wwrwrwaa Mi’ tvanewflimnm nawra flflflfiWM£M%W% mfiww Lfilkfiilfifi W”? %MK¥WMlNWH mwrw hwwnu QJI” ¥\3Wfl§”h?””WWk¥’k,¥% smww §..«’&.g$M*M¥ WW flMWWflBM.F%M WEWW hwwwfi
13 ‘rm men comr or Kama’:-.mA, arr m1m».a___1.em
DATED mm THE aw um! OF AUGUST.
P’R%EN’I’
rumors»: uxmngxm ”
‘rm serum A If i ” .
Iz:.duutria2_Eef€ate ~ % 0%?! % % Rmbya.a.se£amm%%%»T% %
C};z:i€Mann89?{m5l2?–I.__ .. Appellant
.. % g:3y..aaa%_P;$.*,’§nmjunam, Ativncate)
V _
” =;?wy*:é;v§t3zdust2’ia1 Ama Branch
fifik . tM1′ ux.Ra1zxn.Entu’p2ises
‘£310 l£1’a.Ra.&ABawm&
I<Io.5,$iare/eChm:1Bws
m}54,
Pm:u:- 411 065
Andslaa at 93, Palace Road
figalna-e-5G605fi
3 Xamath Iraszufirrmua Pvt Ltd
B»-124,wCroas,}I:taga j T
Pemya Industrial Eatata _ V _V "
Baxzgaloxe-58 (By Sui s K Pruhanz Chmcira, H " ., Sri'l'S This and in ma unamégacsmg 'J
than ordw dated ?-£-2002 in ‘fixecufid-219339
No.1101} 1997 on the ma afxxx Addljctity fiqiuuiomv
Judge, B%t:x’¢ City, tha ay;)}i¢a;i1ioi1″‘fi1od by
the appollnntiobjoctm undw 21 R2:_.1 e’ ’97 $9 100 riw
8ec.151C-PC clnimingtitle m-‘Eka’L .
J.,dalivwedthgfol1owing”: . V ‘ .
. . ' . mg a '¢rt' "ii by the Executfifl Court
dhmiagitg med by the appenant. um-at
cm and mnajxg that deem
R aw-w»«r~»a.asm”w wuzwww wwwmw Vfwii mmmwmfimkwm W553-WW? W.1\J’&3fi?5 W3!” KMKNREMKW
to the amount dagwaited by the
directing reimse oftheaam.
.. “E5: the purpose of eenwnietwe, pawn are
to as tmy are rfiezrad m on the mzecmztian afie.
gl-/.\
mwmma W1 lt”aJ’hIME’I£””‘C£rLWmf\.#”fi wsww WuV»”h39§¢;iy_.V¢«ii’_:W” mmwwmuwmm Wfiww wwwfia WW wwmwmimwm WEWW nwwmfi WW mmmwmafimm WEWW WWMNE W? ?K§’§eNWW.§3HM§’§.4% Wiwfl RWUW3
3.’1’hes1:bject:1mtte:rcafthvaae
mum-iax shed No.3′?! situated at Paenya %
Estate. Bangalore. The Gfmt af 4_
debtor Ml s.Rana Enterprhes
under deed dated 24~12- v.éj&a. 1&m 12%
years. ma said Earn an
Stabs Bank of industry. By
that time mm
shed to objacmr
in Bank insisted
on the objector before a loan
objactnr by Iettaezr dated 23-4-
A to the: judit; debtor to
mid }’.uu@’ty_ as 3 secI.1n.’ty’ for dust:
ioanafiszaw by the Bank. Th: Bank
V ,fL1d daebfor aamixteci damult £1 repaymnt of
x Tkzmmu. *rwm,d%no1am~—~mnkmac:asmin
0.S.No.2533/1986 far recovezy cf the amount advanwd
MW- ..wWM- wwwunw-xwwwm wwwmwwwmwrwmww asmww “om-mmwnn MM!” mmmwmammm WEWW mwwm WE” Mhtmfifllfifi-fiwfi Wfiwfi mmwm U9?” %%¥$N%£”§”%Wfig fifififi $03.33,”?
an loan with intm-wt. Ans: contwt, suit mm; in be
deczfi on 29-9-1995. A preliminary
passed gmnmg mm to the judmn: ] %
property be brought to sale.
Decree finoeedfim age ‘ii1._If’D?’Na. $11995 to
bring the Finally, d%
came: to be; éfin eacecutxian
petition 1v¢.%:%;z§51&;%%1%9§;. 19-4-1997 bx-mg’ ing
me On 15-12-1993 sale
Spot sale tack phce on 9-12~
mm place on 15-124999. The
é an aprplioatéan undex Ordar 21
the a£nrma.1d’ sale mfi apposed
That, appacwon mm to ban dismhaed
1 sale pmmzamzion in be confirmed on16~«B=~2@CK}.
A Nmsszszzm amen was pmmea mam the
oawrmauian afsale mme In be asmm by this
Court cm 114-2001. Sale oearmmte was isaucd an 8~3~
L\_,/
Wwwm wrap awnwawmamrwx rwww %wwm§,_.mw mmueammzmmm mwtaw mswwmfi “am” wfiwawmimmm Wzww mwmmé wt?” ammmmmiflakm mfiwm Kwwwfiié W?’ aammmmmwa Mfimw uwwm
2001. On 15-3-2001 aaie certfflcatc was It
is therwflaer tlw atfiacmr fikd a pmsent
mqueetim the: Court to adjudmtc rghta 4_
before Ilcmsesuiarz. is
purehaaer. In the appiiaatimz
continues’ with the __ anIy
a lcsaoe. Tim Icas¢s”s_ pegs-:s$i§:§1i”i.s_.’tht§f bf objwmr.
The objector is not which decree was L aale wmcn as wrfiucttiai pmnhasa has no 1-gut After aewiee of L A " mi In': objections, and
m;1gien&§& is not maintmmable.
‘ Cc-urt on eamiaearaem <31' me
.' in mwur of 1%' t debtor for smarts:
x t1mj1..,'2i}yaara, an objecwr has mt mmmz his title, he
% km: 21% right us the ma pmpetty. Propmy as acid
% a public aucizion. same 'a mnarmm. In appeal, the
Hgh Ceurt has obscured that in such matters
ht//..
WWJHEI ‘9-dWi”‘°\WrQ§ %fl”93 K”G-£E?’*”B«69’€§n§!’Q!¢A'”‘¥éiME£””$fsifi’%t:;ii€”‘$h fiW§”%#3$J¥2 “*ks£lWnW\&’Wfifl
9nWm’\§w¢”%’\}»ifi %ai9i$ flE’Y».W$|5%5!r”$£”!§¥:?<"'%V"&fl""§'s £9.31}:
Emcutirg Court would mum pomwsfion 3 delivwed
to the arucfim. 0 people wifi not
eomeforwaxd ta purchaeethc propertzfiesirxfifiurt
am.~rma.' 'I'hm~£=me. it %d@'maed me % %
WW r–appollatx. W
thiuappaalizsfiad.
5. 31-“; P 8 Manjunsth. lmrxwd M
aequiredabscolutc title :9 ma; “Via
macmam his favour
was in error in was me
‘\Ve’A!’iemIwsw&m@’ -wan; mm-umxlrwyrmaawbwmsi no
as’:-‘WWI mnmwwamwflwfi wwmwmwmmm mmww wwwwwara wsr” mmmmmmmwmmm wrswam mwwmm WW” wwmwmfimifiwfi mawm ammufiizw Mr” €”&»”$»§*¢fiW%fi-mW~%%5££m¥. mmm fi…M&.#§%
apprecimadby tlrxefixetmtimcourtanni. tlwz-oafarea
m Ema&am
5. mr centre. beamed counsel appeffi: fa
auctnm purchasmwumm
praperty in Court mxcfion; both ” ~
walla; abpctor End.
afsak: um
hasafirfifisa :3rdarwsssci VA Court in
so far as on debtor.
