefitnm the trial c.~.::urt.. ‘I”I1na
1m;% “i’..Z’¢m.1fit mmegx» bmlz; I5!-il_71_.»- M2. gag:
V’.-::>’~-m~§,==,”?fi.a-*éaz’.’riz:’ss;’.g; n”i”1h”i’Lu’%i*i”‘1 frfl i;-Emrci has: rejected
aasiglmhug walid reaann.a at para. ID of
. 1:11:53-‘.”:::e.2:*«r;9.–i:%;A1t.’..’v ‘fisaaauailitng tlm currecetnema cnf the impugxled
¥{!’T.}.””‘sI;’L*.’.”‘»_.f”,. irmtamt remrifiizan is filed.
} 3;’.”LI:Tt.Tui’fi Erafiaruri the ieameti cauzmei for the
}.’.IEfititieI?aI1¢?:1″€€fl . /I
%:L_
CRF. PR3! . 31 . 2008
#1. .m’:’t*xr.-sf -“at-afizl }3M31″1.1=EIfil r.=-f than ia:np1.1gnad t:+1′<1erj,rI do:
nut f.'r-Lmfl .:;m3«"' mrzror much laava iiflegalitgr mar
gatmd gzr-::mL:".1::i 'rt:r:z« m1.t;m'tEai11 tlaia po:~.titiz:a«11 "
– ‘ a-l< ,
st.-qm::*.'.. TV" W mm, 53.1 ilflfiliifi 1, 3"
J» !'m I174!"
:4:
pm?-e;*aa5en.’I:n::«:3I. in B’!lfH;3?« and pa2:7t,éitig:an:?:J1’£: ._h.9.m 1*3.a”::{~V:r:ft:1o£az=.%if1′.tn3 ,
Ma tlnua i1’§;.;g::t].i.i3£§LT;i£¥1T1 sad: 1:}’1n.=:
ccf thafir 1r.uL1=:.2’_im.J. fifimr a:–{f’ yearn may have
n’::,’§.’mr.ssnm:’.1. 13:21 £213 “#135 Euclm :1;
app}.:%.r;:w:4a”:.i:::::”:. H .4 _: sgiéi ‘:q;:”;:=::%.””;isrir:::r Eftieréa
.< l_,.
._ .(
. –l5
gI”:::1.1rn::au}’a EkEI~ n=2.:m3§”.fa. 111;: aw rigI:11′.’t_’y’ obaervacl
mt paw; W —:33′-:?fiLc:::f’!r;§%’v.tl1«:e t1″ia.’i mnurt.
;;u2ar;a _ p’i.aiI11′:. in-. mu:-that” auit, thm plaintiff {R1
L’§;féii;a=cl. flmh the d.e:1’e=:nda11ta wax-at t.t’yi:r1g tn
–V a%:u£i*1e£tf11j;” in «:3-rdfir t-cu: -ziaafe.-at ‘the iflmrast of
.. t’i:Ie–~xn’§!a€r.i;1’1tIdfT.£aaz1;1 til} 111r.m.t flay; “mam has been no refusal
..,
»’ H M .. . -. . . -…-…
43:1 17..’;1a:*; A-an-f tfrm «c*;a§’#.n:1a11.ta ta 1’6:-r1€m.r th 11″
‘c:mm_c::1:i’t:cns.a1″::.1″1ea. Tm. txemma vi” the agraenmnt entered intu
batwamn irlm partiasaa, In View M’ tlw. flflid tr-.::am:nm’r1g
aismigmaemig Fa’. :10 r1::a1; £1″tt1.c1 warty jxxastifinatian ‘tr: interfere in
/*.:’Z..–#
I
CERF . Mm .. 31 . 200$
_. 3 ._
tlm 1.”z::n°1}m§;_2:11r::c’3i c:1’d:5sr,. in E=3!~:fiI”E’:ifi§-r-it mi” patmrer 4::-::s:?’~.jtErraL’::»::1
L1.E3.C§.€s.1!.’ 115 mrf ‘fl~i”‘:3’fl. F’rur.”.:e-d’ure
dmkixxst: am ,yx3a.t;¢:2s:’:tau.irJ.1t£r1e iI’1-*’r’,it1i11il:§:. rcuiairm. pv,=:.*:£t:i_:5~:1=’ .
far.-i.’.!uiIfitL1′;”L”‘l’.$.iI’1fil}ai”.. rsefiziazfaza-:1 g.m1;it.iu31i”fi1E::i 1:r»;g.F, L.
aflmn:l’.:saama:E. Tim.-rs: Tr’ia.i f;Lr:ou:’t crf thus
emit flfifiixtfifi :5.:+Ji’:t”»l”..~m§!ir1g; fi:s…11ax_:££”}ia_a1*1:ies top
:i:a:’1aafirE=1i :gj3vu’~;;:VI’§i»;.’:i1iI,;’;;.:_é,’V’:;i5.:.:1:a:;a;<:'t:': 1!.~a&.::;:,.. }. V
–II: ‘mgr-«:3: