High Court Karnataka High Court

Sri Kariyappa Basappa Avaradi vs The Government Of Karnataka on 9 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Sri Kariyappa Basappa Avaradi vs The Government Of Karnataka on 9 March, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil And Nagaraj
IN 'THE HIGH Comm' ()1: 2<ARNATAKAv..._.' '  : 

{:2}:-mus? amen AT DHARwADh__ "'-..,    %

DATED "THIS THE 9% DAY:é§-4 '1~;;a;A,Ré;,:;.?_§} ;2't'}{59(LA--KIAD B)

BETWEEN;   

1.

SE21. K:§R1Yz§E’PA’F3ASA’§?PA AVARADI

AGES aB{3t3*?~.–4,ir3 *;*m}%S,.~

S/O LATE: B§§53A;’PPA ‘:>?_A§PA AVARABE
Rf 025.

” -SRL “;’g=gr%e£ii;L¢;r~:§qA KARIYAPPA MAEJLEGSWAIE

z%.GE§3VA.Bx{i3~.L5’T ’24 YEARS
. ‘*§:;,t:;> LA;f:’3I=§{;aR13*;a:?PA
“-48! £3′ G,&.§xiAN&G&’?Ti
s~:;§BL:,
BHJERAEREAQ DES’? $85) 32:3.

SR1. KARABASAPPA YELLAPPA KURE

AGED ABOUT 55 VEARS
Sm LATE YELLAPPA
R/C} GAfV£&NAGA’I’T’I
HUBLI~ 530 025.

yt

séi. KENCHAPPA
S/O HANUMARTHAPPA vazm

AGED ABOUT’ ‘?3 YEARS
OCC: AGRICULTURIST

R/O GAMANGATTE
Hum; TQ
DHARWAD ms? – 580 02a,__

SR1. BASAVANEPPA
S/O KARASAPIPA J.QDAHf¥i–,–F
AGED ABOUT 47 ‘2f;3:A1a2s_*
occ: A<3mcuLTUR'i::;T- '

R/<3 GAMANGA'T'T'§ —

HKEBLE TQ ”

DHARwg;fi”E}§$’r -gisgg} . A’

SR1. “§~é£AD’E.Vé§LAP{‘-‘A ‘_ ‘
Sia-V$§§1*;:AP§r;3.VwMAréAG .?~;I:::_»’
AGE’.-E) A’iEC1;UT’ :5?” yzames .
€2.86; ‘A£}R*;£::LIA:;%r;J}%§TS*:.’ ‘

we {}PsMAN{3A:T_’i’E’–~ ”
HUB’L_:’:*Q ” »–

_ .T.2fHARWi§D .3:i:;:’,<s?':*':+ 5375 G28.

.: i"SE§-¥~:: a3URUé1':::§–s§P?A

S/Q :R2a;_3PA '¥''E;BAVANNAVAR

'' V $£=:E'fiv';2gBie.:;T 79 YEARS

– _ writs; AGRECULTQRIST
. Ri€}’z’.’i§é?;§A§JGrA’§’3’E
H:;5B:.:..rrQ

‘§.§§:§aRxr;A:3 mg? «M 533 was

‘ 3&3, mLLA??A
_ _;s/9 QLERGFLFPF: GQRANAKALLEE
AGED A806′? 54 YEARS

QCC: &€}RECLUIff’i.§RIS’E’
R,’ O GAM,?aNGF{E”TI
HUBEJ TQ
if}E£§3iRK’«§fi§§ SE3′? «- 58% 928.

if},

}.L

_ _:~::,¥BLI;~ _

SEE’ GOOLAPPA BASAVANNAPPA H{§LA?v§A¥f+é§ fj ~

AGEE AEGUT 6? YEARS ‘

S/Q LATE BASAVANNMJPA GQLAPPA r~;;; £;;;:x¢1;é;:s:§V ‘%

we GAMAI’~§AG§£T’E’I ViLLAGE§ _
i-UJBLE. ”

