High Court Karnataka High Court

Smt Jayamma vs The Manager on 6 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Smt Jayamma vs The Manager on 6 December, 2010
Author: Aravind Kumar


3%’ Egg §+§§s;§§«§ aagg? CF %§fifi§%§;E”§’:E% g: §f:§§§§%E;g’§é%§._

g§::*;*::% *§§.§3% *’§*:«-:3 gay :33:

§§:;§’§§*§:s ._

€333 E§§E’%T’%E,E §§§.$?§$fE$E §g,:%$$2§”§- ‘
§a%s§’,;%.5.§€§5E’;§s-$3 ” A’ %

A.

35 $§,§<a;§{:2§:a,§
$3,551: Ema ?$§;%a.:§§.2$;§
fisgségi ggggégé 35$ §§°§fi'£'f$e

§§i%: h 3%";


Egg: ifiéia"-3 §§:§a§§&§ -- VA _  g
533% sfizfimz 35$   _  '

W'

33 gm;    'V
fig'; §§;'§% §§--%::j§  é  w ~ .  __

égai .a13§1z’£.§’3;:ée:.§z’i%.._.

$5 ??€%§2:.§§ M V K!
$5 £2 §§”:§’:f,”~’=.V?§=’.1′:f§&§ZI€§3&§;;;
§§3@°§;z%._ 3;

” §a§i§§’L2::§§;:–;_§ “”” H

” ~ .. fig; a! «iéazg “}t:=§$m :-.

. _§”sE gmwa,

fig?

— ‘ $;*%3% ii*7{‘j:a;§.: 3§@*%§%: §§’$_,’7§§afi§
figgéagzéfa iéfifiéség
‘§§.§:,:s§:?

AA , §%-‘§;:’.Eg$.§.’$§:’$ Eagrai Efrigfiéatg

* . _ _;%§§g£§&<::g§ gzgééétém §§s::J£§ is'; 5%
fim fiifafiffi :'$§fs.:2§;

Eiéihfis 23% &§§§§§§”§1 ag
::?§:;§§’§.§,%e

Em? Efifgfigigsaizgg $39? 9%

A’

fvék

AEEEE;

E?

flag §é”a%%z Efiééfi figgaragsg 3}
Vakkésgfia
Eiaaégfizs %;:§:::::ie§
§g::zf:g&§i.$:*a’a«§’T:I

Eiga Saéagam <':im:;r§;$§:% ..

Efiam E313; 5, §’§$§?&§iZ§’§ $::*$_msg,,
Efgflézazfi §§z:7s%§§.,i§
Ezafiyggaifirg, .. V ‘ V!

§§:5;sg%fag;§__i’§-:V_
?%¥§€:§.§:§ is $3 fiéggmfiafi. ?£’§€.§§:§ V ‘ ‘

fkéa _ ‘fig é’3V”i§ zzsé’ Eafiamt “%é’&§§a§

gm; gggg ggaéézzgg-.§f”§.”iE.é§ s:a2$?’§2″§; fiaiaé :2? , E2i§§§””f

§&§§$’-ii £3; 3§§§§?3§’:?§:f€}€%r§§ 333;? 2315 §& gf fig ‘Jfi

ééfifiagéé a.§%.:2;%.g5?%_§ 7§:{“‘E§ma;§”‘ii;:;§;1:§%§ ?%éi’3’£’}

$%§’§§3§§£m*§;:’@?”§§§1§s5i§.,€’.%§*’$_ {%*i:5E§:

‘E””%:g a %$ am wéééseg afzzfi maikmy :35

iifisfiafifimfifé ?z3z$§$;§§§:$, $2’: fififi §§;%:§f:2;§ £3? 52:” €3§€}§x§%§!j:§

4/T

3% g:?z;*x:>:§: £%»:f§€.} gfaifi-,§ éfifififi ‘$23 fifififififififi §%:’a$ §z*€.>§§4§,r3;E£::§

in g zfimggz’ srytsfég an ‘éifi §mz raga? gm;

$i§:’$§$§ a mm? Efigégéimiiém E€a;?§;§’x’}V§~;§%f§f§%§$é
hag agagémi :%”;§ §$$e.«2:.§£5é’;§:9}V%’:n:i;«}°%f;@.;:;a:E’£:.;
fmigii €22?’ §§%;é€::§§§ fisfi iiiififisfififii éfifi
brry mgr}? 3%? 33% “éaafifig ~
éaaéiéé- gamma? éf zimiéé §§’ §::§%;: .f;§:*%:s;€’§; $5 Eiékfi
fiéfiifififififi &a”r::g;f§::s”:.. ._§:Q§a§é§2′:$!§§§m”;. Q?’
E3¢E’€I},i:E$;§}{“‘;§–e fay % A
35% Q? §£Eg%?:$§* §;gi:*”:.. ‘

‘ §;_’5$’§g:%;:§:;:;§ §:s§;_§fiE;is;%-:: “:.;::::fl@:” figsiiafi

§§*i_ :”=,::;.;’:§9%§§«+*:*…¢$:3, ffigszéfimia 3 and; E

$;§§%$£§_’f«€§§, égiggé é;§§§:;§;.;::m2 afié azfifz fififi Eafigafirififigzi;

* 23:3: §E§;’§.*;%:§g fiifiifiiifisi wgzm.

“‘§.»€:§i~i%&;%;§’::{% –

‘ :%§§& ‘?$a§s2:$ fif’ Efifiéaiififiigfi af

§%?’%§; ‘ééw §§§fi’%§'”°f;3’§§ siagzzfia 5%? £23

* r $§;§3-iéfiégaiésié:

£1′: %?*;§i%m§ 22% gmiiéémaem gmvg fiat? em
Qégfififi gr: §_§.§§€} fzzmim at Eéfig E&§*m.:t Efifi
fag: §f.i’%§§.§;§ ‘gig :;§.::&$.%:E”: cmzgfiaé 3:3 322%
E23′ §*%:§§$;§}§::&§ Eéfififi iéifasfi “ii? $§:i§§z§&§§§§:
2%§E§§mm aa”: $32; 2323 mi’: :3?’ 2* gé’ §.4:::’:§§

4″

Elm

Z:i::a:.:§;:”;§:g §%g£$%m:§&:§ §%:?e:*;.Ei§w%iE3;»;%»é§§:;%§:§_ as

‘%?§;*:§%;:,§”:£;%?.* ggséééégzzzaérg gm $3’§§;’$§’:i.f§’ui*2.i*§.’««..’:§;’3::”%
§i’~€}fiE.§}§i”§,$§iE:$E’§? Eff ;3§:2; Ef:s:s%r* :§;2.:=::%§: §:§”:%-‘ii’ vffsigz ”

” in %’;::§°<;§,2:.?::$*: 3£';§ 'gm';

axamizasai fim: §&€:?§?3i::::£;§ é:'é:%»::§3;2f$&:i as

Pigié gzzé gm Eéaitizar mags"

g§~*§%:’:%3$&é wag $§ §fi§’§*v.§?:E 3?’ é”és;$§5;r;:z12:§;$:”§f{$ 31$:

&§§:’»§ {§§$’€§iE§§’§§fE gm Tfiw iriébazzsgfi an

mmifiafégzg _ %:§i::~;=;_;’ 33% :.E*£§&fi:?;§% am :*§&.:’:s:§:*:§§

afiawfi i.§”§;fi {:§§.?§’.”*§?; 23:”; gsmfiz mm? awaréaé a 13%}

‘ §£}%§% ‘eff :§$§e$:::”,§&z’.:s:;’2::5
ii} §;@”§*$- wmfirfimm
iig-:3sl§ 3% Eva & figfifiéfifi
~., ” ?:m§ra§ & gkfiéagtgém
* .%z§ §Z§%:§ sf’ %’€§’§fi
Trgyafigmrgafigzz 9%’ éeafii “mfiiy

