! £5" IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE 1:m"r1::1_> T1 115 TH :: am mm' 01:' JAE\3LJX\.RY. 2010. PRESENT THE HON'BLE MILJUSTICE N.K.PATIL
AND
THE HON’BLE MILJUSTICE B.SREENIVASE.A'(3;V..{3’V4§?:;i:J.x’;1X’ T-
M.F.A.No. 5789 OF 2906 (I1
£3E43″{‘WE’%2i’*21\£: I ‘V 1 V
S1’i.}{a11m’11’1. S/O SW2-1111.y11a1:iia}’O1.
Agc:44 Years. ()crc’:I’21i1O11e1′. O M
R/o.1\’o.I;:-4-2, I.)RD__O Q11211f.1.C11.§s*’.v._
C.\~’_R211na11 Na-Hg;-11′; ..
};3;111g§2iiI(.>1″e–560 OEX3.” ” ‘
[By SI}IE. S1.1’1″I’i1.}’111’B:H-.’AC1\T6t’3£fi'(T; KO1″ S1’i.Su1″cs1’1. M.I,2;1§.L1I’.
/\(1vO(fz-110} ‘ ” = *
.. _ 1 . .. M 7S.£3E’i LI1_”;-3.11’ _g,..{a ‘I7./I;H1l_v21_
V”~-S/Off?’21k:jc1’a 1\/iz.1I_va..
» ur\._:._i(‘Z§f\./”Ii?.j'(5’I’..” O(‘(.’If31.1Si1″ICF3S.
V _ , {iv _\_'”1’ . Lie SI}; ;11f;.:a’1_j 21 R215 I C.
‘=.C3ax-9ipL’11fiz1m'”West. I32111_s_{z1I(.)rL*-5t>'() 9
r *r«, .1-_ _,’..»- , ,.. I . ..’_, ;
T2. TN_:11g_– I{L.Lg1O11a§ M(._1_11(1_gL:I__. _ _ gig New India Assurance
_ A Lil?’ T11$EéUi1″§iiET:.__HOlT1:1§LI,Ls1 E?T9iWC.:1’1 Rcmd.
V ‘U211’1;{a’I1f()1′(-‘~F360 O27.
RC’5’5;)()E’1dE’1’11S
V _ [I3_v§S1’i./\.K.£-*3l’1a.11. Ad\’0(’21ic-? for R2;
‘ i\?’O”1i(.’c’. 10 RI <.1is1")('11s'cci wiI.11 V/0 (iz.1.1(3("E 5/6/2007)
.V /
/¥'w.¢¢r}r§éet'ed Mo.
5 $9: 20199
if _l__._g_”,……_.,.«—»–**”‘
“1”1’1is’a MI”/\ is filcécl U/S 173 (I) of [VW f\(“‘.[ z1g3;z1i1’1.~sI the
§L_1t’1;–_§111m”11 zmcl z-1\.=\.=;,11′(‘l (“1z.11c(.1: ()8.{‘)8.2(‘){)5 1);.1.~s.Ejl~x-‘
a110wi11;;’ the c.:1a;1in1 }f)t”1i[i()1’1 fox’ (t()1’11pc11se.:1inn EIIIC1 _4:acc’1″1’1g3;
L.*r11″1;’111cc%11’1cnL 0? c()1111)c%11s=,21t.i011 01′ t7on’1pm1.~sz:’1Iion \x.*i1.l:1__1m.é* .
21; 12% 1.>.a.:. ”
V»
‘I’1″1i.~s §\/E.1″.A. cm1’1i11§.;’ 011 for z\(T11T11i5’»jA:f3i(:)11 01.1″1’fl’1i:s.:(i2-afifiu1V
PATIL J. (11i\.=e1’L*d the t’c)11(.)\.x’i.1’1g:
:J U D G V34; Na T.—.
Admit. V.
2. This appez-11 {i c’ign1em_
and awalwi clA;§tc(‘i in ,\/IVC
N0. E 182/2002 ].:)”c’-iE_}..’.;.’:.L”t’] ::~}f):\,-‘: 1_L.’VE:’l’Ix”I”1(~’d..~§ §\/Et=:11b(*1’. M0101′
I-‘wv’1c’1&~11vi’v__Clz_1im5 “”I91″‘r!-‘) L,’1’r1;ii’;»_TMva1_y(>]’*i2’1Il Unir. 132111¢t_{z.-11<)1'c-* {SCCI-1–
20} [hcr1'ci1 1u;.1fte1' " '1'1'ibLma}' for Sh(J1'E,].
By ii:-9, ;it::.c_1'.§§113'cr11i""and awar(L the 'I'1'ib1_me11 has
~:-1\.x-*a1vf§:i':c?(.1.. a, -51.1111" '(;*f~~"Rs.72.500/– with i111c%1'cst at 6%
£1'<)I1[1«.2.2A."2.2003 E11! pay1nc?11'{ as e1g_;'z1i1'1sa1. the C};-lim
;?i;;_1t{i;;_.1;y :'{"_}1v_§_=.* 'AV..'K«';':i.}:")'v1.)L'.I1E,l.1'H for 21 sum of Rs,4,()O.()()O/– 011
'cl.('('.()-3_._II'1E ()'f_ 1ihAt-T i11_}'1.11'ice; SUS1E1iI'1('.'.C1 by I'1i1'1'1 in 1110 I'(')dd
*I_mfE'i;1’iL’*\-‘c==:c’l by t.}”1c sai(l V§1.:(lgzT1’1e111′.
jaaAic’i’-e.;w2:1′(1_ the-2 2’1p1Jc}_1a1 has presc11tecl this appcz11.
/:'””””””*WM
£5′
ir1e1c’icqnate a.1’1ci it 1’1ccd.<; to be c='11h2.1.11("(..'d. I1. is 1:01 in
(.1i.=sp11i.e that'. on d(?('()1ll'11 01'1he in__j111*ic$ sus'121ihcd by
him in the acci<1(r111'.. he a1'1s 'taken 1rmt1hm='1'1t as
il1p211iLEI'11 for 20 cizixys in difi'e1'cm hospit;z:1ls zzmd ivnhx-%'i'L'.\fxr
of i'.1'1() il'l_jLH'iC&5 sus;EeLi11c(i he he-=13 s1..:f"fc=-%x'e(.1 1')§i"'1'I1e.i'1*1–.§?_i'11;__'
disamiliiy. I_)111'i11gg the said perioci lg' 1nigh'E"'1'1-21}-<9'"Lu'1dVcr__
g<)11c: pain and a.g(")ny. BL11 this 2T1sApc?–i’ ihc, “:’1’1”;’.1I_fci’—.if1é11j_’
snot bc.>(-‘rm lookccl into or <f'<)_1"1':-1i.(ic'?1'(=-'(.1 by thew»ff1 etwewding compc1’1sa1′.V10_1j’~.__t.’0wa1’cis«._paiz;1 and
s11i”fc1*i11gs. ‘1’1′”1eref()1’C. h’£(\-‘,i1″E§_’3;._ 1–?::%g;z11*:*1.’j tgi ‘~{‘_,hL’ 11atL1re of
in} u rivs; ‘sL:ésI”ai191echi. “hé-“:1″ 11’ :=:*f”:1×1(i _(‘.V11″1Vm{i1’1 of the trca1,n1o1’1t
tiakmu bv’*i:1’1t*– 21 )’T)c’}’i:A§1″x11’_”w&~.gi..:’c:1n ii. fit to awe11’d 21 sum of
Rs. 2A5,,()O()/3″ ]_:i1’E’-L716!’ hc’2.1d iI’1S{CE:1Ci of Rs.20.0()O/~
°’c.1A\\{2’1″1’c1éti-f’byhe “l’x’ikV)”i.’x”1″121i and 2:1(t(‘(T>1’cii11g1y’, it awa11’dcd.
V ‘if’:*.ivE:§:.L11″1z11 has; 21\.va1′(ic(1 21 511111 of Rs.3.000/w
t()\vzfujcisJvnlejditfall €’XpC11SCS and ‘(K sum of Rs.5.500/-«
“F.v€.’3.x-‘;==1rcis”..–€’0nvcy211′”1LtC. n01,1rishi1h1g food 2:-Ind 2:11.1’e11da111
” . (”1}é1’i*g;'(*s a1′”1(‘¥ the Si-11116’ is ‘just. and 1*&’as()ne11’)1c zmd i1
” docs 110E (fall for int”e1’fk”1′<3:'1(:c-?.