saued. and entire sale
' f 1:, At an stage,
are filed to deny
at 'Though the Court has
mused sale oerfificate, time
i kzctsta standi ta preaem the application.
iszén. in pasaessim am; chum, he subnxiits
% L applicaainn £3 mt bk amlthe trialilourt
hcd=””-\I!1″WfllHU’W-’41” Wu mwwmmwwmww-wmwww -any
‘*WWViW%’-‘@rM’Wfl*VhflFI’Q:fl ‘%,$”-I&”‘%”Q.¥l&%”%fi'”9:%fl””&@’V&afl°”% #’fiV£%W¥£’X9( wmwwmm WdWi”‘ F56’*M”‘%fl&Y£WM’% ‘ – – BK
IA””%¥l'<&W'I't HTKWWWW 'MSWWQIWWQ3 hflfi WWIWEWWWEKWWWW §"$K%'W"fi 'bme%:J5'*'M99l%.fi Wé5'l'c' mmmxmmwmmm W3¥'k§3*T% Vau5JTWWfii<'
7. In the lght of the afsrmaid matwial on____rword
axfi the rival cmnsaentiorxs, the points that
ezansidcrataion are:
(1) "Wha:ther the .aaga 2
objwteris _ "
Order 21 97 in ma %
(2)
Court fg
5. The facm are property
bciorm to the promwy
tn the exaecuted lease-
cum-aaléis %%%% Tzm-eatm
tawny ahsaltte sale dead from the
The mlecantitmea to be with
% the said paw-ty was ma-msed
L L debtar no the Bankas security for due
4% of the loan with arm mment of abjectar.
_ x ammmts we not paid, suit £3 med. Suit is
‘m1 decree ?n puma dimctmg me of
é pmpmy. Em-man petmon. was filed for
K/..
“6vt’IlVl’l\# ‘hf!’ mmmuwmfimzwt I’i’W\In’#¥? W6R”$U$IW’?’§~fifl%.W..fi'”& W’&§”5fl’W”‘f WWWM3 W3?” Wwfl”‘KI%I”WD’|si€fl”‘W\flW W”flfi\3W”$ ‘Q:uI’lvJ%fifi’$§* QM?!” #\&””h¥ElVfi”hW!W6¥%.«W%. WE-K??? Wum’%aa£5″VMFfi%$ WW WMWEWMEMWW H”‘%%”9a?W”% Ww’§wfl¥WWaiii’
miseofthexneargagedprepea-t}r.1’1wpz’op4erty_i;aao£d.
Sub is confirmed. Sale am-fificahe is
raga’ awed. Possession ccentinued with VA
debmr all along. me objectnr..wa:s4 mg m
am poaaaasion ofthc Imam V
possmsion in law.
Court. for defimy apfémvwacin is filed.
may 21 Rule
f éf a. dacraw for the
bi’. or the
ef sold in mmcutiaon
of ‘B _maEted. or gfbstzruxztad by any pm-son
15a.ws”wse.£6z1’af thsa pmpm-ty, he may
main: ‘s;u«v..gpp1iaa”t§c2a -an tha Court aomplaiznjxg of
“such -_Ja:4a«bsu-uctxo’ n.
(2) agapacmn is made under
V sub-fruit: (1), shall . 113 adjudicate
upéoiia ;»_thev.%_Aa,ppl£t>zat.’aa’:1 in acmrdanoe with the
, mntanwd.
’99 CFC $6.3 as under:
~~’V ‘{1} Wilma any parser; other than the
fizdi debtor is diaposamsed. cf ixazumvabk:
by the hokder cf 9. dexzree for the
of such property, or where such
pimpex-tyhashmaoIdi:tze:oecutionnfadec:ree,by
pumkmw thareaf, he may males an
x
wwwwmn ‘EVE 9l”WuK””‘Jiv’5f’9&¥$'(§l6′”%fl5″°%l0’*@Wx BI!
10
appfieafian ho the Court complahzirg of such
dkpoasmaien.
