Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Customs vs Akram M D on 11 July, 2008
13 $33 3:33 saga? GE KA§gT&$&.A:~fi§§sgLQRg
mgmgn $313 $3 i1"'ng§ 3@_;fiL3,"2éa§Vf,"~~
PEE§£§E
33$ EQN'ELE ER; JU§TifiE §gLgEfi§§§E§$E
Egg fififi'ELE mRg,sas?:qEvE,¥,E&§aRA$Eflg
..=_ ; §i§- *f=, T
C.3.T.§.w@s.1§/2§a5,2§;2aé5.;?;2§s5 & 2§f2Q§5
c.3.?.A{§G;i§?2é&57{;"
:5 csma:§a§1§1fi?Q£s§§3 7b'
ggrfigafi H
1 Egg :$fifizss:Q§$§--§E §$s§@fi$
EQES Qyygcg, C_R_$fi§L§1E$
Qazgas RQA§,'EANG&L®EE Q A§§ELLAET
5§S$ gr; iraévzfifi §§fiAR;A$$;{AESEfiT3 §
Afl§_:
;gwmgg
as 7x2, sazvzgz Ragfi
*.$fi$vAJ:a&£A2, E§fiG&L§§E §ES?fifi§E§?
g3? 32;; KZEAE 5 Jayaazgggvég
" §§?& fi§.i§{§§ filed u!$.i3§m% af the snstams
1
52, arising' amt af' Qréer fitd:$é«$3m2G$5
'*, p_§a$saa in figpal §.§Q,?§;2§83{§iaai firégr
me
be yleaaefi ts:
Qaaifie aha Qfiéfifiififi Qf law anfi,§gfi_asi$e,§h§ @:&§r
2:..-'i:i~;":;:.::r
Qf tha iffustams, EX€§i$§ and Sairgri-age i;i?aL:::, ;§§;¥}:>€§.=%;'E.'<<f*.;f3.':.€:.VV
fribamaii Zena; B@Q§hgVf.§amg§;ér& [Wi3=,M§p§e&;_*
§,Eag?éf$§§3{final ardg; fig Eififéfififig g@t§:§§--§3~
QSS5 in tha ciraumfitanaeg statfifi abfima afifiiin thg
intarefit Qf justice agd e§ufit§;=" "* *
:3 ¢$$Aj§@.1§ GE 2Ga§:k"
BE?%EE§
3. ?EE §0gfi:s3:§§a§'$3,¢§g?§g3 _*
g§E§5§§E:$§gC "» Vt-'=7 1
$,R&g§:;§:§§",-
gaggfis g§ga;V'§ _*3;:;c<::«::
T J,$;mAaAR'
~T§»_*fiA§§$L§§§
'"= "*~ RSEQEQEEE
._ V _ *ff§S§§ §3.1§§§5 £22 m£S.$3flk afi tha £25232
W_"¢§m§§:§£2 arising fiat Qf aréfix dtfi: ?w22«2$§§
passeé £9932 G.Ee.3§§E2$Q3 ;rayi2g€jtha§ K%$i$u
H9n'bie Cauxt may be pieasefi ta:
aiiew thlfi aggeai amfi $et~as;§% 3&3 $E§§:'é§ the
Suatamsf fixcise and §erv;cé Tax *§@pgi;a:§
Eriufiaif Z3331 Eem$&§9u.Ban§a:%:e= ';xm% $ppeai
agfigkgsazzaag éatad '§?w:2«2§Qé;_g in aha
gzreamstafieafi gtgtafi abgwa &m§_:a ihe imfierest Gf
gustzga aa§.e§a:t, ""--'* V ""'"
zg §$§A.§&e1§ GE ga§§3'
Bfiffigfifi
2, Egg :$§m:S3:§ag§'§g a§$%a§g_'
5QR$a§§F£§$;* * %
C*fi¢§fiEL§EfiS"Qa
gzgggzasg ' _ . _
Efifififigfififi' "jH_= 'g?'_ ,,g A§§§LL&§$
'nu,/"'
{By 5:1: A&v:§§"fi$Ega;g§?,<és"§$;
A53 .