8. T110 ‘i’i’ibLiiia;ii 11:.-is 2.1w2.u'(.1(‘rd ‘(-1 911111 of
Rs.i0.000/– I()\V’dl'(‘1S 1035:. oi’ iI1(‘(.)I”1’1C’ cliiring i’.1’1C pmioci
of lrcgitiiicm. by t.21kii’1g_»; thc iI’1(‘.'()IHC of the a113})L>11;’1′::’it7;1.i
Rs.2.500/ — poi’ 111()1’1i’1’1. T1’1(° said c0mpei”1s211ioi’:”‘é§1’vég;:r(:iCri
by U16’. ‘I’1’ibLii’1a.i is ii’iadec.1LiaE.e ;’ii’1(1 iI.”I’1(?{:3:C:}”[£5 “~tV(‘)~.Ab;}VL_”
(‘l13″1£:1.I’](‘.t:’d. It is the c’1a1s(;* 0i’T1’1c E,1jj’f’)(‘H’E'{i’1.T”:V i’.1’131t’-.ii1V'(*=:-
about 40 years. \-\»'(.)1’1{iI’1g;.§ ‘a_.nc= by t.l”ae’ Tl-‘ibilliéll. it would be just and
‘V’1″5?§1v§(.fnI’12-i-B30V””;:l’I1(} e.i(“:c’§'(‘_’)’i’c.iiugly, ii is taken. If time income
0i*1(i1Q’ 2.a:ii:)«}..)V({*§!;7i’;it:~* is Ieikcm at Rs/3.000/W per month, the
I'(‘)i’éii._ 10s_i_;S’ 2)? inconic diiring ihc. pei’i0d of 11’cam1ci’1t for
“i'<..s1_u.~ 1:T'i(f)]'IH'1S (*01'nc5's to RS.i2.000/– ii'1si.L=*ad of
"?x.S';'i_'('){0OO/M 21\.v£1i*('1c(1 by the TribLina1! zmcil z.i(tc.<)i'(iiiig;{1y.
V' "ii is 'cl\VEEl.I'(1(_'C1.
ALW
i:’1s.+u~z1c! of R:+.15.00(}/- 2-1.\.\re1a'(1c(l by t1″1c ‘l’rib1ma1 e.11’1<1
e1(~(t<)1'c1i11g1y. i1. is é*1\'\-"'c11'(1t'_'d.
10. The ‘1’1’ibu1’1aI has (_?!’1’€{I1 in a\.\»’a1r(‘1i1o1;;
Rs.19.E30(‘)/– 1′.c)\va1rds l():s..~; of f111.u1″c income Ie11<iV:;1gg»._'£:'}'1._g%
il"1C(")I]1L' of {he etppcllalmz 211 Rs.2.500/– per I1'1.{i.ii'i'.i1.V_'Vv.Ii_f.}1;___ _
(o1is'sa1:)i1ity at 5% and by adopti1'1g;,Mu11ip!i£"1"' "i'_1'1c"=.o,"
said v<)n1pc1'1sz1iic):1 axwz-1rdeci lb}-' f"1'i=1i* E_'1*'&l._)'L';.:1'é1i
i11ac'1eq1.1at.e and it needs t'L»:._ i::.;;: cnAI'1;1Vnc.:cd?'_._ mhavc
r
2-.111'ea(.1V a1s&5cssc(_1 131%: i1'1("*()A1?s.1..u_A'~._()!'=._.the "2.1})pQ1E3211'11 211
Rs.3._O00/– per n'11111″1″ _oz1u”1t’.,_fwe _z1uI 40 ye-?a1’s
at the ./I’.imc (;I.’? ax:V(3’i£1(3′:o1t” v211’1d the e:1pp1″()priai’c Mulripiiex’
£t})p.Iir_”e1l:’:$’1’c ’15’ ‘ins1ea(1 of ’13’ as done by the
“.”.1″1’l:T)’_L11A’1a1′{“‘–«.ii’1 0!’ the law iaid down by the Apex
(‘)om-it 11;”i.1iu§’L:e1sL’ of Sarla Verma and others Vs. Delhi
_ ‘i’.ra:.1spVor¢t Corporation and another repc’)1’t’ec1 in 2009
.. “[1298. ‘l’1’1c1’cf<)1'e. the 101211 1().s's:5 of i'u1'.1.1r<' ez':11'1"1in_g§s
" "con-m,v to Rs.1.08.€)OO/-{Rs.3.000/~ x 12 x 15 x 20/100)
ti'
1),
i1’1st(*z.1<.1 of Rs.1E)..'"5(:)(')/T ;1w2.1rdc<1 by Kim' 'i'ribm'1e11 zmd
21c=.c'r(':)1*c1mg'ly, it. 15 aw;-11'ci0c'i.
