E
IN 'm1«: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA A'1'33A_NG_ALORE
DATED '1_'}~1_IS'I'HE 13TH DAY OF JANUARY 2010
BEFORE
THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE RAVE MA14iMAi;*:4_J_V_
WP N0.8227/2008 M
BETWEEN
Smt.Far11ar1..21 Beg_g'L1m,
Aged about 41 years,
W/o.Sri Syed Nazim.
Formerly r/a.No.22,
Old No.8, E N0.6'" Street, A »
Broadway Road (HKP __Roa<:1 Cr_c)isvs],"w
Bangalore-560 O51, p_1'e.s§e11:f'1y _ A "
R/a.O1d No.2, New No'L4f.:e,T--. \_ }
C No.51" Street, Cha.r1c111i" _ 1
Chowk Road (3;~os__s,
Shive115_~iz1eigVg':i1'\;i.f'_, N 'V _ .
BaI1gaf1--()1*c3¥56O'£1'5[£; _ ' .. Petitioner
[By Sn' I«1'»sLI71ad A}.1rfie.(!,.K:;_--.
Amt; kx
" Sliit. Mei: 1"f13}'I1iS(':1.
' Aged a.vb()~11'i:«v_6'3..years,
=. W./ 0. Sh Eu' Ii !S'13i1ai1,
(1'ep';A'esei1t:E:<*d by 1'1e1' GPA Holder].
S1'i'=R()S;h'c:If1.«'iZ8.II1CCl',
Aged bout. 38 years,
A S/(3.Sh21ik Ismail,
= _ R/e':~...N0.5, P K La.r1e.
' , 'AACC)';,tO11})(et'., Bz1;2gz1E01'e:-560 O58,
{$iI1-.- ~ .
rw--x ' '
uv. » <
v-,{';'V.() . {$31331 .
Sn' Roshan ZE11{11€€1'.
aged aboui 42 years,
s/0.Shai1<. Ismail.
Sri Khudmlh Ulla,
aged about 32 yams.
53/o.Shaik Ismail.
Sri Nayec:1111?111a.
aged about 30 years.
S/0.Shaik Ismaii.
Smt .Meher*,
aged about 46 years, T
w/0.Mohammed Inya"fh',"--
No.23, 3*" Cross,
1\/Iathikere, Bangaloi-e. K
Smt.Shamshiya ? ., '
aged about 44 years.._
W/0.1) H' _K'h_;'1E2'a1?1'C3'éi*; .
:1'/£17ASiFV§V§21_}'}'Eii1Q2._ .
49* C.1'()sS. Gé1I;1gm:ji Rozxd.
'FL1111ku 1". ' " ' '
_ _S111tT..1V'i1.z}3e(;1'fa '.1T"e;j . "
aV1§_§x/:61 21bV'(n._x.1". 35 years,
gj / a,I9.;§I'1;Cse1'1t, School
2 ' « R"().';1CE', \KC'i'F.
" Smf."S?1gr1b&%t21'1 'iI_"21j.
e1g;§~c';sc1}1:b01.zt. 28 years,
aw"/.0 . Sarcie-11' I-7233.5 h 21.
1*/.z£.I"Ia §.I2.»1t.I'1 I\/121112111,
A Next to Maciari Shadi Mahal.
. * 'I'1m'1I:1,1_1'.
3
2. Sri l\/lohaunmed Ruhulla.
Major in age,
S/0.late. Abdul 221662.
3. Sr; l\/i0}'1.211nme=3d Asad Ulla.
Major in etgcr.
S/0.1316 Abdul A2662.
4. Sn' Molxammctd S1'bga1:h Ulla,
Major in age,
S/O.l8.liC Abdul Azeez.
5. Sri Mohe1mmed Rizwan Ulla.
Mzljor in age.
S/o.le1t:e Abdul
6. sn Mohammad Sai1'U1ld,""-..:
Major in V =
S/ 0.la1:e3 Abdul 1 l
7'. '1'i"dM ():l'":-2: 1'11l"1'-gga Cd 'Rah11"1alEr'Ulla,
'l\/l21i_(>1*.ii1~.':ag;¢';g -- A
_/ 0} l_e1i:'e At3.c'h,1}
8. Sn' lVl'ol12:1111ned. N'a"s1'1.zlla,
' l\/EA.>.1j 0 r in
A S;/A0.1d_a1;e Al'J<.i*1;;--£«
_ E'&sl._I\?£)S'--;.?glt.ol'E§:3i--;'e r/a.N'o.-4.
' C No. Sm £%.1';',1'e:~<;éT; Cl1a:'1da'1:'
Chowli _l%2.t)'z'1l1.rV_1A AC ross ,
Shiva} N at kg';-11',
Banga1Vo'm~550 05 .2.
OWL-fl
9. Sri Abdul Hafeez,
Major in
S/olate Abdul Wahab,
R/a.No.60. 4"! Main,
New Bagalur Layouii.
Be1n;ge1loi'e#56O 056
{since deceased by L.Rs.)
9a. M1's.Habeebm1 Nissa,
aged about 55 years.
913. Sii Sayeed Ahmed,
aged about 23 years.
QC. Miss Yasmeen Banu,
aged about 30 years.
9d. Miss Azra '1'abavs'sutm,
aged about 25 ye"ays.. '
Sl. No.ve9a'e'is_i:1i'1e viii}:-§' a"n.a*---
9b to Qci aoifesov1'1...ai1d Cl.§liEgl'iT.€i'S
respec:f.i_veiy of_i'.l1ef eic:e2i::~,eld_\,
all 9a to 9d L-1l"f;*, 1*./a".No.8--O,'
4' 1'1 Main, N'ew"Byag;_aii¥_i' 'I.:ayoL1t,
Be1n;g:i'ii>i'eA 560.. 058. .._ Respondents
.l\?V«rifi1: Peizition is filed under Articles 226 and
"Co1'isi:ii:uti()n of India, praying to quash the
"o_i*ti_ei7 €i;:1f.e(_l zl"3.8.2007 passed by the XVII Additional
City ()vi_vil"J1,i€il§_.ge., CCH No.32, Bangalore in OS
No.E385<.i /£1999 per A.IH1€Xi_II'(3-G in respect of l'.A.No.4
lgfiled Liijitiiei' Se.ct:ioi:3 10 of CPC.
Writ. Petit:ioi'i cc'in1iiig on for admission this
day,' the court. passed the following:
054"
ORDER
Agjrieveci by the 01″der dated ‘13.8.2007 it
LAIV filed by The peiiitiouel’ under Section;”‘l’O;fC-}§:C.
0.5. No.8851/1999 passed by the_.~i}{3&’1:i:”:f1eCi’.:: «.Xv1%:1i«ii
Additi0.r1.211 City Civil J1.idg(3,:i_: Cii:j,’r§__
petitioner gm defendant 1’1a1s{i”i.I__ed
2. Sri Irshad Heifppearing
for the petiiimner. V Trial Court
committed an enter \j’.’*’h”‘1’i.€’::”}T)§1S$:i13g..Viihéilxfrilpugned order
by 11c)1cii;-lg suits are not the
sa1ne3t;111d ‘rieiiCe…ime1*iei*e.1f1ce[is called for.
3.”Qi’1 CVI1<-C32'-:v,.1'EV1'*;«.g:;'* ti_1T(:'.._?{?(13't.11"1SE31. Yam oi' the View that
thetje 'i:3_I1() r1'i»e_1fii'f'f'i_n the pet;iti011 and the same requires
"t.<:nABe r'ej:ee_i,ed_. On COI1SiC1(3I'iI1g the similarities of the
A1"pai5iies:*4ii;J'C)w§§-No.391 / 1997 pending on the fiie of {the
C.i:\.?iE'*'kC01,1'rt:. BEl1'"£gE1.1{,)E'C and OS No.8851/1999
the file of the }_e21r1.1ed XVIII AddiU.(_")I}Ei1 City
"CB/*ii:J1.:dge, Ba.1'1g21l01'c City, the 'f'1'ia1 C01.:1"t'; held f,}12'1i:
CV'/\'""
{I1
tlle legal 1″c:p1-eserltaiixres of the p1aim’:iff in OS
No.39}/1997 and the lezgzal 1’ep1’cse11{ai:ives of the 813*
defe1’1ciant’ in OS N().8851/1.999 are not the
‘I’ria1 Court: relied upon the docL1r11ents E1\”c1flZ’Lb1¢ bé}(})i”€–, *
it while passing the 1’111pug1″1ed oxide}; Tliie _1§é1i*i;:i<–=S'
c1iffc:r(»:11t.. there are no i1'1g1'edie r"1ts7._f,dT erii3e 1*t3,i11 "E_;A._.I"\/',
flied under Secttion IO CPE3–_.,::1"'£_c11(:{–: ,' .I__ dQ 1':2joV'1*~-. Vf.'i.'i1'(i'5 any"
error cornr11.it.15ed by t11.rq.'i'ri211V.VCe3–1
For the 1'CE:1SOI1S af(q'1'c:S::1iVi*,1;Vt.}1é–§}t:t'1t§c)11 is rejected
3&7"
sliflfige