(2) Vihere any such applimtion
Court, am]! p1-owed to adjudicatb upei1«%T:’tkwv,
.,
applicamn Em acoordanm with
Itlterpreiuag time muvhijem,
peraoa in peaamion or wait till
he ‘3 dispossessed adjudizmfinn of
has rights. Injhat order 21
Rule 9?_ But a.
«warm! 3€Wa1l”‘lB1Qz83’If.€&”‘Ri?§’aI’Mai’9W’% an-awn Wwkflflflflfl ‘MW’? KEEQNEVWQQPKKFQ E7″flfl”Wl-“‘8 Und\aWWJ’i$fl Wfifl’ W\J”§H9k§Vfi”Qlfl”HI£’§1″Wg Wiififlfl Wgflfiflfiflfl §.dl’fl'” K%J0″&ii%%V$5″\KI’lW%-WC T353351. Vuflflluflfliafl
pousmsion afthe . Auction purchase: ‘5
condition at’ such an
a.pp1ica’I:inr:, 7$ #§ust’he in possession of the
pm-pm-my cf tlrm cinema: and
tries in abmin possmsism,
‘a._VA;§<4-gtwzzx objects to the same, ehligation
to adpxdm' ' 1:3 'upon. the rg&' of
_ ..§u.ch acoorflame with the proviamna
23.31 flu: mm: case, admittedly, me objwmr B
IKQPIE \J\s"\l%\¥ '%al"'& W'l"'li\I:W3""&fi£(""U\$WJ#"'Q WGNWWIVW 'WMr'h-W5imm'm!£»m£
debtor waa met an almaiutc owrm and he
b'/..
Mrkfiwflfi K35″ fififlmfififififl WWW?’ KKIUWW WsJ’@Wl1Vi§%Ei’%3%.i3″& Waww uwuma WW %m’F”*kfl¥’W.WNfl’flW\J”l WEHWWW fiuhlwflfi Wk’ mmnnwmumuwm in
not melting delivcry of povsswsion from He
is seelcixug delivery of possession flora the
debtor. The Court owes a duty to the auctiofl .: ~
tn put him in possession. In fact, in
Purdmaar has akeady berm Put £11 5 I’ ‘
‘ , we are of the V1:-w’ V»
fladby the obiacnor is
preps.-rty on the date
19. Stx*a1g¢§1’y;::.”*~ ‘ C-ml:-t without
oax::¢r1trafi1xgVv’Vt$tiVt1;;;%.:s=:r.%§ a if it in
aqudm’ ting % in the said
magag-my did mt object to
ar 20 years. He has
owxwhip is new trarmferred to
“pagicmm thmugh Court mks. Tm aaici
V are: mt only comraxy to law, but they are
mm’ ful man was of the mal panama
vausvwvwaarnmm wry: %’lrnr”‘h;I’¢l.’li«Wa9″”&||.u!”‘0’)o’Qg”\;§ 3;.
GWWW ‘hfl’$wd”Ul’5\l ‘fill 5’fl””II’V.HV££§”‘W¢$&9″‘k – u . .. _ ” ___
|lNnl”‘Q iklllfiiffifl Mwwna ‘Qufifi ¥I’wWlfi%fiW.l*”‘$1I#’°%I\£”i IIEWEE Ww\l’fl.fl¥&9& Wuflfl fi%..4!”‘&i’%.ii’l.l9″‘fi!)?*’&WfiJ”fi I”‘€i%JW”‘f V-rci’hwI’5aWl’\.! ‘fix?! %’%fl'”‘K$’¥V§”‘I-l”%E’WJ”‘§& WIEQUTI ‘ht\JPi§.flW”%g$&
12
waamlyalwseeofthcaaidizziciustt-ial shed.
contimaaa with the objactcr. There is sale
mom; and wmtam titk: the: juamnt
$811011 tr: aucfim V’ ‘V
hkmm are pmtecred by ma %
thaacourt In mamew
reoerded by the
tlmughlmhns in the and.
11. ordar of
reasons set nut by
us. and aecordhogly it
….. % JUDGE
sa./-3*
‘mDG’E