‘1 1. E—Iavi11;_g z’o§___§a:’s
ofihc <~.2:sc as .*_»"£atc('1 21b<.)v(?. {he im1T)11;___§:1cd _j1.:(1;gI1'1c-*I1t éind
awarci pa-lsscid by the "i'rib1.mz1l is liable. to be§:':1–£1§i§fj'C{.1,._A'
'i'1'1c* 1(Z.)t.Lll c'r0mpe:152-11_i0:1 payable cromc-*5 to /9"
anti the- b1*e¢'11<1..11) 15% as foliows:
. ‘l'<)wa1"ds pain and Sl1ffLt1'iIi1gE&__ Rs. T.'2'E(.A(.)()O/ -V';
1
2. ‘1’o\vards l1’1(‘(‘1i(.’&1l cxpenlses’.-._ “,Z3§00’U’/4
3. “i'()w2-irds cm1\»’€yaI’1(*c. :1<)t11'isl"1"E«1':1g _ '
food emd 2m"e11de-1111 £'*.1)z1.1jg_es"' – Rs. "'*5._%300/–
4. ‘1″0wa11’ds loss of iI’1(r()r1_T{j’ (.11.;_1’ir’§–g,§ i11$-” _
Pc?:”i0d ()1″u’c..a1.n’1c?1″11 A T’ V 12»000/”‘
~. A {Simor;A.%1[m11i;ies o:’&1;i”¢ Rs. 20.000/–
Ei. ‘1″c>\.=m3:.jc.i i'(‘>sS” 0 if”-1T;1I 1,; 1″‘:<~.TVjAc'–"a,1*1"1i'11 Rs. 1 . O8. 000 g —
v 4- "~~._ "271'<_)tal Rs.1,73,500[–
Cfl
r—-4
“E
‘-4
.4
4,”
~<
5.
;_ .2
ha-
a
f-‘\
A12. A<%<uf():j'di'r'1.g!y, '-111%: appeal is a1l<)wc(.1 in p231.rE and
"i'!u* V"'i1'i'1pi.:;.§1'i:)d _jLa<1g_§fi1¢'111 a1T1(.1 d\\='&11'(1 })z1.ssct(:1 by Iihe
xi-1]'VViV:3_'l1V1V1At'ljL: iii}Z No.1 162/2002 siallcis :1'10dific(I. g1'211'1Ii11g
21 (";(}'-111])(j"viSi'1"~{');1 of Rs.1.73.500/– i1':s£'(=uci of R.<s.72.500/~
V{'e1x11j1z'1:1;~<:{.i v<")1?n1.)c=-113211ion m1n('*s to Rs.E.(')14(')(l)()/~). '1"i'1c=*
_ L~':'1VI1»;.1I\';1'L.u:c1 {t()1'npe1'1smion 2.-'shall ctzury imcrcsl at 6% 13.21..
~ .f7:.'<–)Vm the (12110 of p('1i'£io1T1 1.111 its 1'C21!i5satTi(_)1T1.
X
J'!
S
7
it
The sc(‘o11(‘1 1″(-*sp1’1dc:11t–11’1su1*a11″1<%e Cc..)r1'1p2;;11'1y is
(1i1"c<*1.1.'{1 10 (.'1L']'.)(,)F~11 1.111? <=1'11'1a1'1ccc.1 ('()111})(3I'}S211i(.)I1 w111'1 1111'c11*:sl1
\\'il11i11 111111' \'\-'{'.'L.'1i.'-S 1mm 1.110 Cldlt" of 1*c(*ci1)1 (:1 5.116 (''()1')}»' o1'1'111is~;
juc1_g111o3111 and am-'211'c1.
Out 01′ 1’11 C <*111'1211'1c(-?ci com;Jc1'1s;-1110.11' * 017 V
R.~s.1_()1.0()O/–. 21 .='~;1.:1'11 01' Rs.50.0()()/~ wit11__1111<rj)pt.ij_'1=E1111';1.11_c..1
i11to:1'cs1 .=.-1.112111 be 1i<;*.pt in I111? 1"ixc=.d c1(jp<)si14i11 2.1.11yi'N211i0;':;11'1':%Cc11Y
or ES('*11v('1u1cc1 13a11k in 1.119 11:–~.1_'11e 01"- E11t: 211)1.j)b<'i'11.211"1tI 1"(;}1'."a
pc=r:"i<)(.1 <3f1'i\«'v y(-=*a1'.~__; and :*e1'1c\v1;1b11(' for ai1:.()1'i'1v 1:119 i11E.(rrest
&1(“(“!’11(‘.(1′ t311.,11”;;.(1; .1éi:1’%;c.r’1y.’-._ 1
‘1″i1_1c1′ 1’o:111’rj1i11’1.i:1″1;__,1; (-11111’2.1._11’cr-;%(1 1c011’1pc11sa11011 01′ 115.5 1 .000,’ —
\\.ri1,11 1.)1’0p(’11’-I.1o11z11c>.ir’11pi’n;?.$1′ $11411 be 1’c1e21scc”1 i1’11E’1\*o1.11′ 01′ E119
211′)]v_3€>:1;1z1111′. i1’11111A1(-‘v:1j;_11_gj1};. on 011c’ic.1’11–
7 ‘ :’_}101′ *1–i).(11′-“.11 11″m”1’ V
1)1’a–:\§g=’- (E10 2–1w:;11*Ci. 2-u’c.'<.)1'{1111g1'\r.
sdl-3..
311599
sah,
jutlge
tsn ”