SR1. KARABASAPPA BH}MAPI’:A__S}’%£iLAVP;;E§”= = ” 1′

S/0 BHIMAPPA SHALVA.£}i._
EXGEE) fisBCii}”i’ 53 YEARS’»,
R/C3 GAMANAGATT1 VILLAGE
EUBE. an _M__

SR1. KARIYAPPA KEN_{:’ivaAP§>5s 1I_3m;1_ ” .
AGED ABQUT’ ‘?’8 YEAR–S ”

S] 0 LATE. .3A:3AP;1_’>A §a:”b:;_\e’:’::}»’i« [P-‘PA’ IEEHLI
R} 0 GA§y1ArfmQATT: i::’LLA”<:;«;~_:: ' "

gem MAE?§.VAE;;.€\Pi?'.?$'~{;HAN–T'éABASA?PA J&VALi
Ami)' AB€}Efi?,Afi '3» YAEARS '

3,10 LA'I"E2' HAh;Vr~1A§3AsAPPA €'Z§E.§R;3sPPA JAVAEJ
Rf <':2"";f:7A%MAN.aGA'1 Ti 'EIELLAGE:

I Kgkgégasvgg i-EUSENSAB PIMAR

AGEEQABQUT 53 YEARS

Sf;1vQ'%L5;':f;E'z;;UsENsA8 PINJAR

._ – R'}"£§"_~(}g%¢fi;*§NA€}A*PT¥ VILLAGE:
A _ ' Eii.§_B;L{i_g~<E58Q 925.

;*33§§';.B/'f:ALL§s.i3"PA §°iANE}M£'iI*~¥THAF'PA MUQAQEJRE

}§{E~'I:ZI} ABOUT 51 YEARS

«.310 HA,NUMAN'I'I~EAPP& MAN'FfiPPé9s Mumazmz
* ea/<3 GAMANAQAW; VILLAGE

HUBLI «- 580 G225;

16.

3&1. F’AKK}R2’sPPA KARAPPA KADAMMANA’*u:_é&:jV’_T’V. ‘%
AGES A8{)UT$1 YEARS ‘V ‘V ‘

3/0 LATE KARIYAPPA F’A§{§{13″<A Pi4'z'§« 5j;.'DAr;qA§aA;:;§x%~'

R/O GAMANAGATTI VILLA(}E'.__
HUELE. V '

SR1. TIRKAPPA BHIMAPPA._B?i.SAGAL.. '
AGED ABOUT61 YEARS _ _ "

S/C} KARIYAPPA B»HlMAP,F2\ –B_i’SAiE’iAL
R/O GAMANAGA’F’If{“‘1fILLAGE}’ ~ ”

HSBLI. –

ANAsAWA.’Es:.;L>A;éPA’G~::>D1-..jj-__ .
AGED A£?;0-;If1f.28 ‘{.EA¥:);;lg1;:–$_1x'(;§:1:§i…. ‘ ‘ »
R/O (§AM.€{N;.A.G3i’§”F§”Vi.LLA(}E75

SR1. ;–;:Are1Y;;’:~?z>A%::iA§u”MAN’mPPA KEMPU BENGERI
AGED AB(“J¥.fI” 33::-_ ‘x’EARf~’5″

S/0 §;ATE’g Hz;1§JL;Az1A.;~:’i?1–1APPA FAKRXEEAPPA BEINGBER
R/V0 GA’iV{A?¢AGAT”I’§ VILLAGE

” ._§.EiU 13L.L

3 :3R3..AS}i§E–K.APPA FAKKIRAPPA BENGER:
J “Ac;v;«:_:3 fiL¥31Q’UT 4;. YEARS
s;”e.’L_A;rE_’HANUMANT;-IAPPA FA::<:i<;RAPPA Egwgm
. "R/G (3A_M$&NA€}A'?"I"§ VILLAGE
"'««..I~Eij,_§3L§;

Pmfiwa KAR}Y&PP:’~’#. GORANKQLLA

V. ‘ A933 ABC) UT 48 YEARS
= S/C} [ATE EEANUMANTHAPPA B§~§EMAPF*Zi GORANKGL

R O GAMANAGATTE VELLAGEZ
ii BL?-580 G25.