3? ~ zfgfiar ‘aézfi fafifiverérsg

«= $3. 23} :

Zi:§g€:?Fi:§%f3f»
E§§§–::'{:£§§&
§§%%:i:§-

a $3, %I’:3§.EE%f7:§$C§§§~

assmmmwaeawwmm-aawarasasaz.-=ma.c-mm

aw

fie %§s:§?; Réziég agiigféfifi agaiiéi i?:’~fii’:i§%§:§§f{§$Zi azzgagfiéé

hy iiém ‘?::*’§..’§:g:;§aE% am in ggggwi far

$§}§”.§$.§’E€Z,’:%»%EE%%:’1fi:

*3, §5’§§z%:’§3. 3323?: ?}£2,Z§:”§&:9§§

3%? figgfiikfizg mafi

§ i éfiiigfififii s.

23% riwéwméfimi Emg ‘méfixz §§£§3i£ flmzrt

E3; fiffifif’ fifiiféi 3

% 2. Efifirgzfif fifimseaifi
%§*’€}%..E§§a é-é::§§,:;§’i’§ 325% {::::”§m.§:i§.:§ 3:: fifféf £31

fifiazscffiésg E5 $5 5%” aka flwgaafié ifigmaé 9?

fig; gaméa she §:*g§r% far 3%

‘§:’§;§§2§%i§§§§if§iE§E gfiéfiz figs EE$a§i Eggs :3?

Egg §1§’1g giégfi aufimééa iézfii fim

§§:$:.:;a.:’.3m.@ ” giiésm; {T

*~?;*iba2§§.§__ a:}:::m2i%:*§s;é fig §::*§s3:* ix: a;§§}E§;fi:%g mE.1§?§_§§§$f

” :3?

$§ iii

$5 fiféxfi g§a§§fi’%?i$§é& ” ”

‘ §

£§:%i§’%§%f’}€’;’>§E$? Efififimfififiy

mifzziazaégaé; 23%: wézai Ema ‘mm: ggwgrfi by Eém izfifiigimi

is giégi agéafi :*§.§$<:::&E;E.s§ arr: ii ésag 2%: {E332 fag' 355:3;

i{§.t&§*'§&§'fi§"§$$ §:*§jg*§ gag" fiégzzéigaaé sf zézfi «f

373% f§§«._. £?Ea:5;%§§5s:::*3;$:z;§f:%:,.'.VA:§*€i&1g:£a:%: "éfa

W

{M

35:1 €322 5:2?' gm $3? éifié §:'§¥'&;E*§, pagfiaéi? *§§;'

flag 'a'§%§.,z:'<§gf§ fig aéaa iim ramrfifa ai' '%;?£2.$ 'm'éE"::a.::m§§ 2%;

emfigg fig? §°§5§§T'iE'; wfira iii. gii fifiga :::Eg?f§*:az:":".$ ?i"=;§§'§*'?'§""Vi.:%Z.,.:"".3:.'%"". .

mfibmmé mzfigiy zfiéééé 333$ $E€'i%::{§$*f2E?ET}17. _m:"::§f:f:i;§:;-:9: '#2:?

gig?' H;:;:§§::§;§ ?§§s§ Emzi §E%«::§ iééfi §€2é%.§iiA:§)_s§;*%, _§:?:$§%§g'-:;g'11.'_A

mmgfimggiészzg E3: fif iézéagvé'-.;3§:::§§m?.&§V

éggfigfisnig $2-siyzg éiw £31: §;_z.%.§:%§%f;veas5-»..;§&z*§;&..:£§is:~;%,a: Egg

ii$%¥§2 E23? E§§;*'§%3§$ iféififi cf Sm:

;§£;§§ $2, éfi-_é’i”‘,Z§!:*r3;m**%: fig $2? f5:f:’:fi ‘s:.*:~_j<29§1:§~_3§'§$2'*%§ = 3

