§N7Hfl3HKH{COURTCH9KARNATAKKATBANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 14%" DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2010
PRESENT
THE E-1ON'BLE MRJUSTICE N. K. PATEL. ' ;;-I. 2- '
AND
THE HONBLE MR. JUSTECE K. « I
M. F. A. No. 1151 1.'[‘:;>..Q05 (M./__1V T’ ~ A
M. F. A. z~JA;§:9_7_z_t§/2OQ5_;M_\3
IN MFA N0. :1 51 1.22305.
BETWEEN:
T;-«IE MANAGER. » _
Tm; UNITED INDIA INSURANCE co. LTD.
BRANCH “0§’F1(:I.: ”
P.i~3._,NQ.1*23, SHIVAMANGALA BLDG.
CHANNAGIRL BIfi.ADRAVA’E’HI
R139. THROUGH ”
V D1v1s10’N_AL MANAcn5:R
DIVISIONAL GFFiCE
_ _’A~–«_UuN:f1f13D INDTAENSURANCE co. LTD.
” ROAD
= . ” – DAVANGERE
-~ , REP’. ~.BY-I’I?.s THE DEPUTY MANAGER
– UNITED INDIA INSURANCE co. LTD.
* REGIONAL OFFICE
NO. “25. SHANKARANARAYANA
‘»»Bl.3IIJDING, M. G. ROAD
7%,.»
” 3 ” z
33§ RE – Sfifififil
999 L ‘?
E? SE1′. Es. Cf. EHAVYA, Sm IE; ‘9. F3-Gfififififi
we SR3 R ?R§§..BEEP K£3’M£§.R§ fiD”‘e=?’S.}
$11!};
It am aamvamx
EEO’ vfimmnfiwgarra
AGED mam 31 mm
Rm 2%? mm’, 34% cmss
JAE; E’AG&R, fix’-‘€5i.§HQERE
2. B, C. smvmm.
sgaa CBI”Z’R&PP&
mask Rm. 1912;?
“i.i’iVEEA£f.fiHBA mm,
DAV&HGERR
3.. E. MAflESHW£’§..E’.fiPF£§
sic. Mfifififl-E¥$P?fi
mama, Rm. HG.’ §.§’12!’2″i_ _
= _ ‘ –
mvaxsfigg. . . RB»§POHB£K’I”$
wt 3% R, 3231?; my. ma R1;
nsfim :9 B52 was ‘m’s?flSE§ mm v;a,;a°r.%a..:s?.2a§§:
n§:.’§§é&2..2m§.§%3$,%2eg5
-._3;6;vEERA;BH5w I a
EGE1}; A26??? 3}; .¥EFa.%
” fiiagsmm €3″5i’3;1%’ER ctm DRIVER
, 31:3′ am exam ‘mm KAGAR
‘§;avA:a§;;§3E’1_«
” gm namzm x.:m1:mm’s;,3
..J:.F%£.:¥g$R’i”
%~.M
.3.
L M. E:B§.I%fiW
3] G. T. fiV£P?A
OWHER Q1?’ VII€fiYE.K& Efifi
BEAEG E’E{§:&RI}fi’Gv. KG, Ki’£-34f§393
2. ‘ma fififififi-ER
URI”£”EE mum neszrmcg 23:3. LTD. .
Batman sazmcs, P.B.HE2.123 _
%1v.esmc;am3Ln::;.,, G§m’R9AB
sazsnmvxmr
REP’. mxmxsm rrs awweym ma {sag _
niszmtasaz, omca . V. –.
HERE? mam Hi8{JRfiECE c{;:;”~3.m.; _ V ” ~
mnom ‘
mvamsam
:3? am: fix, {:15
Anvs. ma Fm game: m”a;:. am=*m*$£<n mm
v;am$m3?§5k;g¢2a;% N – Q . %
331% 113.1 was' 31$' .fFs;.1–§:; '=¥jl1iI}}ER SE{§.1'?'3(i} SF lav Act'?
aeamsr mfi ..:£;:3G3.;m:ssr!2$Q5 FASSED at: $533 1%.
Ԥ6!2&94 cazrmfi mg 33:? ifififik, man; sums 52.3%.} & m ggaaer,
*.__B”;!*.’3f4$1’¥$EREg, aawwmfs ‘ma mam mmex mg
-:T:om”–z#msa*.{*::}H gems smma wgmagmw :3? fiflkfimfififififi.
fifififliffi QH FER Hfizfififi 131$ fififi’, £3. K3
‘zé§fiL«;.,:_:§;xvEF£n ms FU G:
A
:4:
JHBQHEET
‘Ih:-ma twa apgusak filefi by the ifisumr azzsfi that A’
arise’ (mt cf’ the awe irngpzzfid judgant and .
yxmagoea gagged in E§.V.C.1~Tm.6:6f2f3!%f¢%A»Va::;&th§V”§3fi:.-‘§3§”t}i§ . k
fixdéi. Civil Judge & m max hfitzzi:-er Acci%3;en’é$
navanagm {“}f%1.1na1’fnr mug. byvwiiaiifzflyrugfied
judwaeat, awarfici a sum sf haaw
with’ interest at the; mtg of 6% ‘§;s.. — +{}i§. }&%§§§_;£?:1£i’»»¥§f than in§m*i¢a
auatmnsa’ & 1 T: aa;cc’;5d¥§nt. The apwfimt in
MFA.3.3;51},f izhi-s qumtum af mmplztenaatixm
awmfiaé 13 :32′; fiée ‘fiigfief mm tr; ha riadzmcfi wberaas
wmsiemtiefi that thse qsxannxm
af by the imzmaz in iuaéequate and
¢fi–};am§:w§é’3t¢ Ema: both haw grmegtsfi these two
Tug bfieffacta efthc ewe are:
/éw
The apwnam in m’A.§*zv3;2eaQ5 am a claim
undser 393.166: d’ £.&.V.Ac1: cwmmg _
R3.5,0fi,$%f~ an aamrtzzt af mac iaju:*?z¢;g;…,$;z$ta§iéé’é;’*.:i:;.Q5: ”
mama acmfieat. lie am has and math; mfm;*:’tni”€};3’§2
when thing thtm mad, an 29.e3;2i:z;§4 ai’-.4{@3: 5?
the Qty imfiicipaiity, flezs.*aE_::zag1*¢ ,__’_L: the
ciaimant was: goizzzg in his-xv baa:-11%
Rem.,K0.§{A~2?;E’r-§9flS; ‘the 9:25 imarim
Rm.Ha.Kg~14;9.f3§.*$ %é:’::¥ésh and figment
manner and sf thza claimant an
acecaunt 91′ wihgichy, –‘ séustaiimd fraattifi mm’ his
ieft shcuidar mid befiy. fie Wfifi acimitstaci is
fag’: tgeament mi he is still Lméer
grivatg cbexsaza and M fiafi tam
maatséefit-T’§aTA &.ii”::’:§.;t§gfian£ fer mare than 3 flaw, it £3 tha @333
Vtige hm spent haw sum sf mama? mwaréa
:::_a:§maés, aamyanmz, musfihment amt &.i:tm&anz
%y -3, ‘gm said r.:§aEm pfififien hafi mm up far
eésmiémsatian befare the ‘Frihtxrxsi am my esxmiamam :;:m
A
. 5 ..
ralmrant matarimal avaibabke en. fik anti after &§}§f®r;Z!:&’£i$§3 fif ‘aim
era} axfl énc 1’E’Er}’ ; fix “i’ri%m1&.1 ‘rim
cfiaim pétitieri in mrt, awardiig a sum sf Ra¢§%,*%§6g’- iriimwt
at 6% per annum fiam the date af pefifimrz til} firm
realisaaon. Beirg a<matme«& with the _
xzzompezzsatiasn awafifi by the fiiébtzrwg the u
appeal befem skim Cam, mkizég e:%;fi3.é:r;:§§a§msea§:2i.'
ewmyengatisn, whzarw the appe11a13:§ix1si:r§~ v
the mmpcnaafian awareiéfl is an Hakka
to be prmantgd flame: rm:
agawh seekfizg atatmi game.
4, mama agpmritg far 13% Ex§':..1:-a ' V. the 1%% mumai far the cEa ' t _ for sf
waful pmmml of was impugmfi jadgmem 35
V’ twain avasla’ ble 3:: filfig m sf {ism
a§t%Gi;§i§j:_1t§a11& ‘Elm fixjma sustamé’ by the ciamatz’ t ara mat in
The t Em a13.a?£aixmd izzjmy fm. the 3%:
/4%
zflaviack bane and in the laft am mg the meta: :m%a;:;::¢.~:
that the clfint austainsed 223% m 25%
umfiergemé k’mm;mt far the same V
gem reasanable amum mwmfis
fwd and attsnéant Ghargw.
5. W ‘E’r-ibunai gagmmbxe
mmpenaatiaza ffiad axfi
afienciant fiard {:3
the fiwafiang mfiama by the
e.::1ai%t;, $3.}: 3% Big, ‘§SE’E:
am it fit m pain mzfi Emmy?
Rs..§3,000i§4_;f’&i:avw.rt43.;3 Ra.§,GQ§;- zewaras
L€:;s a_ the lafi up pew’ ég at tha rate at?
, LR3,3,O{i?§;-Q._V% Rsafifififij – tswarfia mzwazm,
a t chamsm and Ra,1fl,fi€.¥§i-«
Eusg ajvifafitm, cfmmmfarm and anhagyirmsa. Tim
firéjiag aged abuzz: 38 3% arzé tbs agpivmiaie
%%%ma;::paay agspiicsebia is 1′?’ ‘Em Tribuzmi Ema magma iim
cf the fi { &’£ /5 anfi fim safi ifl am@tm*
fl
Hanna, lass sf mam mmm is ciaiseirmémé; at
fE?s.3,fi[- X 12 x2’?”x Ii}; 1&3}
‘3’. Having’ find E the éhm
the was, we readastia the aW$;éi§’1:’_j$5i
Trxbunal Lirllifl’ dfimm’ ha-we: as ”
Madm 3,900!»- Cmrvayarxsrse, Rs, Sgfifiaf- Leas % Rs. gma;-» Loss ef arid Rs, mfififfif - _ unhaggéifizms ' ' ~ . 4§3::~.mma Rfi. $1 38%; =» TOTAL Rm 1,$8,29fii~
4333., is mtithafi far Esta} wmpaxmtéefi af
againmt Rs.§4»§4%i=—. The
2 ‘ asmm Rs Ra,-1~3,3W.v’ – with Ezztezmat at 6% imam
% mg sf cliaim msgm an tim éata efma?.£sa’ fima.
%/
..§.
‘Eh: apgai in E$A.1151§.,!28¥35 filaé; by me imazrancse
Gomgany is dismmafl as deveid sf merifit ‘E315 apmai fiké by
tbs apmiiant-«cifiani in §F&&§’??3iQEs is alissssad 31:: pm by
award?11g 3 gum uf %.43,3€@,f- wfih 66% inmrest &nm the
:3: claim pafifign 31? the date af rsalisafion in
caemgtenaatizm. awamkeé by ‘aha “{‘rE:.maL
The Emuranum Cammrxy is
fizmd mmpefmtinn cf 33.4% – ‘?§_?1i:$:*as;’s.5?;:VVA:
at 5%pa’ anrnzm £5131′ wmim ‘$15 at”
cepy !f}f1£hs6j1JLm “””
fin. gush Bnmmngg €115 enzfig
“£2-*2 3′.?:5..$xst:r sf rim claimnz immfiiataiy,
-V awarfixrsg’ iy.
361/-4
Iudgé
Sd/-3
Judge
_. 3% J, u