‘ ..A.PF’ELL!%E\f’1’S

(BY SRE : GVGANGIRBDBY, ADV}

1. THE) GOVERNMEN’I’GF KARNATAKA
BY yrs PRiNC¥?AL SE2CR’E’i’AF_£Y

DEPT are M:v;ER<::.E AND m':3)U;éTiézE'S=–

VIKAS SQGDEA _
BAN{}ALORE.. '

2. THE 31%. LAND Amuis;*i*:'{3′:~i’§3§*1:’-;.cER
1413333, RB. RoA1;)’~..f_–
DHARWAD. I

3. THE KARK A§’N;:’T.’:;IJS13?IAi..:}:’£R’EA«’§IE;VELi3PMEMT BGARD
8? yrs (:iH1E;;;:’~” AL}.?vi§N’£;S’I’RAT§«VE QFPICER

NR1)PA3fr:w~4’t”;;1.__Ro;:a:> , ‘
Bamaagogfi, ‘x ~ ”

RESPQNDE-§E’%?’f’S

air ax;

4;j*1*’s>;I32;s23: :é’i:’R I *:” APPEALS PELEEJ UNBER $EZCTEéI}N 4 0?

~'”~.__TH}§_”i~:’A.RNATAKA”i=%i’:f§¥~£ <:{;:,§§*;* AC2: Pm¥_;:s::;’rE, ‘{:;:2r;m:NG TEE AGREED AMGUNT QF ‘2’5% 0%»:
ME’:z’:3*:rw€__€;4 .%::ATe:3 zmnzaes m THE SIMIEAR LA§~i{}S

i.f§§§§;:i% sgmg fi;CQUESI”E’!0E’€ M3 §.L;E..- GTRER $’f’§§’E’i.?TGR’z”

-« “‘.€;§:$:E1&*:%”>s Arm ¥§\E”§’ERES’}T” 01′? 18% 70 THE §?;Pi~”‘EL}’,.:’aE%3″E’S
..j%jv.§:*_§=zm;: TEE mm 0? 2%{Z{}UIS§”§’iQN.

»’ “THESE; WEE’? APPEALS CGME!”~¥f§ 3?? EUR ORDERS

. _,j”;£’.’f£:S my, HGIWBLE JUS’}’E{‘T;E :=z.;s:.P;m§,§ {EELEVEERED THE
§”{}LL{‘)W’§NG:

JUBGMENT

These writ appfials are fileé by the ap;3a3:1;:§11:;9T

aside the order passed by the 1¢.a’r;1ad¢ u

28.01.2008 in w:c°it petition r~:os.:63:?53*;;’,? 12<§o7;~–

and 15789/2007 in 1:113 :n:eres§1§£.j;us:i;:ise.V_ .

2, L-{:3Jt'I?i€d cou1i'sz:1_ "fsgr a3§peflm1is
S1:i.G'¥i.Gangire&dy, s1:¥3mitt':éV<:i't }1$2f{ tt:r::TV'§::f£;~:?fn&:;1t Writ agapeals

flad by the apgeéiégts hot pmsséci.

3, The $"u%§':;:zis&;n3i,m:j..' made by the iearned ctmmsei

agpearifig the app_éi§;?;i;}§fiS'*~i$ ;73.E::§::cd 0:1 recoifi.

%,_§ The.:a§3pe.%ii=.3._f:§ec1E32' the aqggseihglts are €§§S1Zi}iS%C§ 33

V. 3:16;: %3.t,I':}1:3:v risk sf the ltzarmfl cmmsel appmring for

sd/-

JUDGE

sd/~
JUDGE

J3?’