$2" 3 *2: éaémmfian

igwazfifi mzwztgaam :2? $323 aifiaaaamiufi fig:

3% %.;% %_fé32:;$.§§§$:i:*m?. é.§:'i§–«*§§3% §m§:§§§; §§

. §'a;§z%;::f:",§&;–V5'§.f¥z:*s;:;V§z*': £3: the Ems? $g:=§g.% gag _

:%%1;a::;ié;:*"'é§.$ m§2§;:i§§§$§g' 23$ €fiZ:§?$§'2'§€–{§§ ma §"§é§:«*E'2'§§E$

E333 Emifi

..4_$§:;:: §fi§$'{fi §§§%}.§'€£§3§§%§§" :12: iém saga af' éifkfiifi 52%' 33

£2: wfifiifi Ex 2% aaé ma :4 £8 gfiggfsigfi %y 23%

"=.é:?*§§3§:::af.a £3 $::$§":§ firm mgagfiigaéfig $5" i;§';:$ ii'-£.3§1§§%fi1§$;.§Z§§ZE

gagygéraifi mmgfif flag "gm 3? &$®z1ai%21§%z;*" Ezfi 3%»

§$.;;?1?'§.§%§,?:»§:§§ $3 zszziéfir: 5%"/1

E5 sf Egwffisfiégf} ":22-aéim §a:§.§§§{%j» fig fifiéégisififi

éjizsémfie fif 33% fiafmaaw 31$ ¥E az ;§§'$}'?§;:§5§m,

§§:.3;'?E:€"f~ X :2 g 35% §§j;£?'§5f:%§i.§§-3

mfiggmfigafizgzé ":;°:& Etéazfiiiiig 'xégm Q? §;€§%&:fi:iV;?§§2$§"*j 33$

maéfiféaé. '{3}? :%§$_§§ 5;?

£3: gisfmiiizziéifiza $1? §aa~;.””}3&’.§§é:§.% 35$
fizfigg 333$ fiifiéfifififii *-

wamid ‘kw fiyafia Eg §3éae;%a._:;%§’a:3 E32 Q? iim

aéfizfi é;§§;eg:::;3%::§e§:3§:; §”$}~’;a”sj§*;*§.;a§::§?:”€:’§;2€=*;§%»L?:?§’ géafiééféii

:23 ‘:’Eéa%r:TvLa§:;§;;s;§;§;g3w 25.2′: gatséw

ii} izréfiffir EEEE hfigzziizzg E935 af
{§§»§T$fi§3€§:{§7,i§§§;T_”§§E’3.§’fiZ?Ei£i§€§3; “by §:~r§&::*§$2g fiifififif

I af 2§;aif’;§2;’€é;§fi@§ ~»§ wésigh gfzmii

_ éfifijflffifii as’; 233$ @3322: 5:2?’ f§% gm? &.§”§£’}*%,§:§{E
” gm 3%” §§;aiz::=; gfiaiéfiigsm me éiaég fig

~3$E§§.:§:a§§::’§§:i €23′ iifigfigéé %§?%”;§i{?iE§fi§§f fig améigg, The

Z :§.:”‘§,§¥;.,,E%§.* fiémfi éggmaééi 2335
étfizfigazawéieyi ‘mfagg ‘£25 gzszéfiéiafifiaaé
23%: mag: §r§%_§1%;”z fix fizgafim fmm; ‘aim $323 af
E?-ffiigii 3%” 5: éfifiiéfifiii z::?z:2;§;:g :::=f zfiriimx
§’§;§g:’**Eémf3.:z:g11″i ag zifigafi aim ?.’;;”E”‘§§3’i§.E,°E§§§ 332$}

*- ‘:¢¢§1§:’:r;i=.%:€3 Ea ;§j,%j;%if:.:§ “;>%§:aé.: 7 f

Air.