High Court Karnataka High Court

The Tamil Nadu Handloom Weavers vs M/S Shailashree Estate … on 19 November, 2008

Karnataka High Court
The Tamil Nadu Handloom Weavers vs M/S Shailashree Estate … on 19 November, 2008
Author: P.D.Dinakaran(Cj) & V.G.Sabhahit
'80OZ/AL/O8 GELLVC}
2.0/9

“: 1,2,1 ‘cm NOI.LLL’.z3’c:I .LI&iM 311.; N1 C{1EISSV<:i 33030 :»:u~LL
zacnsv ms OJ. mmvaa mv .LéIf1OC) HSIH vxvwuavx
am. :30 1? Sm (1{EI'II.z§ iisqf;\i~~..gH3’dv2g¢i–:§I£§ Kai)’

.{.E\iV’1’I{‘r}”‘mx;#Ax1sva
eve}: ‘v;I.~{Vc1V1~z1Ae:)::>VV ‘es:
mi. 301.530 133101533 ;S&J’~{)1\€~[:_’LFH
‘4’_cf’;’.1._”I A.I;EIIi30~S E{f1IfL\{&I’3’&£3’*OO
S*!1 w~;€}i{)’IcE=Nv§aI’vi’}:VN1q ‘(I’d ‘aw CEl’1E{.NOI~i mm,

$M3S3&d

‘ ” afiarrémore go AVG mat tam SiH.L cI:a.1.vc1

V .Lv V}IVJ.VNéiV}i d0 .Léif1OC) HDIH SI–LL Ni

3″”

IQSIIIIOQ Gflf} pQ'{I_H1IBX$9-$290.11} {IQQQ seq Qq {)1CIE.’ JSAO S?

gpugmd am, 59 9:3-1::9p;Aa 9:131 -aoaapyaa JO} pawod SBM Jauem

pm»: pamag mam Seuss} ‘}§1’1S sq; II_[ 1t::aum:;1=.-1s u:m§.1m. pafgu

ptm pamacieie 1map1:za_;ap sq’; ‘9Q{)z*9-5 no “psgg SBM nus ;’;;)1;g_’ ,/

~1u9u.1a;e1s ustuyzm am, 3II§{g Aq was my pmsgssx ._

3:21′; 1900 para s11_;o.IcE auszmr Jo; pI1’8 mcfigaxéufjj :V:;’i1}3p u’3§:{:;*;1..V ‘V

am 3Hgoa_fa.I Kg .&1.I9d0.Id ampaqas ggns a41i{3,Aj<:». uo;s$:és.L§¢dA'

~10; fiuwm "E31911 luenadée min 900z£%§(}s:'%i;zu

'91:; new sat: U19-rat: s:a§spI:05$'=~i'i__ éétal,

r;n,zI:;s1::1:.v31::;:: _1jt:;11pm:L;G:.§t;taxi1§iCI9u1ra 10;

ttogzgezagdda sq; ';;1:£n [requiem
'sfipnr Hats 9003/i2S6QI'0N'S'()
I11 9'; 'V1 no zssulgt magma; oz, pauypap
seq. m_1_o .’§_ ‘V’s3_1_:*I*-E4 étfims. .999-mat am U¥9~19T{M aoomxos:

parw’1>__1:é§.z9Va:{1w§t1″””I29A9I-I338 3II!?9’«'{ A008/9ILz.I’0N’d’AA

zafiflffiiad pan”; 9,; prmdde SPILL

;

‘3fi!m0u0J 9:11 P:->-I9A:»”I9p “P .LIi-IVI–iE{‘v’S ‘K911 89313

vv .103 (in Bugumzz feaddv 1§Im syqg,

§”‘\

mu pm; guanadée 91:11 gem, p'[:.:n:1; sagwd mp .10} Bugmsdde

IQSYEHCK} 96;: 3:0 3031391303 sq”; fiupamsuoo .I9Z}Jl?.’ 3.I:}9{v

Sm :0 afipnr 9I3ti’§S paws: am pm 1.005/9u.;I’mjjf

paw metiatide Mr: z.ooz’o*£’za pump ;’:fiamp}I%3m?«« V:

troptaagdde sq; fiugosfax 1.11103 mm sq; /iq :Ia;${z’0_ pg23s.. ” [A

3:11 Aiq panagxfifie Ema-a ‘p91:)e{s.1 sq oi» SEAS

.10} Ltogeogdde sq; ‘souafigfgp J9 EO§ié{IH{dX’.§9
£119 fill souzasqe 9111 H; ‘4 .3i{i§}z%:;);x1;9uIu1oo
azogaq pagg uaaq 1o13 *s}.3q ;i ‘ VSBAA guenadde
mt: rem W-ti 21906 $11: A/iq trorma-:>:Idi}« sIzop,;>:;§qo sq; fitxyrg
fiq .B_1.V11″?’!’=”Id” $11 Sq fiorxeaadde pres 311.1, ‘L mm

Q . _;o I1; sqdexfiemd mm: aanpanmr

03, *p:;V:’fr,;_ i&1Tf1.;:.1;:i§r;:a.v]v,’i2¢.’;$.§;’V-1;1r::.::11y.zAxx at}; ;o ,5 pm; Q»-SB.Il’:?d 11; spam

T’ v.§§ifi’:;m1aA*é 3:; u§§§13{é’g3A1o_; LOQz’g”aa {I0 guamagers tz313;;.1m go

‘ x6;v,__S:’LI§)[s9s uogxeogdde “:9i)’t3£3p’fZA;) s,:uxepu:;_;9p .10}

génnm sq; tratzfm. ptre 1Impu:;_;9p sq), .10; 3¥II_;I¥38(IdE

9

‘a’\
sq: Suyuuguoo Ix; psggsnf 101.1 SBM afipnp $)[3t1’_[S paumag
mp, pure 139133311933 ‘uagzmm go 1″£I3′(IIpII9UZIE’ .10; uogeogddn
sq; pampffe anreq oz, a,q3n,o 31:10:) [am am nag; pzmgaxqn-3

1flfE{{9ddt:2 am mg; fiupreaddta {¢9StIflOO mama; QILL -1»,

‘paces: no *{e;.x:a11au1: aqr; p9$’§{I1_C3t3.I3S ptm 1u9{g;;cidt_e:*;;’q§,_¢’ A4

J0} Bugmacide {saunas pmxxesq sq; pmaaq 95121} 9M V L.

{ “E’;3}ac’?I;’c{.t3″‘«’T-:’§'”11«:~’ 1” – X

pauagmd seq .I:;uo§maci gym sq; ‘¥I(}!_I1’_§i’:1_3’d._.1.’f.Ixi\€L énj

zafipnp enfltrgs p9II.fEE){ sq’; go Japag pges

-uognad mm sq; psssgmsrp 93U§pioa;§;,~,.v’. :1a1;mpu9m”e

Jo; uogzwoygdciig :;}q;I1 AV sq; Xq passed
33910 91;; 1:1; .I0.I.’I”.3,_ (511 s1’azza ;i.’1r.;;~’q’:1< " .':"'}\':{v"['Ii.§Iv.fiCIE)"£iII91]IE% Jo; IIO'_(1I~)':)§{ddE'
911:; fiuqg ug ggafép aqi .:-Q_; 111′;1efi’sI=.-géixs zqqgssod £113 _;o aotmsqe

[II II; 1nta8_r[;p 1139:; 101; seq

3EfE?[{9!C2h”A{B:V sguepuagap 10;; pznsod stem xsnam

.z9f.m9_V saga 9111 30 Q:)t”£:§p§A:9 sq; gage pagg uaaq

‘ ‘séé1;; .1fi:;wpu9$3__5:e; zxopeogdde ptm {egg go guamaousvmmoa

V gen peqj uopmgdde sq; ziqm 03 se mo spam

Y”5\

m9″191′<"r1*1s 'tlajgum
. J0 luampugum J0
J Ho _ ._
W3'°¥{dd1s sq; gugaakitb» .

Jame gm mt” Qmilalm 01 3
slams mm x ‘. +
” 911913..’ %- %

fiq pass” “mm” 9″-I31 lms 9
‘ q} I” -I0} m ,, .’ ‘ -. , , .

‘ 3°33’-am go amlm –

93.1 01 {E13831 fin-[Ag
mm ~mmm.. 3°.V1′”°'”P’? ‘:ame’ J ~

.10} uounoqdde 91:11 gm” _
* ‘ m m luggfifi’ 10:1 A ‘ ‘
‘ 33%’

Pam EI9::.q’~. ”

.10; 3:I01_:m:>”€{ddva gouspma . ‘ A_ ” ,_§1a91}.’1TI9mpq9q1t;
‘ * E-1″”3’Pts9}9’é’f’rg
‘ ‘ “.7 ‘a
N11 Eaqm pug -. =S'”»”.”* 191mm
999010 «~:’em. ;;;3§I~3 2

we 9 . . ¢ ..”~?*’?’F’?”¥¢. “91;¥Ba.ta

G05 8 {yr [[0 gain 1;” ~_ . _ . [D-

 '"  " é 9w91B1-  ' 
J0 lfiamgaugmmoo  b     9131 J' Tegn
 """  .  "R. .5 '¥99€i*1or:§ 
33910 ~'~'9'f3ttn 1t:9mmiéi§' 3; if V'    "I0 4' "W8 9

* ‘V?’7$.li’§~’I%A<i»'§–.<)"'"L4-*19-'11 '

' . ndde

9111 mag: moqs 3' = ~ v .. ..

{.1’é3′:;*{-Q pffiobit ‘ ‘ \\\\
u L. . – J. 9

.. _____ _. « qtmfiaddn

3’-{‘4 ‘..IVo_; Vgutflgxfide
J” ‘ I am 30 ‘I°F1’131uoa

o1uGgmpgguou mm3 W

– Qfi”-*1} am -@

311!-‘IA’.;O 1u9’HpH3mE

I330

ON /89); =xé_iifi’:’~’V1—-I: f .

.. _

A. S]? fsaadde sq; ‘ziyfinypnoaav

‘ffiflddfl 9C1I}{3.I9_]I.IéI1EI§ .10} [[33 O1

‘ go Jana; {Cute mag Jagns 101:1 saop pm: pagpsnf sy