'-3,,§&vEg§»&3E§ Efiéfi
-: §§;;2;_5E3.gga3s
L'KEg§A:A3_3;QCx
Jg$;fiA§éR "
Eafigéfiagg'
~ * ¢g_"=E§fi'bie Qaurt m&§ e §Zea$"4 tg.
,.
vb.-A1
ailaw this ap§§ai ma fifit agzfie ths Qffifif mi
Cufitams, Exciga ané Saria£-& ?ax_'*5y§aiia e
Tribufiaij gang; Eeachf 3§§§ai$:e;'.in Q£§gQ3;
Q Ea 3?§;2§s3 éatafi g?-:2--§§§4;'-,-:n.Yf¢:he
aixgumatafimes statefi ab§m&_an&":fi'fihefini§:@$t%¢§>
fiastise agfi eguii 6
£3 $$T& E$w1? GE 2§§§:
E§;3£*'§::EZ2:?:Efa3
ze $33 cQ§E:s§:Q§3a:$F'§§$:@g$ .
E935gaygggfigygggjgfiiégzfifi."""""
Qfifiififi §@am,i3gw§AL§Rg 9'
4% ;1§§$;;§a;a;*:
{fig ax:;"A§fiv:§gAi§fi&§}§g?5{§$g§E€> }
1 gvgg afiAE§§'EE&§
_V §§¢§2;~5?g $fi§§S
. _
.J»§,§A§,%j7§&fiG%LQE
""«"-~E'. 4?k§Emmmmfi
.a{By Sig: §.$$fi§é§E,é§¥;§
Tj~,*.cs?§"§é.:?;%§ fiiad uf$'3E& sf Qflstwms émi,
__§§fi3'&x;simg gut Qf Qrfiez aid; §?~:2~2§éé §a3$efi
.'eifi %'%$al €.§w.3?§ 2$§3 'r 'ER' fifi E thig E@§§%3e
_, . ? 3? Q' 3 M
' §a§§:gmag be gleafieé ta:
»__ai;é$ this apgfiai aié safiwagifia thfi Qxfiez sf tha
, $u3ficm$; Exciga 33 . Serviaa fax Agyeiiaig
?E£Q§fi3£; Kama; Banéhg figmgaiare ifi £$@§&l
fi.E$.3?3}2§§E datefi a?«:2»2§a4, ,T:n, ="t§e"
$E'i'¥¥$EE€
1 T33 aefimzsszafiafi GE §§5§Q§g_*
§@§£E?EEfC&LE£§EfiQ fi
§;"i}'*'3§§.E.ZE'3E 33%?" , mm"R?*?fa%'fiE;¥ '
,;}"$§$£LL&§$
{B 3:: : A3a§:§a,g3m§§,g§?,€§$sE§?§A 2
EED H . _ _ .
1.
gazgfi ggggg; ¢ ‘»_
a§&1:é?{3§} 2§§_gfix%_R$A§
;*m,g$;g3z§’:Eg3§$§?§§§R
aA§sALaR2}5§a§:2′,» ‘
“= “. I V $9. R§S§§§§Efi?
{E§,grz§*x3§&§ S éévggzfggvfi E
\c§m§~§@g%é;§§ §:2ea u;s.:3aa fif the imatama
_ ct; ‘:§§g; %;g;ggng cut af az§s:T d:¢:§4-Q3w2$§§
:i.:é’ f;’.E=Em».?;€f.:–E£:=§:§ prayifig that @2223
=§:£m’.§’fz::>3.e EX-.2s;:*–i: zvgay ha gzlaasazfg €23:
..’s’;’;?2;e §fE§€§S’1::i{‘3;’f”1 Qf law anti fie: aside the Grier
éfrziiei x;?i,:’:§.=::
mattar is aaiiaé f¢: Ema §hiré,t:me§ T’
2, in the ai§c§fi$ta$é§$; x§fi;» a§&aiS axe
fiismisfiefi far m§fiv§r§Se¢fi§1§fi{H,’
g: